3 ms·
And why does the author not support both? It's articles like this that make me wonder if the purpose of the basic income movement is to act as a sort of pipe d
by pydry 6y ago
And why does the author not support both?
It's articles like this that make me wonder if the purpose of the basic income movement is to act as a sort of pipe dream spoiler for more realistic progressive policies - like a $15 minimum wage.
Either that or a plan to make welfare "fairer" by ensuring that disabled veterans who can't work and tech millionaires get the same $ amount each month from the government.
Especially since the author accused the $15 minimum wage "burdensome"... this is incoherent given the cost of providing, yknow, money for nothing for everyone.
- Turing_Machine 6y agoI think the idea is that while both may "get the same amount", the NET amount is, in fact, smaller for the tech millionaire than the disabled veteran, because the tech millionaire pays a much higher tax rate.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe concern is that we're soon going to reach a point where "our current economic order" - the assumption that every healthy adult should have a full-time job - is unsustainable. I wouldn't say I oppose a $15 minimum wage, and I don't think the author would either, but we do desperately need to start thinking about our transition to a post-work society and I worry minimum wage debates are sucking up a lot of the energy towards that. We risk getting stuck in a terrible equilibrium, where many people can't get jobs but all our social safety nets are built on the assumption that they can. (There's a serious argument to be made that we're already there.)
- pydry 6y agoAmerica is at risk of running out jobs, not at risk of running out of work. It's all too easy to see a lack of infrastructure jobs, for instance, as a signal of a lack of demand. It isn't. America has crumbling infrastructure and a lack of jobs to fix it at the same time. China turning off the trade tap will likely also stimulate the creation of jobs. iPhones will need to be made at home at some point in the not too distant future and they will still need plenty of people to do so. Wealth re-redistribution will also stimulate demand, creating jobs. A lack of demand caused by a lack of wealth is not a "true" lack of demand. When society starts lowering the retirement age to 50 and nobody frets about inflation ever - THAT'S when you know that full time work is really drying up. Not happening.
- wpietri 6y agoWhy do you think we'll run out of things for people to do? The history of the last 500 years or so suggests that when old jobs get optimized out of existence, there's still plenty that needs doing. When I look around, I definitely don't see a society with no unfilled needs, so I expect we can keep going quite a spell.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoLabor force participation data (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11300001 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11300001) strongly suggests that a lot of people believe we've run out of things for them to do over the last century. (The overall chart https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART is confounded by the simultaneous trend of the womens' rights movement getting women into the workforce https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU01300002 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU01300002.)
- rhino369 6y agoDemographics impact this data, no? People in college, increased ability to retire, and an increase in the number of retire people (due to an aging population) all have an effect. What does the data look like from 1900-1948? I imagine WWII had an impact too. I would also consider whether the growth the welfare state is responsible for the drop--rather than just makes up for it.
- wpietri 6y agoI think that's a couple of misunderstandings together. One is that the only kind of thing to do is work at a job, which is what labor force participation measures. But that's not the case at all, and it's obvious from your second graph. Do you believe that in 1950 ~70% of women were idle, doing nothing? Of course not. They were doing all sort of societally valuable work. It just wasn't in the form of a paid job. And that's my key point here: there is plenty of stuff that needs doing that would make the world better. It's just that a lot of it hasn't been converted into paid jobs that would show up in a graph like this. Just try thinking about all the things wrong with the world and ask whether more people helping with them could make them better. Secondarily, a decline in the labor force participation rate can have all sorts of causes. The formal definition is "the percentage of the civilian noninstitutional population 16 years and older that is working or actively looking for work." Labor force participation rate for people 16-19 is low. Is that because there's nothing a teen could do? No, it's because they're in school. Labor force participation rate for people over 65 is even lower, ~15%. And over recent decades, we've seen that that segment of the population grow rapidly. So the labor force participation rate has declined significantly because people are living longer and enjoying retirement. And of course, there's plenty of overlap in the two factors. After my dad retired, he spent a lot of time volunteering at a school. The kids definitely needed the help, but he was unpaid. That's a great example of something for people to do that wasn't counted as part of the labor force. Similarly, my aunts spent a ton of time helping raise their grandkids after they retired. Because of politics and accounting rules, that's not a formal job, but it's absolutely socially valuable labor.
- imtringued 6y ago>the assumption that every healthy adult should have a full-time job - is unsustainable. Inflation makes sure that everyone can get a job. The fact people you even entertain this though is hilarious. The entire point of capitalism is to maintain growth and that growth can only be maintained by employing people. People hate on growth but what's the alternative? Imagine being in the 15th century and saying: This is it, people will never have a full time job again, ever. The 21th century wouldn't have happened if people thought like that. The dark ages would have lasted forever. The reason why we have so much underemployment is quite simple. Inflation has been way too low. Honestly, we have so much inflation to do that even the measly 2% that the Fed targets is way too little. Inflation has slowly picked up and it shows. Underemployment is shrinking in the US.
- akvadrako 6y agoA minimum wage is bad because there is work people want to do which isnt worth 15 an hour. UBI means people will be able to afford rent and food and engage in their choice of labor, even if it's not highly valuable work.
- pydry 6y agoIs there any evidence for this? Most sub 15 minimum wage work produces value far in excess of the wage. This value is then captured in profit margins and stock prices. The minimum wage also doesn't prevent people from selling dolls on Etsy or something if they really want to.