20 ms·
Why webcams aren’t good enough
- liotier 6y agoI use OBS Studio's output as virtual camera - and among the inputs I use cheap old Android tablets with DroidCam OBS over IP on Wi-Fi... They cost less than a USB webcam and deliver much better image quality. Also, lighting. A couple of 5500 Kelvin Led lights on a clip mount, with good color rendition won't dent the budget but they will make even cheap webcams perform much better - color, frame rate, aperture. A softbox is wonderful but I don't have space for that, so I aim the light at the white wall - good enough substitute !
- onion2k 6y agoLiterally all webcam 'problems' come down to expecting your webcam to perform well in conditions that even a $5000 dSLR wouldn't do a particularly good job in. Buy a light and all of the issues from the article will magically disappear.
- jstanley 6y agoSo why is it that the iPhone example looks much better than every webcam in exactly the same lighting conditions?
- asiando 6y agoBecause the iPhone is a pretty expensive mass-produced camera with millions of dollars in development costs that a webcam would never have. Even a highly-optimized “let’s steal a smartphone camera” webcam would never cost under $100, so it would sell extremely little.
- onion2k 6y agoiPhone cameras aren't particularly great. They're good, but the thing that makes iPhone pictures really good is the iPhone's computational photography software. If webcams started including powerful CPUs, GPUs, AI chips, and OSs that can turn average pictures in to amazing pictures then webcams would be good. They'd also be quite a lot more expensive.
- stonogo 6y agoExcept the webcam in my Macbook has a powerful CPU, GPU, AI chip, and an OS from the same company and its webcam still sucks.
- _flux 6y agoSurely you could put all that software on the expensive PC?
- llampx 6y agoA webcam upgrading from a 50 cent ISP (Image Signal Processor) to a $2.00 one and a $3 lens instead of a $2 one (numbers based on conjecture from the average selling price of a low-end USB webcam) doesn't mean you need to build in a battery, a cellular antenna, a Wi-Fi radio, a desktop-grade CPU and GPU, give it a sturdy all-glass design and add speakers to it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tda 6y agoStill doesn't explain why a $300phone has a better camera than a $250 logitech BRIO. I recently bought a BRIO and in non optimal lighting the performance is just as mediocre as a $30 C230 so I returned it immediately. In the en I convinced my wife to just use the DSLR (she was hesitant at first because of the extra hassle). A modern DSL had good IQ even ad candlelight, you really almost can't mess it up. Only way to destroy the image is to use different color lights (warm lightbulb on left side and natural light from a window on the right side will look weird on every camera I know of)
- i_am_proteus 6y agoA DSLR with a lens costs thousands of dollars. A cheap continuous light with a cheap softbox costs about $150, and gets the job done.
- tda 6y agoOf course, the point was more that regardless of price the following holds in poor light: webcam < phone < point and shoot cam < dslr. Why are there no webcams with actual optical zoom lenses and decent sensor sizes? Why doesn't Canon or Nikon have a go, or Sony? The market (at least now) is a lot bigger than that for camera's. Even in the longer run, I bet a lot of people are willing to spend a bit extra to have the best looking image in the meeting. Everybody my wife videoconferences with immediately notices here camera is way better than theirs And also, not everyone wants to sit in front of a bright light
- KineticLensman 6y ago> Why doesn't Canon or Nikon have a go, or Sony? Nikon offer a free webcam utility [0] that allows recent DSLRs (and mirrorless) to be used as a webcam when plugged into a PC. I tried it with my D850. The advantage is, predictably, awesome optics. The downsides were a) finding a place on my desk for the camera and some sort of mount b) the camera battery gets eaten really quickly. Interestingly, the webcam utility isn't available for the smallest Nikon cameras - the Coolpix range - so I guess there won't be a dedicated Nikon webcam. [0] https://downloadcenter.nikonimglib.com/en/products/548/Webcam_Utility.html https://downloadcenter.nikonimglib.com/en/products/548/Webca...
- chrismorgan 6y agoI get the sense that you haven’t read the article. This article controls for lighting, showing the results of different types of cameras in different lighting conditions, and showing that even with good lighting, all of the webcams are still poor, and most are terrible. And they’re all distinctly worse than any Apple phones from the last few years (and even the front-facing camera from an Apple phone from five years ago is better than half of them).
- stretchcat 6y agoI viewed all of the examples in the article and they all look adaquate. The worst of them is fit for purpose, unless maybe you want to stare up somebody's nose and count their boogers. Personally, I've been thinking about how to sandblast the lens on my webcam to permanently fog it. Who would even care? I think nobody.
- Sunspark 6y agoJust buy some sandpaper and rub it over the lens. You can get sandpaper in different grit fineness.
- makomk 6y agoNo, it really isn't just about lighting. Not only do even cheap smartphone cameras perform better than the best webcams in typical indoor lighting conditions, but for example the "good" webcam everyone uses - the Logitech C920 - has a dodgy autoexposure algorithm that overexposes shots if people do use enough lighting, and the manual controls are apparently really buggy. Professional streamers mostly just seem to have gotten used to working around this. (Then there's the colour accuracy and autofocus issues, which everyone just puts up with.)
- nunez 6y agoThis is the truth. Even the Logitech C270, which is a basic, fixed-depth $20 camera, performs really well once you get a ring light. (I landed up getting a BRIO, which is a really nice webcam with the ability to swap out cables, which is handy for travelling.)
- m463 6y agoThey're comparing apples and logitechs. I wouldn't be surprised if the iphone cameras have had a billion dollars of development invested in them. But a large portion of this is on the software/firmware side which logitech doesn't benefit from. That said, we all reap the benefits of this because phone camera hardware has been driven down in cost considerably since phones first got cameras. There just needs to be more open software to help out, maybe like machine learning exposure, focus, color and more. Then even low-margin webcam companies will have good performance.
- coldtea 6y ago>I wouldn't be surprised if the iphone cameras have had a billion dollars of development invested in them Which is neither here, nor there. There are tons of dirt cheap (often cheaper) compact cameras on the market with better quality that most webcams, and have been for years. Including equally small as webcam options. There are also tons of dirt cheap Android phones with far better camera quality in an even more constrained space (for the camera module) than a webcam. There are also embedded laptop cameras with better quality than most $100 and plus webcams. As a sibling comment said: "I use OBS Studio's output as virtual camera - and among the inputs I use cheap old Android tablets with DroidCam OBS over IP on Wi-Fi... They cost less than a USB webcam and deliver much better image quality." There's absolutely no reason webcam makers couldn't build a better product using components found in 5+ year old phones... Even if it was expensive, the problem is there's not even an expensive $300 or $500 webcam with quality compared to a years old Android or iPhone smartphone of equal price, or a compact camera. Heck, webcams sold as $1000 and $2000 "enterprise" webcams, in bulky enclosures to sit on a desk or large TV, have some more conveniences (to fit the enterpise moniker), but same (crap) image quality.
- m463 6y agoThe article is directly comparing apple iphones against logitech webcams. iphones benefit from: a processor that costs more than the entire webcam. A firmware and software stack with a billion dollars behind it.
- 6y ago
- nbzso 6y agoIs it possible to tag promotional blog posts? This must be titled: Why using our software is better than buying a web cam.
- coldtea 6y agoIf it would be possible, of all promotional posts, this would be the one that least needed such a tag. It mentions the product just one time, in passing at the end, and is several pages of well written, well researched, general observations, plus a writeup of the results of actual testing of several cameras.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoYou can also use logi capture with the non high end logitech cameras (which is mentioned in article) by editing the LogiCapture.exe.config file. https://www.reddit.com/r/LogitechG/comments/fox6wy/logitech_c930e_webcam_not_detected_by_logi_capture/ https://www.reddit.com/r/LogitechG/comments/fox6wy/logitech_...
- nbzso 6y agoThanks for your answer. I read your response as: If well written and well researched, self promotion material is presented on HN, there is no need for the reading audience to be aware of this. Ok.
- joking 6y agoI would be satisfied if someone explains to me why such software is a subscription instead of a one time buy.
- llampx 6y agoVC's like recurring revenue..?
- icebraining 6y agoTagging promotional posts gives you a false sense of security. It's best to rely on your own judgment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corysama 6y agoDifferent article from a month ago “Why can’t you buy a good web cam?” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25504771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25504771 Lots of points. Big one being that the market is bifurcated into: 1. People who just want the minimum as cheap as possible. 2. People willing to pay enough to buy a mirrorless photo camera and plug it in as a web cam when they need it.
- Al-Khwarizmi 6y agoI'd be willing to pay for a good webcam, but I'm not willing to plug something as bulky and heavy as a mirrorless camera to my monitor, let alone to my laptop. I don't think that's a weird stance to have.
- llampx 6y agoI daresay that Group #2 comes out of necessity, since none of the webcams, even expensive ones, offer excellent image quality.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI see this pattern everywhere - the market bifurcating into a) race-to-the-bottom garbage products that are barely crossing the legal threshold of fit for purpose, and are essentially a huge waste of natural resources, and b) quality goods sold to specialists or companies, usually severely overpriced (to cover low volume of sales, and/or just because the market will bear it). Does it have a name in economics? Are there good ways of preventing this from happening?
- AstralStorm 6y agoThis is called market segmentation, and is for some reason considered a good thing. Actually it's the means to extract maximum cash out of customers who want anything more than the bare minimum.
- novok 6y agoNo, what he is describing is the lack of a middle market segment, not the fact there are market segments. My guess is the world's middle class is slowly dieing, so all you have are the poor and the rich.
- janandonly 6y agoAlthough this blog is written by someone with a financial incentive, it seems well thought out. The comparison is reasonable in that it compares “the best” webcam (a Logitec c930, according to https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-webcams/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-webcams/) with an iPhone using their software. I don't care if this is an “advertorial” or not, I'm going to test this software because my webcam sucks as well.
- sebmellen 6y agoIf you have a mirrorless or DSLR camera lying around, try this first: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25870161 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25870161. It might end up saving you money!
- mnw21cam 6y agoI bought a HDMI->USB video capture card, and tried to use it with my DSLR camera. It works fine in Teams, but not in Zoom. And that's because Teams selects a reasonable capture resolution that matches the 16:9 aspect ratio image produced by my camera's HDMI output at 1080p. Zoom selects the lowest possible resolution, which is 640x480, which makes me look squished. There is no setting in the Zoom interface that lets me change this.
- kleiba 6y agoGood enough for what? Most of the sample pics look absolutely fine to me for every day use, i.e., online meetings.
- greenimpala 6y agoAgree, It's all wonderful comparing quality until you jump on a call and the stream gets throttled to 480p.
- llampx 6y agoOne step at a time. First let's get the webcam quality looking good locally, then we can solve the network problem.
- Al-Khwarizmi 6y agoAnd a few decades ago most people would say that SDTV looked absolutely fine for everything but some high-visuals movies that they would rather see in the cinema. Now, even a newscast looks crap in SDTV. I think if webcams look absolutely fine to you for online meetings it's probably because you have become used to the crappiness. People don't typically show notebooks or pieces of paper in online meetings, because the cameras are crap, and they know they will create an awkward moment trying to focus on the notes and probably failing. For the same reason, people often won't use a whiteboard in an online meeting, etc. These would be totally normal things to do if we had decent webcams.
- kleiba 6y agoWell, I still have an analog (tube) TV, so I guess I'm not with you on that one...
- bronco21016 6y agoI agree. I rarely find I’m bothered by the quality of another person’s camera in video chat situations. However, it’s significantly bothersome when people refuse to use earbuds or a headset so audio isn’t constantly clipping during conversation, or they have a massive light source behind them like a window and their face is just a shadow the whole time, or their camera is staring god knows where the whole time. There’s a lot of low hanging fruit to up the quality of a video chat before you need to get too worried about the quality of the camera. Obviously this is for everyday video chat. If you’re live-streaming or doing some kind of professional video presentation, then yes it’s frustrating that the market is $100 or $1,500+.
- llampx 6y agoI also noticed fairly early on, that phone cameras were improving by leaps and bounds, while laptop webcams and USB webcams seemed to be at a standstill, image-quality wise. I don't know why that is, but even Apple would seemingly rather shave 50 cents off the BOM by speccing a 720p Facetime camera in their $3000 Macbook Pros, and trying to make up the difference with software, like with the new M1 Macs that have better image quality using the same 720p webcam. For my desktop I've taken to using an action camera, since software that supports using Android phones as webcams seemed to not be so good when I looked. It plugs in via USB, is cheap, has auto-focus and supports a wider angle of view than most webcams. Good for group calls. One can always zoom in with software.
- josephg 6y ago> even Apple would seemingly rather shave 50 cents off the BOM by speccing a 720p Facetime camera in their $3000 Macbook Pros The reason I've heard is that the macbook display assembly simply doesn't have the depth to house a decent camera. The camera bump in phones exists for a reason - and phones are already way fatter than macbook displays. I have no idea if thats true though.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoOn the flip side, you can get some decent cameras in the "nose up position" these days.
- EForEndeavour 6y agoHigher resolution at exactly the wrong angle? Wonderful!
- llampx 6y agoI also thought about this but then look at the iPad and iPhone Facetime cameras. They offer much better image quality than Macbook webcams. There are a few ways to offer "rear camera" quality on Macbooks, like having a little bump sticking out from the back. I don't think that's what people are asking for though. They just want a webcam that's as good as the webcam in their phone. Also this doesn't answer the question of why USB webcams are so terrible. They have tons of room.
- timvdalen 6y agoWhen I wasn't able to purchase a webcam (for a reasonable amount) at the beginning of the lockdown, I started using my Pixel 3 with DroidCam[1]. My video quality is consistently the best in all the meetings I'm in, so I can really recommend using your phone. I stream the video over adb myself, to make sure I don't drain the battery too much and to keep everything wired. [1]: https://www.dev47apps.com/ https://www.dev47apps.com/
- cjnicholls 6y agoI can confirm this as my colleagues have mentioned the quality difference between my feed (samsung tablet) and their webcams. I used a couple different webcam apps orginially but DroidCam was the best IMO.
- llampx 6y agoCouldn't you also just join the meeting from your phone? Or once from your phone and once from your PC?
- timvdalen 6y agoYes, this is what I used to to, but it has drawbacks. If you only join from your phone, you can't really see other participants (unless you use your front cam, and in that case your screen is obviously still very small) and you won't be able to screen share. If you join on both, you will be in the meeting twice (which can look weird to other people). In my case, I want to use a dedicated microphone, not my phone's microphone that might be blocked by the arm that is holding it in place. That results in a weird AV delay since the audio is coming from a different user in the call (and it means your video is not highlighted when you speak). In short - my current setup hides the implementation details and makes it all work transparently without bothering people I'm in a call with.
- llampx 6y agoNice, I have joined a few meetings from my phone and my desktop simultaneously because my desktop didn't have a webcam or microphone. It worked in a pinch but I wouldn't do it on a regular basis.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoI was disapointed by the quality of my Logitech c920. Because I coach people with Zoom I've switched to a Sony ZV1, which is quite expensive but has better quality (although their webcam software only supports 720p - camlink is in the mail) My old iMacPro has the best camera of a computer I know.
- azatris 6y agoBut given that you have a 4K RED setup in your bedroom with a studio microphone, what technology actually preserves most of the quality over the video call? Let's say both participants have fibre connections and located in the same city.
- AstralStorm 6y agoPlain old RTMP stream with h.265 inside probably. The problem is that nobody uses this for streaming because h.265 encoding is expensive even for hardware encoders in GPU. So to satisfice, use h.264 at good bitrate. Over 80 Mbit should be fine ;)
- azatris 6y agoHow would that work? Which application supports it? I don't know of a native way to do this.
- aidenn0 6y agoVLC? OBS?
- azatris 6y agoWhere's the "call a friend" button in VLC?
- aidenn0 6y agoYou just moved the goalposts. The UX for setting this up is terrible, but as approximately zero people have a Red camera hooked up to their computer and a dedicated fiber connection to multiple people, so presumably the setup is a one-time cost.
- sebmellen 6y agoIf you're interested in using a mirrorless or DSLR camera you have lying around as a webcam on Linux, I recommend this article: https://www.crackedthecode.co/how-to-use-your-dslr-as-a-webcam-in-linux/ https://www.crackedthecode.co/how-to-use-your-dslr-as-a-webc.... If you're using a Mac, this article is the best I've found, though the CamTwist Studio setup is a bit slow if you don't have a Macbook Pro with 16GB RAM or more: https://www.nicksherlock.com/2020/04/using-a-canon-dslr-as-a-webcam-with-zoom-us/ https://www.nicksherlock.com/2020/04/using-a-canon-dslr-as-a.... I plan on writing a more comprehensive article for Mac users in the future. All the steps are free! No paid software or hardware needed. I've taken to doing this, and while the setup is a bit tedious, people are always super impressed with the bokeh and all-around nice quality of my "webcam." I haven't told anyone it's really a DSLR yet. With my camera quality, I feel like Bill Gates with his camera setup (see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyFT8qXcOrM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyFT8qXcOrM).
- vr46 6y agoFor the cost of a small desk tripod, £50, and Canon’s latest Webcam Utility, I was able to repurpose a 2012 DSLR (1DX) into an absolutely fantastic webcam.
- dingaling 6y agoA 1DX is still an outstanding camera in professional use daily, well beyond overkill for a webcam! Still commands around 1000GBP on the used market. Any of the Canon xxD or M series from the same era would be sufficient at a fraction of the cost.
- vr46 6y agoDeffo overkill, but it was all I had kicking around (shucks) and works a treat.
- jpalomaki 6y agoIMHO if you have decent lighting the Logitechs are ”good enough” for the usual video call purposes. What real value would much better image quality bring? Most of the time you are just small box on other participant’s screen. Of courae totally different thing if you are producing video content. In order of importance for me 1) Get sound right. Use headset if needed. 2) Try to get good light for your face (check on Youtube three point light setup videos to get the rough idea, then improvise). 3) Try to arrange boring and simple background.
- vorpalhex 6y agoI think the article does a very good job of showing why even professional studio lights can't help a bad webcam - especially Logitechs.
- PM_ME_YOUR_CAT 6y agoWasn't there a discussion about image processing because of a lack of dedicated and optimized on-camera software? Usually phones are tuned to deliver an "as close as possible to the result" viewfinder image, while webcams in general do very little or no processing on their side. I might be completely wrong here though, however I do agree with the article. It's 2021. If Thunderbolt can provide enough bandwidth to support a full-on GPU, then we can dedicate resources to do correct image processing either on our CPUs or boycott Webcam makers to actually invest some time to finetune and optimize Webcams. As the article states, it's better to buy a used iPhone 6 and buy EpocCam by Elgato to use the phone as a cam. At least it's actually good as compared to the C920 which has been price gauged to oblivion throughout the world
- ajsnigrutin 6y agoHow big is the market for "good webcams"? If 99% of the people just need a "good enough" (to recognise your face) webcam, that they turn off after the initial "hello!" (so noone notices they have no pants on if they have to stand up), does that really make it worth it to develop new tech for the 1%? ...compared to phone cameras, where people actually want (and are willing to pay more) for a good camera, especially for one that works better in shitty lighting conditions.
- llampx 6y agoOn the flip side, with my phone I'm usually calling friends and family in my pajamas. With my laptop I'm calling serious people for serious business, sometimes as a group. It makes more sense for the laptop to have a better camera. I think until recently enterprise IT hasn't cared about laptop camera quality because the understanding was that proper video conferencing would be done from a conference room with a $2k camera setup. The pandemic has flipped that on its head.
- biggc 6y agoWith the rising popularity of streaming, a lot of people are getting a mirrorless camera and capture card. This is ridiculous overkill, and I imagine that a "premium" webcam could provide the desired features* at a much lower price point and smaller package * Good auto-focus, depth of field, "natural" color, high resolution.
- bootlooped 6y agoSince there are many webcams available for over $150, I'd say the market for "good webcams" is big enough. If people spend $150 on a webcam I think they expect it to be good.
- curryst 6y agoI keep mine on. I've noticed that coworkers who don't keep their cameras on seem less human. Without a face to the name, it's harder to conceptualize them as a person. So I keep mine on. I think video presentation is going to become the new "dress for the job you want" over the next decade or so, so it's worth it to put a little bit of effort in. Now that remote is becoming normalized, do you want to be the person on Zoom with a video that's grainy from trying to compensate for the lack of light, or the person with lights that make them look like they just came from the spa all the time? It shouldn't make a difference, but it does.
- bdz 6y agoElgato EpocCam https://www.elgato.com/en/epoccam https://www.elgato.com/en/epoccam Best $8 I've spent on a phone app. Works with pretty much everything (including OBS too)
- tchocky 6y agoI started to use my Canon EOS 80D DSLR as a webcam. Canon finally release drivers in November. The image quality amazing. It's also a bit overkill though to use a (back then) 1400€ camera to act as a webcam (also hard to compare with default webcams at that price point), but as long as I'm not using it otherwise, I think it's ok :)
- sebmellen 6y agoAgreed! DSLRs are great for this kind of stuff. I posted two links to guides on how to do this for Mac and Linux here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25870161 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25870161, if someone has a guide for Windows I'd love to see it.
- klausjensen 6y ago+ for a guide for Windows
- sebmellen 6y agoIf you use a Canon camera, you might be able to get the EOS Webcam Utility working: https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/support/self-help-center/eos-webcam-utility/ https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/support/se....
- whatyearisit 6y agoA subscription to remove a forced watermark? No thank you. I wish this to be "Sherlock"d by Apple, hopefully on the next OS release.
- pkvgames 6y agositus pkv games ada disini http://198.54.112.34/ http://198.54.112.34/
- longtom 6y agoIt's assholes selling crap to idiots.
- QasimK 6y agoMy first job straight out of university was at Reincubate. I thought I'd share my experience because Reincubate is a small company - you could count us with your fingers when I joined. It was a fun place to work with nerf guns and rubber balls to throw at each other. You learnt to keep your computer locked the "fun" way. We always went for a team lunch on Fridays - something that I've missed ever since. I enjoyed coming into work every day because of the people. The favourite highlight of my entire career was there, back in 2015. The whole team of engineers (~6ish) worked together to figure out how to decrypt iOS 9 beta backups as Apple had changed the encryption system. Everyone contributed in some way and I delved into using a disassembler, IDA Pro, from zero prior experience armed with a textbook. It took a whole week from the beta being released, and I believe we were the first (public) company to do it. The values of the company, as described on the website, have changed, but what they say now still matches up with my time there. Switching to something more relevant to this article. I was looking for a webcam a couple of months ago for quite a while before it also hit me that my iPhone camera was actually damn good. Since then I've been connecting to Zoom twice (from my phone for the video, and my computer for the audio). It's not a great experience but I never really looked into the "random" apps that could create a virtual camera. Well Reincubate is not random to me and it looks like there's a beta version of Camo for Windows, so I don't really have an excuse :)
- ofrzeta 6y agothe article only tangentially touches on depth of field which adds very much to a professionally looking webcam video, when using a DSLR or other digicam with a decent lens. You have the blur in the background so can still see the person in their surrounding but not so much that you can see all the cruft lying around. Focus is on the face and it's much better than any software solution that blows up the computer fan.
- mr_gibbins 6y agoI got halfway down before realising this was an advertorial for the Camo product. Disappointing.
- imbnwa 6y agoI suspect manufacturers wager they can skimp on quality cause customers will chalk it up to "the internet" or "my connection"
- clairity 6y agofront-facing cameras (i.e., webcams) are unnecessary on a laptop, tablet, or phone. manufacturers should remove them in favor of better supporting dedicated equipment, since they'll never be 'good enough' when video quality actually matters. video calls have been part of the futurism canon for at least 100 years, but they still have little utility beyond a simple phone call (or even text messages in many cases). they just waste bandwidth and add anxiety and frustration (nevermind encouraging narcissism).
- booi 6y agothis is a joke right?
- scotcha1 6y agoi personally use my front facing webcam on my computer 10-20x per day (for video calls, or short quick video walkthroughs). my kids also are using their cheap school laptops front facing webcams 3-4x per day with remote school, and my wife and i frequently use facetime on our iphones to chat throughout the day. i'm not interested in add'l dedicated equipment, i'm interested in the easiest solution to perform the job i need done
- clairity 6y agofor a walkthrough, why would i want to look at you the entire time, rather than whatever it is you're walking me through (for which a rear camera is much better positioned, with voice instructions)? nothing else you mentioned requires video.
- scotcha1 6y agoa rear camera would not be useful at all for an on-screen walkthrough as it would be facing a wall or a surface. my face on the other hand, added for a personal effect, to an on-screen recording or so you can easily match my voice and my mouth to better understand me. perhaps you haven't seen a face + full screen desktop walkthrough? https://www.getcloudapp.com/ https://www.getcloudapp.com/. very useful. a facetime call with my wife does require video, because it's a facetime call. i want to see her. my kids school remote calls do require video because their teachers require video on. they do this because kids from ages 6-18 may not actually be paying attention in class, so the hardware camera is used to help the teacher. if you were to look on youtube for walkthroughs of products, or twitch streams, you'll frequently see front facing cameras added to videos because people do actually like, enjoy, and find value (you can follow along to voice/face/emotion) in them
- krrrh 6y agoI spend a lot of time on video calls every day, and wanted to take advantage of my iPhone camera. I had tried Epoccam and it was buggy, and broke between releases of Zoom or didn’t work in Slack calls. Screwing around with OBS was time consuming and pinned my fans. Reincubate Camo has been a pleasure to use over the last 3 months, and has never let me down. Having good image quality on video calls is on par with wearing a clean shirt or showering before in person meetings. You can get by without it, but you make a much better impression if you step your game up a little bit. One big plus of Camo is that it will also patch software like Slack so that it works with virtual cameras at all.
- andredz 6y agoI can also recommend Camo; it has worked mostly all right.
- my_username_is_ 6y agoAre there any similar options for Android phones?
- netsharc 6y agoDroidCam works for my requirements: http://www.dev47apps.com http://www.dev47apps.com .. it installs a virtual webcam and microphone on Windows, and transmits the video and audio from the phone camera/microphone.
- phreack 6y agoClosest I can think of is Droidcam, which works great on Windows at least - on a wired connection.
- inickt 6y agoCamo for Android looks to be in beta too! https://twitter.com/reincubate/status/1349768570591457281?s=21 https://twitter.com/reincubate/status/1349768570591457281?s=...
- ivan_ah 6y agoI use https://iriun.com https://iriun.com on an old Android phone to get an "overhead projector" setup (to show hand written notes). (using USB connection not wifi; there is a bit of lag but works OK)
- abinaya_rl 6y agoCurious to know, with all these high quality web cams, do we have the support for high quality bandwidth internet connectivity.
- supergeek133 6y agoAlso add to this that most popular Twitch streamers use a very expensive digital SLR as webcams these days to avoid many of the problems discussed here. I never gave much thought to the fact that all the old phones I have sitting around have a better camera than my logitech webcam. Interesting. I have multiple Galaxy S8s/S7s around.
- cbhl 6y agoNewTek NDI has both Android and iOS apps, and plugins exist to use it with the OBS Virtual Cam. They don't have the greatest open source record though (ffmpeg removed integration after they were found to be violating license terms).
- supergeek133 6y agoThanks for the tip!
- klausjensen 6y agoGreat article, a lot of effort went into this.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoJust the other day a user in my problem validation platform posted 'Make entry level webcam better'[1], the main gripe being 10 year old Logitech C270 still being sold at a higher price while improvements in smartphone cameras are being made every 6 months. Posts like these seems to confirm that there's a real need gap for a good quality webcam. Any of you working on solving this? or have ideas? [1]https://needgap.com/problems/185-make-entry-level-webcam-better-webcam-video https://needgap.com/problems/185-make-entry-level-webcam-bet... (Disclaimer: It's a problem validation platform I created).
- tantalor 6y agoWhat is a "problem validation platform"?
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoA place where people who face problem needing commercial solution, makers who are solving/want to solve such problems can participate in constructive discussions to make products which people want. Problems are the first class citizen at needgap[1] as problems are something which exists now unlike an startup idea which becomes real only when executed and a startup could be made out of it. If you're interested in why I had to create it, I've detailed it in 'Startup ideas vs Problems'[2]. [1]https://needgap.com/problems/5-needgap-submit-problems-for-startups-to-solve https://needgap.com/problems/5-needgap-submit-problems-for-s... [2]https://hitstartup.com/startup-ideas-vs-problems/ https://hitstartup.com/startup-ideas-vs-problems/
- kube-system 6y agoWhy does that validate the idea that people need a better quality camera? If anything, I feel like logitech’s success despite their stagnation validates that most people are satisfied with acceptable quality.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y ago>Why does that validate the idea that people need a better quality camera? I feel it validates the problem/needgap because this is the 4th time in <30 days I'm seeing someone complain about the lack of good quality webcam (3 on HN, 1 on needgap) plus DSLR makers (e.g.cannon) rushing to enable webcam support for their cameras using firmware/software and releasing it while still in alpha. >I feel like logitech’s success despite their stagnation validates that most people are satisfied with acceptable quality. Market share with stagnated technology has never stopped a new product with better technology disrupting the market before, otherwise we still probably would have been using Nokia brick phones.
- guenthert 6y agoHmmh, I couldn't care less about webcams. I'm not that pretty and not all that eager to share the interior of my dwelling. I do however care about sound quality. With my accent and mumbling I need all the help I can get. Others reported that the camera in their phone beats most webcams, but what about the microphone(-array)? The sound quality of phablets hasn't quite won me over. Is there anything better available, short of equipment for professional musicians?
- my_username_is_ 6y agoFor a similar price point to these webcams, you can get a very good microphone. The Blue Yeti ($130) is usually one of the go-to recommendations https://www.bluemic.com/en-us/products/yeti/ https://www.bluemic.com/en-us/products/yeti/
- nucleardog 6y agoI wouldn't get one just for audio calls. The Yeti is what I have. It's a condenser microphone. Condenser microphones generally are more sensitive to quiet sounds and pick up range a bit better, but that means they also pick up _everything_ else much better. That's great if you're in a sound studio, but most of us are not. You'll make your life easiest if you get clean audio in _before_ you start trying to do further processing to clean it up. I already had the Yeti on hand, and it was a couple days of tweaking and tuning to get to the point where it will pick up my voice from 6-8" away clearly (so it's not directly in front of my face on camera) but not also transmitting the pitter-patter of every raindrop on the sidewalk outside. If you're looking for a mic just for audio/video calls, I'd look towards a dynamic mic. Something like the Audio-Technica AT2005 ($80) is generally pretty well reviewed, is 2/3 the price of the Yeti, and still includes a built-in ADC so you can just plug it in via USB and call the job done (don't need to add a bunch of input boxes/etc).
- mech422 6y agoI'm in exactly the same boat... I use a SteelSeries Arctis wireless (2.4Ghz!!) headset. Makes a huge difference for group calls. Also, 2.4G headsets have a HUGE range. I can go from my office, outside for a smoke or anywhere in the house. I really like them!
- dougmwne 6y agoI firmly believe that video conferencing is essentially a dead end. It is uncanny and unpleasant. Having experienced some of the early VR social experiences, I think that is the way forward. We will need to fully embody the other person and project them in a 3D AR or VR space with positional audio. I think in many ways we are incredibly close to this goal and should be seeing the first products hit the market within the decade.
- vorpalhex 6y agoI suspect a lot of us are in video conferences that perhaps don't require our full attention. It is very hard to be in VR and quietly code on the side.
- dougmwne 6y agoI think once the tech is mature you will be working on VR/AR monitors anyway. I have the Quest 2 and that is already quite useful for web browsing and movie watching.
- post_break 6y agoThe software in windows is terrible for logitech. On mac there are third party software that lets you adjust literally everything. And doing so I can make the C920 look just as good as my iPhone especially in good lightning.
- snegu 6y agoCan you share the third-party software you are using? I hate my C920 right now. I'm already pale, and it makes me look on the edge of death in every call.
- sethhochberg 6y agoWould also love to know, I use a C920 and the white balance is terrible even compared to my (worse in most other ways) Macbook Pro camera. I've seen people share config software for these on Windows but haven't seen anything that looks decent for Mac use.
- post_break 6y agoIt’s literally called webcam settings in the App Store. Has a rainbow app icon.
- post_break 6y agoIt’s literally called webcam settings in the App Store. Has a rainbow app icon.
- tibbon 6y agoHere's what really bugs me. It's clear Apple has good cameras, excellent even. And small. Yet, the camera in my $2000 Macbook Pro? Remarkably worse than even the worse external webcam. If they can throw an amazing camera in a phone, why can't they put a decent one in a laptop?
- diamondo25 6y agoI think because it has no room for the module. Cameras these days tend to bulge out of the case of the phone...
- redisman 6y agoGood optics need physical space that a super flat screen doesn't have (in depth). My Macbook screen is like 1/4th of the depth of my iPhone
- GiorgioG 6y agoI bought a Sony mirrorless camera (A6000) for photography purposes and decided to buy a Camlink 4k to pipe my camera's live output to my computer for video calls - it works great.
- gherkinnn 6y agoI don’t need my colleagues to keep count of the pimples on my face. Webcams are welcome to stagnate.
- thayne 6y ago> webcams are designed as small devices that need to fit onto existing monitors or laptop lids Ok, but I would be fine with a bigger webcam. Why aren't there affordable large webcams available? Say, the size of a mirrorless camera, but without the big pricetag.
- antomeie 6y agoHopefully I’m not stepping on anyones toes here, but as a hobby project I have been building an app that lets you use your iPhone as a webcam for your Mac. It will be completely free for anyone to use! I am currently running a beta and if you would like to help me test it then you can apply here: https://webcamplus.app/beta https://webcamplus.app/beta For reference, I have had a thread up on MacRumors Forum for a few weeks: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/iphone-as-a-webcam-for-mac-looking-for-beta-testers.2278028 https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/iphone-as-a-webcam-for-...
- mydjtl 6y agoDo you plan on making a Windows version?
- wazoox 6y agoI have a C920. My main problem is that the camera runs at 60 fps, but here in Europe, lights are 50Hz. therefore, flickering is unbearably as soon as you're not using natural light. I can't find any solution to this...
- empiricus 6y agoSome Led lights might work.
- julienfr112 6y agoI've got no problem with this camera from europe. I remember tinkering with the same camera model while setting up a camera booth for rescruting interview. There was an option in the python video library to set the camera to a frequency that prevent flickering.
- julienfr112 6y agoare you using linux ? guvcview expose a lot of option from your camera.
- wazoox 6y agoAh, interesting. My office is lit with fluorescent tubes, so the flickering is extreme. I'll check guvcview.
- glitcher 6y agoThis is a completely minor and silly gripe, but one of the things I don't like about the video conferencing experience on computer screens is the lack of direct eye contact. I just can't escape the feeling of everyone looking at each other looking at each other, instead of looking each other in the eyes and knowing when someone is looking at you as opposed to someone else. It's really an odd shift from our natural face to face encounters.
- beisner 6y agoNot minor, making eye contact when communicating is a super deep instinct. Even animals make eye contact. It totally takes you out of the moment when it isn’t there.
- tacon 6y agoIt really isn't a minor point. Lack of eye contact is really important. I pulled out a gooseneck webcam mount I had bought and never used from years ago. I can position it almost right in front of the Zoom window and achieve almost direct eye contact, though it is tricky if I need to see detail behind the webcam itself. Multiple monitors with extra area reduce that problem. I ran across a video that showed how to create an actual direct eye to eye contact effect, using a half-silvered mirror and parts from a laptop webcam[0]. I started shopping for a used laptop webcam part, and then realized I have never seen laptops rated by their webcams, so it is almost a shot in the dark to get something good. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AecAXinars https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AecAXinars
- crakhamster01 6y agoI went down this rabbit hole a few months back when I was looking to buy a webcam for a new gaming PC that I had built. Also reached the same conclusion as the author (i.e. all webcams are shit). I ended up using a mirrorless camera that I bought in 2015 and hooked it up to my PC via mini-HDMI + this USB capture device (https://www.amazon.com/Elgato-Cam-Link-Broadcast-Camcorder/dp/B07K3FN5MR https://www.amazon.com/Elgato-Cam-Link-Broadcast-Camcorder/d...). The video quality is incredible and set up is fairly simple. It also works with the Macbook Pro I use for my job, which is great since the webcam on that is also garbage.
- mimo84 6y agoAfter struggling with different webcams, including the MacBook Pro camera, I opted for this setup: - Canon RP - 50mm Canon lens - Tripod located between my two monitors All it fully tax deductible, amazing quality and even more flexibility when I have a meeting, for example ability to show my desk.
- dataminer 6y agoI found that GoPro Hero 9 has a webcam mode, works quite well and the quality is really good. However it is more expensive than regular webcams, but if you already have one , use it as a webcam.
- Havoc 6y agoSurprised they didn’t test a cheap mid range previous gen Android phone