9 ms·
The State of VR on Linux
- foxrider 6y agoI was also pleasantly surprised by how well VR works on Linux and how much work had been put in to make even the Proton experience seamless. I now have over 1500 hours in VR exclusively on Linux.
- sliken 6y agoWhat are your favorite VR games/apps on linux?
- foxrider 6y agoBoneworks certainly takes the cake as my absolute VR title. It beats even Alyx in terms of gameplay alone. Playtime-wise I spent most hours in Elite Dangerous - flying in an HMD adds so much to the game that its hard to put in words how immersed I feel.
- leeoniya 6y agoi'm waiting to try Alyx, cause i think the outlay for the hardware alone will be quite large. any insight into how compatible Valve's Index will be with non-valve games? i don't really wanna drop $2k-$3k to play a single title and have the VR hardware work poorly with other games or become obsolete in 2 months; the pace of state-of-the-art in VR was so rapid, that i didn't want to spend money on anything until some bug-free plateau was reached.
- zlsa 6y agoValve Index will work with any SteamVR game natively, and with a community-maintained wrapper, will work with many Oculus exclusive titles as well.
- mikenew 6y agoThe Index controllers can do everything other controllers can do + extra stuff. If you play a game that doesn't have finger tracking, that just means you don't get finger tracking. But the controllers themselves work just fine. There are some games that might not have a good set of bindings for the index controllers by default (something might be bound to "squeeze the grip" when it should be bound to the trigger, for example), but you just open the settings menu (inside VR), click "custom bindings", and then pick the most upvoted community made set of bindings and it just works. Takes a few seconds.
- gen3 6y agoI bought and index and have been driving it with a 2700x and 1060 6gb. Alyx was hands down one of, if not the best gaming experience I’ve ever had. I think the index controllers really take the experience to another level. Being able to pick up things by grabbing them is awesome. The headphones on the index are amazing too, and really help with immersion. Support with other games is pretty good. I bought a bunch of games during the summer sale, and haven’t found anything unplayable for me. Not all games have full finger tracking, and not all games have the ability to pick things up like you can in Alyx. Some older games have been updated for Alyx style controls, but many control exactly how they did with the Vive. I tried VR in Linux first, then tried on windows. Windows has better feature support and performance hands down. If you have a better GPU, you might be fine, but the advantages to booting into windows was worth it to me.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway3699 6y agoIndex will work with anything. And vice versa, any headset can play Alyx well. If you're not up for spending all the money, you can mix and match SteamVR controllers/headsets (e.g. old school Vive with the fancier Knuckles Controllers).
- RamRodification 6y agoIsn't Oculus stuff DRM:ed to Oculus setups only somehow? Through their appstore maybe? Or have I just eaten the FUD to make me believe that
- jowsie 6y agoPretty much every game worth playing is also available on steam or via some other method. If you REALLY want the Oculus stuff there's always Revive. https://github.com/LibreVR/Revive https://github.com/LibreVR/Revive
- RamRodification 6y agoThanks
- porphyra 6y agoNot OP, but Beat Saber and Project Cars 2 work flawlessly in VR via Proton. Pretty surprising tbh. And of course Half Life Alyx is natively supported.
- xtracto 6y agoWhat's a good VR setup for Linux?
- ekianjo 6y agoValve Index + AMD GPU.
- ourlordcaffeine 6y agoHmmm, for me, with steamvr and a htc vive on linux, there is about a half second delay on tracking which quickly gives me nausea. The issue does not happen on windows.
- ve55 6y agoWith how user-hostile Windows has become lately I've been happy to see gaming on Linux go from how esoteric it used to be to the more commonplace scenario that it now is. While it's obviously a small fraction compared to Windows (as noted in the article, 0.5-2% seems accurate), those that tried playing modern games on Linux a decade ago would be pleasantly surprised to see how much more feasible it is today; it's come a long way. Valve and Steam have played an important role in this, but we've also seen significant improvements in wine, applications like Lutris, and all-around steady improvements in hardware support and drivers, as well as a much larger and more accessible community and body of knowledge. While there's still quite a few games that seem near-impossible to play from linux, I think a lot of people that decided against trying this many years ago would find things much better off than where they left off, especially for someone that is willing to put in just a little bit of time to fix potential issues (but of course, we must admit that sometimes one can be unlucky and spend hours trying to fix some specific issues, even if that is much more rare than it used to be). Although I don't play much, I'm happy to not have to dual boot Windows just to run a few select applications and I hope that things look even better this decade with the amount of interest we've seen in FOSS, user privacy and security, and so on, all increasing.
- pjmlp 6y agoAs proven by Netbooks, ChromeOS, Android and maker consoles. Anything Linux based that goes mainstream has very little to do with regular GNU/Linux, or is based on customized distributions, tainted with OEM specific drivers and kernels that never get updated.
- podiki 6y agoGreat article (disclosure: from my colleague at Boiling Steam)! Definitely learned a lot as a newbie to VR on Linux. I'm still new to VR but not Linux gaming, and have been having a blast. I really appreciate it especially in the winter (great and fun workouts while playing games) and when other activities are limited due to the tragedy that is the US coronovirus response. The sense of space is what really gets me, never have I felt so transported somewhere else. This is in contrast to things like 3D movies where stuff pops out at you, while this gives depth and openness as you step into huge rooms, landscapes, whatever. I also wrote [0] about just getting the Valve Index and playing on Linux with my aging but still capable desktop (poor 970 was still going strong but VR is really pushing it). [0] https://boilingsteam.com/the-valve-index-on-linux-on-a-min-spec-machine/ https://boilingsteam.com/the-valve-index-on-linux-on-a-min-s...
- gcblkjaidfj 6y agoSad to see the focus being on gaming. Installing any modern game on windows is a nightmare. You install one root kit after another. All running as administrator and installing things left and right, with each studio having their own identity tracking running forever in the background. The benefit of VR will be when it is decoupled entirely from games. Just like we got window manager composers when we finally stoped looking at openGL as a game technology.
- throwaway3699 6y agoOpenVR/OpenXR are already decoupled from games. You can target both Oculus and SteamVR with these APIs and pretty much do whatever you want. I think the only reason games dominate the medium is because of the hardware. It's very difficult to do productivity in VR, but comparatively easy to put a player into a simulated world to have fun.
- BlueTemplar 6y ago> You can target both Oculus and SteamVR with these APIs This hardly makes it better, and insures that VR will still be locked to other proprietary (and potentially spywareish) platforms (just not Windows).
- throwaway3699 6y agoThe point is that you can create a full FOSS runtime (+ drivers) for VR that will be compatible with most software out of the box. I think there was a project called OSVR that tried to do this, but I'm not sure how that's going. You could probably bring a lot of this work into the kernel if VR becomes popular enough. I've found that Valve is pretty good when it comes to respecting their users. SteamVR software isn't even DRM'd and can run without Steam.
- BlueTemplar 6y ago> So, a few early adopters of the technology started developing an alternative implementation of [Valve's] OpenVR called “Open Source Virtual Reality (OSVR) which even had open-source hardware projects. Sadly, its development stalled and even today its main site is offline. Ah, I didn't know that SteamVR could run without Steam. Can Alyx (once installed) ? Still, this leaves the issue is that being theoretically Steam-free isn't enough, as the experience with AOSP/Google Play Store has shown. Valve might be 'pretty good' with their own users, but still the result of Steam's dominance is that it's getting harder and harder to get mods and play multiplayer outside of Steam.
- FullyFunctional 6y agoI read these reports with a mixture of jealousy and frustration; my Valve Index + 3900XT + Radeon Vega 56 (sigh) works splendidly under Windows 10, but despite everything I've tried, it Just Doesn't Work for me when I boot the same setup to Ubuntu 21.04 (note, Steam and non-VR Steam games work great). When I try to launch it, I get a "Only one instance of the game can be running at one time." pop-up and a "StreamVR has detected your headset running as a monitor. For best results, please switch to Direct Display Mode." Clicking "nable Disrect Display Mo" (sic) restarts SteamVR to a big window of grey binoculars. At no point is anything displayed in the headset.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 6y agoGot the same thing, I've tried everything in this issue to no avail but maybe something will work for you: https://github.com/ValveSoftware/SteamVR-for-Linux/issues/334 https://github.com/ValveSoftware/SteamVR-for-Linux/issues/33...
- FullyFunctional 6y agoThanks, I had already tried everything in there, but since posting I saw people suggesting unplugging the HDM and plugging it into another DP port. That actually worked, but the end result was very buggy and flaky, unusable in practice. I'll try again in 2022 when GPUs might be back in stock.
- ta988 6y agoI would be interested in developping (research) software based on VR under Linux, any recommendation for devices that work well? are there any Open frameworks?
- Ericson2314 6y agoRead the article: OpenXR.
- beervirus 6y agoI can’t even get a low-latency mouse response in X. What chance does VR have?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BlueTemplar 6y agoIt should be titled : "The State of VR Games on Linux : SteamVR only." I don't know about others, but the main reason why I moved to Linux is to get away from the spyware, DRM, closed source Windows which has reached for me the breaking point with Windows 8/10. So I'm not really interested to play games on Linux, if it's only to be forced to, yet again, use closed source, potentially DRM and spyware-riddled software. Even Valve got worse in this aspect, as, unlike for their earlier games, you seem to be forced to run Steam just to run Alyx. (Also I'm pissed that I now can't seem to be able to install Oculus Rift CV1's software on Windows 7 any more despite it having been sold as compatible with it for several years (and with Linux support having been promised in the still not materialized future !). Yes, I know, Facebook, but this was before the Cambridge Analytica scandal, though I still should have known better.) Sure, OpenXR : Monado and Arcan sound promising, but will they attract video game developers ? Vulkan seemed extremely promising too, but without Xbox support, it currently seems to go the way of OS/2, with no game developers directly targeting it (without even bothering with DirectX), and it being mostly used as a compatibility layer in the Steam/Proton stack.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoTo the downvoter : What, you really think that my title is NOT more accurate ? Have you even RTFA ?!?
- BlueTemplar 6y ago> Consider that we Linux users are a tiny slice of the desktop market. Let us be optimistic and say that we are 2% of desktop users (although in Steam it fluctuates around 0.86%). VR users in Steam are around 1.9% according to the latest hardware surveys, and those are gamers, they are not representative of the desktop users, but nevertheless let’s suppose that 2% of desktop users have some kind of VR device. If the proportions hold, Linux VR users would be 2 percent of 2 percent, or 0.04% of PC users, or 4 people in 10,000, and scattered all around the world. That tiny market would not even be a consideration for any sane investor. This math assumes that being a VR enthusiast and an (even occasional) Linux user are independent. On the opposite, I would guess that there's a lot of overlap between the two ! (Also with things like being a gadget-loving 'geek', still owning a desktop PC, &c.) P.S.: "Scattered around the world" is not an issue for software, and maybe even not for hardware, as the overwhelming majority of the users able to afford desktop 6DoF VR are going to be either in North America or Europe.