42 ms·
WhatsApp loses millions of users after terms update
- asiachick 6y agoI'd be surprised if many of them didn't just come back. It's kind of hard to give up talking to your friends or being part of some group who communicates in a whatsapp shared thread
- ademup 6y agoAnecdotal: my tight group of 12 tech-unsavvy friends very trepedatiously migrated to Signal after the terms update and I said I'm bailing on WhatsApp whether you're coming with me or not. As soon as the group came over, I got tons of "wow, I like Signal better!". Then the outage happened and I was worried, but everyone stayed and I strongly doubt will go back. Though some do keep WhatsApp for other friends, I think our litte migration will actually cascade into more.
- boringg 6y agoI'd agree with this - so many of my non-tech friends are now on signal and seem to like it. The traction that Signal is getting right now feels like its the classic word-of-mouth organic growth that snowballs quickly. I bet their engineering team is getting stretched right now.
- godelski 6y ago> I bet their engineering team is getting stretched right now. Last week servers were unstable for about 24hrs. But they did grow by about 10x in approximately a week's time, so that's not entirely surprising. I think it's more surprising that they've been so stable so far.
- boringg 6y ago100% this. That's what I mean - I bet their team is just slammed with all that growth and pressure on their systems.
- meibo 6y agoHow technical is that group? My family isn't and they've noted a few times that Signal feels sluggish(therefore not enjoyable) to them and missing stuff they enjoy on WhatsApp, like statuses.
- xqNbcB8oqZ 6y agoA group of my tech-unsavvy friends were enraged by the privacy policy update and decided to move from Whatsapp too, but decided to move to telegram instead, in spite of me warning that telegram is not encrypted and that if privacy was your concern you should consider signal. I bet they didn't read the privacy notice update and I wouldn't be surprised if they got their information from some Whatsapp forward that misinformed them about the actual contents of the privacy update, ironically. Turns out there's a lot of misguided and uninformed people too perhaps worse off now than when they used Whatsapp in terms of privacy considering telegram isn't end to end encrypted.
- wyattpeak 6y agoI agree few people are going to switch immediately and permanently, but I reckon they've created a long-term drain on their userbase. The policy change prompted me to finally download Signal (as apparently it did a lot of people), and while I'm currently using both side-by-side and will continue to for the foreseeable future, given the choice I'll be suggesting Signal from here on out.
- rainyMammoth 6y agoThe shift over the last few days is that where WhatsApp was seen as the default way to communicate, Signal now became the default. I'm still on WhatsApp but reduced my usage by 95% in favor of Signal now that most of my thread or individual users switched to Signal. It will take time but hopefully WhatsApp will become irrelevant in the long run. It was very entertaining seeing all my group chats move one by one to Signal now that there is a critical mass of users that agree that it is the right choice. I tried to make it happen in the past and it was too much a pain to convince people that Signal was way better than WhatsApp.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corty 6y agoThat's why ToS and privacy policy must be readable for John Doe. If it isn't clear what will happen with users' data, rumours and theories will grow. That will hurt your business like WhatsApp just shows (although I'm not sure Facebook will care all that much, to them it's just a drop in the bucket).
- wyattpeak 6y agoI think Facebook would be unwise not to care, and whatever else they may be I don't think they're unwise. All of their products trade on enormous network effects, so I think they'd be very aware of maintaining that barrier to entry for new competitors. They've stumbled badly on that front here, and once competitors gain a foothold it'll be hard to keep them out.
- ketamine__ 6y agoNetwork effect is the moat that is insurmountable according to those that believe big tech should be regulated like a utility. If a new TOS policy with a bunch of legalese can damage the moat I would say the moat is pretty vulnerable. It seems less clear that the market can deliver a solution for people that post untrue things on the internet.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Network effect is the moat that is insurmountable according to those that believe big tech should be regulated like a utility. The network effect in messaging apps is significantly lower than it is in other cases because people are not going to carry two brands of cell phone in their pocket but they very well might have five different messaging apps on their phone. > It seems less clear that the market can deliver a solution for people that post untrue things on the internet. It seems less clear that anything could do that ever.
- chopin 6y agoIt's even less clear if you would like that solution even if it exists...
- aninteger 6y agoThey have 2 billion users though, so I doubt they care if they lose a couple percentage.
- dorkwood 6y agoI think it's only a couple of percentage if you round up.
- Taek 6y agoPrivacy policies are unenforceable because social lock-in means you can't leave even if you eventually decide the new policies are bad for you. I don't want Facebook to get my list of contacts, but I also don't want to lose touch with my extended family. Guess which one is more important to me?
- sfg 6y agoI deleted WhatsApp and moved to Signal and many contacts followed. Not all, but most. If the momentum continues, then the rest will follow. Viral growth and shrinkage means this is one case where being the change you want to see can have immediate effect. If you can, try it. If it doesn't work, you can always go back to WhatsApp in a few months.
- Taek 6y agoA lot of people have had success moving their friends to signal, and that I think that is very encouraging. Well done to you, and certainly I'm trying to do my part as well.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoBelief that you depend on Facebook to stay in touch with your family is so misguided and sad. No matter where you live in the world, you don’t need Facebook, not at all, not one bit. It requires absolutely zero extra effort to stay in touch to exactly the same degree, see all the photos, send all the messages you want, with dozens and hundreds of other global services that all your contacts, even tech-phobic grandma, already can super easily interact with. I have never had a Facebook account, yet I still keep in touch with all the many contacts in my network from high school, college, past jobs, global extended family, immediate family, OSS project acquaintances, etc. etc. - all with zero Facebook. This utterly false myth that Facebook is necessary, or even the slightest bit important or even useful, to keep in touch very closely with all the photos, comments, etc., really needs to die. You can completely delete Facebook on a whim right now, and 100% of all that stuff is just as immediately, easily achievable right away with zero loss or deficiency from removing Facebook.
- hit8run 6y agoWhy should our communication belong to one company? Makes no sense to me. Therefore start using signal and try to spread the word. E-Mail is an open Standard. Instant messaging can be too!
- Taek 6y agoSignal is hosted over centralized servers, I don't think it's that much of a break from the status quo in terms of control. That's not to say it's not the best out there. As a company, Signal is a million times better and more deserving of our trust than almost any other option on the market, but if we want to break out into open communications, the Signal protocol needs better decentralization.
- godelski 6y agoIn theory I like the idea of decentralization but in practice I haven't seen it work out well. For example email didn't become prolific until large centralized players became the dominant force. I see federation/decentralization being better as a late feature in software. Through centralization you can move a lot faster, which in the case of Signal is extremely useful. They wouldn't be able to provide the product they have with decentralization. That's why Moxie has been against decentralization. Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't see chat apps as having an unbounded number of features. As I see it once Signal moves into more of maintenance mode then we can talk about federation, by allowing outside servers being able to communicate to the main Signal server. But for now it seems better to focus on getting people to the platform and if we're talking about it from a privacy and security point of view, this is the higher priority. Decentralization doesn't provide much more security while Signal is still trustworthy. There's bigger fish to fry right now.
- Taek 6y agoFor what it's worth I think you are wrong. Decentralization is a complicated technology that needs a lot longer to mature than I think most people realize. But once it is mature - and we're getting close, imo just a few years left - it'll move way faster and more efficiently than the centralized world ever did. In many ways it feels like decentralization is the same as discovering the internal combustion engine before modern alloys existed. We have to invent a lot of extra stuff to make decentralization practical, and we will, but the vision definitely started many steps ahead of the technological progress.
- tarruda 6y agoThis mainstream concern with privacy is somewhat ironic, considering most people already put all their personal info on Facebook and Instagram
- drcross 6y agoPersonal info is not the same as my constantly generated stream of data.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoBefore we jump to conclusions: 1) Downloads are not usage. 2) One month _in one country_ is not a pattern. 3) If we believe WhatsApp has two billion users, "millions" - while subjectively significant - is objectively minor (at this point).
- f430 6y agolooks like facebook is getting a lot of pushbacks recently. VR too.
- dmurray 6y agoI wonder if it's really lost users, or conversations. The article only cites download numbers declining in the various app stores. Lots of people seem to have downloaded Signal or Telegram, but how many deleted WhatsApp? I don't plan on deleting it and I'm going to approve the new T&C or whatever it is, but I'm quite happy to migrate to Signal for my contacts who use both. Presumably losing x% of conversations is just as bad as losing x% of monthly users for Facebook, so maybe this is moot, but it's still lazy journalism.
- bla3 6y agoIf we're doing anecdotes, I deleted my account after all my contacts moved to signal.
- davchana 6y agoCall it toc insensitivity, or habit of last 20 years, but as soon as I saw that new TOC when I opened whatsapp about 20 days ago, I didn't even look at the button text, just clicked it as soon I read app.. of Approve. Wonders of auto pilot brain.
- bassman9000 6y agoI instructed my family how to do it today, both deleting account, and deleting the app. They'll go and tell the people in their groups, which in turn they'll tell theirs. By this point they all have signal and/or telegram, and they've set it up themselves, parents included. Again, they are spreaders. It's not like whatsapp is disappearing. But you can bet they're losing millions of accounts.
- outime 6y agoWhatsApp worldwide usage is estimated to be more than 2B+ users. Even if this article is accurate, it doesn’t really mean much. In the HN bubble lots of people have migrated to Signal with all of their contacts but outside of that bubble nothing much seems to be happening. Note that I’m not agreeing with these changes, I’m just observing reality. To put things into perspective, let’s assume that 25M users (as stated in the article) actually moved to Telegram - which I use and like by the way. Let’s assume they fully moved and stopped using WhatsApp (very unlikely). That means less than 1.25% users moved to another platform - and this means assuming many things that aren’t probably real. It reminds me a bit of the articles about DuckDuckGo vs Google where many people think big changes in usage are happening while ignoring that the average Joe will keep using whatever it’s using unless there’s way too much trouble to continue using it.
- calvinmorrison 6y agoThe extremely positive side of this is that you can be a 'competitor' to Google, or other megaservices and steal enough customers to run a 10M+ user company and they woudln't even register you as a competitor. The internet market is HUGE.
- emptyparadise 6y agoPerception matters. You can't get to two billion without getting to 25 million first.
- outime 6y agoWe could also say 1M and still be a valid statement. I don’t know if that tells anything though. Perception does matter a lot, and that’s why I used the 1% figure. It means one percent of WhatsApp users are investigating a competitor (not even deleting their account in WhatsApp, but I guess few did) and here people seem to see it as a clear tipping point to which I disagree - raw numbers don’t mean much if you have nothing to compare with.
- addicted 6y agoThe problem is that what makes Whatsapp sticky is the network effect. People use Whatsapp because everyone has Whatsapp. But if you now have several millions of people who will not use Whatsapp at all, all the groups that they are in will need to migrate to the alternative (which is pretty much Signal/Telegram at this point). So those few million become few tens of millions. And once they migrate and start liking it, they may avoid Whatsapp as well, because it's far easier to just use one app, and then their groups need to migrate, and so on. Edit 1: Added Telegram as an alternative.
- richardw 6y agoIt’s not just the numbers, it’s who they are. Having a good portion of the tech/media scene move to Signal, even if it’s just conversations and intent, shifts the needle. Impact is more influential than most other segments. I do worry about the move to Telegram. I’ve seen large law firms and privacy experts defend WhatsApp in comparisons to Telegram. I could easily see WhatsApp get those users back.
- febin 6y agoThey should have been nice, instead of communicating agree with their terms or go and delete your account. It's a lesson. No matter how big you are. 1. Communicate for understandability. 2. Don't take your customers for granted. 3. Change is hard, nudge them towards it instead of a push.
- yalogin 6y agoI don’t think they really will lose any users, and in fact this whole saga is a big loss for privacy. FB will see that there is a lot of discussion but at the end of the day no real loss is users or traffic and so realizes it has a large moat and so don’t have to do anything to improve privacy. I tried really hard to move people away but they always come back to it, particularly for groups across continents WhatsApp is really entrenched.
- darig 6y agoFacebook bought WhatsApp for their user connection graph data and logs. They had no intention to grow or continue running the service.
- aerosmile 6y agoI understand why FB needs to do this, but the execution was so out of touch it's bizarre. My elderly parents called me and were alarmed that WhatsApp is threatening with removing their account unless they agree to share their data. They wondered if FB will be able to track their transactions or perhaps even get into their bank accounts. After years in the tech industry, I've learned that my parents' feedback is a good predictor for how well my messaging will be perceived by the wider world. I would have assumed that at FB they would do something similar (or rather, that their testing is 100x more sophisticated), so it's bizarre that they would miss the mark with messaging and with their prediction of overall success when it came to something so strategically important and sensitive.
- FreakyT 6y ago> the execution was so out of touch it's bizarre This more or less describes Facebook's entire corporate ethos at this point. Almost all of their products are now clearly driven by PMs who are so focused on random metrics that they make various awful tweaks to the UX, all of which are clearly intended to drive some metric. Case in point 1: Instagram replacing the "notifications" counter with a link to their "shopping" function that no one wants or uses. Case in point 2: Trying to add a GIF on Facebook messenger opens up another entry point to Rooms, the video chat. No one is going to start a video chat from the keyboard, Facebook. (Then again, I'll bet 0.5% of users accidentally started one, so the metric is up! Ship it!)
- aerosmile 6y agoI think when it comes to your point 1, they deserve a bit more credit - the prioritization of Shopping is a reaction to the threat of iOS 14-related loss of targeting capabilities. The only viable long-term response is to keep the entire user flow within the app, from click to checkout. While hiding the notifications will impact some engagement metrics, nothing is as important right now as achieving the above goal.
- leokennis 6y agoThe thing is, how useful is an app with a shopping-button and no notifications-button, if no one uses it anymore? Walmart would be way more profitable if every item was $100. But then no one shops there anymore. So you need to walk the line between serving your users and serving your bottom line.
- donw 6y agoAnecdotally, my entire EU rolodex has shifted from WhatsApp to Telegram and Signal over the past month. Now, my friends-and-neighbors lean heavily towards the software industry, so this most likely does not translate immediately across WhatsApp's entire EU user base. On the other hand, software people tend to be on the leading edge of new trends in technology. Europeans tend to care a lot more about privacy than their American counterparts, and I doubt that Facebook's rather ham-fisted approach towards EU markets and their associated regulators is going to play well in the medium-to-long term.
- christophergs 6y agoThis feels different. My non-tech friends, who I've been badgering to switch to Signal for years with no luck, suddenly just all started agreeing to switch.
- decrypt 6y agoSame situation in my circles two weeks ago, but the hype has died. Folks are back on WhatsApp. Some even moved to Telegram, which is a downgrade from WhatsApp, in terms of privacy. Signal's ranking on the app charts has fallen as well, that it's below the top 10 list.
- marketingtech 6y agoI'm not an expert in antitrust, but I feel like this gives Facebook a stronger defense against governments trying to break up the company. "Look at all the other messaging options out there with millions of users! If people don't like our decisions, users have shown that they can easily leave us for our competitors."
- kortilla 6y agoAnti-trust isn’t as simple as “look how easily users can switch”. Microsoft got busted despite how easy it was to get another browser because they leveraged their position of power to push IE.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoUnfortunately anti-trust has become synonymous with whatever scores the administration at the time feels like settling.
- wilsonfiifi 6y agoBefore this, not many people had a reason to even think of having an alternative to whatsapp. Now, that conversation has begun and more folks are installing alternative chat apps. It's not an exodus, it's more of a transition. The main point is, the average Joe has realized there are other options beyond Whatsapp and is more willing to now explore them.
- system2 6y agoWhich average Joe? I have 100+ friends on whatsapp, I asked some if they are planning to use another app and not even one knows what's going on. I assure you, 99% of the userbase click whatever popup comes blindly.
- agumonkey 6y agoWho else got a Google Play notification about this 'communication app' suggestion who turned out to be WhatsApp ?
- gdelfino01 6y agoBesides the terms update, the recent Facebook censorship in the USA has pushed many people to migrate away from WhatsApp just because it is owned by Facebook. BTW, I deleted by WhatsApp for this reason and convinced my family group about it too. My wife and her family also migrated to Signal for yet another reason. The audio quality of the voice calls is much better.
- f430 6y ago"You won't be required to login to your Occulus Rift" "You won't need Facebook to use Whatsapp" "You won't need Facebook when I'm president"
- anonytrary 6y agoI joined Signal and maybe 5% of my contacts are on signal as of right now. I don't think the critical mass is there yet, but I hope more people make the switch. I effectively cannot use Signal unless my main contacts are on it, which they aren't. The best thing I could do is try and convince all of them to move to signal so we can group chat on Signal instead, but it's a hard sell, despite the fact that most of the people I actively talk to are in tech or academia. I think many people are probably fine with moving from Android messenger or WhatsApp, but it is going to be extremely hard to convince the Apple folks to stop using iMessage (or whatever they call it). Apple has also been working hard (e.g. green texts) to ensure that people stay on or convert to iMessage.
- cortesoft 6y agoWhy do you want people to stop using iMessage?
- pmlnr 6y agoBecause it's ios only?
- andrewzah 6y agoThe short of it is group chats lose functionality when even 1 non-apple user joins, and apple works hard to make sure you can't use imessage on other devices. It's so frustrating. I want to like apple and their approach to privacy, but then they do stuff like this that alienates non-apple users. Anyway, imessage is like a caveman compared to messaging apps like Kakaotalk and LINE. Those have more features and I like group chats on them much more than I do on imessage. Not that I had a choice; I don't think I ever got my Korean friends' actual numbers because everyone uses Kakaotalk. [0]: https://www.androidauthority.com/green-bubble-phenomenon-1021350/ https://www.androidauthority.com/green-bubble-phenomenon-102...
- screamingninja 6y agoFor one, it happens to be a walled garden.
- ronnier 6y ago
- hoppla 6y ago« She said that update was intended to do two things: enable a new set of features around business messaging, and “make clarifications and provide greater transparency” around the company’s pre-existing policies. “There are no changes to our data sharing with Facebook anywhere in the world,” Sweeney said.» This is worrying - does she say that the policy was updated to reflect what they already was doing?
- hadrien01 6y agoThat's a quote from the director of public policy for Europe, and the new terms don't apply in Europe.
- beagle3 6y agoWhatsApp and Facebook have been sharing metadata since about 1 year after the acquisition (so, 5 years already). They weren’t public about it, but they have acknowledged it. I don’t know if that applies to Europe as well; they promised European regulators they wouldn’t, but (a) it was before GDPR, and (b) it’s easier to get forgiveness than permission. If I had to guess, I’d say they have shared it for Europeans before GDPR and perhaps stopped since. Perhaps not. And perhaps they have this weird bug that copies WhatsApp metadata to Facebook, like many other accidental bugs that help their cause.
- gmueckl 6y agoFacebook agreed to not share WhatsApp data with other products as part of the agreement that gave them the EU regulator's permission to take over WhatsApp. If they shared data, it would have been a breach of that agreement.
- beagle3 6y agoThey have shared data. I believe it was even acknowledged publicly (and especially now, with the “the tos change actually reflects practices”). They’re ignoring GDPR and a variety of other laws; why would this agreement be different?
- mlang23 6y agoCan confirm. Deleted WhatsApp the day the TOS-changes-dialog popped up. Got a number of "So-and-so is now new in so-and-so" messages from telegram and signal. This is not just a HN bubble. Many people in my network just dumped WhatsApp and moved on. Good. Downgraded my mother from WhatsApp to SMS regarding contacting me, which is actually an advantage since now she can't share stupid videos with me anymore. All in all, win-win for everyone.
- ThePhysicist 6y agoDrop in the bucket. I'd say 95 % of users probably didn't even think twice about the new terms and conditions.
- usremane 6y ago> Signal has gained 7.5 million users globally It does not mean they use Signal. Because of the bubble, many of my friends have installed Signal, including myself, but continue to use Whatsapp. I personally use whatsapp only for very close people and I don’t want to break the chat history so switching to any other app is a bit disconcerting.
- anonytrary 6y agoI have installed Signal and do not use it because none of my friends are on it yet. A critical mass is required before I can start using it. You can't migrate group chats from platform X to Signal until everyone in the group is on Signal. This isn't bad news really, as long as people continue installing Signal, eventually I'll be able to start group threads on Signal. I guess it is only a matter of time, assuming more people continue downloading Signal. I think the easier sell is to just get people to install it -- they don't have to use it right away. Then the early adopters can start group threads and chats as they become possible, which will start the shift from other platforms to Signal (assuming people continue installing Signal, of course).
- andy_ppp 6y agoMy plan to help make this happen is just to respond to any WhatsApp messages with “You can find me on Signal... https://signal.org/install” https://signal.org/install” people seem to be installing it so far.
- hans1729 6y agoI've set my Whatsapp status to "I'm not using WhatsApp anymore, please contact me on Signal or on this email: ..." and uninstalled WhatsApp
- qwerty456127 6y agoThat's amazing! It means millions of users have some idea about digital privacy, actually value it and are ready to do something for it. I used to pessimistically believe that's just a handful of geeks.
- nobrains 6y ago*temporarily
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 1ncorrect 6y agoFriends don’t let friends use Facebook.
- tonymet 6y agoAudience engagement follows Pareto distribution. For those saying "it's only 1 % or 0.1 %" – that could mean 10% of your overall engagement depending on who leaves
- trabant00 6y agoWe can see from past examples that market share has big inertia. Even in cases where the top choice was under performing by a large margin it took years for majority of users to make the switch. Think about examples like Internet Explorer, Yahoo Mail, Windows on servers, etc. We can also see from those past experiences that at first a very small minority of - let's call them power users - made the switch when otherwise the underdog seemed hopeless. But from them the infection spread. I think power users are also "influencers" and are worth a lot more that one single normal user as far as market share goes. Now, functionally, WhatsApp is still good. So it's not clear if this will lead to anything. But something happened, there's no denying that.
- sdoering 6y agoShortly after I started online in '97 I had a multitude of messangers/chat tools on my computer. Some people used ICQ, some AIM, some Yahoo. Some IRC. And so it is today. At work and in private context. I feel we have come full circle in the 20 or so years. Now I have Signal, WhatsApp, Telegram, FB Messenger, Slack, SMS, Google Hangouts, MS Teams on my mobile phone. Not to forget that some use Instagram and some LinkedIn to communicate. Nowadays I need to have a mapping table of whom to contact via which channel/app.
- jraby3 6y agoThis reminds me of what’s currently happening with Netflix, Hulu, Apple TV, HBO Max etc. We’ve also come full circle with cable.
- system2 6y agoNot exactly yet. ATT is still at $139 (full package), I am using Hulu and sharing the pass with my family members, while they have netflix and sharing theirs with mine. $10 a month for me is not too bad to watch my fav Star Trek episodes on demand. They can come full circle with anything they want at this point, worse case scenario I will torrent the hell out of everything and plex it with my nas if I am pushed enough.
- f1refly 6y agoTheres an xkcd for that, of course: https://xkcd.com/1810/ https://xkcd.com/1810/
- sdoering 6y agoThanks so much. Missed that one and loved it instantly.
- eloisant 6y agoYes, I had hope in the early 2000's with XMPP, but considering 20 years later we still have a fragmented ecosystem and none of the actors are willing to push for a federated network (even the open source, NPO, Signal!) is really depressing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _the_inflator 6y agoToo early to judge. Let's talk again in 3 month. Judging from my experience, people do not leave, they simply install new communication channels. They want to stay connected, are curious. Appeal of a new app, other features. SnapChat, TikTok etc. also didn't kill facebook, they augmented it. Remember Bleeper? The search of the umbrella messenger. Welcome back early Instand Messangers from the 2000er years. ;)
- skc 6y agoJust anecdotally, only one of my chat groups on WA have moved over to Signal an that's because it's a group of four of us (we are long time friends who use the group to talk about our favorite sports team) With my other far larger groups it's been a struggle to get a majority of members to care enough about this. The reality is that most people moving to Signal/Telegram will end up having to keep WhatsApp anyway.
- furyg3 6y agoIt's the same for me, lots of people came over, but not everyone (especially large groups). WA is particularly entrenched in the Netherlands, so it's difficult to get to the point where you can completely remove the app. But I still consider what's happened so far a major win. Breaking the monopoly WA has on text messaging is important.
- gowthamgts12 6y agoI just migrated one of the gaming groups that I'm part of to signal and it works well. if someone pings me on whatsapp i ask them to install signal and some people actually did. but like others said, i still have whatsapp - i just open it rarely.
- teekert 6y agoI have 3 (!) groups that haven't moved because of 1 person out of 5 or so that refuses and has a "I have nothing to hide, I don't mind targeted ads."-attitude (and tbh a majority of people that care just a little bit). The network effect is strong. It's annoying. I ask them to use another (almost exact copy of an) app, they ask me to share my address book (among others) with FaceBook (probably also among others).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hliyan 6y agoI have multiple family members who made the transition from WhatsApp to Signal without any issue. I think the 1 in 5 stragglers are best left behind.
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y agofamily is easier b/c of different social dynamics. there's no risk of losing a relationship to a family member over a messenger. you can just play it passively saying you're not using WA anymore but they are welcome to contact you via EMail, SMS or Signal, Telegram. with friends or rather acquaintances it's more difficult. you're easily being framed as a weirdo who tries to gain control over how people are communicating. soon you'll be "accidentally" skipped at invitations.
- jeffrallen 6y agoThe great philosopher Groucho Marx considered that problem and came up with an elegant solution. If there was more room in the margins here I would include it.
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y agoWell, he wouldn't have that problem to begin with as he'd not be interested in being part of a group which would accept him as a member.
- lxgr 6y agoThe last two paragraphs make me very happy. I am tired of most (non-tech) mainstream news outlets blindly regurgitating Telegram's "encryption" claims, or mentioning Telegram in the same clause as Signal under the umbrella of "more secure alteratives".
- camillomiller 6y agoIt doesn’t account for this, though: >> To protect the data that is not covered by end-to-end encryption, Telegram uses a distributed infrastructure. Cloud chat data is stored in multiple data centers around the globe that are controlled by different legal entities spread across different jurisdictions. The relevant decryption keys are split into parts and are never kept in the same place as the data they protect. As a result, several court orders from different jurisdictions are required to force us to give up any data. Thanks to this structure, we can ensure that no single government or block of like-minded countries can intrude on people's privacy and freedom of expression. Telegram can be forced to give up data only if an issue is grave and universal enough to pass the scrutiny of several different legal systems around the world. To this day, we have disclosed 0 bytes of user data to third parties, including governments. >>
- lxgr 6y agoWhy should they account for it? Telegram's marketing blurb sure sounds nice but at the same time is completely impossible to empirically validate from the outside, just like WhatsApp sharing (or not sharing) your data with Facebook. So why trust someone when others have an architecture that lets us actually verify their claims?
- cheph 6y agoAnother Signal jerking thread, spare me. At this point I am so sick of hearing about Signal that I will also insist people keep using WhatsApp. I'm not moving to something which is basically WhatsApp but this time with someone you can "definitely trust" because "reasons".
- auggierose 6y agoI don't see any advantage of moving from WhatsApp to Signal or Telegram. From a privacy / security point of view, WhatsApp seems to be better than Telegram, and on par with Signal. What exactly is the reason to change apart from wanting to be hip?
- utf_8x 6y agoHow about not allowing Facebook to spy on you?
- auggierose 6y agoHow does using WhatsApp help Facebook to spy on me? It's end to end encrypted. I haven't used Facebook itself for more than 10 years. In Telegram, you have to switch on "Secure Chat" to get the same kind of privacy. So people switching from WhatsApp to Telegram is somewhat ridiculous.
- shaoonb 6y agoIt may be end to end encrypted, but you've got to remember that the client at each of those ends is controlled by Facebook.
- auggierose 6y agoSo would you say that according to their terms of use they could just upload my messages to their servers for data-mining? If you would say so, you would be wrong: https://faq.whatsapp.com/general/security-and-privacy/end-to-end-encryption https://faq.whatsapp.com/general/security-and-privacy/end-to...
- samoa42 6y agoi think he was saying that there is nothing preventing fb from having the wa-client piggyback the content of the messages back to them and call "oops" if found out. also the issue of device-backups containing the unecrypted message history which is beeing shared from google to facebook.
- lodovic 6y agoI received the popup a couple of times to accept the new TOS and rejected it each time, but it has stopped showing itself. I fear I may have accidently accepted it. Does anyone know how can I check what my TOS-acceptance status is (whether my device thinks I accepted or not)? I really do not consent with Facebook owning my address book.
- jerrygoyal 6y agoThere's so much of misinformation spreading about what exactly was going to change in privacy policy of WA. For instance, there's rumour that fb will be able to read messages, shared location etc despite having E2E encryption (how's that possible? backdoor?). could someone please decode the proposed policy of WA?
- adem 6y agoHow do you know it's misinformation if you need a decomposition of the proposed policy itself?
- jerrygoyal 6y agobecause there are multiple viewpoints given by people, various publications, and later fb itself towards proposed policy and they all can't be right. It's a prime example of spreading misinformation.
- hliyan 6y agoTo me, it's not about the actual changes to the privacy policy. This was an opportunity to educate people about the existing risks of a very large advertising company having access to your contact list, and what alternatives were available. Most people didn't even know that Signal is open source and being developed by a non-profit until the WhatsApp concern popped up.
- tomaszs 6y agoIt is amazing how Facebook is sure about power of it's and Messanger network effect, that it sacrifices WhatsApp to advertise the company transparency.
- Havoc 6y agoGot my family group chat moved to signal by some minor miracle which is 99% of my traffic. Still don’t think I can delete it though
- villgax 6y agoIf work doesn't ping you on WhatsApp then you'd already have moved out.
- zerop 6y agoWhichever app I am using is taking my data. My privacy is not anymore. I don't cry about anything.
- Mindwipe 6y agoWhatsApp's biggest problem here is that their best defence is to note they were already doing lots of things users were worried about before these new terms. That's not a great message. Facebook baffles me sometimes. You'd save yourself so many policy headaches if you'd let some things be turned off, because nobody (i.e. not detectable numbers at FB's scale) would use it, but you could always point towards that ability when criticised. Just let people manage the data used for friend suggestions. Let people switch back to a chronological timeline, and give them filters.
- thinkingemote 6y agoAs Facebook bought WhatsApp after a few years when WhatsApp got big enough what's to stop another huge corporation to buy Signal or Telegram when they become big enough? Because it will happen, it always happens. Whats to stop the cycle?
- sneak 6y agoSignal is a nonprofit, does not store metadata, and is likely not for sale.
- thinkingemote 6y agoAll great things when they are small. Many small organisations have noble aims. When they have 2 billion users what's to stop change? We see it all the time. But I'm talking more generally here: how can we structure our organisations to be resistant to take overs? Foundations? Cooperatives perhaps? We've seen with some coops (most mutual banks/building societies in the UK) you just need to pay enough members some money to remove the restrictions
- Jedd 6y agoIt's a source of some significant regret that Keybase was acquired by Zoom, and the subsequent loss of street-cred that ensued - as I'd swung a few groups over, and really appreciated some of the features (you don't need a mobile phone number, you add / block people as needed (not phone numbers out of your contact list), and the effectively syncthing-alike feature of a synchronised file system you could share with specific persons or groups of persons.)
- crossroadsguy 6y agoNot even a visible dent. Here, in India if you mention SMS you get weird looks even from people who crossed their youth using SMS. Communication is WhatsApp here. My physiotherapist, my doctor's nurse (who handles my appointment) they all function on WhatsApp, and no, they are even going to try Signal. Grocers, delivery people — it goes on. My bank and credit card relationship managers communicate with me on WhatsApp. They are never "migrating to" Signal. I am the only one among my contacts who will be moving away from WhatsApp — everyone else (among my people who are using Signal sparsely or actively as of now) have WhatsApp installed and will keep it. Most of my recent Signal convert contacts have already started replying on Signal after hours or days, some have uninstalled. Most of those people will soon uninstall it is what I expect. Unless Signal brings social features that makes these people experience FOMO of broadcasting their lives on one more network :) Penetration of Signal in real world is way too different from what it "feels" here on HN.
- jeffrallen 6y agoDuring the time you were that, my son's daycare provider joined Signal. The network->tsunami effect is real and is currently happening in Switzerland. WhatsApp has burned their bridge to Swiss society, somehow. Shocking, but welcome.
- crossroadsguy 6y ago> Swiss society Of course. I was talking about an entirely different place with huge differences — from education to value of life (which is close to zero IMHO).
- dbrgn 6y agoSwiss person here. Over the last 2 weeks, dozens of my contacts (often total non-techies) have installed Threema and/or Signal. I've heard of a lot of family chatgroups moving away from WhatsApp. WhatsApp has near-total market penetration in Switzerland. I hope this will change now, at least a bit. Until recently, you'd get strange looks if you mentioned that you don't use WhatsApp. (People sometimes assume that means you don't own a smartphone.)
- moron4hire 6y ago38, living on the east coast USA: I don't know anyone who has ever used WhatsApp.
- Markoff 6y agoMisleading headline, it says: "WhatsApp loses millions of users after terms update" without single proof in article other than number of installs of competing apps if you wanna show how many users Whatsapp LOST you must show how many users DELETED their Whatsapp account just because someone install other app alongside Whatsapp means nothing and majority of these users will just return back to Whatsapp when this temporary hype dies by this logic every major game loses millions of users after release of other major apps ignoring fact you can play more than one game and have them all installed
- jokoon 6y agoThe worst thing about Signal is that it was probably some some sort of CIA/NSA initiative. It could be a simple honeypot, or just a way to make users feel like they are not listened to: once the app is created, you have to insert some very subtle coding error, like heartbleed (a missing semicolon), if you can manage to hijack the computer of one of the signal team. I doubt that a benevolent team of developers can match the expertise of the NSA. Of course, most users don't really have to care about such security flaws since they're very advanced issues, and most users care about their privacy. Meanwhile, I honestly would like to voluntarily submit my interests so I can choose what ads I would like to see. Advertisers should do that.
- sparkling 6y agoPersonal experience (Germany, non-techie contacts): - about 20% of my active conversations have now moved to Telegram - about 5% of my active conversations have now moved to Signal
- rcarmo 6y agoI've been using Signal for a long while -- most comments I see here already mention enough similarities/differences, so I'll just add one that drove me there first: - WhatsApp still does not have an iPad native app that talks to its servers without any interaction with my phone. Yes, I can use the web version (and have the desktop one on my Macs), but Signal just worked on all my devices (including my iPad) from day one of my adopting it years back, and it is embarrassing that WhatsApp never really bothered.
- kuon 6y agoI use element/matrix because I don't want to need a phone to use signal. But signal seems to be the most "migrated to" alternative.
- dbrgn 6y agoWhen announcing the delay in the implementation of their new TOS, WhatsApp wrote: “We want to be clear that the policy update does not affect the privacy of your messages with friends or family in any way”. Note the careful wording regarding “the privacy of your messages with friends or family”: - This excludes the privacy of messages with third parties (WA business) - This excludes your privacy as a person (your communication behavior and all metadata)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cammil 6y agoVegan alternatives are in all restaurants now. Vegans simply refuse to eat animal products.
- bitlevel 6y agoA question that intrigues me is this - from the article: "Niamh Sweeney, WhatsApp’s director of public policy for Europe, the Middle East and Africa, told the home affairs committee" Why would WhatsApps director be speaking with the home affairs committee? Concerning that they are taking such an interest, is it not?