12 ms·
Long-term study reveals harm in regular cannabis use
- snypher 6y ago"and not be in a relationship at age 35". Get back to me with some real science, please.
- ta988 6y agoSociological studies are not "real" science?
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoYes, exactly. Real science does repeatable experiments. Humans are all different. There is no true control.
- subaquamille 6y agoBesides ethics - should we also stop calling science studies implying monkeys ? Non self aware animals as rats ? What about Ants or Coral ? Please defined "no true control" because you may only make science on Math then.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoA true control is a control group that is physically indistinguishable from the experiment group. You mention monkeys and rats, this is precisely why they use knockout mice for many studies and the same reason why demonstrating something in mice doesn’t always translate to demonstration in another organism. Math is a formal system, it admits no experiments.
- antegamisou 6y agoSeeing science, humans and control, cybernetics comes to mind. You're in for a surprise if you still hold the unsubstantial belief social science is not real science.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoIts a semantic debate and I’m gatekeeping “real science” to mean things that can be repeated and verified or disproven.
- mrbungie 6y agoWhat is "Real science"? May you're thinking something that follows a specific method or satisfies some specific requirements. If you want to challenge that view, see this: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-method/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-method/ PS: That's not to say that this specific study is not bullshit.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoI’m making the bold claim that science is about falsifiable hypotheses. Falsification breaks down in situations where there is no proper control.
- phobosanomaly 6y agoHere's a repeatable experiment in the social sciences: Do Conditional Cash Transfers Improve Child Health? Evidence from PROGRESA's Control Randomized Experiment Author(s): Paul Gertler Source: The American Economic Review, Vol. 94, No. 2, Papers and Proceedings of the One Hundred Sixteenth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association San Diego, CA, January 3-5, 2004 (May, 2004), pp. 336-341 From Section IV (you're gonna have to Sci-Hub it): "The randomization and the fact that the control and treatment samples are well balanced in the observed characteristics imply that a simple comparison of mean outcomes post-intervention will likely provide an unbiased estimate of program impacts. However, I also control for other observed socioeconomic characteristics in order to reduce idiosyncratic variation and to improve the power of the estimates." Is this really more sus than a cell bio paper? Are the conclusions so weak that it's not real science? Were you just being sarcastic and it went over my head?
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoIt’s not strictly repeatable because those experimental subjects are not identical to the ones you would use to repeat the experiment. Not only are they morphologically different specimens, but they are culturally/behaviorally different as well. I’m not being sarcastic, I’m being strict about what constitutes a basis for a valid generalization. > Is this really more sus than a cell bio paper? Are the conclusions so weak that it's not real science? Its not necessarily that its more suspect or weaker, but that it is in a different epistemological category. Its a different kind of evidence. When you inject particles into a cloud chamber, you believe with very high confidence that those particles have fundamentally identical properties as the other particles of the same kind. We know that humans are not alike each other in the same way as particles. Therefore we are not permitted to treat them that way.
- phobosanomaly 6y agoWhat's the purpose of being so strict about what constitutes that basis for a valid generalization? What does it ultimately accomplish?
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aksss 6y agohttps://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/8/27/17761466/psychology-replication-crisis-nature-social-science https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/8/27/17761466/ps...
- asymptosis 6y agoThe person you're replying to didn't say anything about whether or not sociological studies are or are not real science. Being unable to make that distinction, do you think you're in a good position to explore the scientific demarcation problem as it pertains to sociological studies?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rarefied_tomato 6y agoI don't think that statement is outlandish. Regular users might, say: - smoke alone instead of meeting up with friends - be less productive/successful - smoke as an aid for emotional pain
- antiquark 6y ago> It compared adulthood life outcomes at age 35, including alcohol use, tobacco smoking, illicit drug use, relationship status, financial hardship, depression, anxiety and employment status. As always, remember that correlation is not causation. For example, maybe people with depression or anxiety are using cannabis to self-medicate.
- joe-collins 6y agoAdditionally: > The research project followed 1792 Australian high school students aged 15 in 1992, investigating patterns of cannabis use across 20 years. So, mix in the confounding factor of it not being legal during those years.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- saalweachter 6y agoKeep in mind that correlation doesn't prove causation, but it does go along with it. Any time you find correlation, something goes along with it. Maybe A causes B. Maybe B causes A. Maybe A and B have a common cause C. Each of those is interesting, even if you don't know which is which from just the correlation. Consider if the data had fallen out the other way: if there was no correlation between these measures of harm and cannabis use, that would have been evidence of a lack of harm from cannabis use. So even if you can't draw any strong conclusions from this study, it's still an interesting data point.
- pintxo 6y agoIt might also just be a coincidence like the correlation of the "Per capita consumption of cheese (US)" with the "Number of people who died by becoming tangled in their bedsheets" [1] [1] http://tylervigen.com/view_correlation?id=7 http://tylervigen.com/view_correlation?id=7
- saalweachter 6y agoEh, correlating two time-series trends is almost a gimmick. If you saw that the per-capita cheese consumption of people who died by becoming tangled in their bedsheets was twice or ten times that of the baseline population, that could still be a coincidence, because hey, that's always a possibility, but it would be a much more suggestive correlation than just observing that any two monotonic time series correlate.
- dimeatree 6y agoBest way to sum this article: correlation does not imply causation. It is implying people who are regular users, are masking deeper psychological issues without going further into what the "harmful" effects are, of course if anyone is abusing anything it is because of a deeper problem.
- brdd 6y agoIf you're on HN, chances are, you're not very correlated to the sample from this research study... which looks entirely at correlation, not causation. I'm interested in a long-term study that identifies real differences in health outcomes, not just population bias.
- worik 6y agoIn the 1970s there was the Shaffer (sp?) study in Jamacia. Since then there have been hundreds of studies. Generally cannabis, and recreational drugs generally, have not much in the way of negative measurable effects. Remember it is only good drugs that have to be banned: There are no laws (generally) against Atrpine (datura), digitalis (foxglove) et. el. Just the good, fun, safe drugs have to have laws against them.
- adamjb 6y agoThere's no point banning it if no one's doing it.
- the_only_law 6y agoWell from my understanding a lot of the reason some of the “good, fun, safe” drugs were criminalized in the first place had to do with targeting specific groups. I don’t think there are any large enough groups crazy enough to use datura regularly the government would want to target lol.
- whalesalad 6y agoI can’t get the full study but from the summary this looks pretty weak.
- subaquamille 6y agoYou may want to click the link at the bottom of the article ;) https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/dar.13239 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/dar.13239
- whalesalad 6y agoThat’s not the full text. The full text is locked behind a paywall.
- betenoire 6y ago"Consequences" sure does imply causation, but this doesn't say that. It says "linked to negative life outcomes" which sounds a lot more like correlation to me.
- lmilcin 6y agoOr maybe the causality is reversed, and it is not that weed causes higher alcohol consumption but rather people who would choose to consume more alcohol would also be more likely to choose to consume more weed? Maybe there is no causality and only correlation? Has this been explained in the article? Maybe having paid job makes you use weed less (for possible consequences of being high at work)? Maybe cannabis doesn't cause depression but rather it is just correlated for some other unknown reason? That's again, very poorly written article by a confused author who does not understand causality and correlation.
- nickff 6y agoI am not sure that this study demonstrates causation, but most of the comments here reek of motivated reasoning.
- username90 6y agoYeah, there are quite a lot of evidence hinting at cannabis being bad for you long term, especially when used as a kid. Doesn't mean it should be illegal, but just like with alcohol or smoking it almost surely isn't good for you and trying to ignore that doesn't do you any good. https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/research-reports/marijuana/what-are-marijuanas-long-term-effects-brain https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/research-reports/mari... We wont know for sure until this bigger study is done, but if you care about your brain you probably should stop with cannabis until we know its safe: https://www.drugabuse.gov/drug-topics/adolescent-brain/longitudinal-study-adolescent-brain-cognitive-development-abcd-study https://www.drugabuse.gov/drug-topics/adolescent-brain/longi...
- ashtonkem 6y agoPart of the issue here is that anti-cannabis groups here have absolutely cried wolf. The stories of the purported harms of cannabis has been so long and ridiculous that most people instinctively disregard such warnings as nonsense.
- bawolff 6y ago> but just like with alcohol or smoking it almost surely isn't good for you I dont think we should compare the two so blithley. We have very strong evidence alcohol and tobacco is super bad for you, especially if you use it constantly. We have what is basically conjecture, rat studies, and correlation that doesnt paticularly control for confounding factors for marijuana [despite a concerted political effort to make it scary]. That doesn't make it "safe" but its just as wrong if not more so to say its comparable to things which we are very sure are unsafe.
- EE84M3i 6y agowell, we do know that combusting plant matter and inhaling the smoke is bad for any plant (although particularly bad for tabacco). For the actual effects of the active ingredients though it's definitely not clear cut either way.
- wintorez 6y agoHow much of this is correlation and how much causation?
- ogre_codes 6y agoEveryone I knew who used weed regularly in high school and college had ghosts. Either issues with depression, neglect, and lot of abuse. Sometimes it's not the drug use that causes the problems, it's the problems that cause the drug use. Not bashing folks who smoke weed here. I partake on occasion. But this study is bullshit. “Overall, regular use of cannabis – more than weekly and especially daily use – was found to have harmful consequences, regardless of the age people began using it.” Regular use of anything, particularly if it's mind altering, is likely to cause harmful long term effects. Particularly if it starts at young ages. That said, the study doesn't seem to even attempt to ask why these people were regularly smoking weed in their teens.
- fartcannon 6y agoI grew up in a place where nearly everyone smoked weed. It was more associated with your ability to socialize than any kind of psychological issue. This was an affluent suburb of a Canadian city.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoSounds like cigarette smoking in the 50s, 60s, 70s, and in some places even in the 80s. “Don’t drink don’t smoke what do you do?” Not cool if you don’t smoke pot. What crap. I wish I had known that when I was younger.
- justinator 6y agoI listened to hardcore music and danced very aggressively in the straight edge scene!
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoThis study followed "Australian high school students aged 15 in 1992." It was only last year that a single territory passed laws legalizing "possession and growth of small amounts of cannabis for personal use" [1]. There are a lot of confounding variables around this paper. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_Australia
- hprotagonist 6y agoWell i'm employed, i am happy with my personal life, and i don't smoke. I don't drink to excess, and everyone's depressed right now. So these are the sorts of harms i think i can ignore.
- techdragon 6y agoNever had any myself but know plenty who have. However as an Australian I want to point out that this study uses Australian people as it’s dataset. Therefore it’s tainted by the implication that cannabis is an illegal drug and the people in this study spent some portion of their life associated with regularly performing a illegal act... This is basically worthless from the foundation up since they can’t possibly account for all the ways this might have influenced a persons upbringing, from the socially acceptable nature of taking risks with the law, to associating with drug dealers who may (or may not) try to push harder more addictive drugs on their customers. It’s going to be a while until we get similar studies from the parts of America where it was made legal for recreational use, but until then, we have to remember that everything has been tainted with the implications of the subject participants in any study being involved in socially “unacceptable” illegal behaviour which is connected to a huge tangled web of second order effects.
- jonhendry18 6y agoAlso use of an illegal substance can lead to legal consequences that can harm one's employability for years afterward. So if pot weren't illegal in Australia during the period being examined, perhaps their life outcomes would have been better?
- eigenrick 6y agoPopulation bias. Correlation. Population bias. Correlation. Slow day in the academic universe?
- skierguy 6y agoYes, yes, yes. My advisor would have laughed me out of the room if I brought this narrative to her.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoAll of those things may be true. But the findings may also be true (just not supported by this particular study).
- account42 6y agoThe flying spaghetti monster may also be real (just not supported by this particular study).
- Hydraulix989 6y agoFrom the actual paper: "By the mid‐30s, both young‐adult and adolescent‐onset regular users were more likely than minimal/non‐users (63.5%) to have used other illicit drugs (odds ratio [OR] > 20.4), be a high‐risk alcohol drinker (OR > 3.7), smoked daily (OR > 7.2) and less likely to be in relationships (OR < 0.4)." So this study basically shows that cannabis users are more likely to experiment with other drugs -- meanwhile, the "less likely to be in relationships" factor might not even be statistically significant (the OR is < 0.4). I'm not sure how one defines "anti-social behaviours" either, other than conforming into some societal box.
- ttt0 6y ago> So this study basically shows that cannabis users are more likely to experiment with other drugs I didn't even need a study to know that. Why people are so in denial about cannabis?
- stretchcat 6y agoPublic school anti-drug programs told kids that cannabis use often leads to other drugs, and also said that it would make you peal your skin off to get rid of the spiders. They casually mixed truth with lies to create the most frightening narrative possible. But once the lies became apparent, everything they ever claimed came into doubt.
- pixelpoet 6y agoThis is exactly the non-argument people use for antivax, religions, cults, ... "who needs science when I know I'm right?" Anyone can say this about anything and it leads nowhere. There's a fundamental difference between beliefs stemming from faith (or gut feel, anecdotes etc) and results from rigorous and falsifiable experiments, even if they happen to agree.
- ttt0 6y agoIt's not faith, it's called experience. Every single one of my friends that regularly smoked weed, regardless of social or economic status, ended up using harder drugs. Despite the fact that we had a very strong culture of looking down on people using hard drugs as junkies. But sure, I have to deny my own senses, because they're not peer-reviewed and I should smoke weed by default until some scientists will tell me otherwise.
- yters 6y agoI've noticed a trend where if a study has unpleasant conclusions the people trot out correlation does not imply causation. On the other hand, a study with a pleasant conclusion is taken as evidence for causation in a preferable direction. E.g. a study showing positive correlation between atheism and IQ scores is considered evidence that atheists are that way because they are smarter than most people. It is a very interesting correlation, but guess I cannot infer causation in this case ;)
- dimeatree 6y agoThe issue with this study is that it is pigeon holed on psychological issues, which is not really a great metric to go by as all of our mileage varies and it really is an individual journey - if the study were more focused on the physical health related issues then this discussion would have a different tone.
- yters 6y agoWhat do you think the comments here would be like if the study found extensive marijuana use is strongly correlated with extreme happiness, strong relationships, and fantastic libido? Would we see as much correlation does not imply causation canard?
- kapp_in_life 6y agoReading these comments is strange. I thought it was well accepted that regular marijuana use in adolescence leads to all kinds of negative health implications. I'd be more interested in excluding daily users and seeing the impact of recreational use, say once or twice a week.
- oddlama 6y ago> “Compared to non-users, regular cannabis users were more likely to engage in high-risk alcohol consumption, smoke tobacco, use other illicit drugs and not be in a relationship at age 35,” Dr Chan said. [...] They were also at higher risk of depression and less likely to have a paid job. > “Overall, regular use of cannabis [...] was found to have harmful consequences, regardless of the age people began using it.” I am skeptical that this study is actually representative of the effects of cannabis, and does not instead depend on other, highly correlated effects, which are then presented as the reason. From my general (non-user) perspective, I would assume that there is probably a bias towards groups of people who have a higher chance to use substances in general, or live in a comparatively poor environment. For example: Children of smokers often become smokers themselves (as numerous credible studies show). If they now start with cannabis, they would be included as the victims of cannabis in the discussed study. However, the causality is probably reversed here.
- ehvatum 6y ago> Compared to non-users, regular cannabis users were more likely to ... not be in a relationship at age 35 In 20 years of various relationships, the only girlfriend who didn’t request that I quit smoking weed was extremely naughty and experimented with all kinds of substances, as she completed her residency at a children’s hospital. She married someone with more money, God help him. So, it doesn’t surprise me that people not in a relationship tend to smoke more weed.
- CameronNemo 6y agoThe use of the phrase consequences is so unscientific. Almost like they deliberately avoided writing correlation or causation.
- mpfundstein 6y agoone would assume they controlled for this. Its a scientific study. But then I've just finished reading the thread about scientific misconduct.... Not sure what to trust anymore
- rorykoehler 6y ago
- julienb_sea 6y ago"regular cannabis users were more likely to ... not be in a relationship at age 35" Well this is really a stab to the heart
- devlopr 6y agoI can't see how this study is measuring the harms of regular cannabis use. This is measuring how many people who experienced problems in their early 20s dealt with them. More depression / hard drug use / more likely to take weed daily / etc. Other headlines they could have used. Being a relationship doesn't affect your depression / hard drug use / etc Austrialians start using weed much later in life
- tqi 6y agoThe contrast between the discussions around the social media study posted earlier[1] and this study is pretty interesting. I guess it's only causal if it confirms one's priors? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25928310 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25928310
- abandonliberty 6y agoThe correlation vs causation arguments are most correct, but not as fun as inverting cause and effect. Because I don't have poor mental health, I don't use social media or cannabis. Poor mental health predisposes you for social media use. Would someone with good mental health really get deeply involved with those platforms? :)
- loktarogar 6y agoJust the fact that it's illegal in Australia puts a huge asterisk on these results.
- 2muchcoffeeman 6y agoI doubt that. I live in Sydney and all the people I know who smoke weed have jobs. I’m not sure how much they indulge but the illegality does not really pose a problem and I’ve never seen anyone deterred because of that. In certain areas you can smell it regularly. There was one street I used to walk down after work and the residents would be smoking weed everyday at the same time. Legal status is not stopping anyone.
- wpietri 6y agoThis study "followed 1792 Australian high school students aged 15 in 1992". I lived in Sydney 1992-4 and saw very little weed smoking. Legal status may not be stopping anybody now, but perhaps it was different then? Certainly here in California, legality makes a significant difference. Previously, my weed-smoking friends would have to have a connection to a drug dealer, and it was not what you'd call a convenient commercial experience. It's a different thing now that there are a variety of cheerful, brightly lit shops that anybody can just walk into. One obvious way that makes a difference to a study like this, which measures use of other illegal drugs, is that marijuana shops just sell marijuana, whereas I'm given to understand that drug dealers can connect their customers to a variety of stuff.
- loktarogar 6y agoLegal status is not stopping anyone from acquiring it, sure. The fact that it is illegal DOES stop people from deciding to try to acquire it or even try it. Like me, for example, when I was growing up. So that's instantly not including a segment of the population, and without knowing how big of a segment that is, the results are questionable.
- 2muchcoffeeman 6y agoThe people I know range from very casual users to more regular users. Varying range of jobs from professional to shift workers. I think you guys are really trying to poke holes in the study without having actually read it. If you’re covering 1792 users, that could be a decent cross section of society. Could also not be. But I can’t read the study.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoSo why are we legalizing it all over the US?
- skierguy 6y agoBecause the study pushes the narrative that correlation is causation, and that's just not true. The data is interesting, but the spin is irresponsible. Many people with mental health issues feel a stigma to seeing therapists and reach for something to numb the pain. Plus, just because something has percieved negative effects on life outcome doesn't mean we outlaw it. For example, alcohol, prescription meds, having children before completing your education, the lottery, cigarettes, etc.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoHm, good points. But maybe we should at least raise the minimum age ? ( I feel the same about minimum age of gun ownership ... don’t ban guns but raise the age ... how many school shootings are committed by 25 year olds? I digress)
- thisarticle 6y agoI’d much rather use THC/CBD than benzos. Look ‘em up and the withdrawal symptoms for each.
- 12bits 6y agoWas glad to be the opposite of this study, been consuming cannabis since 13-14 pretty much daily, a few breaks here there maybe 6 months total not consuming in that time span. Happily married with a kid and full time job. BUT I will say it became a crutch and a money sink. Heading into my 40s with the plan to stop daily consumption, currently only have CBD strains in the house, my friend likes to the call it methadone for pot heads. Wish me luck. The one person from our group of friends is schizophrenic and it was heavy cocaine use that seemed to have opened that pandoras box. He's many many years sober and steady eddy on his medication doing really well. Another friend is bipolar schizoaffective and his relationship with cannabis is toxic at best. He knows it's the last thing he should be indulging in, but unfortunately in his mind he can't find any other way to fall asleep. Heavy indica strains tend to bring on mania for him.
- zaroth 6y ago> He knows it's the last thing he should be indulging in, but unfortunately in his mind he can't find any other way to fall asleep. I used to use indica to sleep, due to absurd levels of restless leg that only kick in as soon as I lie down. Then a physician friend recommended trazodone. I really enjoyed being able to dream again. I hadn't quite noticed that I had basically entirely stopped dreaming when using pot. And mostly, I like being able to smoke purely recreationally and sporadically, not relying on it medicinally and regularly.
- acct776 6y agoThis is a VERY important topic of research that many users aren't aware of. Legalize for more research and better harnessing of this drug. Many strains of Cannabis inhibit REM sleep. Some do not, for some physiologies. Blue Dream does not block my REM. Interestingly, a small amount (2 shots or less) of alcohol will accelerate REM.
- 12bits 6y agoBlue Dream is a wonderful strain. I am (was) a sucker for Haze cultivars. There tends to be Haze in a lot of CBD strains. I live in Canada and we have legalization rocking already, a friend of mine works at a licensed producer, their sole focus is terpenes, the India vs Sativa and THC % is more marketing vs truth at this point. Wonder if the terps would unlock more reality into your points.
- sjm 6y ago> “This is particularly important for jurisdictions that have already legalised recreational cannabis, such as Canada and some US states.” What a joke. How many studies have been done on the negative effects of alcohol with no comment on the "importance for countries who have already legalised" recreational alcohol use?
- dukeofdoom 6y agoI quit smoking because I was getting gum infections all the time. It wasn't the only reason, just that last one that pushed me to quit. Inflamed gums don't feel so good. I still have a recessed gum line around a tooth where I would hold the cigarette. I have to believe that hot smoke from a joint causes the same type of irritation to tissue.
- bigsteve90 6y agoComments are proof the new anti vaccine group are people addicted to weed who bought into the “cannabis cures cancer” meme.
- missedthecue 6y agoI concur. It seems obvious to me that at the very least, pouring copious amounts of hot smoke into your mouth/lungs on a regular basis is not good for your long term health. It's humorous to me that so many of the 'pro-science' crowd become strong skeptics when it seems the facts might reflect poorly on thing they care about.
- AngryData 6y agoIt gets pretty confusing when cannabis itself is thought to have anti-cancer properties and the actual amount and temperature of the smoke is much less than that of tobacco. Yeah breathing in any smoke is not good for you, but is it like smoking a pack of cigarettes? Or is it like enjoying a campfire and breathing in a small bit of smoke? One is profoundly bad for you, the other is of such little concern that nobody should be worrying about it unless they have serious lung conditions.
- missedthecue 6y agoBreathing in campfire smoke once in a while is not a concern. If you are breathing it in day after day...
- annoyingnoob 6y agoSomething tells me that this study isn't representative of people outside of 'Australian high school students aged 15 in 1992'. My take away, make sure you are on a career path before you start your pot habit.
- quaternion69 6y agoIf it wasn’t for my habitual cannabis use, I’d probably have made twice as much money last year and have gotten a better job. Whatever — I guess half a mil isn’t that bad for a pothead.
- NalNezumi 6y agoThere's really nothing to discuss around this article. None of the point is new (Cannabis users in where it is illegal also showed strong correlation with other substance use), The strong claims are click-bait: >not be in a relationship at age 35 and it's light on any details or insight. It's a ridiculous hit piece with nothing but academic resume padding, but from none other than professors, that get amplified by shoddy journalism. Probably with some ulterior ideological motives (for funding maybe?) Most of all: It's not tech related. Why is this voted up so much?
- hombre_fatal 6y agoI think not being in a relationship at 35 is like BMI: it’s probably a good enough measure for most people, and the outliers can just excuse themselves. Single high value people at age 35 describes most long term expats I meet at the beach who have very little in common with most of the population. Btw look around, this isn’t just a tech forum that wants to debate JS and OO all day (just half of every day). It’s on the front page because we like talking about drugs. Though let me be the first to point out to you that drugs are a permanent passenger in the larger culture of tech.
- coinward 6y agoSomething ironic about U of 'Queensland' pushing out a study which could be used in justifying the long running prohibition and demonization of a medicinal plant by state authorities.
- Clewza313 6y agoFor our non-Australian readers in the audience, Queensland is generally considered the most conservative/least progressive state in the country, with the police service in particular embroiled in endless scandals around corruption, racism, violence, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queensland_Police_Service#Criticisms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queensland_Police_Service#Crit...
- enw 6y agoEvery stoner I know agrees long-term use has somewhat negative effects. (I smoke occasionally and enjoy it)
- mobjack 6y agoFrom my personal experience, it does have some negative effects especially if you do it daily. I would be more skeptical of a study that showed that cannabis had no harm.
- Joking_Phantom 6y agoGoing over the background of who did the study, the abstract, and their assertions, it appears they've made the classic mistake of correlation = causation. Nothing in their study supports their assertion of a casual link. Based on their alarmist and projective tone, they probably made this error on purpose in order to push an agenda for their own benefit. The fact that Rupert Murdoch's disreputable name is attached is only 1 of numerous red flags. Disappointing. Title of Article: Long-term study reveals harm in regular cannabis use Original Paper: Young-adult compared to adolescent onset of regular cannabis use: A 20-year prospective cohort study of later consequences Lead Author Dr Gary Chan, excerpt from Bio: "Dr. Gary Chan is a NHMRC Emerging Leadership Fellow at the National Centre for Youth Substance Use Research. His principal research interest lies in the field of substance misuse prevention and the application of cutting-edge statistical method for longitudinal analysis and causal inference." Methods: "A state-representative sample in Victoria, Australia (n = 1792) participated in a 10-wave longitudinal study and was followed from age 15 to 35 years. Exposure variable: Patterns of cannabis use across 20-years. Outcomes at age 35: Alcohol use, smoking, illicit drug use, relationship status, financial hardship, depression, anxiety and employment status." Results: "Substantially more participants (13.6%) initiated regular use after high school (young-adult onset) than in adolescence (7.7%, adolescent onset). By the mid-30s, both young-adult and adolescent-onset regular users were more likely than minimal/non-users (63.5%) to have used other illicit drugs (odds ratio [OR] > 20.4), be a high-risk alcohol drinker (OR > 3.7), smoked daily (OR > 7.2) and less likely to be in relationships (OR < 0.4). As the prevalence of the young-adult-onset group was nearly double of the adolescent-onset group, it accounted for a higher proportion of adverse consequences than the adolescent-onset group" Dr Chan says: "Overall, regular use of cannabis – more than weekly and especially daily use – was found to have harmful consequences, regardless of the age people began using it." "The study was conducted in collaboration with Murdoch Children’s Research Institute and the University of Melbourne."
- miirrorhouse 6y agoOne peculiar thing I don't think this study accounts for is the general climate around marijuana use in 1992 compared to now. For example, the stigma of being a "druggie", before it become more widely accepted in the recent years, could definitely lend itself to users building that identity around themselves. After building this identity that could further their likelihood of aligning with other "illicit" activities. TLDR not sold on this study.
- mathattack 6y agoI’m not a cannabis user. The conclusions may be correct but the report doesn’t separate causation from correlation. Murders are correlated with ice cream sales. Murders don’t make people binge on Baskin Robbins. Heat waves cause both to spike.
- damm 6y agoWhat I have read about the harm in regular cannabis use is related to how society has demonized it. It speaks nothing about the actual harms that Cannabis can have. Additionally if that is all the harm; fucking legalize it. Gutless cowards
- hellothree23 6y agoDuh.
- crawfordcomeaux 6y agoWhat if this is simply revealing regular cannabis use as a popular method for coping with trauma? Or connecting with oneself in an age of ever-increasing disconnection from one's body?
- httpz 6y agoIf you replace cannabis in the title with alcohol or tobacco everyone would have said "duh.." and move on. The difference is that the legalization of marijuana is a hotly debated subject so people's opinion on the health effects seems to be more affected by their position on legalization. If you showed this article to a Dutch person, they'll probably just say "duh.." then continue smoking their weed instead of tearing apart this article like a lot of people here.
- ipnon 6y agoWe should assert every person's right to engage in behavior where there is risk of bringing harm upon yourself, because every behavior carries this risk, and the presence of risk should not disqualify an endeavor from taking place at all.
- julienb_sea 6y agoThis really rings true to me. I've consumed cannabis over the past decade varying degrees of regularly, typically in cycles of a few months of daily usage followed by a few months of very infrequent usage. I've found when I am in a daily usage phase, I am overall more lethargic, less motivated at work, less motivated at fitness, and less motivated to go on dates. These problems don't entirely clear up when I am outside of a daily usage phase, but progress made in those areas tends to erode. This doesn't dramatically affect my life, I am certainly functional and overall productive at work and in my social life, but at the same time the findings make sense to me.
- Simulacra 6y ago"The study examined people who began regular cannabis use in high school or in their early 20s" I think this study should be taken with a grain of salt because of that statement right there. High school and even early twenties, we are still developing, and not everyone is going to develop to full adulthood by their early 20s. Anything that influences brain chemistry at that young age - be it drugs, hormones, etc. - is going to have lasting effect. I hope this leads to more studies about people who started later in life, say 30.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoVerklemmte Spaßbremsen! (uptight killjoys)
- mikkelam 6y agoAnecdotally, the worst effect I'm personally getting is from my mental health. There is this thought inside me that I should not be doing it and that it's bad for me. That is, psychologically, the worst effect for me, is my own mind punishing me for it. Due to that I have been quitting on and off.
- leesec 6y agoYeah I know, but I'm an escapist and I like my liver.