6 ms·
I wonder if the end game of higher education looks like purely administrative bodies with enormous tuition that just provide the students with leisure, varsity
by inglor_cz 6y ago
I wonder if the end game of higher education looks like purely administrative bodies with enormous tuition that just provide the students with leisure, varsity sports and regular events on the currently hot social justice topics.
I studied pure math in the Czech Rep. between 1996 and 2003. The administrative staff was about 10 per cent of the entire body of employees.
Reading that administrators actually outnumber teaching staff at some American universities today, I cannot help but ask what went wrong. This kind of bureaucratic bloat would make late Soviet Union blush and professor Parkinson rewrite his books.
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/feb/28/teachers-outnumbered-schools-administrators-suppor/ https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/feb/28/teachers-ou...
- foldr 6y ago> regular events on the currently hot social justice topics. This is a cheap shot and totally inaccurate. Do you really think UK universities are closing their maths departments so that they can spend more on the humanities?
- inglor_cz 6y agoNo, but this is the kind of stuff that can keep students busy and not asking whether they get their money's worth. A very efficient distraction.
- foldr 6y agoStudents wanting to get their money’s worth is exactly the root cause of this. Trust me, British Universities are bending over backwards to give students what they want. If you’ve been anywhere near a British University you’d know how ridiculous it is to suggest that the staff are somehow secretly organizing BLM protests (??) as part of a plan to stop students noticing how much money they’re spending (??)
- throwaways885 6y agoThe universities should cut their losses then, and tell students to go somewhere else. Part of the issue is placating every whim of students, focusing on the fluff and not on the teaching.
- foldr 6y agoI fully agree. It turns out that there are long-term costs to giving 18 year olds everything they think that they want for your short-term financial gain.
- inglor_cz 6y agoI noticed the general bending over backwards and I think the various political activities are a part of that. But you do not have to secretly organize X to benefit from it. You can just let the river flow and float on it. It is safe, non-controversial and does not require much effort.
- foldr 6y agoUniversities have been centers of protest for a long time, and extracurricular stuff has always been a major component of what attracts students. I don’t really see much connection between this and the closing of the maths department at the University of Leicester. Students these days are very career focused, and research is funded based on “impact”. These are the driving forces. The image of the student who cares more about radical politics than learning anything or finding a job is from the 1960s, not the 2020s. I’ve been in plenty of meetings where we tried to make students happier, and I can assure you that it’s all by boring means such as inflating grades and reducing workloads (and indeed by more worthy and less cynical means from time to time). Politics on campus gets a lot of press coverage, but it’s a marginal issue in terms of student satisfaction.
- GrantZvolsky 6y agoHaving studied both in Prague and the UK I can attest that British students are getting their money's worth of leisure and luxury. An interesting side effect is that the same facilities enjoyed by the largely native undergraduate students attract foreign nationals who made up 54% of the postgraduate and 49% of the doctoral student population in 2018/2019, and on whom Britain depends for staying competitive in this local optimum of an education system. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-7976/ https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-...
- walkedaway 6y agoNot sure how things are in the UK, but in the US, this is pretty much spot on. You'll see all sorts of curriculum pop up from grade school through universities to "teach" the SJW topic du jour. If Europe hasn't gone in this direction, well, that's probably why Europeans are so much better educated than Americans. It's gone so far that the SF school board is more worried about names of their schools named after American greats than they are re-opening schools (which have been closed in California since March). https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/san-francisco-mayor-london-breed-criticizes-school-board-s-covid-plan-as-they-rename-44-schools/ar-BB1d9uj7 https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/san-francisco-mayor-london...
- foldr 6y agoIsn’t this just a generic rant about so-called SJWs etc. etc.? I can assure you that US universities aren’t defunding or closing their math departments in order to add more humanities courses about hot social issues. You may not like what some professors choose to teach, but a quick glance at the numbers will show you that, if anything, everyone else is being sacrificed on the altar of STEM, not vice versa. Your second paragraph is about schools, not universities, and I can’t see how it’s at all relevant to this discussion.
- imtringued 6y agoIf maths departments have trouble retaining students then yes, absolutely.
- foldr 6y agoYou really think the money saved is going to the humanities? Could you provide one example of this actually happening?
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoSome people will only be happy when anything resembling a left-wing point of view is removed from education and the media. Some of the "ism" culture war teaching in academia is indeed trite and silly. But it's far less silly than Fox News and the entire right-wing media machinery - which most recently somehow managed to persuade tens of millions of Americans that a valid election was stolen, that Covid is a hoax, and attacking your own political representatives is a valid expression of democracy. Honestly, compared to that having to pay attention to pronouns or learn something about black history is a complete non-issue.
- ficklepickle 6y agoThat reminds me of my favorite saying: "-isms make schisms" I heard it from a Rastafarian in a documentary and I have cherished it ever since.
- hedberg10 6y agoThose who can't do, teach. Those who can't teach, administrate.
- ssss11 6y agoThis pattern of phrase is so condescending, and insulting to those who genuinely choose to enter a profession.
- hedberg10 6y agoThose who can't humor, virtue signal.
- choeger 6y agoUnfortunately, it contains a kernel of truth. I personally met staffers at my alma mater that worked there after failing to advance in their academic career but being too well connected to not have a safety net.
- netrus 6y agoI always considered that part of a much needed safety net for a professional where stagnation in the hierarchy is no option, but there are less positions at the top than at the bottom. So yes, a kernel of truth, but not necessarily a bad thing.
- djrogers 6y agoIt’s a bad thing when the cost of higher education is rising at rates 8-10x than inflation due to this excess administrative overhead. If you’ve been out of school for >10yrs, I’d strongly encourage you to look at the current cost of your alma matter - it may well shock you.
- choeger 6y agoTo the contrary. It might shock you to hear that it's still free.
- pydry 6y agoIt's part of the MBAization of universities combined with typical company politics (the more people under you => the more important you are => the more you get paid). It's a recipe for a lavishly paid executive class running universities who try to run them like a business.
- bilbo0s 6y agoI'll just throw this out here to put some numbers on this so people understand it's more than just a political narrative. At the University that I went to, Wisconsin, there are 2200 academic staff. (Professors, TAs, Deans, etc). The total number of employees, however, is roughly 21000. Now I understand that this is due to large, operations level bureaucracies that are necessary to pull off something like a University of Wisconsin. Facilities and Plant, Campus police, not to even speak of the big ones like DoIT. (DoIT is all the IT people. Network support, web developers, DBAs etc.) I get that. At the same time, that's almost a 10 to 1 ratio. Keep in mind, the University of Wisconsin is one of the more frugal universities out there in this regard. Again, I don't question that some of this is necessary, how much? I don't know. But having the numbers and the positions these people are employed in does put us in a better position to, at a minimum, have an informed discussion of the subject. I know that if the University of Wisconsin shut down the math department because the web developers and DBAs at DoIT had to be paid, I would definitely be someone who would assume that to be an unwise decision. Just putting myself in the shoes of the people who care about the subject university.
- qwantim1 6y agoIt could be about budget. It could also be perceived incompetence. If students don’t seem to be getting benefit from education by professors who focus solely on mathematics, then that problem needs to be understood. This is the second time this has happened according to the tweet, and the professors have been unable to defend themselves both times. Maybe someone should offer to assist in improvement of the program. It’s probably a fine place to work if they want to stay there this much.
- 6y ago
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y ago> leisure, varsity sports and regular events on the currently hot social justice topics This seems like a smear of people who care about social justice by implication. Why do you suppose they are not interested in education and research?
- rblatz 6y agoI think the key word is “hot”. Focusing only on shallow hot topic issues like who uses which bathroom feels good, but universities should be exploring the depths of social justice issues from a more holistic place. I went to university and never had to take a women’s studies class or an African American history class, so I didn’t take one. In fact no courses on diversity were required, I believe that has been to my detriment, and I’d be a much more thoughtful well rounded individual had I taken those courses.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y ago> shallow hot topic issues like who uses which bathroom This is only shallow because you have made it so. I could also say “shallow hot topic issues like bra burning”. Drop the strawman.
- mola 6y agoI think the current mindset of american universities is commodification of the concept of higher education. Teaching, scholastic tradition and enlightment values are sidelined by values like customer satisfaction, marketing, and money making optimization.
- the_only_law 6y agoIn this case, just let me purchase the fucking credentials without having to follow curriculum at their speed or pay for any of the things that won't benefit me anymore
- tillinghast 6y agoBut! Think of the middlemen! (sorry, middlepersons)
- lumost 6y agoThis mindset is ultimately what many universities are optimizing for. The credential is pretty meaningless if it can simply be purchased, people will catch on quickly enough. The ideal business is then one that actively inflates the credential's value while lowering the difficulty of achieving it. The best way to do this is to increase selectivity/restrict supply, raise prices, lower difficulty (grade inflation), and increase the time required to get the credential, while providing alternate activities for those who are inclined to do something other than receiving an education. Heck you can get degree credit by virtue of living in a foreign country via a study abroad program. The other activities a university may participate in like research, or educating only matter to the extent they enhance the "prestige" of the credential or to benefit the minority of students who value academic rigor more so than the credential.
- Balgair 6y ago> The best way to do this is to increase selectivity/restrict supply, raise prices, lower difficulty (grade inflation), and increase the time required to get the credential, while providing alternate activities for those who are inclined to do something other than receiving an education. A mission that the Ivies are well on their way with. The average grade at Harvard is a 3.67 (as of a 2013 source) and the prices have never been higher (though that's an individual thing, what with scholarships). They only need to make it a 5 year program with a MA/MS tagged in to get really going; degree-inflation hopped onto grade-inflation and dollar-inflation. Somehow, you then have to work Ultimate Frisbee or chess in there too, an athletics-inflation and club-inflation (?), so to speak. Kinda like Laurie Laughlin's daughter did with the varsity-blues scandal for admissions. I'd guess that's already happened then. What do you end up with besides an empty savings account? A 22 years old with a very good resume and a very bad taste in beer and jazz. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2013/12/9/stats-grade-inflation/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2013/12/9/stats-grade-inf...
- dls2016 6y agoWhile I disagree with your framing (only slightly), it has historically been the case that university is where the upper class spends their early 20s with the content of the education not really having a bearing on the direction of the students’ lives. I think we’ve done a pretty good job duplicating this model for the masses! Even down to the alternate justice model inside most universities. Perpetrate a drug or sexual crime? No big deal, just switch schools and start over! Takes a lot of admins to recreate the upper class bubble for the poors. I can’t really blame people for wanting this security for their children. Ultimately I don't think it will change until (at least in the US) we address things like universal healthcare, justice system reform and maybe even a UBI.
- whymauri 6y agoYeah, it's actually funny that the GP's characterization is more aligned with the historical/ancient function of colleges and universities than the current one. For many decades at a time, you could characterize the student body of legendary schools like Oxford as "Bands of bored and inebriated wealthy teenagers." For the best example, look no further than the St. Scholastica Day Riots, which started with a drunk angry scholar and escalated into a mob riot with nearly 100 casualties. [0] When not rioting against the villagers, Oxford scholars in the 13th and 14th century were prone to riot amongst themselves. Similar disagreements in the past culminated in lynchings and led to the founding of the University of Cambridge (to avoid more bloodshed from angry villagers, but also in part to avoid accountability for other kerfuffles). So yeah, wealthy teenager daycare with education on the side is nothing new. Edit: fixed a few historical inaccuracies, I mixed a few events in my head. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Scholastica_Day_riot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Scholastica_Day_riot
- Zuider 6y agoFrom your link: >The seed of the riot was an altercation in the Swindlestock Tavern in Oxford [ when two students became angry at being served poor quality drink ] I wonder if this is the etymological origin of the word 'swindle?' The online etymological dictionary indicates that the term was of German origin, brought to England by German Jews, meaning a giddy or untrustworthy person, based on an older word meaning to languish or decline but that seems incognate with its current meaning.
- mistersquid 6y ago> Reading that administrators actually outnumber teaching staff at some American universities today This is an issue in the US, but it is worth noting this particular administrative maneuver is at University of Leicester which is in the UK. [0] [0] https://le.ac.uk/about https://le.ac.uk/about
- cloudedcordial 6y ago> provide the students with leisure, varsity sports and regular events on the currently hot social justice topics. It's already happening. I went to a Canadian university. The marketing material says the school wanted to give the students a "great student experience". What's great student experience? The glossy pamphlets shows varsity sports facilities, bright lecture halls and students hanging out in residences.
- jancsika 6y ago> events on the currently hot social justice topics. Namespace collision detected: 1. a lecture series or seminar by a researcher specializing in social justice movements, civil rights leaders, abolitionists, etc. Possibly focusing on insights from newly discovered primary documents. 2. events hosted by any political college organization whose participants may be painted with the derisive term "social justice warrior" Definition #1 isn't an edge case-- most universities are chock full of such events and seminars. Shit like this: a linguist who was tasked with helping a Northern California tribe fill in the blanks in the documentation of their dead language so they could revive it. If your curiosity isn't peaked by that concept and it's associated practical challenges and sets of choices, I'm not sure what you're doing on HN. Definition #2 is like HN's version of cheating celebrity stories in the Enquirer. If you wanted to spend the rest of your life enumerating each case, you certainly wouldn't run out of bona fide material. But if all you talk about 99% of the time is that-- to the extent that you forget definition #1 even exists-- you have to admit at least part of your outrage is due not to your own free will but due to people clicking upvote buttons as if nudging trays of junk food close to where you're sitting. Edit: typo
- skindoe 6y ago> a lecture series or seminar by a researcher specializing in social justice movements, civil rights leaders, abolitionists, etc. Possibly focusing on insights from newly discovered primary documents. "Newly discovered primary documents" something makes me doubt that this is what the professors are looking into...
- laretluval 6y agoWhich of those do you think is more likely to draw a large audience? That's the one that will be more common.
- jancsika 6y agoQuick digression followed by rank speculation, but I think it will be useful-- What draws the largest general audience at colleges are sports. It would be reasonable if many HN posters wanted to critique college sports fans for diverting funds and energy from more important scholarly pursuits. It would be reasonable, if a bit odd, for them to do this by sarcastically nicknaming college sports fans, "Einsteins." It would be understandable if HN posters extended the sarcastic nickname "Einstein" to other domains to target people who ruin that domain by spamming it with superficial, loud-mouthed, low-effort pursuits. It would not be reasonable, understandable nor healthy if a critical mass of HN posters did this without knowing a) who Einstein is, b) the obvious fact that the nickname is being used sarcastically, and c) an entire department in every major college is concerned with an intellectual pursuit of extending the work that Einstein started. After all, hackers are supposed to understand the systems they hack! Anyway, if this were the case then anyone with even a passing interest in impugning the reputation of Einstein himself could then leverage that ignorance to do so. It's my rank speculation that "social justice" to a critical mass of HN'ers has become something of a backformation from "social justice warrior." E.g., an ignorant lurker reads a snippet about some historical figure from a social justice movement (or just a topic tangentially related to a social justice movement from the past), feels outrage over the superficiality and arrogance of SJW's, and unconsciously applies those same feels to whatever the conversation happens to be about. This happens all the time with memes-- e.g., Tim and Eric make a convincing "Free Real Estate" infomercial parody, parody becomes a meme, Tim shows up in a film, and Redditors mock him: "Hey, it's that Free Real Estate huckster guy!"
- proc0 6y agoThe end game of higher education is to become churches, recruit followers, and teach a religion. It even includes original sin.
- mathattack 6y agoThe selective schools can sell their signaling services and support massive bloated administrative groups. People will pay for the validation. Non-selective schools (like Leicester, which admits 80%!of applicants, of which only 20% choose to attend) won’t be able to pull this off. The signaling value is too weak. They can’t get you an interview at a top company. If they can’t prepare you for it, how many parents will pay for a 4 year vacation?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- prirun 6y agoIMO, the main problem with university finances is the easy loans and the fact they survive bankruptcy - the only loans I'm aware of with this status. Without this easy money, colleges and universities could not have raised tuition like they have, because most people couldn't pay it. But with the loans, colleges and universities are flush with cash, so they build extravagant dorms, hire way too many administrators, VP's, etc. My idea to fix this is to make the universities provide the loans. Then they have an incentive to make sure students graduate and have a career path that makes sense (and money!) We have allowed and encouraged an entire generation to screw themselves with these outrageous loans.
- travisporter 6y ago"Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice", which founded the study is motivated to magnify "bloat" in establishment institutions. The article preempts this criticism but does not refute it. A more honest study would try to break down what the administrative roles actually do.