23 ms·
I've known this for decades. When Bill Gates started publishing Smart Basic (or whatever) in magazines, I got a copy and saw what crap it was. I could do better
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
I've known this for decades. When Bill Gates started publishing Smart Basic (or whatever) in magazines, I got a copy and saw what crap it was. I could do better.
Why didn't I? That was my very first thought. The reason was, I had to work halftime to pay tuition and buy food. I was mired in working to live. Ol Bill had a family to support him as he bought resources (ads in magazines etc), recruited staff, took meetings etc. Always a hot meal on the table when he got home from a big day.
One result of a Basic Income: more folks can be entrepreneurs, if they're willing to live off that few dollars a month. It could make all the difference.
- fred_is_fred 6y agoBill's high school also had a PDP terminal connected to UW. Basically no other high school had that - which gave him an early head start.
- elliekelly 6y agoThis was mentioned in Outliers, I think. I wonder what the equivalent one-in-a-billion “head start” technology is for kids today.
- adenozine 6y agoCall me crazy, but I think if there's any HS classes or earlier, teaching algorithmic thinking, those kids are have a crazy head start if they choose CS. I don't mean these classes where they get out and write class Dog(Animal): def bark(self): print("a Dog is barking!") but if there's young people being taught the difference between quadratic/exponential/polynomial algorithms, that's going to stew in their brains and ferment into gray matter that will ACTUALLY make them better programmers. I'm not an educator, nor am I educated ABOUT education, but it's just my hunch. I've seen many a young buck come around with a fancy degree or whatever, and not be able to see a skip-list shaped hole for his skip-list shaped peg. That's hard to deal with at a meta scale. I can't develop a way to quickly train people OTJ how to think algorithmically. They either learned to think about the problems that way, or they learned to rely on some stupid Haskell/Python/Elixir/Kotlin/Blub thing, and can't get any meaningful work done quickly.
- DC1350 6y agoThere’s already a trend in certain high schools where kids start doing competitive programming, hackathons, blog writing, etc. way before university starts. By the time they’re college freshmen they’re ahead of the average new grad already when it comes to interview skills. These kids end up interning for FAANG or unicorns in freshman or sophomore year. There’s thousands of them.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> teaching algorithmic thinking Even outside of CS this will give them a huge head start. Functional decomposition is one of the most valuable skill one can have. Knowing what an interface is and being able to see a system as a series of layers of abstraction is too.
- dualthro 6y agoI would guess if your parents have a VR headset, a 3D printer, and some sort of home lab that you can tinker around with. And of course, as the OP indicates, without worrying about earning an income. edit: and probably also superfast internet, and a machine with a GPU, and maybe even some way of setting up a server cluster
- reidjs 6y agoMy prediction is it will be students receiving education i with little to no technology. The paradox being modern technology is so streamlined UX wise you don’t inherently learn anything about modern tech by using them.
- sjg007 6y agoMost kids still don't have reliable internet access and computers at home. So I would say that is still the biggest tech head start.
- cgh 6y agoNot exactly a technology, but parents who are mathematicians would be my guess. Developing a reasonably deep and intuitive understanding of statistics, probability and linear algebra at a young age would be a huge advantage, especially when coupled with eg R or Python.
- diogenescynic 6y agoAnd Bill's mom provided the connection to IBM. That's a huge advantage.
- throwaway2037 6y agoI logged in with a throw-away account just to refute the down vote. However, it already looks "neutralised" after my login. Assuming it is true, why would anyone done vote this comment? Makes no sense lah. Less controversial: High level, this comment seems believable. It seems reasonable and possible. Has this be written about? If yes, please kindly provide some links. I would like to read more about it. This high school was really something special!
- fred_is_fred 6y agoIt was discussed in the book Outliers. Here's another link I found discussing it. https://www.gatesnotes.com/About-Bill-Gates/Early-Days-as-a-Computer-Programmer https://www.gatesnotes.com/About-Bill-Gates/Early-Days-as-a-...
- souprock 6y agoHis high school was out of the norm, but certainly not the best. At that time, a school in LA had an IBM 360 mainframe. Having an oil rig on school property sure helps.
- segmondy 6y agoSure, and where are the rest of his classmates? Are they all billionaires? early head start is only one if utilized. For everyone that's rich, you can find critical junctions in there lives that really moved them forward to that part. for everyone that's not, we have all had critical moments in our lives where we made the wrong choice.
- birdsbirdsbirds 6y agoAs a programmer, it's possible to do the same, just one decade later. Jack Ma argues in some talk that people should gain experience before starting a company. This mirrors the numbers that show that older founders have a much higher success rate. After having worked for a decade, there can be enough money to handle some years without income. Bill Gates was not successful because he started young, but because his mother had the connections to IBM (see some other comment). That cannot be replicated with basic income.
- Bakary 6y agoNo aspect of a massively successful person's path can be meaningfully analyzed and replicated other than in general principles that are already obvious (be ambitious, proactive, etc.)
- nomay 6y agoWhat Jack Ma didn't tell you is that those things don't matter that much, it's more of a lip service to burnish his image, a victory lap. His father is well-connected both in business and politics and provided him access and opportunities plebs counld dream of. Hell he didn't even have any tech experience, he was a english teacher. And Alipay would have been killed a million times as it infringes the state monopoly on finance, had him not been shielded by the quagmire of local and central politics.
- SilasX 6y agoOr all the UBI money would pump up rents to the point that living costs make it infeasible again.
- epistasis 6y agoRents only get pumped up if we don't have enough housing to go around... in which case regular incomes do the same thing.
- iguy 6y agoBut we do have lots of housing, it's just located in places people don't want to live. Rents are high in places they do want to be, and that's partly a positional thing -- if you want to live where the top-10% of earners live, you need to bid against them for housing.
- epistasis 6y agoFrom this angle, a UBI is even more powerful, in that it will go a lot further in areas that are less economically productive, and let us use "surplus" housing there. Ideally we'd just let more people live closer together like they want to, but the elites won't let more people get close to them.
- rubicon33 6y agoExactly. The high costing of housing really has more to do with the type of person you've living around/near, than the house.
- PeterisP 6y agoThing is, requirement for on-site employment requires you to live where lots of people live; only the very wealthy can afford to live in places without jobs nearby - as UBI decouples income from where you live, then it would be a pressure to equalize rents, as underemployed people - the demand for whose labor is decreasing and will decrease further - can afford live in the many places which are currently shedding population because of lack of jobs despite being actually very nice to live in.
- abhiyerra 6y agoHealthcare and Basic Income would do a lot to encourage entrepreneurship. I had to also wait till I paid off my student loans. There are a whole lot of shackles if you come from a humble background to starting a company full time. On the other hand it has never been cheaper to start a side hustle.
- war1025 6y ago> Healthcare and Basic Income would do a lot to encourage entrepreneurship. I have a dream that Healthcare will someday be decoupled from employment. So much waste is tolerated simply due to the fact that the majority of the expense is borne by your employer before the number they put on your paycheck. I can live on a part time salary without issue, but health insurance, which is already $200/wk for my family with my employer chipping in, would jump to more like $600/wk, which is just completely untenable. There is no sane reason why health insurance should be my single largest expense each month.
- nemo136 6y agoThat is more or less what we have in France, it comes with other issues... like really high taxes. But we have many start-ups, which usually migrate to the US as soon as they grow big.
- danilocesar 6y agoYou know that your dream is actually the standard in every developed nation except the US right?
- war1025 6y agoThat's what makes it seem achievable.
- Someone1234 6y agoThey could even do this without too many major changes. Just three in fact: - Increase HSA Contribution Limit - Allow both Traditional & High Deductible insurance premiums to be paid with the HSA - Ban employers from directly providing/choosing insurance (ex. US Military) Essentially everyone goes out onto the open market and buys their insurance using pre-tax HSA contributions (similar to tax benefits to employers now). Employers can continue to "help" be providing dollars to HSA/HSA match, rather than picking your insurance for you. There are more radical and arguably better solutions, but if you want to see a large improvement with minimal changes/the least controversy this is it. Most insurance companies could likely just convert existing employer provided policies into employee direct ones paid via HSA.
- theinverseidea 6y agoI cant wait for basic income, because I cant wait to quit my job and focus on my ideas.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoI wouldn't hold my breath if I were you. As much as it is discussed and promoted in certain circles, it has basically no traction in national politics and its hard to see that it ever will since national level politics is currently pre-occupied with trying to figure out if crimes are actually illegal when their own party does them.
- theinverseidea 6y agoYou can tell from the downvotes that proponents of this idea believe people like me do not exist. We do. I welcome UBI and I will quit my job.
- koverda 6y agoIf you can't wait, start focusing on your ideas now. Chip away, one hour a day, every day.
- theinverseidea 6y agoOf course, I'm not complaining. Just stating plainly I welcome the opportunity to do it full-time.
- methyl 6y ago> pay tuition Going to college is not required to become a successful entrepreneur.
- danilocesar 6y agoWhile you have a few examples of drop outs (Zuck, gates, etc) the vast majority of those famous entrepreneur went to college. Not a requirement, but increases your chances a lot.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoNever mind the 99% (a guess here) of successful people that are not "entrepreneurs" but wealthy, successful. Unless we are only talking about Bill Gates.
- aksss 6y agoWhy are we only talking about the small percentage of entrepreneurs that become famous? Most are not and never will be, nor is that a requirement for entrepreneur success. That bar is entirely irrelevant to any conversation about how to encourage entrepreneurship.
- narrator 6y agoThe problem with most welfare schemes is they have big welfare cliffs. You make one dollar more than a certain amount and you lose thousands in benefits. It's the virtual equivalent of a greater than 100% marginal income tax. Also, countries with greater welfare programs don't have greater entrepreneurship. The opposite is somewhat true. Probably due to higher taxes and it's very hard to go out of business once you're in business and to fire employees in other countries.
- yardie 6y agoI know that France is the butt of many jokes about work, "no French word for entrepreneurship," but in my experience almost every business I interacted with around socialist Paris was a small, independent business. This was the unintentional consequence of labor laws. <50 employees fall under one set of labor laws, >50 employees you're in a tight spot until you're >1000 employees. Then the additional overhead of benefits for those employees is subsidized by economies of scale.
- sjg007 6y agoHaving UBI could loosen job protection rules and labor laws too.
- yardie 6y agoUBI and single-payer HC may be fastest way to unlocking capital to the lower and middle class. I know far too many smart people who stick with a job they hate simply because the group healthcare is the only thing keeping the individual or family from bankruptcy.
- Knufferlbert 6y agoI don't think those reasons are true for the "lack of entrepreneurship". I'd love to know some numbers actually, I know EU doesn't have as many unicorns like Uber, Google, Amazon, etc. But that is a tiny amount of people who started those (and now employ a staggering number of people). I think there are two reasons why that may be: - Generally larger regulatory barriers. GDPR is an obvious recent one, but also market complexity with EU countries regulations/laws differing more than US states. I think (without knowing). That coupled with "first to market" advantage of US companies. - Money isn't as big as a driver for Europeans. "Rags to riches" is a pretty American thing. "Get educated and live well" is closer to our lookout I think.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoI knew Bill Gates's family was well to do when he started with his endeavors, but I recently came to know Bill Gates Sr. was a prominent personality from Howard Schultz's account of him. The story goes like this - When Howard was offered Starbucks for US$3.8 million by original founders, he was working to raise funds for that and his current investors went over his back to buy Starbucks. Howard was introduced to Bill Gates Sr.(Lawyer) by a friend, who took Howard to the building where those investors were straight away and threatened them out of it immediately.
- hogFeast 6y agoGates was also introduced to Warren Buffett through his dad.
- aksss 6y agoIsn’t this a really bad comparison though? Most entrepreneurs own small (I mean small) businesses providing services and employment to a mostly local area. Bill Gates and his dad are not representative of most small business owners, and seem rather immaterial to a conversation about entrepreneur success.
- rasz 6y agoand to IBM CEO thru his mother. https://www.pcworld.com/article/243311/former_ibm_ceo_john_opel_dies.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/243311/former_ibm_ceo_john_o... "it was Opel who met with Bill Gates, CEO of the then-small software firm Microsoft, to discuss the possibility of using Microsoft PC-DOS OS for IBM's about-to-be-released PC. Opel set up the meeting at the request of Gates' mother, Mary Maxwell Gates. The two had both served on the National United Way's executive committee."
- Vaslo 6y agoWhile there will be a few folks that will prosper from basic income, I can’t say I’m interested in paying people to pursue things that are more like hobbies. For every entrepreneur or community volunteer that makes a difference, I fear 9 others will set their sights on being gaming streamers or will just sit around writing blogposts. If you aren’t adding value somewhere and are able minded and able bodied, I don’t want to invest my money in you.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> For every entrepreneur or community volunteer that makes a difference, I fear 9 others will set their sights on being gaming streamers or will just sit around writing blogposts. Providing entertainment and insight has no value to society?
- caskstrength 6y agoPeople who provide good entertainment and valuable insight already collect money through subscriptions.
- bumby 6y agoI really appreciate Jack Goldstone’s perspective on this. Instead of perpetual UBI, he’s in favor of a larger single lump sum paid out after a period of time post-civil service. The idea being instead of the slow morphine drip of $1k a month for life, you can get, say, $25k-$50k in a lump sum after serving a year or two in the Peace Corps, AmeriCorps etc. The advantage being service builds a stronger sense of community and gives you more skin in the game. Additionally, a larger single lump sum is more conducive to helping start a business as well as being cheaper long term. It parallels the GI Bill in a lot of aspects.
- aksss 6y agoI’m not sure that’s a good plan with such a huge dependency on financial wisdom. Look at Alaska - they have the PFD every year (well, mostly) and people just use it to buy TV’s, quads, and all the rest. You could say it frees up other income to pay bills, but I think generally people indulge themselves with lump sums of cash unless they are really struggling and have some good sense. In Alaska there are people who would favor switching the PFD to a monthly stipend rather than a lump sum to discourage this behavior.
- Aunche 6y agoIn that case, you would except a lot more entrepreneurs from Saudi Arabia. Instead, you have a bunch of freeloaders who outsource their work to foreigners. They started a UBI program a few years ago. Before that, they had a jobs program that essentially functioned as UBI, since it was nearly impossible to fire a Saudi citizen.
- AZRS 6y agoNot really, it can be multi factor, with a set of minimum values in several metrics being required before parental wealth becomes the dominant factor. To be glib, some people leave millions to their cats but I don't see any entrepreneur kittens..... That is, the baseline genetic, cultural, and environmental potential for entrepreneurship probably needs to be in place before familial wealth becomes so important. Given that Saudi Arabia has entirely different ethnic groups, with an extremely different culture, and a very different climate and business environment, I am not surprised at all that the principle factor in north American derived populations entrepreneurship isn't that in the Saudi Arabian population.
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y agoThis, times a large number. It doesn't have to primarily be UBI either. Given where we are technologically, it could be PV/wind/demand management/batteries on every roof, a semi-automated garden in every yard, etc... With a little bit of UBI for whatever people aren't able to do at home (eg TP).
- snarf21 6y agoThis is all very true but UBI isn't the solution. The middle class can win this game with a perspective change. Instead of saddling their kids with school loans and pressuring them to "get a job" right out of school, they should give them 5 years where they "angel" them in their own houses for a stake in the company. Get four young sharp kids a couple of years with no bills to pay and I bet they could create something viable. This is the difference. Entrepreneurs need funding and encouragement. Parents could play this role instead of VCs and they could bank big when funding comes. You don't need $MM to fund a start-up if you approach it will bootstrap principles.
- remirk 6y agoThis works with the assumption that parents have enough disposible income to fully maintain their children well into their 20's. Which isn't always the case.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoMaking the rich, richer and the poor just stay where they are.
- ilaksh 6y agoThat's the point though. You do need money for a startup and rich kid's parents give it to them.
- anovikov 6y agoThing is, elites are hereditary. They always will be. If we enable entrepreneurship (or education) for that matter for the poor, other social mechanisms will appear that will make both of these irrelevant so that elites are preserved. Which in particular? I'd rather not find it out.
- Geminidog 6y agoI mean who didn't know this? It's quite obvious that if you're in debt or are poor you're not in a position to start a startup. Meanwhile if mommy and daddy are billionaires you can start up a business and fail with no worries. Look at the extremes and the outcomes of the extremes. If the outcomes are opposite then it's quite likely that a gradient exists in between.
- danenania 6y agoIt definitely makes a huge difference to have savings if you want to be an entrepreneur. But these days, a decent programmer can save up a year or more of runway and build industry connections just by working for a few years and not spending outlandishly. If the startup doesn't work out, a new cushy job is waiting for you. So yeah, startups are risky and favor the wealthy, but let's not overstate the case. I'm in favor of basic income and I agree it would be a boon to entrepreneurship, but people with the skills to build a tech startup have already won the lottery. We're not the ones in need.
- advisedwang 6y agoRealistically a startup needs more than a year or two of runway for one person. It requires several years of runway for several people, plus paying for infrastructure, legal work, marketing etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pastage 6y agoThat means some extra years/decades off from your career, to get to the same level of security. So this is not overstating it, it just basically says if there is capital available ambitious ventures will succed at a more frequent rate.
- mhh__ 6y agoWhereabouts? I guess this might be true in the valley but in the UK for example I'd imagine you'd have to live off nowt for years to be able to do that - i.e. salaries are pretty horrific in some industries.
- pipipzz 6y agoAlso, getting a job after a startup failure might be easy in the US or other developed countries, but this will not be the situation in a country like India, where the supply of cheap labor far exceeds the demand and only people from elite university titles will be able to get back to a job better than their last one.
- Axsuul 6y agoWhy are we using Bill Gates as an example here? He is an extreme outlier that is far beyond the goal post of what most entrepreneurs would see success as. It doesn't require the seminal upbringing and kismet growth environment of Bill Gates just to get into entrepreneurship.
- Arainach 6y ago....but it helps a huge amount. That's the point of this article. It's much easier to risk doing a startup when you know that no matter what, you won't have to go hungry or homeless because there's family who will help you. You're a lot less worried about pouring dollars into your 401k at age 22 if you know that you stand to eventually inherit a few million from your parents, so whatever.
- Axsuul 6y agoI'm not denying it helps and isn't significant. But why do you need to inherit a few million just to feel secure enough to pursue entrepreneurship? Being an entrepreneur doesn't mean you have to go big or go home. There is just as much entrepreneurship with immigrants as there is with the US-born, with the former less likely to have a comfortable safety net.
- Arainach 6y agoOpportunity cost and time value of money. In general, if person A puts $5K a year into a 401k between ages 25-35 and then stops, while person B puts in $5K a year between ages 35-65, at age 65 person A will have a larger retirement balance despite having put in only 1/3 as much principal. This generalizes to the rest of your net worth (salary+stock) as well. If you win the lottery and manage to have significant equity in a startup worth millions, congratulations. If not, you're faced with the prospect of being older and having minimal (or at least far fewer) assets. This is a big problem if you want to raise a family or even if you want to advance your status in life. The economics of software are simply different. Someone good enough to start a business that brings in $10-20K MRR and barely survive is almost certainly good enough to get hired and paid $200K+ by any number of companies. If you're not going big or going home, it doesn't make sense to do a software startup these days. Even in other industries, starting and running your own business is a LOT of work. If your goal isn't to (try to) get rich, you can almost always make more money climbing some corporate ladder for a lot fewer hours.
- terryf 6y agoI am a son of a single mother, who was a teacher at the time. In a country that was just recently liberated from the soviet union. Trust me, I was not rich. Started my first company at 20, after dropping out from university. (mom wasn't exactly happy) Sorry, your excuse doesn't apply. Unless you want to claim that going to a state-funded university is a privilege, in which case I guess everyone in all the countries where universities are free are privileged?!?
- mgkimsal 6y agoThe term 'privileged' almost becomes meaningless when comparing between different countries/cultures. Yes, compared to many in the US, you were 'privileged' with respect to education, because you had free university-level education provided. This is something that is outside the reach of many who want it here, and for some who get it, they get it with burdensome financial strings attached. So..., in that respect, you were privileged. People in the US are 'privileged' in other respects compared to your circumstances. But using the word 'privileged' as some sort of singular distinctive quality doesn't make much sense.
- nec4b 6y agoFor one Bill Gates there are probably a million of other successful entrepreneurs who likely started poorer than you.
- mhh__ 6y agoOn top of the basic income idea I also would be perfectly happy to have the government fund little businesses in a similar manner - not a corporate basic income, but the next great business might be in the head of someone working for minimum wage in shop. Give them a few quid, keep an eye on them, see where it goes.
- complexmango 6y agoThis is amazing - just ignore Steve Jobs, Larry Ellison, Andrew Carnegie and several other of the richest people of all time who came from humble beginnings, just because they don’t fit your narrative. For the past 15 years I have worked with wealthy people for a living, hundreds of them. Two things stand out: 1. Most of them came from humble beginnings, typically as immigrants 2. Most of them stress their kids won’t be as successful because of having it too easy It’s alarming to me how much ignorance there is about real life outside of tech on hackernews, and how insidious academic leftist propaganda is.
- ilaksh 6y agoWell, forgive me for giving more credence to a scientific study than to your impressions of self-reported humble beginning from wealthy clients.