7 ms·
Facebook will pay more than $300 each to 1.6M Illinois users in settlement
- fingerlocks 6y agoI realize that Facebook is like the Phillip-Morris of the tech industry around here, but I still find this a little unsettling. Facial recognition is near ubiquitous among social media and photo library apps. The “tangible” damages to all of these users is not clear to me. I can’t help but wonder if there was some other driving factor here The legal firms representing the plaintiffs asked to get about $110 million of the settlement money. And there it is.
- chaostheory 6y agoThat’s the driving factor for many consumer lawsuits against companies
- ve55 6y agoThat is how class action lawsuits always work though; Facebook is an obvious target for breaking the law here for many reasons, but I would say their scale (being the largest) and their ability to profit more efficiently than most other services contributed greatly to it. I'm happy the users get paid directly here rather than the money going to a barely-related government agency, as they were the ones whose privacy was breached illegally.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pseudalopex 6y agoThe law requires other social media services get consent too. Photo library apps can recognize faces locally. The law Facebook broke is designed to prevent tangible harm. Class actions are designed to make unprofitable cases profitable. $110M seems excessive but it's only 16% of the settlement.
- handedness 6y ago16% unusually low for a class action suit.
- gruez 6y ago>The legal firms representing the plaintiffs asked to get about $110 million of the settlement money. >And there it is. Would you rather that there's no profit motive, and they don't get sued at all?
- fingerlocks 6y agoNo, and I did not intend to suggest that. I naively believed that class action lawsuits required at least some amount of actual harm/fraud to individuals.
- sixothree 6y agoThe people chose to live in Illinois where they are protected from something. Whether you agree or disagree with that something is besides the point.
- fingerlocks 6y agoBesides what point? I started the thread making the point that I don’t agree with that “something”, so no I’m still very much on point.
- mNovak 6y agoNot to play into the metaphor, but that feels a little like saying every brand of cigarettes is dangerous, why should Marlboro take heat? Sure, it may not literally kill you, but I think a lot of people agree that ubiquitous data harvesting is not great. Illinois took a small stand against that with its biometric data law.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- snoshy 6y agoI don't quite agree that this is a meaningless or trivial violation of Illinois law, but let's set that aside. The fact that end users actually get anything more than a few dollars is what's actually shocking to me. Usually it's a case of the lawyers keeping near 80-90% and the rest of the pittance is allocated to administrative overhead, with a few pennies thrown to plaintiffs that weren't actually driving the lawsuit. Or then the payout (if it's big) goes to the state or federal coffers, is another one, with victims seeing no compensation at all. I am actually very genuinely curious about how they managed to get even a $100+ payout to those affected.
- apple_innocent 6y ago"The "tangible" damages to all these users is not clear to me." The Illinois Supreme Court decided there is no need to claim actual damages. As the article clearly states, there are statutory damages.1 You might think of these as like a fine you pay everytime you violate Illinois privacy law. 1. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/01/victory-illinois-supreme-court-protects-biometric-privacy https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/01/victory-illinois-supre... Certainly we can be cynical about class actions. Class action lawyers handling cases with millions of class members probably care about individual class members as much as over-compensated Facebook employees care about individual Facebook users (or internet users Facebook spies on in general). One difference is lawyers are regulated, licensed professionals who have to follow ethics rules, while Facebook employees implementing and deploying privacy-violating technology for profit are under no such restrictions. Imagine if lawyers could use all the personal, confidential information they see in the course of their work with clients to finance an online "platform" for targeted advertising. Knowing so much about people's personal lives, they could pass on "relevant ads" to clients. Perhaps they could even promise that their services would "always be free". Fortunately, they can't. However, Facebook can.
- spurdoman77 6y ago> One difference is lawyers are regulated, licensed professionals who have to follow ethics rules LOL
- dodobirdlord 6y agoSeriously though, lawyers are basically never sanctioned or disbarred, and the level of misbehavior required to invite sanctions is extremely high.
- washadjeffmad 6y agoSo it's an effective deterrent? What matters is there's a recognized process for it. What does Facebook call doing something profitable that crosses a legal or ethical boundary before their competitors can do it? Promotable innovation, probably.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoThe legal firms taking the case of the plaintiffs took on risk, normally when you take on risk and succeed you should be rewarded.
- fingerlocks 6y agoWhat’s the downside risk of losing this case?
- Invictus0 6y agoThe cost of paying a bunch of lawyer's salaries for months on end...
- spoonjim 6y agoThe benefit of class actions isn’t the money paid to the plaintiff, it’s the money taken from the defendant. The money could be set on fire and the judgment would still be a good thing because it punishes the offender, the problem is that at FB’s wealth even $500 million is a sneeze.
- lovecg 6y agoIt’s a system that converts greed into (an approximation of) justice. There might be better systems, but it’s not the worst one to have.
- njarboe 6y agoAt least in this class action suit the members of the class are getting $338. A decent amount of money. Not just some $10 coupon the company would have been happy to send you for free.
- stickfigure 6y agoThe plaintiffs in the case argued that Facebook violated that law when it introduced the "tag suggestions" feature without gaining express consent from users. I'm going to step out on a limb here and say the outrage police are getting out of hand. Tag suggestions are incredibly useful. If I have a library of pictures (and I do), I want software to suggest tags for them. They're my pictures, FFS.
- AdamTReineke 6y agoI'm pretty sure it's because Facebook started suggesting that Alice should be tagged in Bob's photos without Alice's consent. They're Bob's photos but it's using Alice's likeness to suggest tagging her without her consent. Edit: And the law in Illinois is (to quote the article): 'The statute requires any entity that gathers biometric data—including fingerprints, voice prints, "hand or face geometry," and retinal or iris scans—to get informed consent from those individuals whose data it collects'
- blackoil 6y agoIf I have a 4/8k video where I recorded voice and face of a person, do I need to get a consent or only when I extract it and use it as biometric data?
- opnitro 6y agodepends on the state and the context, but yes: audio/video recordings without consent of both parties can be illegal.
- stickfigure 6y agoSo in Illinois it's illegal to run face detection against my own photo library, the way iPhoto did 5 years ago?
- eganist 6y agoSounds like there's a difference between gathering prints (faceprints, fingerprints, voiceprints) that can be used to identify people v. simply identifying that something is a face, a fingertip, or a voice, which is what iPhoto did.
- jennyyang 6y ago$110M for the lawyers is absurd. We as a country need to disincentivize lawyers from filing lawsuits like this. There should be a limit based on how many hours they work, etc. Lawyers fees should be negotiated on top of the settlement, it's one of the reasons why our country is the way it is, lawyers trying to make a huge payday.
- adventured 6y agoThat's an interesting balancing problem, because if you disincentivize it too much, Facebook can afford to own all the lawyers (so to speak) and grease their wheels enough (or intimidate them away) that nobody of any consequential skill will pursue the cases (and this is where someone argues that the government should do it instead and it should all be a public legal effort; which is where I point out that Facebook, Google, Amazon etc. are deep in bed with the government). Further, when going after monster corporations it can be both physically dangerous to your well-being and career threatening, so the financial reward should be there to take on a trillion dollar company with tens of billions in annual profit and extreme political clout. Any lawyer willing to try to cut into these extraordinarily evil companies, I say give them the money. The lawyers are being compensated like SEC whistleblowers in a modern war against vast human rights violations, they're mercenaries in a conflict and should probably be compensated as such when they achieve big results.
- rubyist5eva 6y agoIf lawyers don't get paid, they don't bother going to court at all. Do they deserve to be abundantly compensated for their skills and time spent taking on one of the most powerful companies in the history of the humanity? If not - who would bother?
- BoorishBears 6y agoThis isn't a response to a good faith reading of their comment. There is a vast gulf between 110 million dollars and not getting paid. Even keeping in mind just how expensive a lawyer's time is, how would say, 10 million dollars not be enough of a jackpot for a lawyer to take on a case like this? It really does seem like a truly arbitrary and overinflated amount for the lawyers to make out like this. I wonder how many of those 1.6M users would benefit from 50 dollars more than the lawyer will benefit from an extra 100 million.
- rhacker 6y agoI think local law is absolutely the way to change big company practices. We keep thinking we need to change US or world law to affect privacy practices, but in reality, local laws can absolutely make these large companies re-think the consequences of rolling out something. It might be a drop in the bucket for them, but these stories teach other jurisdictions that they too can fight back. I mean think about prop 65 warnings. Nearly every box in the US has these warnings because of one state's law. (Not arguing for or against prop 65 here - that's a different issue - but look at what effect it has on the entire system)
- mensetmanusman 6y agoAs a reminder that lawyers still run the world, they got over $1M each in the settlement :)
- xnyan 6y agoI'm not a superfan of lawyers, but they got 110 out of 650 millon or a little over 16% of the total settlement. For 5 years of work and the very real risk of getting nothing if they lose, that sounds reasonable to me.
- ydlr 6y agoFor 5 years of work.
- np_tedious 6y agoYes important point, but also probably not 5 years of active work. I'm sure they were doing other things, performing some steps and then waiting for others to act, etc. You don't "work" 8 hours to make a crockpot stew