12 ms·
Food Grammar: Unspoken rules of cuisine
- grawprog 6y agoI've never heard those.concepts described as grammar before, but it makes a lot of sense and puts into words well the reason why some food just feels like it doesn't go together. As far as adapting food goes vs traditional recipes. Personally, I think there's room for both. I really enjoy getting to try food done 'traditonally' but I also enjoy fusions of food, or new rakes on old things or just finding a recipe myself somewhere and changing it up in some way. Food's great and it's great people keep experimenting, adapting food from other cultures and combining things.
- Djvacto 6y agoYou can see this in stuff like Chinese-American restaurants, or British-Indian food, but a lot of great food comes from what cooks have to do when using their original recipes/cooking styles in a region with distinct ingredients. I end up accumulating a lot of ingredients that are traditional from international groceries and stuff, but a lot of interesting and tasty dishes come from what you can substitute regarding local produce and ingredients.
- ziml77 6y agoIt really is wonderful to see how food is adapted between regions and cultures. It drives me crazy when I see people concerned about "appropriation" when one culture adopts the cuisine of another (appropriation exists, but the usages I've seen apply it far too broadly). People want others to enjoy what they enjoy. It's great to share recipes! I know that ordering American food in another country will not get me what I expect... and that's totally fine. The adaptation might not appeal to my tastes, but that doesn't make it bad. It doesn't mean they're not allowed to call it American food.
- pmontra 6y ago> fish is often perched on risotto As Italian I confirm that this is The Horror, really. And yet I can have a Spanish paella with no problem.
- bonzini 6y agoNot entirely true. It's kind of traditional in some places to prepare it with lightly fried lake fish (I am from the Como area). The horror would be parmesan with fish. But it is "small" fish, not a whole bass or trout.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoA lot of Italian food rules tend to be more regional than most italians think. Even the classic heretical example of spaghetti and meatballs pretty closely resembles traditional dishes from Abruzzo - https://www.lacucinaitaliana.it/ricetta/primi/spaghetti-alla-chitarra-con-pallottine https://www.lacucinaitaliana.it/ricetta/primi/spaghetti-alla...
- bonzini 6y agoAgreed on the regional rules and the spaghetti and meatballs might indeed be related to the dish you mention. However, while you _can_ have spaghetti and meatballs in the "Italian food grammar", people from Abruzzo might be even more horrified by the American dish: 1) their meatballs are small enough to be part of the sauce. You don't have to tear them apart 2) the pasta remains the base of the dish rather than a kind of side 3) you would never serve "plain" pasta with the sauce and meatballs on top [1], the sauce and to some extent the meatballs would be well mixed with the pasta before it reaches the table. So it's not the concept of spaghetti and meatballs, but rather the way ingredients are balanced and presented. [1] https://www.bettycrocker.com/recipes/spaghetti-and-meatballs/cb9f45ff-f143-429d-a950-5e366e63e7c7 https://www.bettycrocker.com/recipes/spaghetti-and-meatballs...
- ryanbrunner 6y agoFor sure, I'm definitely not claiming they're the same dish, absolutely the concept of spaghetti and meatballs has evolved from whatever it's original origins were. I guess my overall point is that I think the author is overstating the strictness of these rules, even in famously rigid traditions like Italy. Changing food around as it is shared and moves between cultures isn't a uniquely American or even modern thing, it's been happening for ages and a whole lot of traditional foods have been heavily influenced by other cultures. Also super nitpicky but most folks in north america would incorporate the sauce in spaghetti and meatballs before serving, the whole sauce on top thing is mostly relegated to grandparents and betty crocker recipes - I'm sure a not small part of the reason for that is people rediscovering italian techniques though.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- klyrs 6y agoIn my life, I've made a commitment to combining foods that break the grammars that I've been exposed to. Much of the time, I've enjoyed (pear compote on steak!) or at least tolerated (hot dog, peanut butter and banana? Only whilst camping) the results. However: never mix strawberries and shrimp. It wasn't my idea, but I did execute on the suggestion.
- yomly 6y agoWow I was with you until strawberry and shrimp. Korean marinades use pears for kalbi iirc. PB on a hot dog isn't crazy tho the addition of banana is slightly more odd. But my god. Strawberry and shrimp. Especially that very rich full bodied shrimp would be awful with strawberry! Gross! And yet the brain is ticking, if you chose sweeter prawns that were very fresh and steamed them, I could see them going with milder raw strawberries. At least not contradicting them. Maybe some balsamic can bridge the two.
- burke 6y agoRiffing on ceviche seems like a plausible path to something edible.
- monocasa 6y agoYeah, I was about to say, I've had mango salsa ceviche that was pretty killer. Strawberry isn't a leap.
- klyrs 6y ago> And yet the brain is ticking... Well met, friend! After writing that, I started reconsidering how it could be done. I arrived at a sibling comment's observation, that ceviche could be a better approach. Not so far from the balsamic! Onion in the ceviche may help (on second thought, it might be another strike against the strawberries). But no, the original incident was a grilled skewer -- yikes. One flavor that I've found to be a a very flexible "strange bridge" is mustard. But... ye gods... that'd only turn the retch up to 11.
- jimbokun 6y agoThis is why I don't like "fusion" dishes. When I'm exploring new cuisines, I want to learn the grammar of that culture and how they put food together. I find those traditional dishes that have evolved over a long period of time to have flavors that complement each other very well. And also like imagining the experience of people from that culture. And I know others enjoy something new and innovative that hasn't been done before, and that's OK, too.
- OnlyOneCannolo 6y agoWhere do you draw the line? At the Columbian Exchange?
- retrac 6y agoA valid question. When my mother was growing up, pizza was considered a somewhat exotic Italian-American import.
- GuB-42 6y agoA lot of "traditional" dishes are not that old. Japanese Ramen is my favorite example. Inspired by Chinese noodles, it is only about a century old, and it really took off during WW2. A sign of it not being of Japanese tradition is the fact it is most often written in katakana (ラーメン). The fact it is not traditional is actually a strength. While more traditional Japanese food like sushi or tempura is highly codified, Ramen shops are free to do as they please, which result in a great deal of variety. There is no "one true Ramen".
- lhorie 6y agoFun fact: tempura are actually of portuguese origin. And california rolls are, as the name suggest, from California. Another japanese staple that has a weird history is curry: it mimics the _british_ curry, rather than the indian/thai varieties.
- bostonvaulter2 6y ago
- pierrebai 6y agoGive this article to someone, taking out every occurence of 'food grammar'. I'll bet they'll guess the missing words are 'eating habits'. Why invent new words for existing concepts? Most of the times, in my experience, it is done to either appear more intelligent or to stake a new ground and be the self-anointed expert. What's wrong with eating habits?
- morsch 6y agoThe article (and the related book[1], written by a linguist) introduce the term to refer to cultural rules around what foods to combine, either at the same time or sequentially. Eating habits is a very general term. The first 3 google results I got[2][3][4] aren't really related to what the article refers to as food grammar. I'd say referring to habit stresses the individual preference, while referring to a grammar stresses the cultural preference. I'll say that if the Google results for grammar inside the book are exhaustive, the concept isn't fully developed though. I'd have expected a longer, systematic list of food-grammatical rules. [1] https://www.google.com/books/edition/_/7BF0AwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PT163&bsq=grammar https://www.google.com/books/edition/_/7BF0AwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gb... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/losing_weight/eating_habits.html https://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/losing_weight/eating_habit... [3] https://www.healthlinkbc.ca/health-topics/ad1169 https://www.healthlinkbc.ca/health-topics/ad1169 [4] https://www.everydayhealth.com/diet-and-nutrition-pictures/bad-eating-habits-and-how-to-break-them.aspx https://www.everydayhealth.com/diet-and-nutrition-pictures/b...
- crazygringo 6y agoThey're different concepts. Eating habits are, well, just habits. They're what you usually do. But they don't embody notions of right and wrong. Grammars embody notions of right and wrong. Americans don't avoid eating horses and dogs because it's not part of their habit, they do it because they think it's wrong. Habits are relatively easy to change. Grammars are not. I think food grammar is a great term.
- roelschroeven 6y agoI think 'style' would be a much better name. Grammar describes how to put words together, style describes which combinations are a good idea and which aren't.
- icefrakker 6y agoWhat this article partly talks about is one of the reasons I think "cultural appropriation" is such a silly and offensive concept, an indication of the intellectual bankruptcy of the American left when it comes to things like multiculturalism and race.
- dekhn 6y agoI love this idea and want to expand on it. I personally think of all cuisines in the worlds as points within a large embedding- "recipe space". Every recipe is a graph of nodes representing items, and edges representing actions ("take sugar and flour and mix in a bowl"). Out of this whole space, different cultures have explored various areas but we've ended up with a number of very similar approaches, such as: flatbreads. a wide range of cultures/cuisines use a flatbread as a starch structural vehicle (tortilla, dumpling wrappers) combined with a protein/fat interior (cheese, dumplings, whatever). This pattern shows up over and over and suggests a wide range of new fusion approaches ("world wrapps" is an example of prior art). Once you've cooked across enough cuisines you'll see people have rediscovered a number of techniques (quick fermentation, drying, evaporating) to get rich flavors quickly. There's a side comment in one my cookbooks (Sauces) which dives into salsa- which means "sauce" but most people think of it as a condiment. It points out that if you think of salsa as fresh sauces it opens up a whole new world of saucing opportunities. Building the latent space for recipes would mean taking every recipe in the world, encoding it, and generating an embedding; with the result, you could easily create fusion food by casting vectors between two cuisines and sampling points between them.
- blt 6y agoDo it!
- polygotdomain 6y agoWhile I've never heard it expressed that as "food grammar", there's definitely a context that tends to get lost with cuisines from another culture. Interestingly enough, that context tends to get "filled in" with their local vernacular. When done well, it can result in some really interesting fusion cuisine and dining experiences. That's not always the case though, and I'm reminded of an experience I had in Rome ordering a cheese burger in a quasi-Irish pub, and getting a dry puck of ground beef with a cold thick slice of fresh mozzarella on top. Not really what I was hoping for.
- madcaptenor 6y agoEggs are breakfast food.
- dsr_ 6y agoEggs hold things together. Cake, enriched breads, sauces, breading on your fried foods...
- yawnxyz 6y agoeggs are a food fit for every meal... does that mean every meal is breakfast?
- NullPrefix 6y agoYes. You break your fast everytime you eat.
- technothrasher 6y agoOffer an American a hamburger patty coated in thick demi-glace, and they’ll likely raise an eyebrow at this common Japanese staple dubbed hambagoo. But I'm an American, and that immediately sounds pretty good to me. Like a little Japanese meatloaf. The only "grammar" problem I see there is that I suspect the word is hambagu.
- quicklime 6y agoOne of the mistakes that many gaijin make (myself included) is to assume that katakana words are always loan words from their home country. "Hambagoo" is the Japanese take on a Hamburg steak, not an American hamburger. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamburg_steak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamburg_steak
- princeb 6y agoyes. the japanese word for the hamburger is hanbaga, which is a distinct word from hanbagu. hanbaga is as different from hanbaga as macaroons are from macarons.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mikehollinger 6y agoThere's a pretty good article from the BBC [1] on the "bad grammar" of ordering a marinara pizza with cheese in Italy. It got covered on HN back in 2015. [2] There're some pretty good anecdotes in there if you like this article. :-) [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-33542392 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-33542392 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10026519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10026519
- hirundo 6y agoAbout 300 million McDonald's Fillet-O-Fish sandwiches, "topped with melty American cheese," are sold each year. I offer this as proof that cheese-on-fish does not violate the American food grammar, just the {haute cuisine,foodie} American food grammar, a very different thing. Just because they say "ain't" ain't right don't mean ain't ain't right.
- Spivak 6y agoI think you're thinking about rules too much like a programmer in that they are something absolute rather than the rules of thumb that they actually are. Fillet-o-fish (and fish-sticks in general) are an exceptional dish in American cuisine that is akin to an irregular verb. It doesn't matter if the individual dish itself is popular but that the paring it rare among the different types of dishes in American cuisine. Just because an irregular verb is commonly used doesn't mean it's not still irregular.
- hirundo 6y agoAn irregular verb is not ungrammatical. It just follows an exceptional rule of conjugation. Same with a fish sandwich with cheese.
- Spivak 6y agoFair enough. I consider these to be spiritually equivalent since any ungrammatical form can be made grammatical with the addition of a new rule.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Fillet-o-fish (and fish-sticks in general) are an exceptional dish in American cuisine that is akin to an irregular verb. Ironically, irregular verbs get regularized over time as the language evolves (hell, I saw some paper the other day that attempted to compute half-life of irregular verbs in English; can't find it now) - but in case of food, I fully expect the opposite to happen; that is, cheese-on-fish will become normalized. McDonald's is the vanguard of the universal culture - whatever stuff it sells everywhere is here to stay.
- vz8 6y agoHunched over a bitter + savory hotpot in Nanning, China was both dizzying and delicious. A tour-de-force of sinus-clearing, palate-disorienting goodness. Boiling roiling fungus and grasses (lemon, bamboo, some things entirely new) A wordless meal, punctuated by satisfied sighs and appreciative noises Plates of piled high greens. Mystery broth, mystery guests. The live entertainment: torchlit, rhythmic caterwauling over a PA
- jeromenerf 6y agoGrammar was very much a class thing, imposed top-down. However, one had to wonder how Icelanders came up with the rotten-shark-in-a-clay-pot, french with garlic and snails. It feels like survival tactics turned cuisine grammar.
- pkkim 6y agoAs the article briefly touches on, these aren't limited to cooking, but even extend to eating. One weird experience I've had recently is having to explain to friends how to eat Korean food: you pick out individual bites of side dishes from shared containers one at a time, and alternate them with bites of rice. Usually their instinct is to put a bunch of side dishes in their bowls at the beginning of the meal, which is the equivalent of putting the verb before the subject.
- autarch 6y agoI'm an American married to a Taiwanese woman, so I've been there many times. I've had a lot of amusing "Western" (by which they mostly mean American) food on these trips. The last time few times I was there I went to a vegan place that specializes in Western food. Some of the stuff was what you'd expect, like a burger and fries, but there was also some oddities. My favorite was the mashed potato sub, which was room temperature mashed potatoes mixed with bits of chopped vegan ham and carrots, served in a hot dog roll, topped with ketchup and mustard. It was really good, though it cracked me up that this was what they might think we eat in the US. I've also noticed that many of the vegan Western food places serve dishes that they call "risotto" which are basically just cooked rice with sauce on top. I understand how they settled on risotto, but it can be a bit of disappointment if you're expecting actual risotto. Overall, I have a lot of fun trying the Taiwanese interpretations of American food. The food quality there is just really high in general. Even if it's weird, it's weird with good ingredients and flavors, so you never end up with something inedible, just surprising in a fun way.
- bonzini 6y agoI had the best Italian food outside Italy :) in Japan at a conference. The food was super simple, but really authentic---like, what you could find at a family gathering or potluck party---and good. Plus the pizza makers were tossing dough like there's no tomorrow, one of them had even learnt in Italy!
- asiachick 6y agoJapan has won best pizza in the world 5 times by some Italian pizza judging contest in Italy https://www.google.com/search?q=japan+wins+best+pizza https://www.google.com/search?q=japan+wins+best+pizza Yes there is also bad pizza in Japan but, for example, there are around 90 "certified" neapolitan pizza restaurants in Tokyo. https://www.pizzanapoletana.org/en/ https://www.pizzanapoletana.org/en/ Whether or not you believe the certification means anything, the point is there's lots of good pizza. There's also lots of bad too ...
- rayiner 6y agoChefs in Japan are incredible at doing non-Japanese food. I haven't had the best croissants in Paris, but croissants I've had in Tokyo are better than the ones I've had in Paris.
- snapetom 6y agoHaha. I was born in Hong Kong and spoke Cantonese growing up. I never really thought about what sung means until this article. To me, it was basically "everything that's not rice," which is a more casual, flippant definition in the article. But it's still an odd word and an odd concept if you think about it. What a mindfuck.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- standardUser 6y agoIf someone has genuine advice on how to enjoy food more, I am always game. But arbitrary rules about when and how to eat food bring me no joy.
- vrc 6y agoI found the line, "And much like linguistic false friends...such as... jungli, which means wild in Gujarati, not jungle" amusing because it's right for the wrong reason. "Jungli" means "person from the jungle" in many Indian languages, but the word "jungle," which in English connotes a dense forest, comes from a Sanskrit root that actually refers to an arid, undeveloped, semi-desert environment. So, the word means exactly what the author thinks -- a wild person from the jungle -- but because it was borrowed incorrectly, it's a completely different "jungle". So it remains a "linguistic false friend"!
- jehb 6y agoMy wife was trying to make us pumpkin pancakes this weekend, ended up an egg short, did a Google search for "egg substitutes" and ended up trying a dollop of mayonnaise, alongside traditional pumpkin spices. Mayonnaise is, after all, just egg and oil with a touch of an acid. They almost tasted right, until they didn't. There's something about falling into the uncanny valley with foods that makes them more unacceptable than something completely foreign. We both had a good laugh at the mayo-squash-clove patties, and how close, yet so very far away they ended up being from something acceptable for our palates.
- asiachick 6y agoHmmm, I totally agree there are local cultural food grammars. And I love trying some of the things that stick outI would not have thought of like the fruit in whipped cream sandwiches (yum) or the hamburger served as a steak (also yum). But some of the things in the articles are like??? > TO an Italian, and they may question why pasta and meat are being served together. Pasta and meat together are common in Italy. https://www.google.it/search?q=ricetta+pasta+carne&source=lnms&tbm=isch https://www.google.it/search?q=ricetta+pasta+carne&source=ln... > In China, explains Jennifer 8. Lee, author of The Fortune Cookie Chronicles, rice is served after the main and before the soup Never heard of this. I'm Chinese. Spent lots of time in China. Never once had this experience. > shokupan, a Japanese white bread that’s even sweeter and softer than American Wonder Bread shokupan is not sweeter and softer than wonder bread. It is delicious though!
- tomcooks 6y ago> Pasta and meat together are common in Italy. As you can see in the results of the search you linked, its all ragù or other tiny bits of sausage. The reason why pasta and meat is considered dumb ("bad grammar") in most parts of Italy is that a big chunk of meat would off the pasta/meat ratio in a bite.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoHam and pineapple on Pizza is famously offensive to Italians and oddly not mentioned in the article (probably because it is such a cliche). Yet it works. And those saying fruit has no place on a pizza: tomato is a fruit. Some of this grammar is simply irrational habit. Sometimes food rules are even encoded in religion. E.g. Halal and Kosher food rules are pretty strict about what you can and cannot eat and how things should be prepared. Or the Catholic habit of eating fish on a Friday or indeed serving wine during church. Going against the rules can yield nice results. Fusion cooking is a thing. Also, Neil Stephenson wrote about a North American thing called recombinant cooking. I'm not sure if he invented that term but it refers to the practice of cooking food with store bought processed food (e.g. rice crispies) and recombining it with other ingredients. Basically, it's the notion that some people only know heavily processed food and use them as ingredients.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoTomato is a fruit In botany, sure. So are Peppers, Beans, Peapods, Avocado, Squash, Zucchini, Cucumbers, Olives, Corn Kernels, Pumpkins & Nuts. In culinary terms, though, most of these are vegetables - none of them are fruit. Mostly because none of these are sweet in the same way as fruit. I think tomatoes get brought up because their sweetness ranges between "vegetables" and "fruit".
- jillesvangurp 6y agoYeah, the Japanese language for classifying things as sweet, sour, salty, bitter, and umami might be more useful. But that kind of is the point here, a lot of this stuff revolves around these arbitrary classifications that we've used historically and culturally and you get interesting results when you mix that up a little. Which is why taking sweet and salty things like pineapple and ham and putting them on a Pizza is completely normal to some and offensive to others even when using other, similarly salty and sweet ingredients is considered normal to them.
- adingus 6y agoKnowledge is knowing a tomato is a fruit, wisdom is knowing it doesn't belong in a fruit salad. - unknown