6 ms·
My favourite interview question for engineering grads: * Someone has just invented a 1 minute charge time car battery. They want you to design the cable for t
by londons_explore 6y ago
My favourite interview question for engineering grads:
* Someone has just invented a 1 minute charge time car battery. They want you to design the cable for the user to plug the car into the charge station. Can you sketch some design ideas and point out the pros and cons of each?
It's a great question because it's almost impossible... Any cable that can deliver the tens of megawatts needs a ton of copper and a ton of cooling, and usually ends up too heavy for grandma to move. Then high voltages are investigated, leading to insulators which can't do high temperatures, are stupidly thick themselves, or are non-flexible... Sometimes candidates suggest superconductors, but then they need to come up with an answer to cooling, keeping it flexible, and stopping the user getting frostbite.
As an interviewer, it shows me how quickly a candidate can guess the magnitude of each parameter in their design and iterate designs to get everything reasonable. That ability tends to match an engineer who can make a prototype of something in a few days.
- numlock86 6y agoI've seen prototype "cables" designed to handle up to 800 volts at 100 amps for EV DC charging. In fact I had to carry a sample (just the cable and plug on the EV side, other end was open) a few meters and oh boy, I can still feel my shoulder and back just thinking about that. No idea how any regular everyday consumer is supposed to handle that. And that was even without any cooling liquid pumped inside which you'd probably have in the live application.
- londons_explore 6y agoThat's 80 kilowatts. To 'charge' a big gasoline truck, you'd put in say 20 gallons, which if done via electricity in 1 minute would be 57 megawatts, nearly 1000x more.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- audunw 6y agoA gallon of gasoline is around 33kWh of energy. 33.41kWh*20/1min = 40MW Diesel might be closer to 50MW? But regardless, it's not 33kWh per gallon of energy to the wheels. Most of the energy is wasted. So of course a battery electric truck wouldn't require that much energy to do the same work. I've seen that trucks and buses just use multiple charging cables. But yeah, you'll never charge a large truck from 0 to 100% in 1 minute. Overnight charging will be the norm.
- numlock86 6y agoYes, that was my point: Even cables that are already in the realm of "too big/bulky to be handled" don't come anywhere close.
- techdragon 6y agoThese cables continue to surprise me, I remember prototypes for robotic “hands off” fuel pumps for petrol/gas that were being built in the 90s. With the rise of the standards around charging electric cars, it seems like a no brainer to standardise on robotics to handle the hook up as we go to higher power levels. Park car roughly in the correct place, and wait. No more issues using any cable technology that’s appropriate like coolants or the sheer cable mass in terms of copper. The robot can be built to match , and every charging port makes a nice standard looking target for vision tracking and alignment to drive the robot to the right place every time.
- chris11 6y agoThat's what I was thinking. And with autopilot type systems the car could line it self up to the cable. The major downside is that this might increase vendor lock-in for recharging stations.
- TakawaraJu 6y agoThat is where legislation could come in.
- csunbird 6y agoThis seems to be a great idea actually. An ISO standard cable with several tiers or power delivery ratings, mandatory for all EVs to accept should be the way to go. We have a standard gas/diesel "plugs" all over the world, why not have the same with EVs? Edit: Obviously, a car should accept only the "tiers" that it is rated for, but the charging station and the car can negotiate which "tier" that they would like to charge.
- imtringued 6y agoWhy not just standardize the height of the charging port? You can then just put the plug on a movable stand. No robots needed. This is what I mean by "movable stand": https://www.slimlinewarehouse.com.au/movable-lcd-tv-stand/tvm100wht.aspx https://www.slimlinewarehouse.com.au/movable-lcd-tv-stand/tv...
- magicalhippo 6y agoWe got a BMW i3, it has a battery capacity of 33 kWh. Fully charging it in 5 minutes, as the article claims, would thus require a 400kW charger, assuming an unrealistic constant charging condition. With a nominal battery voltage of 360V that would be 1.1kA, which seems quite a challenge. And that's a fairly tiny battery as far as electric cars go. A Tesla 3 with the new 82kWh battery pack would require over 1MW. On a related note there was an article[1] in the news here just yesterday about how building the charging infrastructure is challenged by the fact that the cost of expanding local transformer stations has to be shared by those wanting the extra power, like say a gas station wanting to add EV charging stations. This cost can be quite high due to the power requirements. [1]: https://www.nrk.no/norge/ma-ut-med-mer-enn-25-millioner-for-a-gi-elbiler-lademulighet-1.15329438 https://www.nrk.no/norge/ma-ut-med-mer-enn-25-millioner-for-...
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoAmong other issues, I think that you would melt/fry the battery, unless you could charge it inside a freezer or something like that.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoNot an engineer so this is just me spitballing / getting nerdsniped, but for that kind of use case I can imagine a charging station that you have to drive the car over, with a solid chunky connector sticking up into the car. Any cabling would be underground, and it could be combined with providing cooling for both the cable and the battery itself. That would be the fast charging option, for at home charging you'd have to use the regular slow plug.
- gambiting 6y agoFor a 100kWh battery, you're taking 6MW of power to charge the battery to full in a minute. 6MW is a small nuclear reactor or a medium sized hydroelectric dam. I cannot imagine a charging station wired for that kind of power being drawn when charging, nor can I imagine a connector that would safely carry this power. It can be done "safely" in the million volt range, but you're not going to charge a battery(typically 400-800V) with that. Just for a "fun" calculation, 6MW at 800V is 7500 amps - the cable for it would be bigger and heavier than the car, if it's even possible at all. And then finally, I can't believe there really exists a battery that just wouldn't boil at those rates, nor that we could effectively cool it.
- londons_explore 6y agoBatteries do exist that can charge that fast. Some RC car batteries are "60C" indicating they can do a full discharge in 1 minute. To achieve that, substantial capacity and lifespan tradeoffs are made, and you're right that cooling becomes necessary. 7500 amps isn't 'bigger than car' territory either. If you're happy to have copper the thickness of your forearm it wouldn't melt at 7500 amps, even with simple air cooling. "Not melting" isn't quite the standard we're after, but shows that it isn't unachievable.
- gambiting 6y agoThat's good to know - I was extrapolating from some 1000amp cables I had to work with, and those were already too big and heavy to move once you had any length of it at all. >>Some RC car batteries are "60C" indicating they can do a full discharge in 1 minute. I mean, plenty of batteries can discharge that quickly, but that isn't synonymous with them being able to charge that fast, no? I can think of several examples of batteries, both Ni-Cd as well as Lithium which can be safely discharged fully at very rapid speeds, but you can't(shouldn't?) charge them that quickly.
- nojokes 6y agoNot an electrical engineer. Why not inductive charging or any other wireless technology? Also it does not require a single entry point - do it in parallel. Also when 1 minute is not possible, how about increasing the time? Edit: in addition, charging entry does not have to be on the side, it can be on top or on bottom - we do not need any gravity assist.
- gambiting 6y agoWireless charging doesn't solve anything - you would still need to deliver 100kWh(for a large car battery) into the charging pad within a minute. And then you need to receive it on the other end - you don't have a plug, but obviously your receiver now has the same issue. You just moved where the problem is. I'd argue that having such an incredibly strong inductive field is a problem as well, but yeah, you're not even going to get that far. Parallel charging is potentially the answer - but even with 10 cables, for a 100kWh battery, you're still talking.....600kW per cable? CCS goes only up to 200kW(and those are THICK cables), so if you increase the charging speed to 3 minutes then yes, you could do it with 10 cables. 6 minutes with 5 cables, 30 minutes with one cable.....and we're(almost) back to what existing technology already allows?
- nojokes 6y agoThe issue is that with current plug placement there must be a really hefty cable inside the car too. What about short range inductive charging from the bellow of the car (where the battery is)? With grid of 5x5 or 6x6 for example? Inductive charging because it would be very difficult to have any kind of plug below the car because of the high corrosion risk. Charger must align itself automatically to the right position and distance.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoInductive chargers are ~80% efficient, compared to cables which are well over 99% efficient. Even though super efficient and despite electrical conductors being good heat conductors, the cable still needs active cooling to dump waste heat. Your inductive charger and the attached vehicle are going to have dump tens of kWh of heat in a few minutes, and will have to do it through air, without barbecuing the humans inside.
- akvadrako 6y agoWhat about using very high voltage like 100kV? All the heavy parts could be in the vehicle and the charging station. I did find this using 13 kV: https://www.energytrend.com/news/20180904-12449.html https://www.energytrend.com/news/20180904-12449.html
- londons_explore 6y agoWhat material will you make the insulators from? Will the insulation itself not be too heavy?
- akvadrako 6y agoHow about these: https://www.schleich.com/en/product/high-voltage-cables-en/ https://www.schleich.com/en/product/high-voltage-cables-en/ 100 kV DC, outer diameter 14 mm
- londons_explore 6y agoNow that's the kind of thing. How many amps will that center core take (presumably not enough as is), and how might we modify that design to take more amps? 14mm is perhaps even smaller and lighter than needed for this application too - how might you expect diameter/weight to scale for cables over 100kV?
- akvadrako 6y agoThe plugs are rated for 5A so lets say that; 2.2mm core is overkill. 10kV is 5mm, 65kV is 10mm, so something like sqrt(V) + 4mm. I guess 500 kV would be around 30mm for each wire, which is starting to get unwieldy.