13 ms·
German laptop retailer fined $12.7M under GDPR for employee surveillance
- benjohnson 6y agoWhile the US doesn't have GDPR - there's some lessons to learn: it's not nice to put people under the microscope all day long. We're trying to strike a reasonable ballance: For our business we have an inventory room that is under full and complete survalence - but the rest of the office has none.
- Bayart 6y agoI'm quite certain I've seen at some point on HN a paper to the effect of workplace surveillance and paranoia being actively detrimental to productivity. Plus there was that story about surveillance-as-a-feature being put into Office 360 a short while back.
- darkfirefly 6y agoJust look up the Panopticon, tbh.
- scotty79 6y agoThat's weird. There was some research that people behave more morally when they think they are being observed. Even if they see themselves looking at themselves in the mirror.
- Bayart 6y agoBehaving morally and doing useful work aren't the same thing. Imagining Jesus is behind my shoulder might make me question my need for masturbation, but it sure won't help focusing on code.
- oaiey 6y agoExactly the point. It is not nice to be under a microscope.
- olieidel 6y agoHaving stricter data privacy regulation in the EU is good. But I'm getting the impression that the authorities prefer to look into local companies where "easy wins" can be had - like in this article. Let's get this straight: I think the video surveillance here was not okay. But - shouldn't the authorities rather pursue things which matter more, i.e. maximising the impact of (number of humans affected * magnitude of effect)? The WhatsApp <> Facebook data sharing situation comes to mind. Or the recent change of their privacy policy. There's lots more. I feel that big (SV) tech companies have much more leeway than local companies, simply because their probability of being fined is lower.
- StavrosK 6y agoI don't think they're not doing both. Also, the probability of getting fined might be lower, but when Facebook gets fined it won't be for 12.7 million.
- ognarb 6y agoThe problem is that if you only fine the big tech companies, the small companies will just don't bother with the GDPR. What we need is more people working on GDPR cases.
- wojcikstefan 6y agoAFAICT the WA <> FB data sharing will not happen to the users in the EU. Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/carlypage/2021/01/08/whatsapp-tells-users-share-your-data-with-facebook-or-well-deactivate-your-account/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/carlypage/2021/01/08/whatsapp-t... says "In a statement given to Forbes, a WhatsApp spokesperson confirmed that there will be no changes to WhatsApp’s data-sharing practices in Europe and the UK."
- actuator 6y agowhich makes it even worse looking for rest of the world. If it is indeed not harmful like Facebook is claiming to be by pushing WhatsApp status updates, they can choose to do it in EU also.
- Keyframe 6y agoI'm not sure I follow/agree on blanket surveillance of a workplace... Would this translate to a bank as well? Having a recording of an armed robbery or theft during daily count would come in handy as probably often does. If that's alright for a bank, how's this different?
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoBanks are high-risk, and video surveillance is longstanding practice and generally fine. BUT I believe it is required to face the customer area (and, therefore, film employees mostly from the back). There's also usually a "pit"-like work area that's employee-only and I would imagine that's out of bounds, as well.
- detaro 6y agoIn the way it's described in the article? yes, that very likely wouldn't fly in a bank as well. Banks do have video surveillance, but with more restricted terms, e.g. clear information which areas are monitored, risk assessments which areas justify being monitored, restricted recording (i.e. only very short-term storage that needs human intervention to be preserved), processes around when and through whom recordings can be accessed at all, ...
- Quanttek 6y ago> According to the regulator, cameras recorded employees in workplaces, salesrooms, warehouses, and common areas. NBB claimed the aim was to prevent and investigate criminal offenses and to track the flow of goods in the warehouses. > However, in order to prevent theft, a company must first use “milder” methods, such as random bag checks when employees leave the premises. Moreover, the LfD said video surveillance is only lawful if there is “justified suspicion” against specific persons, and even then, video monitoring may only be used for a “limited” time. > The data authority found NBB’s video surveillance was neither limited to a specific period of time nor to specific employees. The recordings were saved for 60 days in many cases. Customers were also filmed in seating areas without their knowledge or consent. > The regulator said “the allegedly deterrent effect of video surveillance, which is repeatedly put forward, does not justify a permanent and unprovoked interference with the personal rights of employees” in a translated press release. > “We are dealing with a serious case of video surveillance in the company,” said Barbara Thiel, head of LfD Lower Saxony, in a translated statement. “Companies must understand that with such intensive video surveillance they are massively violating the rights of their employees.” > Thiel added video surveillance is “a particularly intensive encroachment on personal rights” because it can pressurize employees “to behave as inconspicuously as possible in order not to be criticized or sanctioned for deviating behavior.” Finally! It always amazes me how computer monitoring and video surveillance at the workplace have become so widespread. Also, the idea of focussing on widespread breaches of the right to privacy is a great one. It helps spread a better understanding of the meaning of the right to privacy.
- detaro 6y ago> Finally! This isn't exactly a new legal situation in Germany at least. (Which obviously doesn't mean companies don't try, otherwise we wouldn't have headlines like this...)
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoYep. WW2 legacy resulted in two major additions to the foundations of new Germany: spying on citizens is highly regulated, freedom of speech does not exist for certain types of speech.
- fersarr 6y agocan offices have cameras then, or is a warehouse somehow different? because they seem to be all over the place in most companies
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoNo, office cannot have cameras (in Germany). The legal framework is rather easy (and hasn't changed with GDPR, as far as I can tell): video surveillance is generally illegal. There are specific circumstances where it is legal, and those tend to require two things: - there needs to be some "risk" that is higher than usual, and where video surveillance can make a difference. - it's extremely hard to justify surveillance of spaces where people regularly spend long amounts of time, such as their workplace. Generic offices fail both tests: what, exactly, are you looking for? Stapler thefts? And, at the same time, the intrusion is rather is far more significant than, say, a public transit station that you pass through.
- oaiey 6y agoExactly. To add crimes and punishment have to be in balance. Stealing staples or calling a cop a name cannot bring you in prison in Germany. Same is applied here: you are in fear of loosing $10k/y in warehouse to theft... Not a rationale to steal legal rights from 20 workers. Numbers are made up :)
- kamyarg 6y agoI see a lot of mentions of GDPR in the comments, but the fact is that the sensitivity of personal information is an older mindset(not only a law) in Germany. It is called "Datenschutz", and you see people proactively adhering to it, needed some time as a foreigner to get used to how rigorously they apply it, but when I got used to it, felt "safer" knowing whoever handles my data, knows how sensitive it is. See https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datenschutz https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datenschutz for more information about the history.
- pacamara619 6y agoA newer term being heard more often is "Datensparsamkeit". Id est only saving the absolutely necessary amount of data such that extensive surveillance and data abuse isn't possible.
- tleb_ 6y agoThis seems to refer to the concept of "data minimisation", that can be seen as an important concept in the GDPR. See article 5 § 1.c https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32016R0679&from=FR#d1e1807-1-1 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...
- TulliusCicero 6y agoDoes the money go to the employees? Since it was their privacy that was violated?
- epanchin 6y agoIf that happened, authorities would rapidly lose the will to investigate breaches.
- markdown 6y agoWait, do the police and public prosecutor in your country personally receive the money from fines resulting from their prosecution of crimes like this one?
- Triv888 6y agoThey do, when it comes to civil forfeiture/seizure [1]... not sure about lawsuits. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Civil_forfeiture_in_the_U...
- __m 6y agoArticle is about a german company.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corty 6y agoIn Germany, fines go to the general state or federal budget, not the police budget. The only thing where there is a really obvious wrong incentive are parking violations, those go to the community, the community prosecutes and sets the local parking regs. So that, along with speeding tickets inside city limits (in parts), is a money-printing business for them.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIs there a way to move to Europe? Considering it.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoEither you marry someone, find an employer happy to sponsor you or buy a residency - the cheapest is Latvia at 300k$ (you invest in real estate). Once you spend 5 years in the country you can become a citizen and you can move wherever you want in EU or get a job without visa sponsorship. It's generally easier than going EU -> US, from my peers' experience.
- 2rsf 6y ago> find an employer happy to sponsor you That's common and easy in Sweden, "sponsorship" is cheap and doesn't require a lot from the employers
- oaiey 6y agoJust apply for a Visa :)
- dependsontheq 6y agoFrom which country? US citizen get special priority when they move to Germany, in reality that means that I never heard of any US citizen having any kind of problem emigrating to Germany (and my wife is an immigration attorney).
- alex_duf 6y agoUnless you go to Ireland you might have to learn a second language if you don't already. (which I would recommend!) And get a visa, which depending on which country in europe you target will have different rules
- eythian 6y agoIt does depend a lot. Where I live there are many expats who haven't learnt anything beyond the basics of the local language, and get along fine in English. Even a lot of government departments here will send letters in both languages.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI wonder how well the money retrieved will be used by the government and how the company is going to cope. Are employees going to be fired because their privacy was being infringed?
- hh3k0 6y agoThe government will use the money as it sees fit. You don't like what your government spends money on? Don't vote for the ruling party at upcoming elections. That laptop website had a turnover of 879 million Euro in 2018, btw. They'll probably manage. Your priorities are weird, though. "How will the criminal entity cope with the consequences of their unlawful actions?"
- oaiey 6y agoIt is a business risk and an employee risk to work for a company doing shady stuff. Yeah, may backfire on employees but this fine is not about the employees but the company violating a law.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoHeadline next year: NBB laptops found to have hardware back door, apparently installed by rogue worker who was NSA agent at factory.
- xbar 6y agoMeanwhile, London Police....
- Steppschuh 6y agoI worked for NBB as an Android Engineer about 5 years ago. While refactoring the analytics / tracking services (5 different providers in the app), I noticed that customers credit card data was leaking to analytics providers. I informed my PO about this, but he decided that this wouldn't be worth the effort fixing. I left the next day.
- confiq 6y agoout of curiosity, did you say the reason why you quit?
- Steppschuh 6y agoSure. This wasn't the only reason and I had a meeting with my team lead talking about all of them.
- bitL 6y agoI am wondering if NVidia is going to drop NBB as their exclusive Founder Edition distributor now. I wouldn't be suprised if NBB went bankrupt after this (HW margins are super low).