5 ms·
I think this is backwards. (After thoroughly testing of course) I'd rather see Watson be the first-tier of diagnosis, backed up by a doctor when Watson isn't s
by nostromo 15y ago
I think this is backwards. (After thoroughly testing of course) I'd rather see Watson be the first-tier of diagnosis, backed up by a doctor when Watson isn't so sure of an answer, as opposed to Watson just helping befuddled doctors. This could really bring down medical costs at scale.
- astrofinch 15y agoAnd also possibly make it harder for doctors to, say, recommend a more expensive procedure because their hospital gets paid more.
- ginkgo 15y agoActually, this seems like the perfect opportunity for pharma companies to "help" in creating the database. That's actually what they are already doing when pitching new drugs to doctors. Now they only have to convince the system designers and not thousands of practicing doctors.
- aheilbut 15y agoIn the end, the power is going to be with the payors, who are plenty savvy themselves, not the pharma companies. Drugs are a relatively small part (10-15%) of the overall cost of healthcare.
- arohner 15y agoMost new drugs today win on marketing, rather than efficacy. Once you have a system like watson, it's rather trivial to do the expected value calculation of "This treatment has an X% chance of working, and costs Y. The competing treatment has X'%, and costs Y'." As long as that data is available to patients (and it should be), I'm with the parent poster, this will make it harder to pad treatments.
- btilly 15y agoThe customers for the software are the hospitals that people go to, not the insurance companies or the patients. I guarantee you that the hospitals will prefer whatever option results in the best possible financial outcomes for themselves.
- nradov 15y agoWell then who is going to do the clinical observation, coding, and data entry? That work doesn't get done for free and in most cases it would actually take the healthcare providers more time to do.
- Entaroadun 15y agoThere's (going to be) an app for that! Input data -> output diagnoses!
- nradov 15y agoHa ha. Seriously, clinical data entry is not quick or easy (outside a few limited special cases) regardless of how well you design that mythical app. Even perfect speech recognition would only get you part of the way there, and we aren't likely to get that any time soon.
- Entaroadun 15y agoI really don't think perfect speech recognition is that far away. 10 years and we're gonna have something that can work. 10 years and we'll have an advanced Google Goggles that can help with diagnosis. Ask the question "What are the limits of human input?" Nothing besides touch, taste, hear, see and smell, and we're getting closer and closer to being able to input that data and process it as humans would.
- jimbokun 15y ago"Even perfect speech recognition would only get you part of the way there, and we aren't likely to get that any time soon." We're working on it, though. http://www.mmodal.com http://www.mmodal.com Most of the time, there is still a transcriptionist in the loop. Or the doctor has to make his own edits.
- nradov 15y agoI know, we use your service. :-) It works well for increasing the productivity of our human transcriptionists but it doesn't really solve the automated diagnosis data entry problem that others were asking about.