12 ms·
My problem is renting apartments. If you ask the strata or the building managers about charging points in the carpark, they look at you like you're speaking Kli
by jiggawatts 6y ago
My problem is renting apartments. If you ask the strata or the building managers about charging points in the carpark, they look at you like you're speaking Klingon.
This is true of even very recently completed buildings in well-off areas of relatively wealthy western countries. Heck, I just walked past three Teslas in my building's car park, one of which is new and wasn't there last week!
Do people... not plan ahead? Do architects not read the news? Are they from another planet where electricity delivery is not a problem that architects have to deal with in building design?
Mind you, I got the exact same dumbfounded stare from people when talking to cafe managers and gym owners about the impending COVID lockdowns back in February 2020: "Lock...down...? You think so? Really? Here?" (Don't think IT is spared from this, I get the same vacant expression when I talk to network engineers about IPv4 exhaustion and the need for IPv6.)
On a more practical note, I have business idea that might interest the YC News crowd: The main problem raised by building managers I spoke to was that it was "too hard" to solve charge-back and the like. Wiring is "easy", that's just a matter of calling out contractor, but organising the billing of the tenant and then splitting the revenue between the various parties involved is more work for them than it is worth, because it is complex to set up but initially there may be only a couple of electric cars generating very little revenue. An "electric charging billing" cloud service that manages everything with low overheads might sell well...
- kylecordes 6y agoWidespread charging points in newly constructed parking areas will happen when required by building code and enforced by local governments; and likely not one minute before. The construction industry is brutally competiive and cost-centric; things are included because they are required or because of customer demand, almost never just because they are a good idea.
- stcredzero 6y agoMy problem is renting apartments. If you ask the strata or the building managers about charging points in the carpark, they look at you like you're speaking Klingon. There is legislation on your side in California now. It's even called "right to charge!"
- twblalock 6y agoDespite that law, it can still be difficult to get a charger installed if the property owner or HOA is against it. In some cases the electrical work requires trenching across a parking lot to a carport, or upgrading the electrical system in a parking garage. Those costs need to be borne by the tenants if they are exercising their rights under this law.
- mywittyname 6y agoA staggering amount of buildings are built to code, and nothing more. If code says that there needs to be 1.5 parking spaces per bedroom for the complex, and the complex has 80 bedrooms, you can bet there will be 120 parking spots. Apartment managers will be dragged kicking and screaming into offering chargers for cars. The best way to get chargers into apartment buildings is going to be a local mandate that they have a charger per X units.
- neltnerb 6y agoWith the rare exception for when the expected marketing value of having those spots or tax subsidies make installing them appear to have a positive value. The exception that definitely proves the rule. Until it's mandatory in new construction it won't even start to become normal. I'm curious how street parking is supposed to work, that photo is hilarious but I imagine that on the streets of Boston where you'll get hit with a bat over trying to save a parking spot (or trying to use a saved parking spot, it's Boston in the winter). I have the feeling you're going to see better adoption in suburbs and lower density urban areas first because the range doesn't need to be so high but it's also not impossible to have a consistent parking space (or garage or driveway) that you can invest in improving. I'd probably have to get a special variance from the city to install an outlet in the sidewalk...
- amluto 6y agoFortunately, the CalGreen code has some charging requirements: https://up.codes/viewer/california/ca-green-code-2016/chapter/5/nonresidential-mandatory-measures#table_5.106.5.3.3 https://up.codes/viewer/california/ca-green-code-2016/chapte... I think the requirements should be higher, but this is a start.
- resonantjacket5 6y agoA bit off topic, but your example of parking spots probably isn't the best. There's been some calls to lower the kinda ludicrous parking requirements mandated by local authorities
- brewdad 6y ago
- drewg123 6y agoI rent a townhouse right now. When I moved in, the landlord allowed me to install a 240v outlet in the garage at my own expense.
- pfdietz 6y agoAnd why not? You upgraded his property and he didn't have to pay a dime.
- vkou 6y ago> Do people... not plan ahead? Do architects not read the news? Neither the architect, nor the developer, nor the landlord are the beneficiaries of charger infrastructure. They aren't going to spend money on it until they absolutely have to. Given the decade of record-low vacancy rates in coastal metros, if a lack of an electric charger is a deal-breaker for you, they will shrug their shoulders, and move on to the next applicant. To them, you are the product, not the customer - the customer is the bank that underwrites their loans, that they use to buy/build more properties, backed by cashflow from tenants. They certainly aren't going to put dollars down today, to meet demand that will come a decade from now. The entire business model of being a residential landlord is spending every penny you have on acquiring more property to lease - not making long-term investments into existing property. If you're looking for someone to blame, blame cheap availability of credit, or your local municipality for not updating their building codes to require electric chargers [1]. [1] The reason they haven't updated their building codes is because in my experience, 8 times out of 10, municipal politics is completely dominated by landlords and developers. Those groups of people are the most affected by municipal law, so they have a huge vested interest in making sure government is looking out for their financial interests.
- sgnelson 6y agoOne part of it is that in many urban areas, the intent is to reduce the number of cars, not necessarily provide accommodation for them (gas or electric.)
- jlos 6y ago>> Do people... not plan ahead? Construction companies (on average) don't look further than the point of sale. It doesn't matter if a poorly chosen element of design in an apartment building will potentially affect thousands of people over the course of decades, the incentive/risk structure just doesn't exist to make forward thinking decisions. Its basically got to be in the building code or (almost) no one will do it.
- blablabla123 6y agoI can relate to that kind of frustration but at the end of the day nobody plans ahead further. For various reasons, to be fair not even EV consumers and producers look much further speaking of ecological risks from the supply chain. It's a gamble anyway, hoping that EVs will not only look great on the surface. But that depends also on scientific progress, production and engineering capabilities. On the other hand if EVs gets serious mass adoption outside of Scandinavia, I bet upgradeability of building infrastructure will become a topic and companies will make money by selling some sort of upgrade solution for properties.
- TheSmiddy 6y agoI'm in China where everybody rides ebikes and my building has a free for all parking space where 2/3rds of the parks have no chargers and the spots with charge ports all have qr codes you scan and pay with wechat to turn the port on. This is an easy problem to solve.
- bartvk 6y agoJust curious, what's the kWh price for this? Here in The Netherlands, we get charged about 0.33 euro per kWh (= 0.40 US$), and that's for overnight charging of cars, where you typically draw no more than 11 kW.
- OJFord 6y agoHow does that compare to your household €/kWh? I appreciate there's a value-add, just seems a lot compared to mine (£0.12something). I suppose if expect to pay roughly a day's standing charge, plus the kWh used. I'd rather pay for it like that than roll it together and have my overnight charge subsidise someone else's 30min top-up.
- TheSmiddy 6y agoI pay ¥2 for 6 hours at 400w (2400w total) which is ¥0.83/kwh or US$0.128. My household electricity is about 30% cheaper so it's a pretty good deal.
- lostlogin 6y agoIt sounds good - but the dark side of wechat and social credit lurks in the back of my mind. That is not an easy problem to solve.
- jgalt212 6y ago> I get the same vacant expression when I talk to network engineers about IPv4 exhaustion As long as there is a free market to buy/sell addresses, we'll never run out of them.
- kiwijamo 6y agoPerhaps not but we are at the point now where it is not economically viable to buy new IPv4 blocks. Many smaller (and more recently established ISPs) ISPs have given up on buying IPv4 addresses and are now running CG-NAT behind the handful of IPv4 addresses they still own. Even big (especially older) ISPs with large IPv4 blocks are experimenting with CG-NAT (e.g. I know one large ISP who is doing it only for wireless broadband probably because it's a easy test market). Either they're looking at selling part of their blocks (since they could operate out of smaller blocks with CG-NAT if they downsized) or they are genuinely predicting that they will eventually run out of space in their existing blocks--and these blocks are huge.
- jiggawatts 6y agoMy ISP runs CGNAT, and they published a report in 2019 predicting that: "Even with CGNAT, we will still exhaust our current IPv4 space in September 2021." That's about half a year away!
- safog 6y agoSo no one has said this yet, but a lot of people charge their cars at work. I don't know if you're in the US but in my experience this seems like a east coast phenomenon. Lots of electric chargers in bay area, seattle and generally urban areas on the west coast.
- brewdad 6y ago"Lots" is still relative though. A large employer near me has something like 50 chargers available in their lot. Of course, on a normal workday, 8,000 cars are being parked there. If 4,000 of those employees start driving electrics, I'm not sure it would be possible to accommodate them.
- cbozeman 6y agoDo you really need 4,000 chargers though? I don't think so. Between charging at home and charging at work, it shouldn't be necessary to occupy the charger every single time you pull in. Maybe once or twice a week, depending on your commute. A long range Model 3 has as much range as your average gasoline vehicle... how often do most people fill that up? Seems to me if 4000 employees go electric and you can slow charge anywhere from 5-30 miles' worth of power per hour at a worst case scenario and up to 44 at the best, then it stands to reason not everyone has to plug in every single day. In fact, I'd argue most folks would only need to charge up once a week, and for those with very short commutes, once every 2-3 weeks. I think 250-500 chargers for 4000 vehicles would likely be sufficient to keep everyone charged up and moving around.
- lostlogin 6y agoI could imagine an opportunity here too. Some places have a bulk buy or business rate for electricity that is cheaper. If a car park has 8k spaces and a meaningful number were electric, it may even justify battery storage to get off peak rates (this may be a stretch), with the employer splitting the saving with staff or pocketing the lot.
- jjav 6y agoPre-pandemic I was commuting to a large bay area employer. About a ~hundred or so chargers in the parking lots. The choices were to either arrive very, very early (<8am) or you missed it. Then had to wait until around 4+pm when the early risers started to leave and move the car to a charging spot. I mostly left after 7pm so it was ok but on days when I had to go at 5pm it was a big problem, didn't have time to get enough charge to get back home. Also, there's not enough power available to feed all the chargers simultaneously. So when all chargers are used and charging, the power delivery dropped to ~1.5kW. As cars started to get full and stopped drawing power only then power delivery would rise later in the day. So there's no way to install a thousand+ more chargers, there's not enough power delivery available.
- gok 6y agoIn 1998 few building managers knew what you meant if you asked about fast internet access. They'll figure it out when start losing leases.
- borcean 6y agoIt is so incredibly varied as well. Some municipalities, like Burnaby, are leading the charge (pun intended) requiring all new buildings to have stalls wired for EVSEs. But this is far from the norm, unfortunately.
- resonantjacket5 6y agoThere is Nio where they swap the battery instead. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrgH07lwfVM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrgH07lwfVM There are some large drawbacks with the large structure needed to swap the batteries though. Not sure if it'll be that successful in places where people mostly have single family homes.
- derekp7 6y agoHow do people with gas cars handle living in apartments without gasoline lines? They go to a gas station. So the tipping point is when you can take a 300-mile range car and quick-charge it in 5 - 10 minutes. Or when it is profitable enough to have charging ports at destinations (parking garages in the cities, credit-card swipe charging outlets at the mall, chargers at the office, etc).
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoQuick charging is a just in case solution and probably shouldn’t be relied on. It’s more efficient and likely much easier on the battery to slow charge it overnight.
- riffraff 6y agoThe problem with that is that in many places (i.e. most European cities) you don't have a dedicated parking spot, so to park overnight you would need to put charging spots on every street every five meters. The task is possible, but gargantuan.
- dagurp 6y agoFor those people it's a matter of buying a number of chargers that they can choose between. They can limit access to those chargers to the people living in the building or allow anyone to use them and make some money by selling the electricity. You can even have access control depending on the time of day. Another benefit is that you get load balancing when many people are charging at the same time. Private chargers are only a good idea if you there's only a few living spaces.
- tyfon 6y agoThey're doing that in Oslo now, many street parking slots are getting 22 kW poles next to them. It's just a matter of political will.
- aden1ne 6y ago
- TedShiller 6y agoThe problem is actually lithium batteries. Mining that material destroys the earth.
- worik 6y agoMining anything causes great big holes in the ground and piles of tailings. It does not destroy the Earth. It rearranges the furniture. Drastically
- TedShiller 6y agoIf you lived in the places where lithium is mined you’d be devastated
- oblio 6y agoAs opposed to all the other stuff we're mining? Lithium mining outrage is a sham. What about the many, many more tons of iron ore, aluminum ore, copper ore, etc., that we're mining? Lithium mining is just a tiny fraction of those.
- TedShiller 6y agoIt’s a sham unless you live there
- oblio 6y agoYou're not getting my point. There is no "do A or do nothing at all". It's always "do A or do B". So there is always an opportunity cost. Do you think people living near coal mines or fracking sites or whatever have it any better? Do you think that if we didn't mine lithium we'd all become noble savages* again and live in peace with nature? The objective is to minimize harm, choose the lesser of two evils. * This is a myth, by the way.
- TedShiller 6y ago
- mr_toad 6y agoI used to get the same deer-in-headlights look when I asked landlords about internet connectivity 20 years ago. Now they advertise it.
- julienb_sea 6y agoOn the other hand its pretty easy to retrofit car parks with chargers if there is demand for it. My building (which, to be fair, is a new construction highrise in seattle) has ~15% of its carpark with charging capacity and I suspect they could add more if needed.
- lightfooted 6y agoThis is certainly location-dependent. I just went through an apartment search in San Francisco where one of my requirements was electric car charging. Yes of course SF is tech-forward, but most buildings are fifty years or older which makes installation of a charger non-trivial. I just signed a lease for an apartment that doesn’t have a car charger, but the property manager added an amendment which stipulated that one will be installed in a few months, otherwise I’m free to break from the lease. I’d say about half of the property managers I talked to across about 15 tours were amenable to it.
- m463 6y agoThere are many companies in that space: chargepoint, blink, evgo... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_vehicle_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_vehicle_network My (US-based) experience: - chargepoint is a good service - people own the chargers, but they can be public or private. - blink is a terrible service - people own the chargers but in my experience the fast public ones are always broken. - evgo is a good service - they own the chargers but will install high-kw fast chargers and slow chargers at every location.
- ccorda 6y agoTesla has also recently added wi-fi to their existing chargers, and will facilitate payment processing: > With a growing number of Tesla cars on the road, a Wall Connector can pay for itself over time. Property managers will soon be able to set the price of charging sessions while Tesla handles payments automatically and securely – with no monthly fees. [1] This is a model similar to what chargepoint offers, though I suspect it will have lower fees as their main goal is to sell more cars. * [1] https://www.tesla.com/commercial-charging https://www.tesla.com/commercial-charging * https://cleantechnica.com/2020/12/02/tesla-launching-commercial-ev-charging-arm-focus-on-apartments/ https://cleantechnica.com/2020/12/02/tesla-launching-commerc...
- ascorbic 6y agoI used to just charge at work. Workplaces seem more likely to be able to persuade to install charging points.
- pfdietz 6y agoWorkplace charging also allows the charging to occur during daylight hours, when solar energy is more available.
- georgeplusplus 6y agoGlad I stumbled upon your post. The problem is you have all the best ideas and there is only one of you in the world to go around. I will point people to your posts from now on when they have menial solutions to modern problems and hopefully they are self aware enough to get a swift jolt of what the best way to move forward in life looks like.
- petre 6y agoThey'll have no choice but to offer these services, otherwise they shall rent for lesser amounts to people without electric vehicles.
- hannob 6y ago> Do people... not plan ahead? Do architects not read the news? They do read the news, but there's still plenty of news that EV is still largely powered by coal and also something about lithium mining (while never ever talking about other minig issues, particularly oil), therefore we should use hydrogen (which will need more electricity, but we skip over that) or synthetic fuels (which will need crazy amounts of electricity, but we won't mention that) and that'll be the future. Of course you can read the other news, the ones that correctly point out that between EV, hydrogen and synfuels EV has the vast advantage of being much more efficient, and that will never change, because physics. But you can pick and choose your news, and if you would prefer the news that tell you nothing changes you may just decide to trust those.
- 205guy 6y agoAs others have mentioned, Teslas charge at their fast chargers (and getting faster all the time) spread around the area. Other cars can do the same, or at workplaces. Some new building codes now mandate that the parking be charging ready, so they have to put the conduit under the pavement, but they don’t need to wire it right away. So that’s a first step to simplifying a retro-install. I do think apartment parking will eventually be retrofitted. The charging networks could easily have a apartment product—or license their network access to a manufacturer. So you would just use your charging network app or card as when charging around town. There are also products like Evercharge that split the power from a single circuit across several plugged in cars (optimizing power usage and reducing the need for conduits and wiring). The various EV promoters have been tackling this issue for a while, something like the Electric Auto Association may have people or resources to help convince an apartment owner. I wonder: shouldn’t a grid with lots of solar incentivize workplace charging (day-time use of peak generation), and a grid with wind majority incentivize home charging (night-time use of peak generation)? Maybe
- iso1631 6y ago> This is true of even very recently completed buildings in well-off areas of relatively wealthy western countries In the UK planning guidelines say that charging stations have to be provided, have done for a while 110. Within this context, applications for development should: ... (e) be designed to enable charging of plug-in and other ultra-low emission vehicles in safe, accessible and convenient locations. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/national-planning-policy-framework/9-promoting-sustainable-transport https://www.gov.uk/guidance/national-planning-policy-framewo... Locally planning permissions in my area (I'm a local councillor and have to view them all) for new houses have come with power for some years The larger problem we'll see as we move away from petrol based cars is people in old terraces that park on narrow streets. The options are 1) Remove parking space to put in chargers 2) Remove footpath to put in chargers (won't pass muster in my council area at the moment, fortunatly) 3) Not do anything until after new petrol cars are banned and hope that something magically comes along
- mjul 6y agoI think the market has already solved this with companies like E-on and the like solving all the complexity for both public and private charging stations. Perhaps there is still an open market opportunity for this in your local market for entrepreneurs to fill.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe market hasn't solved jack untill they have actually installed enough chargers to support at least 50% EV ownership. Untill then the jury is still out, so please don't claim that the probelm is solved and we can rest easy because 'muh market'
- mjul 6y agoLet me clarify that the “solved problem” I was referring to was that of the complexity for the building owners if they thought the only solution was to roll their own charging and billing solution.
- todd8 6y agoI had to pay a large (too large) an amount to purchase an extra parking space when I bought my condo. I personally didn't need the space all the time, but guests to the condo didn't have to hunt for parking on the street in an area with busy nightlife. I figured that when I sold the condo the parking space would raise the value of the condo, maybe not enough to make up for the cost but enough to be worth having the parking spot and it's convenience. It turned out that in the building there were owners of units with two cars but only one space that wanted to rent unused parking spots. I didn't do this but there were posting where condo owners could find people to pay for the right to use otherwise unused parking. All this seems a bit off topic, but couldn't electric chargers be handled the same way. Pay for the cost of a charger to be installed in one's designated parking spot and "resell" the improvement to the next condo owner. One could even allow others to use the charger while being reimbursed for the electricity. Of course being the owner of a unit in a condo building isn't the same as leasing an apartment and dealing with a large company that owns the apartment building.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI've random workers from a restaurant nearby parking in my unused space (in a private enclosing) all the time. And my parking space even require a special card to use. It would be nice if they offered to pay. I reported them to the police, but I haven't heard about them fining them and they don't stop using it. A neighbour used the parking space once and my landlord that was passing by reported her and she got a fine. What I can't stand about the police here in UK is that it's so inconsistent. Having a charger I get charged for would be an absolute nightmare.
- iso1631 6y agoI assume you never accidently left nails or broken glass in your parking space?
- anovikov 6y agoWhat makes it especially weird is that (at least for now - while electric cars are still expensive) putting in chargers will make a big competitive advantage, and a very right kind of it - by attracting wealthier, more responsible tenants that make building a good image, attracting other better tenants and driving up prices... It's a big win for any building.
- richardw 6y agoIt seems like car sharing should sort this out. Uber, car share schemes, self-driving cars...the trend seems towards less ownership and more short term use. Having a car sit around for 22 hours a day is a massive waste. These schemes suit cities, exactly where parking is a problem.
- chovybizzass 6y agoHere in East Palo Alto there are a number of charging stations at the shopping mall. I don't know what the markup is compared to a home charging station.
- arpa 6y agoI get IPv4 exhaustion, but IPv6 is hardly a solution.