8 ms·
> The weak man is a terrible argument that only a few unrepresentative people hold, which was only brought to prominence so your side had something easy to defe
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> The weak man is a terrible argument that only a few unrepresentative people hold, which was only brought to prominence so your side had something easy to defeat.
This reminds me of the Buzzfeed story circa 2012 about how Christians were campaigning against Starbucks for their holiday cups unadorned with Christmas paraphernalia. It became a meme right away to the delight of people who already weren't very fond of Christians. I thought this was particularly strange because even my most conservative Christian friends held opinions in the vein of "If you're a Christian and are getting upset about these cups, you're way off". I was really curious to figure out who all of these Christians were that held this opinion and, lo-and-behold, it was one single Christian from Arizona. This particular "weak man" argument was the basis for much criticism of Christian culture for a couple of years.
Maybe this seems less significant nowadays after the media has shown us consistently over the better part of the last decade exactly what level of depravity it will sink to in order to gain a click, but at the time it was really surprising.
- chc 6y agoI don't know if this is a great example, because Fox News actually incorporated Starbucks' lack of Christmas messaging into the weird "War on Christmas" narrative it tries to manufacture every year.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don't know how that would invalidate the example; that still doesn't show that there were Christians who felt that way, rather that Fox believed the BuzzFeed story and leaned into it.
- Spivak 6y agoYeah, assuming that Fox News is representative voice for Christians seems way off. They are just as hungry for manufactured outrage and clicks at everyone else. Fox running a bit telling their viewers they should be angry about something isn’t evidence that anyone was actually angry.
- wrs 6y agoIn fact you could just about say the opposite. It is arguably Fox News’s primary business model to tell people what newly manufactured outrage they should be angry about today.
- ImprovedSilence 6y agoYeah, but I would argue that Fox news is seeding that rage and making it mainstream. I guarantee that my grandparents would never ever give even a second thought to a starbucks cup that they will never see in their life and if they did come across would would not get offended on their own, but the second they get fed that story from Fox News, it becomes "holy hell look what them damn liberals are doing to christianity, I'd rather die then vote for them!!". This manufactured rage creates extremism by a thousand paper cuts.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoI found that whole story quite amusing. A group of people are supposedly upset that symbols of pagan idolatry are absent from a business whose logo is a bare-breasted sea hag/siren exposing her unmentionables. Even if the kernel of the story isn't true there are a lot of people who are easily manipulated by this sort of outrage journalism.
- Brendinooo 6y agoYeah! I use this same example often in the same way.
- majormajor 6y agoHere's that original story as seen from Fox: https://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/internet-evangelist-says-starbucks-holiday-cups-are-red-because-they-hate-jesus https://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/internet-evangelist-says-... Something about it stuck with their audience, it seems, since here's them covering a new iteration in 2019... https://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/starbucks-risks-more-war-on-christmas-backlash-with-merry-coffee-cups https://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/starbucks-risks-more-war-... > Whether an aversion to using the word “Christmas” extends beyond Starbucks is difficult to measure. But in 2017, President Trump tweeted on Christmas Eve that Americans were “proud to be saying Merry Christmas again,” since he took office. It's nice that your conservative Christian friends aren't so easily triggered, but that Trump quote points to the views of a sizable set of their peers.
- edbob 6y agoI don't know the extent to which this is a problem (i.e., I don't want to make this into a "weak man"), but there are some legitimate reasons to be concerned with the replacement and/or minimization of traditional holidays. At least one important motive for the replacement was to create the foundation for violent revolution: "the creation of its own series of holidays all underscored Karenga's premise that 'you must have a cultural revolution before the violent revolution. The cultural revolution gives identity, purpose, and direction.'" [0] It's easy for people to laugh at such concerns when they don't see them as plausible, but when you also have people like Dick Costolo promising shootings and a violent revolution, it's hard to know who can be trusted. When the left spends a year "mostly peacefully" killing dozens of people and burning our cities, it becomes a lot easier to believe that they might want a full revolution. Again, not to say that these concerns are necessarily justified, but that it's very difficult to know whether they are or not. If one prefers to err on the side of caution and criticize Starbucks here, I think that's a legitimate position. (Kind of hoping that someone can give me a good way to debunk these concerns, so I'm just going to ignore any troll responses). [0] https://books.google.com/books?id=Vhgk72OGBRYC&pg=PA65#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=Vhgk72OGBRYC&pg=PA65#v=one...
- majormajor 6y ago
- brundolf 6y agoThere's a famous tweet (since made private, but screenshotted): "Twitter is 90% someone imagining a guy, tricking themselves into believing that guy exists and then getting mad about it" I think you could substitute "Twitter" with just "social media"
- defen 6y agoThe New York Times (and other outlets, I'm sure) is notorious for writing trend pieces based on the fact that two or three people the reporter knows are doing some thing. Which then often turns it into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- astrange 6y agoIn political stories it constantly happens that someone is quoted as a man on the street, but then you look them up and they're actually the head of the state party or some such thing. It's surprising that the writer would lie about their credential but still leave their real names in.
- a1369209993 6y ago> writing trend pieces based on the fact that two or three people the reporter knows are doing some thing. This is standard journalistic practice - one person is happenstance, two people is coincidence, three people is a trend.
- joaomacp 6y agoRelevant: https://www.robrhinehart.com/the-new-york-times/ https://www.robrhinehart.com/the-new-york-times/
- cam_l 6y agoSure, but there is bound to be someone who sincerely believes that the person you imagined is themselves, and they will take up that mantle out of some peculiar mix of indignation and gullibility and no doubt, recruit others to their cause with your tweet as their touchstone. Belief does not subscribe to the first law of thermodynamics. It is not a preexisting condition with neatly defined boundaries. People have no need for consistency in their beliefs, or even any understanding of why they hold them or where they came from. Point being, it is not just the systemic political issue of being for or against that SA suggests shores up the Weak Man, but their beliefs themselves which shift and flow and pop in and out of existence. The only antidote to not fall in with the politics or the belief is to maintaina sense of self doubt and empathy. (And i say that as someone who also self diagnosed with much research, but also doubts). And even that doesn't protect you from other peoples' beliefs. Has no one read Foucault's Pendulum?
- mikestew 6y agoThis particular "weak man" argument was the basis for much criticism of Christian culture for a couple of years. When I see my neighborhood adorned in coroplast signs every year reminding me that "it's okay to say Merry Christmas", it becomes believable that someone will get butt-hurt about a Starbucks cup. Then again, perhaps the weak man argument here is of those that are against saying "merry xmas".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tim333 6y agoAs a Brit it seems a standard and odd thing that American businesses don't seem able to say "merry xmas" and have to make it happy holidays. I don't fully get why mentioning christmas is discriminatory when mentioning hanukkah or eid or Chinese new year isn't?
- throwaway894345 6y agoThe argument is that because Christians were so numerous, their culture needed to be policed to keep it from infringing on the hegemony that secular liberalism enjoyed. No significant number of religious minorities objected to "merry Christmas", but rather "it's offensive to religious minorities" was a false pretense employed by these "radical secularists" (or whatever we might call them) similar to how some (mostly white, probably anarchist) folks in America today are arguing that we need to abolish police for the sake of black Americans even though this opinion is fringe among black Americans.
- devwastaken 6y agoIf you live in rural areas plenty of people tout the "bring merry Christmas back" mantra. The origin of the cups story may be one person but it's reflective of a larger group.
- ahepp 6y agoIt's not clear to me whether this is the cause or effect though. I don't know how to present this theory in a falsifiable way, but I get the distinct feeling that a lot of these culture war battles are conjured up out "weak man" arguments in a hyper-real manner. Buzzfeed writes an article about how conservative nuts (more properly a single conservative nut) is boycotting Starbucks because there's no Madonna in their latte foam. Blue tribe clicks the article and laughs at Red Tribe for being so stupid. Red tribe clicks the article and decides "Blue tribe is laughing, at us!". Red tribe grifter starts accepting donations to buy Starbucks cups and throw them into a paper shredder. Blue tribe starts a Foundation for Freedom from Religious Latte Art demanding depictions of Satan in their lattes. Suddenly everyone has extremely strong feelings about something as absurd as whether or not there should be a Madonna depicted in their latte. In many cases, it seems the original nut turns out to be someone who spent most of their life at reality TV auditions.
- majormajor 6y agoThere's a common theme in a lot of these "you can't trust what you see" replies that it's specifically being amplified by the liberal side, to make conservatives look stupid. If you take that one step further down the sequence of events, though, we'd be aiming that critique at the Christian side of the media that's been making hay about the "War on Christmas" for decades. Find one person saying something, or one company doing something you can take the wrong way, use it to tell your audience they're under attack; lather, rinse, repeat. Growing up in it, I'd hear about this stuff in youth group, in chapel in school, even in not-officially-religious classes like History. Before the internet, it wasn't easy to escape that bubble if your parents were deep into it. Or do posters here really think there really are a lot of people out there trying to eliminate Christmas?
- BurningFrog 6y agoThis is a whole genre of easy to write enraging articles. 1. Think of something crazy upsetting someone could say. 2. Find the 3 people who have already said it on Twitter. 3. Write your article quoting them, and watch the clicks and rage roll in.
- asddubs 6y agothis also describes all the cringe based subreddits and various other subreddits designed for ridiculing random tweets with 4 likes
- dragonwriter 6y ago> This reminds me of the Buzzfeed story circa 2012 2015, and, like, every media outlet in the country, not just Buzzfeed. > I was really curious to figure out who all of these Christians were that held this opinion and, lo-and-behold, it was one single Christian from Arizona. No, it wasn’t. Now, sure, it became a controversy because of one internet (and former radio and TV) evangelist in Arizona, who already had substantial attention because of other campaigns he’d launched that year, but it got picked up by a lot of the publicly Christian political and media voices already engaged in the “Christians victimized by secular society” narrative, (including eventually President Trump, because it was active that long.)
- happytoexplain 6y agoThat is a good example of weak man. Also, your post is a good example of how devious the weak man is. You're using one to criticize another (the implication that the people criticizing the people who are antagonistically defensive of Christmas are largely criticizing Christians in general, and further, are doing so in large part because of a single Arizona man's actions, and further, that they are "not fond of Christians", which is not required to criticize something that occurred in the Christian world).
- colechristensen 6y agoI saw people i knew personally parroting those complaints about christmas starbucks cups on social media. To be fair, I also saw many times more people “fighting back” against that mostly invisible enemy. People like moral signaling, they usually get their ideas from others / ridiculous media stories.
- tqi 6y agoI think the problem is with our hyper polarized culture, the single Christian from Arizona snowballs into a real movement, because we reflexively and reliably take up our respective corners no matter how absurd. One of my concerns is that journalists (especially center-left types) seem to be unwilling to acknowledge their role in creating these movements rather than merely reporting on them.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI think this is very possible as well. An amusing/sad example is how 4chan trolled the left into thinking the “ok” gesture actually means “white power”. The left took the bait and started policing this gesture, and then right-wing folks would start using it to trigger them—which the left wing folks took to be “proof” that the symbol was a white power symbol (look! the right is using this symbol! vindication!) and indeed even had a hispanic utility worker fired for absent-mindlessly making the gesture. Self fulfilling prophesy.