21 ms·
A lot of folks here are calling out the lower pay for SWEs in Europe and Canada as a failure - but also praise the low wealth inequality and low income inequali
by arcticbull 6y ago
A lot of folks here are calling out the lower pay for SWEs in Europe and Canada as a failure - but also praise the low wealth inequality and low income inequality in Europe and Canada.
You can't have low inequality by definition if you decide to start paying one group a ton of money.
Well, this is a lot like the housing conversation in the US. "I want my house to go up in value, and be a great investment!" Also: "Why can't I afford a house?"
You can't have your cake and eat it too.
It's not necessarily a failure, it's just a different place to draw the line on social contract. While individual contributors earn less the social safety net also makes it much easier to found and grow a business without the threat of death and guarantees a peaceable minimum standard of living. It's also worth pointing out that salary, especially at high seniority levels, becomes a smaller and smaller part of total compensation.
- betaby 6y agoI wouldn't call Canadian (or Fr or Se) wealth inequality 'low'. 'Why I can't afford a house', again is more a problem in Fr/De/Se than in US, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_home_ownership_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_home_owne...
- arcticbull 6y agoInequality in Canada is substantially lower than in America (and is on par with Australia, and between Fr and Se). This is evidenced in their Gini coefficients. [1] - Gini for SE is 0.25 - Gini for FR is 0.31 - Gini for CA is 0.33 - Gini for US is 0.48 - Gini for ZA is 0.65 I've also included South Africa for comparison, one of the least equal societies on earth. A photo of what a 0.65 Gini country looks like is here (https://blog.prif.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/SA_Drone_Picture_BLOG.jpg https://blog.prif.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/SA_Drone_Pi...) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient
- betaby 6y agoFrom your link, GINI of Canada and Tajikistan is the same or Finland and Azerbaijan. Totalitarian states like Belarus or Kazakhstan have one of the lowest GINIs in the world, now I question gini usefulness even more.
- arcticbull 6y agoI assumed you realized we were constraining ourselves to places with a High or Very High HDI. If nobody has any money at all, would you not say inequality is low? If everyone in Tajikistan has $5 except the president, Emomali Rahmon, is inequality not low? I suspect you are looking for a pairing of HDI and Gini, which factors in both the development (and hence the standard of living) and the inequality. Sweden: (Gini: 0.25, HDI: 0.933), France: (Gini: 0.31, HDI: 0.901), Canada: (Gini: 0.33, HDI: 0.926), USA: (Gini: 0.48, HDI: 0.924), South Africa: (Gini: 0.65, HDI: 0.709). Now, Tajikistan has an HDI of 0.66 ("medium"), and Azerbaijan 0.756 ("high"). Kazakhstan might surprise you, the HDI is 0.817 ("very high"). The standard of living there is actually good, in spite of what you may have seen on Borat - incidentally filmed in Romania. Almaty's been on my list of places to visit for a long time :) [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almaty
- dnautics 6y ago> If everyone in Tajikistan has $5 except the president That distribution will yield a very high gini coefficient of very close to 1.
- tobinfricke 6y agoNo, it yields a Gini coefficient very close to zero. The Gini coefficient is defined as 1/2 the mean absolute difference considering all pairs of households: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient A group of people where everyone has the same income as a Gini coefficient of exactly zero. Adding a single outlier will increase it a little. A group of 1001 with 1000 people earning $1 and one person earning $100 has a Gini coefficient of 0.09.
- 6y ago
- majormajor 6y agoAre those wealth or income coefficients? My impression has been that wealth inequality in many places in Europe is much higher than income inequality, as a factor of it being an older society. The places in Europe I'd want to move to are really no cheaper to buy a house than the places I'd want to live in the US.
- arcticbull 6y agoI grabbed these from FRED and it looks like they use the income version, not the wealth version. [1] [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SIPOVGINICAN https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SIPOVGINICAN
- majormajor 6y agoGotcha, thanks. I pulled some city-level numbers and it seems like at least in some areas, European SWE are missing out compared to coastal US ones: London 2018: 0.7 https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/nationalaccounts/uksectoraccounts/compendium/economicreview/february2020/analysingregionaleconomicandwellbeingtrends https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/nationalaccounts/uksectoracco... SF 2012: 0.523 https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Income-inequality-on-par-with-developing-nations-5486434.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Income-inequality-on-... (probably this has gone up!) Paris 2015: ~0.492 https://www.institutmontaigne.org/en/blog/data-inequalities-france-doing-better-most-oecd-countries https://www.institutmontaigne.org/en/blog/data-inequalities-... (they just say "similar to brazil", which is 0.492 Its unfortunately harder to find a bunch of city-level data, I wasn't able to find any German cities on quick googling, so I'm definitely fulfilling stereotypes of "Americans who think of Europe as just a couple famous cities", but those capture at least a couple of major population centers that aren't so appealing if you're a dev compared to the US hotspots: they're still unequal, but suddenly you're not nearly as high on the totem pole.
- gustavpaul 6y agoThat picture likely contrasts lower middle class and lower class - middle class and upper middle class houses in south africa would not be across the road from an informal settlement due to unbelievable levels of theft and violent crime in such areas.
- qwytw 6y agoHowever you look at wealth inequality Sweden is actually the most unequal country in that list: SE is 0.867 FR is 0.687 CA is 0.726 US is 0.852 ZA is 0.806
- hogFeast 6y agoI don't know about the other countries you have mentioned but German residential real estate has very high levels of institutional investment and the legacy of rent control (famously, Berlin...although that changed a few years ago). So you have very high wealth inequality, average German net financial wealth is equal to Greece and Germany has a significant number of billionaires, but you also have a system that fundamentally cannot be compared with the US. It just optimises for different things. That being said, whilst recognising those differences, lower wealth inequality is not the result of most of these systems. Income inequality is generally lower but the cost of this is usually: low competition, high structural unemployment, weak unions, low levels of business creation...it isn't free. It is readly apparent from the EU that whilst the US has high inequality, it also has a far more dynamic economy that results in more people actually becoming wealthy (to take Germany as an example, most billionaires come from families that got rich in the 30s and inherited...the level of downward mobility is very high in the US) and higher levels of innovation.
- coliveira 6y ago> more dynamic economy that results in more people actually becoming wealthy This is exactly the other side of inequality: if there is a big gap, someone must be taking advantage of this gap. The problem is that most people are losers in this competition.
- oblio 6y agoMost statistics contradict you, despite the popular impression. The US has lower social mobility than most European countries. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Social_Mobility_Index https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Social_Mobility_Index
- collyw 6y agoWhat happened with rent control in Berlin? Rent control sounds like a good idea in theory but in practice it seems the opposite, creating two tiers of renters.
- llampx 6y ago
- adrianN 6y agoHome ownership is strongly influenced by culture. Germans are just happier to rent. Buying often doesn't make a lot of sense financially either. It's not much cheaper to buy than to rent and you lose a lot of flexibility. I could afford to buy a house, but I don't want to. That would just tie up a large fraction of my wealth into one fairly risky investment and make it much harder to move when my life changes.
- throwaway894345 6y agoWhat’s risky about the investment? I’m of the impression that real estate is one of the more stable investments, subprime mortgage scandals notwithstanding.
- fulafel 6y agoWhat isn't? Volatile market value, risks of breakdowns and fires and previously undiscovered structural flaws, fires, natural distasters, etc. It's putting a lot of your eggs in one basket, which in investment terms is same as foregoing diversification, ie taking on a lot of risk for no corresponding increase in returns. Depending on jurisdiction, risk of unfair treatment in a divorce. High transaction costs when changing housing due to changing life circumstances. And to top it off you are binding the important service of having a roof over your head to the fate of this investment.
- throwaway894345 6y agoHome process in the US are historically very stable. I would think this is also true in Europe? As for diversification, your house shouldn’t be your only investment. As for fires and natural disasters, this is why insurance exists. Owning a home isn’t for everyone, but I don’t think there’s anything particularly risky about it as far as investments go.
- fulafel 6y agoAre you looking at home prices as aggregate? It will naturally seem a lot more stable then since you are then looking at what you'd have if you had diversification! As for individual cases of housing, I think we've recently seen enough discussion of CA volatility to conclude that at least big cities have a lot of volatility in individual housing units. (Of course this all depends on the alternative too: renting regulations vary widely over the world in how strong the position of the occupants is wrt rent increases and landlord initiated termination)
- 908B64B197 6y ago> but also praise the low wealth inequality and low income inequality in Europe and Canada. Now what happens if you include expats in the calculation? > makes it much easier to found and grow a business without the threat of death And yet you see a lot of Europeans and Canadians founders going to the valley for funding. Yet the opposite almost never happens.
- webmaven 6y ago> > makes it much easier to found and grow a business without the threat of death > And yet you see a lot of Europeans and Canadians founders going to the valley for funding. Yet the opposite almost never happens. Just because it is easier to found and grow a business doesn't mean the environment is friendly to founding and funding a high-growth business. In fact, an environment that is friendlier to SMEs, lifestyle, and bootstrapped companies probably reduces the pressure to jump into a VC-funded high-growth swing-for-the-fences model. Combine that with a less generous funding climate, and those who do want to go that route will go somewhere else for their funding. But I don't think the reverse applies in terms of attracting entrepreneurs that don't wish to go the high-growth route from elsewhere.
- imtringued 6y agoI think in our current economical climate it is actually good if there are rich people willing to part with their money, even if it is just a moonshot. What I don't like is that the VC model often just devolves into the same boring strategy of outgrowing the competition. Lots of good companies died because of this and lots of bad companies are still alive.
- webmaven 6y agoI share your distaste, and even more so when outgrowing devolves into outspending and outlasting.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Now what happens if you include expats in the calculation? Pretty sure expats are included in Gini calculations. > And yet you see a lot of Europeans and Canadians founders going to the valley for funding. Yet the opposite almost never happens. Why wouldn't you raise money from where the money is? Inequality means there's a small handful of people with giant piles of money. That's a good bet to go knocking at if you want some. Generally if you want to build a successful business you should raise on the best terms possible, and European investors are not known for offering particularly compelling terms. I should also say, just because you raise money in the bay doesn't mean you have to run your business in the bay. Should you choose to do so remotely, you'll like take a bit of a discount, but it's worth mentioning this year's YC class was entirely remote. I'm not sure this argument is connected.
- 6510 6y agoThey pay peanuts then say we need more programmers. They also say managers are really valuable while we have plenty of those. Programming is also a really intense job, pretty much no one can do it for 8 hours straight and managers sit on their ass drinking coffee all day with brief interruption by tasks 85% should have been automated 20 years ago.
- viraptor 6y ago> managers sit on their ass drinking coffee all day You have experience with some really terrible managers. Have a look at other places.
- sidlls 6y agoPaying laborers more does not lead to the kind of inequality we see. "You can't have low inequality by definition if you decide to start paying one group a ton of money." Very few of even FAANG-level salaries are high enough to put them in the same bucket as the people who wield power through their wealth. Paying the entire field of SWE laborers even 50% more salary is not going to appreciably change the inequality gap.
- frombody 6y agoMarginal tax rates are much higher in Europe at lower levels, so in order to pay someone 50% more, you would have to pay them 100% more for them to get a 50% pay increase to make up for the money taken by taxes (the mechanism that prevents wealth inequality)
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoThat's more or less true in the U.S. too, at the rates software engineers make, at least in NY and CA. In my locality a software engineer making $100k will face a 40% marginal tax rate.
- strombofulous 6y ago40%?! Where do you live? The effective federal income tax at 100k is 22.75%. I don't think any state has a 17.25% effective income tax, certainly not if you only earn 100k.
- arcticbull 6y agoIf you're making 100K in California, your marginal tax rate is: - Federal: 24% - State: 9.3% - FICA: 7.65% (6.2% social security, 1.45% medicare) - SDI: 1% This gets you to 42%. Your employer matches the FICA payments too, so that's closer to 50% of your take-home pay. Once you make enough to pay off the regressive FICA taxes ($142K) you get bumped back down to "just" the mid-high 30% range briefly, until you hit $163K, then its back up to 40% again.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoIf you increase housing stock, there can be more cheap homes for new entrants in the market, meanwhile existing homeowners may still see significant appreciation on their home value, depending on lots of market variables. Wanting affordable home ownership is not contradictory to growth of home asset prices. I also think your argument about income inequality is not right. Achieving income equality by suppressing wages and paying below competitive market rates is nothing to be proud of - and largely for professions like SWE, it has absolutely nothing to do with income levels at the low end close to poverty, which is what matters when understanding income inequality. We should be raising purchasing power and unlocking possibilities for people. That’s the real purpose of reducing inequality. Otherwise we can just take the trivial solution: destroy all technology and return everyone to subsistence agrarian society. Near perfect income equality, near zero societal level wealth.
- geodel 6y ago> paying below competitive market rates That does not make sense. How is it below competitive if every company in Europe is paying in same range? By definition it is competitive.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoThe talent they are competing for can work anywhere, and this untethering of geolocation is only increasing. The relevant market of candidates for large European cities is increasingly just a pan-Western talent market, and lower cultural salary norms are really hurting Europe, leading to brain drain and reduction of major tech hubs.
- Izikiel43 6y agoCanadians are kind in a shit position. Real state is stupidly expensive everywhere where you would like to live (Greater Vancouver, Greater Toronto, Ottawa is getting more expensive), and salaries are not keeping up at all. For example, cost of living in Vancouver and Seattle, disregarding the currency, is more or less the same, however in Vancouver it's like you earn 2k less than Seattle for an entry level Big 4 position. In Canada you need 2 professional incomes at least to buy a house/condo.
- arcticbull 6y agoVancouver and the GTA for sure, Ottawa had been relatively affordable - prices in town went up before COVID, but down during. Montreal remains quite affordable. Edmonton and Calgary aren't bad, and Kitchener/Waterloo's pretty reasonable still. I mean, it's clear a lot of that is mainland Chinese money parking, which cities are actively pushing back on.
- Izikiel43 6y agoThe problem I see is that everywhere in Canada but Lower Mainland in BC you freeze 6 months out of a year.
- aprdm 6y agoHouse/condo have very different prices. You can totally buy a condo anywhere in Vancouver with a software engineer salary of 120k+ which is very doable for senior positions..
- thinkloop 6y agoThe wealth inequality debate is about Bezos and wall street ceo's type thing - I don't think many people have issue with some making $50k and others making $200k.
- arcticbull 6y agoRemember the whole drive to push all the Techies out of SF? Remember rocks getting thrown at the Google busses? It's both. At the end of the day Bezos makes headlines but his personal largesse has very little effect on most people in the country. It has very little impact on the lives of folks getting "pushed out" of SF. That's the folks he employs.
- sidlls 6y ago> Remember the whole drive to push all the Techies out of SF? Remember rocks getting thrown at the Google busses? It's both. This is primarily attributable to two causes: 1. distorted views that result directly from inequality and the extreme poverty some communities have: to the (stereo)typical Tenderloin resident, as person who is able to afford a modest 3/2 townhome appears to be vastly wealthy 2. the mistaken view of techies, themselves, as being in the same class as those who actually are wealthy, and presenting as such (including the disaffected/indifferent attitude towards those in even lower socioeconomic brackets), which reinforces (1) > At the end of the day Bezos makes headlines but his personal largesse has very little effect on most people in the country. It has very little impact on the lives of folks getting "pushed out" of SF. That's the folks he employs. That's so out of line with actual reality it's best classified as "not even wrong." I don't even know where to begin with it. The people pushing others out in SF are not Bezos' employees; they're a tiny, tiny fraction of tech workers, most of whom won a VC/IPO lottery. Bezos and his social class benefit immensely from the lower socioeconomic classes in-fighting. For example, by some thinking paying a laborer more will lead to more inequality.
- arcticbull 6y agoSure, but reducing inequality is as much about pulling the bottom up as it is pulling the top down. If you bring people closer together you solve both (1) and (2).
- aaomidi 6y agoThe salaries aren't low because of equality though. You're just shifting the high earners from the people doing the work to the managers of the people doing the work.
- arcticbull 6y agoNo, the other way around. Inequality is low because the distribution of salaries across roles, across industries is tightly clustered. I suspect it's true of the managers too. The point is there aren't high earners.
- ricardobeat 6y agoAs far as my experience goes, managers make about the same, or less, as an engineer at a similar experience level. They may end up at a higher compensation level if far enough in the career ladder, but I don't think it's significant in the bigger picture. The average CEO earnings in the Netherlands, including bonuses, is only 5x-6x the average engineer salary.
- paxys 6y agoSo maybe the real answer to the question is that European tech companies are just not making a lot of money?
- ricardobeat 6y agoThere are few growth stocks, so I'd expect compensation figures are not strongly skewed by stock bonuses, and are a function of market and fiscal environments much more than profit. When they are raking it in, it will be mostly going to US investors' pockets via buybacks. Mind you, there are exceptions. The CEO of a certain hotel bookings company makes €17M/year. Technically an american company though.
- antupis 6y agoProbably this I only know Finland tech scene but eg lot of Nokia engineers did FAANG like salaries in 2000s and there is now couple unicorns here where senior employees do very well.
- s17n 6y agoA SWE might make like 5 times what a teacher makes but a CEO can make like 1000 times what a SWE makes (eg $50k for the teacher, $250k for the SWE, and $250M for the CEO).
- jachee 6y agoI believe you're vastly overestimating the CEO earnings. I doubt you'll find many 8-digit CEO earnings, let alone 9-digit.
- colinmhayes 6y agoAlmost no CEO makes anywhere close to 250 million.
- Izikiel43 6y agoWhat kind of CEO makes 250 million? Microsoft's CEO made ~44 million last year, and Microsoft is a trillion dollar company (https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2020/10/20/microsoft-ceo-satya-nadella-2020-compensation.html#:~:text=The%20filing%2C%20released%20Monday%2C%20revealed,for%20the%20year%20was%20%24172%2C142 https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2020/10/20/microsof....)
- arcticbull 6y agoWell, there's papa elon who made $2.3B in 2018. Though, I agree, that's a massive outlier :) Zaslav at Discovery was next in line with $129M total comp in 2018 [1]. Sounds like Satya needs to ask for a raise ;) [1] https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/discovery-ceo-david-zaslavs-2018-pay-jumps-1294-million-1195333 https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/discovery-ceo-david-z...
- zensavona 6y agoWe seem to have it both ways in Australia somehow
- throwaway894345 6y agoWe’re talking about upper middle class jobs though, not billionaires. Seems like giving SWEs more crumbs from the billionaires’ slices (because the alternative is that the investors and execs take the difference) is only going to reduce inequality. Which isn’t to say that this is optimal from a welfare perspective, only that enriching SWEs isn’t incompatible with lower inequality.
- arp242 6y ago> Well, this is a lot like the housing conversation in the US. "I want my house to go up in value, and be a great investment!" Also: "Why can't I afford a house?" This problem isn't unique to the US, and exists in Europe too, as well as New Zealand and probably other countries too. For this particular point, the US and Europe aren't all that different.
- didibus 6y ago> You can't have low inequality by definition if you decide to start paying one group a ton of money. That's true, but the question is, the higher salary you refuse to take as a SWE in Europe, does it really go instead to someone else in need of it? Or is it just pocketed by someone who already has more money than you?
- CaptArmchair 6y agoBoth. Fiscal policies and budgeting policies aren't "This group of people will pay for that group of people, and that group will pay for the other." Your taxes become part of a revenue line on various budgets. Who gets what is defined through various public policies, grants, subsidies, procurement. Maybe a chunk of your taxes will be allotted to social programs, another chunk to NASA and maybe another chunk to various endowments such as the Humanities and the Arts. Moreover, the issue isn't just how tax revenue is spend. The issue is just as much in how taxes are levied. Income taxes for individuals vary from taxes on financial instruments, corporate taxes, value added taxes and various other taxes. Or even the taxes that get tacked on your various utility bills, the estate you inherit from a loved one and so on. > Or is it just pocketed by someone who already has more money than you? Money is often seen as a store of value. The more you have of it, the better of you are. But that's only part of the story. Money only gains real value when it is exchanged. That's how wealth is created. Money acts as "oil in an engine". If money doesn't get exchanged, you have an economic crisis. The big issue is today is that 50 years of complex global policy making have generated dynamics that pushed holes in the engine, causing that oil to leak away. Where to? The financial markets. Where money is exchanged for debts. If you want an equitable economy, you have to address fiscal and monetary policies first. Not this "who gets my money" argument.
- eecks 6y ago> you refuse to take as a SWE in Europe Refuse to take?
- elindbe3 6y agoOr it could be neither. Perhaps that revenue isn't being generated in the first place.
- thomasahle 6y ago> You can't have low inequality by definition if you decide to start paying one group a ton of money. You can, if you give the other groups a ton of money too. Wages in Europe have stagnated compared to GDP [1] too, so it's not unreasonable to fight for higher wages. [1]: https://www.robert-schuman.eu/en/european-issues/0289-labour-costs-and-crisis-management-in-the-euro-zone-a-reinterpretation-of-divergences-in#:~:text=Conversely%20the%20share%20of%20profits%20has%20increased https://www.robert-schuman.eu/en/european-issues/0289-labour...
- IMTDb 6y agoThere is only so much "richness" you can share. You can't give 400 million american a nice car, a big house with a view on the ocean, 100% organic food and access to top level healthcare and education. Unless you produce those thing at that scale, and some things are by definition not scalable (there is only one "best medical school in the US"). So some people have more power to get access to/acquire those desirable items. And software engineers are often amongst the first in line. If you want other people to have a better access to these, by definition that leads to current "first in line" to loose something. Giving more money to everyone is easy, everyone was a billionaire in Zimbabwe few years back. That did not make them "rich".
- silvestrov 6y ago> those things at that scale When everybody have those things, you no longer think of them as "richness". Richness is what sticks out. 150 years ago very few people had running water, electricity, fridge, WC, etc. Most urban americans live "richer" lives today than the rich did 150 years ago.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>Most urban americans live "richer" lives today than the rich did 150 years ago. This "richness" is also relative: If you own a goat in a village with no goats, you're rich. If you own an apartment in a village of McMansions you're poor. And let's not mistake comfort with wealth. Just because I have electricity, a WC, a fridge and don't plow the fields like my grandparents did might make me seem rich, but my grandparents owned that land they were plowing while I don't own the "land" I am "plowing" at my comfy deskjob, but the corporation does, nor do I own the land I live and sleep on, but the landlord/bank does. Our lives are now much more safe and comfortable than 150 years ago, but in the end, most of us who are not asset owners, are set to be serfs for life, just like 150 years ago except that instead of being serfs to a crown we are serfs to banks and publicly traded megacorps.
- neilparikh 6y ago> You can't have low inequality by definition if you decide to start paying one group a ton of money. Sure, but you can still ensure that the lower classes have a good standard of living. Most wealth isn't zero sum. People talk about income/wealth inequality in the US, but to me, based on the complaints people have, it just seems like a proxy for poor standard of living. > Well, this is a lot like the housing conversation in the US. "I want my house to go up in value, and be a great investment!" Also: "Why can't I afford a house?" The big difference here is that the supply of land is fixed, and thus (almost all) housing wealth is zero sum. But for other things, this is not the case, so you can't apply the logic of housing to other things.
- collyw 6y ago> Most wealth isn't zero sum. Most solutions to inequality seems to be zero sum. "Tax the rich".
- KptMarchewa 6y agoWhat matters is wealth inequality by top 5 to 1%. Some wealth inequality between the lowest 80% to the top 20% to 5%, on which devs are, is actually somehow desired - ensures that people are going to work those harder jobs, requiring more responsibility. This does not mean that devs are supposed to earn millions, but 2x or 3x average salary is not the inequality that's ethically bad.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> You can't have low inequality by definition if you decide to start paying one group a ton of money. The inequality exists between those who need to work for a living and the ownership class that does not.
- pjc50 6y agoThe situation is very odd because the inequality graph is a lot steeper than anyone is willing to believe. For the UK, look up your salary on here: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/percentile-points-from-1-to-99-for-total-income-before-and-after-tax https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/percentile-points-f... If you're a SWE on a half or even a third of an SV salary, you're still in the top 5%. Do you feel rich? No. Are you easily able to buy a house in the southeast early in your career? No. But for every person earning more than you there are twenty earning less than you. The number of super-rich dominating the conversation, the political donations, and the housebuying is surprisingly small, and most of them make far more from investments than from salary. Actual income for "work" caps out at a few million for celebrities and sportspeople. Even among the ordinary I know people who've been out-earned by their houses - that is, the annual rise in the value of their (mortgaged) house was more than their salaried income.
- esond 6y agoOne of the issues that I know Canada faces (having been in this exact position) is a southward "brain drain". There is no small amount of top talent that graduate from Universities and ship out to SV, or of top talent that seek out remote gigs in the States. The remote work proposition in particular is extremely enticing. Getting paid in a currency with 10-20% more buying power while still receiving the same government services was pretty swell.
- Aerroon 6y ago>A lot of folks here are calling out the lower pay for SWEs in Europe and Canada as a failure - but also praise the low wealth inequality and low income inequality in Europe and Canada. I think when it comes to Europe people should specificity the countries. If you take Europe or even the EU as one entity then it is one of the most unequal places on Earth when it comes to income and wealth. Bulgaria is an EU member state and in 2018 had an adjusted net national income per capita of $8,148.[0] Luxembourg is part of the EU as well and in 2018 it was $60,189. Denmark was at $52,641. Poland was at $12,954. All of this varies enormously from country to country.
- swat535 6y agoThe thing is you only see this attitude with Software Engineers and not other high paying professions such as Doctors or Lawyers. If you were to compare the roots of Computer Science and its culture to other professions, it initially stemmed from the nerds and nerds were always trained to see themselves as low status, in fact by definition being a geek would make you an outcast amongst others.. It just so happened by pure luck that many successful startups grew thanks to our field and being a SWE became suddenly desirable. So I'm not surprised that demanding a fair wage or forming unions are some of the things we struggle with. Our industry is constantly trying to bring its own value down (anyone can code, it's easy,..), you never hear about other industries complaining they are "overpaid" or belittle the value they bring to people and businesses. It's an unfortunate truth about studying CS and if I may be boldly controversial on HN, it might also one of the reasons we don't see too many women in this low status field.
- fatnoah 6y agoI live in the US, in a major East Coast city. FAANG level income lets me live a fairly worry-free life in a nice neighborhood, including a nice 2-3 bedroom flat and a private school. It's a tremendous luxury, for which I'm greatly appreciative. Many of my colleagues in Europe, make far less than 1/2 of what I do from a compensation perspective. However, they're able to live essentially the same lifestyle I am. Nice flat in a vibrant, walkable, top-tier urban locale with the ability to afford most things in life. They're able to do so because they have less worry about surprise medical bills, paying to care for their elders, saving $200k for the kids' college, etc. My employment is also at will. I can leave or be forced to leave at a moment's notice. Obviously, I'm only offering anecdotes here, but (IMHO) once that lifestyle moves out of reach, then companies will be forced to increase pay.
- curryst 6y ago> They're able to do so because they have less worry about surprise medical bills, paying to care for their elders, saving $200k for the kids' college, etc. I think that makes up a large part of the difference. In the US, those things are pay on use. In Europe, they're done through taxes that everyone pays. If you don't have kids, that can be a substantial difference. I do not, so I don't have to pay into a college fund, or pay for healthcare for kids, or private school, etc, etc. I think once you take it as a given that you pay for those things one way or another, it evens out a bit. Probably slanted a little bit towards more pay in the US, but not by nearly the gap between a single 20-something SWE in the US vs the EU.