8 ms·
Internet disrupted in Russia amid opposition protests
- alexryndin 6y agoHello. I'm in Russia, Moscow now and actually internet works fine. :)
- dualthro 6y agoYou can verify that cell/mobile internet works fine at the site of the protests?
- uniformlyrandom 6y agoAccording to the link, it was restored around 11am PST (10pm MSK)
- jseliger 6y agoI wonder whether SpaceX will allow Starlink service (https://www.starlink.com/ https://www.starlink.com/) to the open Internet even in repressive countries. Obviously there are many barriers, ranging from the states's security apparatuses to getting payment for service to Starlink to smuggling the dishes into the repressive countries, but it's not impossible to imagine a future in which open Internet access is much harder to block in many places.
- trillic 6y agoAt some point in the near future there may open source antenna designs that could run SpaceX's closed source software on commodity equipment with service paid for by Bitcoin.
- ducktective 6y agoyeah, good luck with hiding the actual physical electromagnetic waves...heard those could be easily tracked.
- drdaeman 6y agoTIL that Starlink uses phased arrays in their terminals, but I wonder if - for discretion's sake - it can be also made to work with parabolic dish antennas. Or do those phased arrays those days have small sidelobes? Either way, still should be possible to catch those in denser areas by wardriving, I think.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoThe satellites are continuously moving so they use the phased array to track the motion of the satellites in real time (I believe). You could make a dish on a movable mount, but from an RF perspective that would be no less detectable than a dish. The point is that Starlink is a two way link, so someone flying overhead in an airplane could detect the transmitted signal. TV dishes are harder to detect because they don’t transmit when receiving TV, not because they are a dish.
- drdaeman 6y agoYeah, I get it's bidirectional and was thinking about a movable mount exactly. Flying over felt costly which is why I thought about wardriving and relying on transmitter antenna sidelobes for detection - as I believe they're smaller for parabolic antennas. From what I've heard, this is the most common approach - just a van roaming the city and comparing what they see to list of licensed radios. Although, now, thinking about the costs I feel that maybe I was wrong in that assumption, and flying drones is cheap enough for this purpose.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoAh yes that makes sense. I am not familiar with the differences in emission patterns.
- walrus01 6y agotwo problems there: a) the present starlink architecture is bent pipe from each satellite. meaning that a satellite (for uninterrupted service, two or more satellites at the same time), in its moving LEO orbit needs to be simultaneously in view of the customer premises small terminal, and also a starlink earth station which is a link into terrestrial fiber networks. spacex is working on satellite-to-satellite trunk link connectivity but to the best of everyone's knowledge outside of the company, none of those have launched yet. because of that, you can't presently have a starlink terminal for an ordinary customer without a spacex-operated earth station geographically located in the same region. b) an adversarial high tech nation like russia (or iran, whatever) would have absolutely no problems with operating portable spectrum analyzers on the ground to identify and confiscate starlink terminals. it needs to be on a roof or other place with a clear view of the sky, isn't very small, and it needs to transmit. if it transmits in known bands, from the ground towards space, it can be identified from the ground and confiscated. training relatively unskilled law enforcement to use a portable spectrum analyzer and a ku band horn antenna would be at most a one day, eight hour training course. see what happens if you try to operate an unauthorized two-way VSAT link, 1.2 to 2.4m dish size, in the C or Ku bands in Ethiopia today, for example. Men with a pickup truck and firearms will show up to take your equipment and arrest you. all of that said, I think that there is still a lot of possibilities for circumvention of government censorship and filtering, even in an aggressive environment such as behind the great firewall of china. I highly encourage any interested persons with linux/networking software development expertise, and network engineering expertise to put some thought into how they might assist open source projects related to censorship, obfuscation/stego, and traffic-blockage circumvention. Except in an environment where the government literally orders EVERYTHING to be shut off (Kashmir, recently!), there will likely always remain some paths for traffic, because a country can only cripple its own internet for so long without causing significant economic impacts domestically.
- mbar84 6y agoI believe data transmission between the satellites is planned, or at least it was, maybe they dropped those plans entirely.
- alicorn 6y agoIt is already all but illegal to use Starlink in Russia, and given modern surveillance technologies, setting up an access point against the will of authorities might be practically impossible.
- pietor 6y agoEverybody in Teheran has satellite dishes on their roof to watch illegal tv programming. You might be overestimating the efficiency of repressive authorities
- modeless 6y agoSatellite TV dishes don't transmit and don't require the service provider to know your location.
- bpodgursky 6y agoYeah but if SpaceX has no actual corporate entity in Russia, Russia has no real way to force SpaceX to disclose the data. (short of threatening to shoot down satellites, which would normally be a viable threat, but honestly now SpaceX can launch a StarLink satellite for less than it costs to shoot one down)
- tristanj 6y agoThis is not the grandparent comment's point. SpaceX is not the weakest link here, the user on the ground transmitting radio signals is. Satellite communications are easily identifiable, and can be rapidly triangulated.
- bpodgursky 6y agoHmm is it true that the dishes can be triangulated? I was under the impression that they were motorized and directional (not like a cell phone that's omnidirectional). Obviously they're a bit bulky for now, but I suspect they will shrink considerably over time.
- modeless 6y agoThe chance of this is about zero unfortunately. Space is very heavily regulated and I don't see SpaceX trying to rock the boat at the expense of any possibility of eventually providing service in those countries. They don't have plausible deniability about where terminals are located. Knowledge of location is required for the system to work.
- mrtksn 6y agoIt may not go well for the car business. If I recall correctly, Musk himself said that he will respect countries laws.
- BurningFrog 6y agoThen again, all criminals say that.
- eznzt 6y agoInternet access over satellite has been around since forever. It's a big thing in Cuba for example. Evidently, possession of the necessary equipment is illegal, and smuggling it in is extremely expensive.
- rasz 6y agoNot the space faring ones for sure.
- fasteddie31003 6y agoSame headline could have been in America a few weeks ago. "Internet disrupted in United States amid opposition protests" Except private companies disrupted the internet over central governments.
- mhh__ 6y agoBy that same logic every single act of moderation is disrupting the internet?
- trentnix 6y agoIf it moderates the same political speech simultaneously across multiple, supposedly "independent" networks, then yeah.
- uniformlyrandom 6y agoThis is Hacker News, not Facebook. Arguably, the internet ends at the network level (TCP). Everything above it is just the payload. Application layer disruptions are not internet disruptions.
- trentnix 6y agoThat's just a different weapon that can be aimed at the same enemy.
- uniformlyrandom 6y agoYes, but application layer "weapons" are very democratic. Everyone can have one.
- mhh__ 6y agoWhat is "it"? If you punched the mayor in a bar would you be surprised all the local establishments kick you out as well?
- throwawaysea 6y agoIn case you’re looking for background, this concerns the arrest of Alexei Navalny, a Putin political opponent. He was recently poisoned (almost certainly by the Russian state), treated in [EDIT: Germany], and immediately arrested upon return to Russia. Now his wife and other associates have also been detained. There are widespread protests as a result. See https://ground.news/article/7bdfdb69-fbf5-4fb5-be1b-43c8d8b31825 https://ground.news/article/7bdfdb69-fbf5-4fb5-be1b-43c8d8b3... for articles related to the protest from different news media with various biases.
- pmoriarty 6y agoProtestors really need to find a more censorship-resistant means of communication. In the heat of the moment, when protests are organized and coordinated over the internet, internet censorship can be very effective, and countries have become adept at controlling it. John Gilmour's quip about the internet interpreting censorship as damage and routing around is far from true for mainstream internet users, if it ever was.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoThey just shut of the internet in Russia. In its entirety. What new "means of communication" are protesters supposed to come up with, and why wouldn't anyone else come up with those, considering any means of mass communication independent of the internet would probably be useful for a lot more than just protesting?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> What new "means of communication" are protesters supposed to come up with Did protests not exist and revolutions not occur before the Internet? If anything, the Internet appears to have tilted the table in favour of rulers.
- dmix 6y agoYou could always start an underground pamphlet printing press! ... although the pro-censorship crowd have an exploit for that as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jx3svMxAIas https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jx3svMxAIas
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 6y agoAnother option is to make Internet itself more censorship resistant. Remember, cable is actually way more physically resistant to adversary interference in comparison to radio, satellite, or microwave towers. You need to destroy cables, and equipment physically, unlike anything of above, and you can repair it quickly using omnipresent, off the shelf hardware. In other words, you can expend a great amount of resources sending goons to wreck thousands of DCs, and exchanges to little effect. Physically denying regime's access to network exchanges will work. Same with cell networks. Easy to jam locally, but even a big city is practically impossible without massive expense to physically take down cell towers. Idlib in Syria is a good example how a cutoff segment of cell network managed to stay online for a remarkable amount of time under military aggression.
- tpmx 6y agoSo, Navalny produced this 1h52m Russian-language video that was published on Youtube 4-5 days ago, just after he returned to Russia and was arrested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipAnwilMncI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipAnwilMncI (it has English subtitles) Putin's palace. History of world's largest bribe It's very well produced. I saw all of it and it helped me understand a lot of the history of how the current gang of eh.. er, about how Putin got to where he is today. I really recommend watching it. After these 4-5 days, it has 74M views. The view count is at the moment still growing at ~0.7M views per hour - I just had to edit that view count. 70% of those views are from russian IPs, as per the Navalny people. Makes sense to me. Russia has a population of 144M people. I think it's only a matter of time until Putin/Russia bans Youtube.
- sand_castles 6y agoplease get parlar online.
- petre 6y agoEven if all Internet based video is banned, movies will still circulate on USB flash drives. It happened before with Roadside Picnic and other books that the regime wouldn't print because of foul language or subversive ideas. Do not underestimate the creativity of citizens from the former Eastern block.
- tpmx 6y agoSure, but the spread will slow down. Discovery is everything, distribution is commodity. Edit: And when Putin does shut down access to Youtube, I bet he'll reference how US tech companies shut down "hostiles" after the Capitol Building incident. And it will seem like he has a has a reason for shutting down Youtube in Russia, to his dwindling group of supporters.
- petre 6y agoThat's like shooting flies with an artilery cannon, but Putin could probably do it none the less. No offense to Russians, but the late senator John McCain's comments spring back to mind when I read news like this. He was critical of Putin, not of Russia, although depicted otherwise by the state's media. US companies deplatformed certain users and groups insead of shutting down the service. That alone was a controversial move which drew comments from other heads of state.
- rossdavidh 6y agoI could easily imagine the Russian government shutting down internet usage for a few hours until they had a better handle on the situation. But, I have to ask, how possible is it that this was instead a lot more people than usual trying to use the internet in that area, because they were all on their smartphones trying to coordinate their activities in bandwidth-hungry ways? Not saying it's likely, I don't know enough about the tech and infrastructure to evaluate that. Just asking the question in case somebody on HN does know.
- stopChanging 6y agoI'm wondering the same thing. The article only says this: "Purposeful internet outages generally have a distinct network pattern used by NetBlocks to determine and attribute the root cause of an outage, a process known as attribution which follows detection and classification stages." To me they just drop some silly terms and fail to actually explain anything.
- owl57 6y agoUnlikely. My fixed internet provider in Moscow suburb went down citing "upstream network failure", came up around 11pm. Today's load is probably less than a pre-pandemic football game and definitely less than new year, and our networks handle that just fine.
- jcpenny1 6y agoPlease be very careful of pasting Netblocks links here. They have no documented methodology and put users at risk by scanning for websites without any consent. https://netblocked.org/ https://netblocked.org/ https://twitter.com/Berryhillj/status/1300776162868826114 https://twitter.com/Berryhillj/status/1300776162868826114
- rdiddly 6y agoIn America they leave the internet connected through the protest, the better to gather evidence.
- 10000truths 6y agoThey can do that because the social media websites that a vast majority of people use all fall under US jurisdiction, so obtaining evidence is just a subpoena away. I guarantee you that the US government would more strongly push for Internet censorship if the US protests in the past four years were organized over, say, Vkontakte.
- rdiddly 6y agoYou can bet that anything happening on Vkontakte gets vacuumed up by the NSA and can be used as evidence too. The real reason blackouts don't happen is probably because it would be too disruptive to business.
- seniorivn 6y agovk is a bad example, some e2e encrypted anonymous service would have not effect
- fatsdomino001 6y agoSo begins another attempted colour revolution...