11 ms·
Personally I think at this point she should be required to prove that she understands what Bitcoin and Ethereum actually are in detail and what applications the
by ilaksh 6y ago
Personally I think at this point she should be required to prove that she understands what Bitcoin and Ethereum actually are in detail and what applications they may have.
I suspect she does not know much about them. And I believe that should disqualify her from that job.
- viraptor 6y agoWhy do you think the details matter? She works at a different level that deals with the flow of money and various investment/trade devices. Do you think her decisions would be different when learning the tech details vs treating them at black box stock tickers?
- ilaksh 6y agoThis is a new type of money that is going to play a crucial role at the intersection of money and government. It is not a different level. It is exactly her level. It may be several years or even a generation, but people in jobs like her will eventually need to understand and incorporate cutting-edge cryptocurrencies and other decentralized technologies or those governments will simply be completely obsoleted. The lack of understanding and integration now means that current governments are obsolescent.
- viraptor 6y agoWhat do you mean by "new type"? You can transfer it, you can trade it, you have a known rate of generation. The implementation details don't change anything from the treasury PoV. (Which is mostly about market impact, legality of transfers, etc.)
- ilaksh 6y agoThe type of generation and rate is new. The distribution of computing (global) is new. The security and availability is new. Ethereum is a brand new thing. Enables new forms of governance, information distribution and synchronization, etc. Research it.
- viraptor 6y agoOk. And why do you think the type of generation on a technical level matters at the treasury level? Do you think they must know the chemical process of creating steel to understand impacts of steel industry on the market? Yes, I know ETH. Whatever processes you program are not different than people executing them with equivalent paperwork. They can be analysed / taken into consideration in just about the same way as actions of a company.
- chii 6y agoDo you need the traffic regulation policy makers to understand the inner workings of a tesla engine, or combustion engine, or gear boxes, to make good traffic policies?
- ilaksh 6y agoThe equivalent metaphor is autonomous vehicles. It would be as if a transportation secretary's only comment about self-driving cars was that they were dangerous.
- seanhunter 6y agoJanet Yellen is a very highly-regarded academic economist, and was famed for the depth of her preparation, both when she used to teach at Harvard, LSE and elsewhere, when she was an economic advisor and as a fed chair. She studied under a nobel prizewinner and is co-author on many papers with her husband George Akerlof, who is also a nobel prizewinner. She's no intellectual lightweight. I'd be really surprised if she hasn't done the work to understand these details.
- ilaksh 6y agoHas she ever written a paper or made a comment about cryptocurrency that evidences any significant depth of understanding? Her eminence in the traditional field could actually be detracting from her willingness to explore and accept disruptive new developments.
- avmich 6y agoYes. If Yellen is so competent as she seems to be - to many, including myself - I'd like to listen to her explanations why arguments in favor of cryptocurrencies aren't good enough. After all, there are some ideas behind Bitcoin, some explanations of benefits, which apparently bring some people to cryptocurrencies even without get-rich-quick hopes. What are Yellen's answers to those requests which led to creation of cryptocurrencies?
- jjeaff 6y agoTo understand the economic implications of cryptocurrency, all you would need to know is that it is a decentralized currency that can't be controlled by any one entity and that is frequently used for crime because it is psuedo-anonymous. I don't see how knowing any of the technical details would make any difference in her expert analysis.
- ilaksh 6y agoThose are not all of the salient facts about Bitcoin and Ethereum. Not even close.