6 ms·
> It doesn't take a genius to know that such a controversial website is going to get dropped, even if it's just because it makes the webhost look bad. Parler w
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> It doesn't take a genius to know that such a controversial website is going to get dropped, even if it's just because it makes the webhost look bad.
Parler wasn't dropped for making Amazon look bad. Parler was dropped for repeatedly failing to address blatant terms of service violations.
AWS still hosts the National Enquirer, the magazine that literally tried to blackmail Jeff Bezos. AWS is hardly in the habit of removing sites that make them look bad.
Parler has gained a reputation for being some sort of free-speech platform, but it was anything but. They had heavy-handed moderation that routinely banned people and removed content for not agreeing with the popular sentiment. They made a deliberate choice to continue to leave explicit calls to violence on their website, and they were removed from AWS for it.
Twitter doesn't have perfect execution of their moderation across all of their tweets, obviously, but they are at least making a good faith effort to remove content that has explicit calls to violence.
- richardARPANET 6y agoDropped by Amazon, in coordination with both App Stores just as it reached #1 ranked app. Really really interesting.
- GavinMcG 6y agoNot everything is a grand conspiracy. Sometimes society really isn't okay with what you're doing.
- richardARPANET 6y agoExactly, it's not a conspiracy if they're telling you they're doing it: https://twitter.com/Policy/status/1349059276975857664 https://twitter.com/Policy/status/1349059276975857664 It's a big club, and you ain't in it.
- Spivak 6y agoAlso I think dogpiling is often confused, intentionally or not, as conspiracy. It seems like a lot of people really really wanted to drop them but weren't brave enough to make the first move.
- thebigman433 6y agoI really think this is a significant part of the whole thing. Tech companies are conspiring to ban Trump from their platforms so he cant speak, they just want to do it but dont want the ridiculous backlash from going first.
- salawat 6y agoIt's not society not being okay with they are doing that makes it intersting. It's that the subjects of multiple anti-trust probes and companies known for on the down colluding in the past happened to be the ones pulling the plug. You can argue it was "everyone" having a problem with it, but keep in mind that the Valley is not "everyone". That's the funny thing about conspiracies. Everyone whose in on it flatly denies it, even when it is obvious. Not saying there was one mind. Just pointing out that assuming "management in the Valley" who have go/no-go on firing customers equates to "everyone" not being okay with it. It does not build confidence to many when unilateral decisions by execs shape the landscape for everyone else. Also yes, some of that population who aren't okay with that likely buy in to more conspirarial thought as well. Doesn't change the facts of the matter.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- isaacremuant 6y agoIf society wasn't ok they wouldn't be the most downloaded app. This is like saying that society wasn't ok with Trump when almost half voted for him. Trying to rewrite history because there's a Ideological and political control of tech companies doesn't mean you're right. The same goes for law. Just because something is legal or you don't win a case, it doesn't mean it's right or fair.
- GavinMcG 6y agoBeing an especially rabid minority does not make a majority.
- isaacremuant 6y agoI never talked about majorities but I'm not surprised to see the needless adjective. In my experience, rabid attitudes come up whenever you don't toe conventional lines regarding the good Vs the bad American parties. You're not allowed to an opinion that's not the right one.
- bdamm 6y agoSimilar to how a car accident is interesting, perhaps. My wife checked out the site just to see if it was really that bad. She concluded it was. No doubt many installed it for the same reason.
- ceejayoz 6y agoYou'll find that large corporations tend to average out to having fairly similar thresholds for "oh, these guys can fuck right off from our service". No conspiracy is needed. Same thing happens in neighborhoods - assholes tend to get a reputation as "the asshole neighbor" pretty rapidly. There doesn't have to be a neighborhood meeting to decide this; it just happens.
- tobylane 6y agoDo you have a source for it reaching that rank? Iirc it was dropped from the two app stores about 12h apart.
- kyrra 6y agoIf you listen to Parler's CEO arguing about being shut down[0] (interview with Megyn Kelly), he was saying that their tech rep at Amazon gave no hints that they were in danger of being shut down. It sounded like they were doing a decent job and they tried to remedy Amazon's issues, but Amazon wanted nothing to do with them anymore. EDIT: to add, this is just his take. There is obviously 2-sides to the story, so hard to know the full truth here. [0] https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5tZWdhcGhvbmUuZm0vdGhlbWVneW5rZWxseXNob3c/episode/Mjg2MDhjYjAtNTU1Yy0xMWViLWJhNzUtZjc4YjhlZWZiNjA0?sa=X&ved=0CAUQkfYCahcKEwio8Lbo_q3uAhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQAQ https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5tZWdhcGh...
- minikites 6y agoWhat leads you to believe the Parler CEO is a reliable narrator?
- kyrra 6y ago100% agree, he has a reason to paint a certain narrative. (I added my edit before you replied I think). Either way, without knowing the full picture from both sides (like a court case going through discovering to fully put out the communciations between Amazon and Parler), we don't know the answer. We see that Amazon canceled Parler with little external communication. And we see what Parler is saying. Amazon could share what they communicated with Parler (assuming they legally can), then we could see another side to this story. It would be nice for this court case to go through discovery, then we'll know who said what and when. But until then, we have very imperfect data and have to weigh it as best we can.
- notahacker 6y agoI've seen a copy of an email exchange between Amazon and Parler from Nov/Dec (which is difficult to Google for at the moment) which was shared publicly. Amazon bring up some examples of posts that concern them. Parler say they will look at the post that constitute actual threats but have a policy of not removing content like the post that's just a long, content free screed of racial abuse. That alone can easily be considered violation of Amazon's conveniently broad AUP. Amazon appear not to have chosen to terminate or threaten to at the time, presumably on the basis they were getting plenty of money and relatively little grief for hosting them, but it puts a very different perspective on the idea that Parler was caught completely by surprise, and would have cleaned up everything they could if only they'd had more time and resources.
- ravenstine 6y ago> Twitter doesn't have perfect execution of their moderation across all of their tweets, obviously, but they are at least making a good faith effort to remove content that has explicit calls to violence. Isn't that mainly due to their amount of revenue? Are newer services supposed to be shut down because they can't(yet?) compete with Twitter on budget for moderation?
- duskwuff 6y agoModeration scales with the size of the site. Obviously a tiny little web forum with a few dozen users isn't expected to have a Twitter-sized moderation team -- but if you're at a few million users and growing fast, you're expected to have some plans in place.
- ravenstine 6y agoThat sounds good on paper, but what happens when your revenue doesn't closely correlate with the number of users? Hypothetically, a site can have a million users but have a shoestring budget. On the other side of the scale, Twitter not only has the support structure to mass moderate but they have investors providing millions of dollars. Hiring a full time moderator isn't trivial; it's thousands a year per person, which can be tough for a website that operates on mere thousands to even a few million.
- filleduchaos 6y ago> but what happens when your revenue doesn't closely correlate with the number of users? Then you stop chasing growth at all costs or you go under/lose business partnerships/etc. Sounds like the free market to me - I don't get the idea that a business is entitled to existence no matter what, whether or not it can afford to pay labour (or even get enough volunteers) to do its work.
- duskwuff 6y ago> That sounds good on paper, but what happens when your revenue doesn't closely correlate with the number of users? I mean, moderation or no moderation, your overall costs are going to roughly correlate with your number of users. If you can't come up with some kind of revenue stream -- be it subscriptions, advertising, or donations -- your site is going to be a money pit. Besides, depending on what kind of site you're operating, moderation can sometimes be managed by volunteers. Some high profile sites like 4chan make that work pretty well. But it depends on having dedicated volunteers who can agree to enforce rules, which isn't always easy.
- robbrown451 6y agoOk but dropping the National Enquirer would make Amazon look even worse. And keeping National Enquirer doesn't make Amazon "look bad"... you are mixing issues here. National Enquirer itself may not be pro-Amazon, but they'd be that way whereever they are hosted. Their existence on AWS, though, does not impact Amazon one way or the other, because even those who dislike what they publish, aren't generally claiming they should be denied hosting.