4 ms·
The US has an interesting problem right now. Wild hogs are wreaking utter havoc and we don't have effective means to control their population. I'm fairly conf
by klyrs 6y ago
The US has an interesting problem right now. Wild hogs are wreaking utter havoc and we don't have effective means to control their population. I'm fairly confident that humans will win that battle. But what if we nuked population centers? Most of the hogs would survive, but only a fraction of the humans. Who would win out in the decades to come? Hogs can eat all sorts of roughage, survive out in the elements, etc., humans are much more dependant on their technology. Want crops? Sorry, hogs ate 'em. Wanna eat hogs? They're smart, and after your ammo stores are depleted, you're back to the stone age.
But the question isn't mere survival -- can intelligent life thrive to the point where we can achieve interstellar travel?
- Retric 6y agoI think you’re underestimating Stone Age humans, we used to hunt freaking lions and other big cats with stone tools. We started causing mass extinctions long before industrialization.
- klyrs 6y agoI'm not underestimating stone age humans -- I've spent much of my life learning and using stone age skills. Not enough that I can actually live as a stone age human, mind, and there's the rub. In that learning, I've met a very small number of folks (like [1]) who are actually equipped to survive a stone age. Judging by my experience, by watching other "good" students in those classes... with good training by masters, we still fail hard on our first few times out. And we're well-fed, moderately well-equipped, and not suffering from radiation poisoning. The real question isn't "how badass were stone age humans", it's "can the smartphone generation re-invent stone age technology quickly enough to survive"? https://www.outsideonline.com/2411125/lynx-vilden-stone-age-life https://www.outsideonline.com/2411125/lynx-vilden-stone-age-...
- dwaltrip 6y agoIt would probably incredibly brutal and many would die early on, but as long as enough people survived the initial transition and found some sort of stability, humanity would carry on. Even if conditions were generally terrible, just a few areas where the survivors can grab a toehold could be enough. The prospect of a grim, untimely death for yourself and everyone you love would be rather motivating.
- lumost 6y agoThis sounds like a great premise for a novel, and the question could be explored at a quite deep level. Consider that most ecosystems are now codependent on human civilization, and many locales do not have the necessary flora or water availability to support stone age civilization. There are certainly some ecosystems such as fishing communities north of Vancouver that would do well and be shielded from any nuclear exchange, but the wild deer population in Massachusetts would likely not be sufficient for any significant number of modern stone age men to survive.
- The_rationalist 6y agoI recommend the anime Dr Stone which answer the inverse question: can a smartphone generation, put in a stone age world, re-invent modern technology quickly enough to survive"?
- rriepe 6y agoTribes are how humans survive. What we think of as "survivalism"-- a single person getting by alone in the woods-- wouldn't work in any era with any technology.
- perl4ever 6y agoThere weren't very many humans in the world back in the stone age. With a future catastrophe, there will be so many people that there will be a lot of them way out on the tail of the distribution, whatever is selected for.
- imtringued 6y agoGoing by the how to make everything series I am 100% confident a million people with a smartphone with an offline copy of wikipedia and a single solar farm to charge them could rebuild human society within a lifetime to 15th century level with some early elements of industrial machinery. The few centuries after that are quite insignificant.