6 ms·
Technosolutionism Isn’t the Fix
- curiousllama 6y ago> Technosolutionists were blithely dismissive of such proven measures [...] because the recommendations relied on the public (that mass of humanity whom technosolutionists, in the main, view as irrational and misguided) to adhere to them voluntarily. Big fan of techno-solutionist critique in general, but the one critique that frustrates me is "Solution X is bad because we could do Solution Y instead." Don't yell at people doing something to help (as it happens, probably the _only_ way they know to help) because some other people, with some other expertise, could theoretically do it differently/better/more human. > the same sort of surveillance used to track the spread of a virus can just as easily track one’s movements during a political protest This is the type of critique that's productive: "your thing helps in one way, but not in another; let's figure out how to max(good) and min(bad)"
- LiquidSky 6y ago>Don't yell at people doing something to help (as it happens, probably the _only_ way they know to help) because some other people, with some other expertise, could theoretically do it differently/better/more human. This seems to rest on the premise that doing something is always better than doing nothing, which may actually not be the case. It's possible that the "solution" just makes things worse/complicates implementing better, longer-term solutions. The "_only_ way they know to help" part especially raises red flags, because it's exactly that narrow-mindedness and ignorance of context and alternatives that leads to "if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail" thinking. A big problem with "technosolutionism", as the article calls it, is precisely people forcing complex social, political, economic, cultural, etc. problems into the technical paradigms with which they are familiar, and then attempting to solve those problems as if they were technical or engineering issues.
- yepguy 6y ago> It's possible that the "solution" just makes things worse/complicates implementing better, longer-term solutions. I would go further, and suggest that nearly all social interventions make things worse. Extreme caution is especially necessary if the intervention is top-down.
- curiousllama 6y ago> This seems to rest on the premise that doing something is always better than doing nothing Not always, just often. Typically, smart people trying hard to help end up helping. This is my point: you're saying "stop trying to help if you're not capable of totally solving the problem." Giving one piece of a super complicated puzzle is a legit contribution. Imagine I build "Uber for Food Banks." Instead of a physical food bank, you punch in that app "I need help this month" and someone delivers food to you for free. Imagine it takes off and triples the amount of food aid in the US. This technosolution completely, 100% ignores the "complex, social political, economic, cultural etc." components of food insecurity. It won't solve the problem. A valid critique is: "Because social services beyond food are serendipitously delivered through traditional food bank infra, you need to help sustain the traditional infra while expanding the delivery, even if the infra may look different (e.g., transform into medical clinics)." A bad critique is: "Because social services beyond food are serendipitously delivered through traditional food bank infra, you shouldn't build Uber for Food Banks." Rich people don't get to look at a problem and say "the only solution is a perfect solution." Help how you can, dude.
- kitsunesoba 6y ago"Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good" may also be relevant here. By all means, criticize proposals to help weed out those that are truly bad and to refine those with problems into something better, but don't rule them out entirely because they don't check every box. Obviously every situation is different and cost-to-benefit must always be weighed, but I think it's often better to implement an imperfect solution while waiting on something better.
- closeparen 6y ago>complicates implementing better, longer-term solutions. The problem is that nobody is actually implementing them. Comprehensive public housing doesn't exist. There are no construction sites, there is no program, there is no money, there is no will. It's just talk. The only time it has a real impact on anyone's housing situation is when it's the reason to block a private development and maintain status quo. Comprehensive public transit doesn't exist. The agency is in year 5 of 10 for community consultations about adding 1.5 more miles of joke to the pile of jokes. We know how fast it can expand and what it costs. Becoming remotely as useful as TNCs or scooters or whatever would take 3 generations to build and consume the entire productive capacity of 5. Everyone knows this, which is why no one is seriously trying. The realest that the proposal will ever be is when it is listed as the rationale for blocking scooters/TNCs/whatever. Credibility on the right way to solve a problem is earned through progress. The "real solution" people will say they don't have the capital needed to make progress. Well, part of being a real solution is having a workable funding story. If the opposition is reliably defeating attempts to fund it, there you go. Not a real solution.
- vncecartersknee 6y ago>Big fan of techno-solutionist critique in general, but the one critique that frustrates me is "Solution X is bad because we could do Solution Y instead." Don't yell at people doing something to help (as it happens, probably the _only_ way they know to help) because some other people, with some other expertise, could theoretically do it differently/better/more human. not exactly sure what you mean by this... do you really think Zoom is just 'trying to help'? They're a corporation trying to make money you can't seriously think they actually give a shit about 'helping' or whatever.
- apocalypstyx 6y agoThe answer to technosolutionism will be more technosolutionism.
- smolder 6y agoAs it happens, I'm working on an app to help people find alternatives to technosolutionism! :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- amelius 6y agoNot yet. But just wait until the singularity is here.
- beamatronic 6y agoI have released a new app that will help you determine when the singularity has arrived
- tim333 6y agoTechnosolutionism doesn't seem to have a dictionary definition but the author seems to use if for crap tech fixes like apps for covid rather than good tech fixes like masks and vaccines. If that's the case then technosolutionism is trivially not the fix by definition. On the other hand good tech advances mostly are the answer to pandemic problems like the plague, smallpox etc.
- davidivadavid 6y agoThere's a whole cottage industry of journalism based on criticism of "technology" that's predicated on the idea that "technology" == Silicon-Valley-based software/apps. Of course, that has the downside of overlooking the fact that most problems are actually solved by technology, technology being what humans create to solve their problems. Somehow, mRNA vaccines, which are to a large extent more high tech than most CRUD software developed in SV, isn't considered "technology".
- bonoboTP 6y agoI think it's specifically "tech", the shortened form, that refers to websites and apps in today's usage. "Technology", the full word includes medical advances, aerospace, innovative construction materials, solar panels, whatever. What really drives me up the wall is when people call a library or a software framework or platform "a technology" (countable noun) in software. Like "Silverlight technology". I'm like "no, it's still a minor facet of information technology or computing technology, it's not a technology on its own".
- Miraste 6y agoThis is an unconvincing article. If we look past the paragraphs of emotional appeals, the actual results for "technosolutionism" during the pandemic are this: China created a technosolutionist fix. They implemented it widely with government backing. It was invasive but worked. South Korea created a technosolutionist fix, which was less invasive than China's. It was implemented widely with government backing. It also worked. Apple/Google created a technosolutionist fix. It was not implemented in the US and did not receive government backing. It did not work. The article claims this disparity is really because South Korea is "homogenous" and "trusting". The US instead attempted to implement "proven measures" that "relied on the public . . . to adhere to them." This also did not work, for the reason technosolutionists said it wouldn't: the public didn't adhere to them. What part of this is supposed to show that "technosolutionism isn't the fix?"
- ralfd 6y agoYes, and the ultimate technosolution by the west is a vaccine.
- cbozeman 6y agoVietnam created a technosolutionist fix, it was also implemented widely with government backing. It did also work. And now its being used by police to crack down on specific groups and individuals that the government doesn't particularly like, even after that same government assured the Vietnamese people that this data wouldn't be used in such a way. > The US instead attempted to implement "proven measures" that "relied on the public . . . to adhere to them." This also did not work, for the reason technosolutionists said it wouldn't: the public didn't adhere to them. It didn't work because America is advanced freedom. Not freedom in the sense of, "You're free to eat sushi or have a burger instead," but freedom in the sense of, "You're free to make a cornucopia of bad choices... but you're going to be free to suffer from them too." The best quote I've ever heard in regards to this: "The true price of freedom is having to endure what other people do with it."
- toiletfuneral 6y agoThe US Gov is already kidnapping citizens in unmarked vans and snooping on all our data so I’m not even sure we’re really getting the freedom part. I wonder what number of COVID deaths stops being acceptable losses for our amazing liberty? After sandy hook I’m guessing there is no limit
- balozi 6y agoConsider the application of technosolutionism as described to other modern spheres, example climate change, where the economic stakes are extremely high for the ordinary citizen.
- makerofspoons 6y agoIt is under reported in media and public service campaigns about climate that we can no longer mitigate the problem merely by cutting emissions- we have committed ourselves to carbon sequestration which is the unproven brainchild of technosolutionism and most of us never got a vote.
- twblalock 6y agoAside from China, a substantial amount of global carbon emissions comes from rich Western democracies where everyone did have a vote, in multiple elections over decades, during which scientists were warning the public about climate change. The voters chose to elect politicians who didn't solve the problem. In some cases, the voters chose politicians who denied that problem existed. It's not a good situation, but we definitely got a vote.
- scythe 6y ago>Technosolutionism is a way of understanding the world that assigns priority to engineered solutions to human problems. Its first principle is the notion that an app, a machine, a software program, or an algorithm offers the best solution to any complicated problem. Critics of "technosolutionism" as the author calls it often end up committing the same mistake backwards. Why implement an unpopular, slow, inconsistent and/or expensive social reform when a perfectly good technology does exist? One example is noise pollution. We continue to build buildings with thin walls where even the "recommended" STC 50 means that you can hear "loud speech" through the wall, to say nothing of music: http://commercial-acoustics.com/common-wall-stc-values/ http://commercial-acoustics.com/common-wall-stc-values/ Then we waste inordinate amounts of time and energy fining noise violations, which fails to actually prevent noise, but does do a good job of making young people hate the cops. After more than 10 years living in what passes for multi-unit housing in the United States, I still lie awake at night wishing for technosolutionism to put a proper wall between me and my neighbors.
- helen___keller 6y agoAn aside: to say we should use technology build to better sound insulation is one thing, but first we have to build at all, which some American cities cannot even manage. This old 1920s-built 3 bedroom 1 bathroom unit I live in rents out at $3500/mo. Renovation is vastly cheaper than demolition/reconstruction (assuming such a thing could even be approved).
- burnthrow 6y ago> Technosolutionism is a way of understanding the world that assigns priority to engineered solutions to human problems. Also known as technocracy, but someone has to feed The Saurus I guess.
- jjk166 6y agoTechnocracy is rule by technical experts, usually taking the form of a bureaucracy composed primarily of educated and experienced professionals. Technosolutionism is the belief that "there should be an app for that"
- anchpop 6y ago> Technosolutionists were blithely dismissive of such proven measures not only because their advocates were often inconsistent in their advice (don’t wear a mask, wear a mask) but because the recommendations relied on the public (that mass of humanity whom technosolutionists, in the main, view as irrational and misguided) to adhere to them voluntarily. Sounds like the technosolutionists were right on the money?
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI think what underpins this type of criticism is an irrational desire for computationalism as a general philosophy to be wrong and inapplicable, despite the dramatic empirical success it enjoys. > “ Technosolutionism is a way of understanding the world that assigns priority to engineered solutions to human problems. Its first principle is the notion that an app, a machine, a software program, or an algorithm offers the best solution to any complicated problem.” But you can’t escape science. Whatever is a solution, if it can be reduced to repeatable physical processes and computational substrates, is amenable to engineering and engineering has almost universally made such solutions more scalable, more reliable, safer, more affordable and so on. I think there is a dangerous Luddite narrative underpinning this that ultimately is not self-consistent and likely to do more harm than good. Also anecdotally, as an introvert, I can’t overstate how much happier I feel working from home. I’ll take all the flaws of videoconferencing any day, over the constant fight-vs-flight reflex exhaustion of open plan offices and a constant stream of in-person interaction when I need solitude and privacy to get mental clarity about my work.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago> I think there is a dangerous Luddite narrative ... What was ever dangerous about the actual Luddites, as opposed to the story told about the Luddites by their foes?
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoApplying headwinds to progress causes immense compounded harm.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago"Progress" is an undefined, or ill-defined, and highly subjective term. In the 90's, Chris Lasch even argued that it was a relatively new concept, and unknown to his favorite class of human being (the "yeoman", with the traditional US family farmer as a key example, though the concept goes back to at least the Greeks). The Luddites were not against progress. They were against specific forms of progress in which they (1) had no say (2) lost their livelihoods (3) to others who benefitted in what they considered unreasonable ways.
- isoskeles 6y agoThis article doesn't present a thoughtful definition on what technology, and by extension technosolutionism, is. This is what we get: > Technosolutionism is a way of understanding the world that assigns priority to engineered solutions to human problems. Its first principle is the notion that an app, a machine, a software program, or an algorithm offers the best solution to any complicated problem. As a clear example, the article proposes that contract tracing apps are ineffective unless we are also testing the population at risk. Okay, where does testing come from? Testing is also a technological solution. A human does not look at your sample with a pen and pad and make a decision on whether you have covid. The sample doesn't speak to us and admit actually it does have covid. Testing is technology. Vaccination is technology. I'll even argue that washing your hands is technology, in the sense that >99% of us interpret the message as to use mass-produced soap with water delivered to your sink through plumbing. --- Technology usually makes life easier in some way of convenience. Although it can be unclear if it really makes life easier, as technology will often come at the cost of maintaining it. The invention of cars probably looked like a huge convenience, and out of it birthed an entire industry where people made their livelihoods, and now we've moved on to hating ourselves for inventing cars and ruining the environment, creating another industry that creates technology to make the use of energy have less of an effect on the environment. One day, we'll have a problem with that too. My biggest issue with this article isn't that it's against technosolutionism, it's that it tries to draw some ARBITRARY line in the sand where the procession of technological progress must end. Sending kids to school over Zoom is where we draw the line? What about the problem where public schools closely model the idea of working at an industrial factory?
- randcraw 6y agoI think the author sees technosolutionism (TS) as a blind faith that technology will solve each problem we have... eventually. Of course, like capitalism, if the problem is harder or less profitable than another, it will receive less attention than lower-hanging/sexier alternatives and perhaps never be addressed at all, much less to a degree of competence or integration that provides lasting improvement to our world. That said, I think the principal problem with TS is its essential entanglement with novelty. We are drawn to novelty like moths to flame, often responding with disproportionate favor to the sexiness of the Next Next Thing, regardless of its prospect for real utility (e.g. the Segway...). The invention doesn't have to add significant value; it just has to capture enough mindshare for the inventors to use the favorable press to sell off the business. Then the product is absorbed into a bigger fish's ecosystem where filling a niche profitably, however trivial, is good enough. The fundamental problem with TS is that its impact is mostly promotional and ephemeral —- that of introducing A New and Better Way. While revolution is sexier, it's much less viable to make lasting impact than evolution. It can't be sustained in an ephemera-based ecosystem driven only by advancing the next quarter's mindshare. For TS to escape the surly bonds of Earth, it has to be driven by more than enthusiasm for the latest cool demo. In decades past, large firms with deep pockets and long term tech agendas (IBM, Intel, GE) provided persistent inertia to turn TS into lasting infrastructure. But with their demise, I see no Next Next generation firms to fill those shoes. Perhaps the only form of invention left now is TS, and I agree with the author; that's clearly not enough.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrRandomGuy 6y agoThink a lot of posters are taking the criticism of `Technosolutionism` to literally mean _technology_; not various apps/services which are hailed to solve problem X without any actual evidence/merit of that claim. I really don't think they bundle vaccines into that department...
- TeMPOraL 6y agoBecause that's how its expressed. Like other criticism in this now fashionable genre, it accuses technology of being the problem. Of course this is a complete red herring, but it bites, because commenting on the actual source of the problem will make you sound like you're just rehashing Marxist tropes, which everyone has heard already and thus they don't drive engagement.
- causalmodels 6y agoMy issue with the article that o treat technosolutionism as something imposed on society by engineers misses the point entirely. Technosolutionism is a response to the complete failure of our deliberative democratic institutions to deliver actual solutions to our problems. It is not reasonable to ask people to trust their institutions when they have frequently and completely failed the people they were created to serve. If we want people to trust deliberative democratic processes, and I think we should, then we need to ensure those bodies are actually capable of functioning.
- adamlangsner 6y agoI think I'm the only one here who liked this article. While there are some good, albeit somewhat pedantic, points raised in the comments. I think we may be missing the forest for the trees. There is a sort of sophomoric myopia that exists in silicon valley and maybe it's not technology per se that is the problem, but in fact the incentives created around the tech community. I think the problem is more accurately described as the combination of access to large amounts of capital and low cost mass communication/experimentation technologies (i.e. the internet). This has a created a culture that thinks they can solve any problem with one of the two. But I think what's even worse is that the solutionists subconsciously have an unspoken prerequisite to "solving" a problem, which is "It needs to be wildly profitable". And it's that incentive that lead to the myopia and pervert the "solutions" they create. Instacart and Uber are great examples. Did they actually solve a problem? For whom did they solve it for? For whom did they not solve it for? Did they make certain things worse than they were before? You probably have your own answers to those questions.
- peytn 6y agoI liked it too. In the case of the pandemic, if we were as smart as we think we are, we would’ve had the public doing drills. We didn’t put in the work ahead of time. The countries that’ve done well are the countries that faced SARS back in 2003. I don’t blame anybody for not wanting to go along with these just-in-time pandemic fixes or for self-soothing with misinformation. Educational initiatives would’ve been funded and followed during swine flu with little difficulty. We’ve had ten years to pull together a well-orchestrated plan and build up our societal immune system.
- dqpb 6y agoFine example of truly moronic thinking: > "distance education assumes a great deal about its recipients that has not proven true. Children who expertly sift through YouTube videos and Instagram posts, or master video games like Fortnite, have honed skills that have not proven transferrable to online learning. Nevertheless, the country’s experiment in online learning—which is also an experiment in the desocialization of education—is one that some technosolutionist leaders hope to continue, despite early evidence of its failures." Distance and online education has been effectively used for decades, and is rapidly improving with the recent growth of Coursera, EdX, and Udacity. Public schools Zoom classroom shitshows don't in any way comprise "early evidence of failures of online learning". It shows only that ad-hoc Zoom classes set up by public schools aren't effective methods of online-learning.
- petercooper 6y agoOne word you can't find in this article is 'vaccine.' Yes, there are downsides to the overuse of technology in society and discussing them is fine. But there are huge upsides which are keeping people alive whether through the extremely rapid development of vaccines or the mitigation of disability or, even at a minimum, keeping people employed. Can you imagine if coronavirus had hit in 1985 and we'd had lockdowns like these?