5 ms·
I don't understand why we don't implement the isolation procedures of countries that have gotten this under control, following these procedures for both foreign
by jedberg 6y ago
I don't understand why we don't implement the isolation procedures of countries that have gotten this under control, following these procedures for both foreign citizens AND US citizens:
- When you arrive in the US, you either spend two weeks at a government approved hotel, at your expense, which is monitored by federal agents to make sure you don't leave your room. You pay for room service for two weeks to get food. This is what Singapore does.
- If you don't want to stay at the government hotel, you agree to let the government track your cell phone for two weeks to make sure you stay in your home, and randomly call you twice a day to make sure you didn't ditch your phone. This is what Taiwan does.
As a plus, all the hotels near airports would be so thankful for all the forced business to make up for the loss of travel business.
They should have been doing this for the last nine months.
Edit: And obviously combine these rules with a relief bill that helps the industries that are hurt by these rules, or you know, everyone.
- ashtonkem 6y agoIt’s fairly straightforward: leadership matters, and a lot of people who were supposed to be helming the ship were clearly asleep at the wheel.
- wrs 6y agoThey were not asleep, they were deliberately letting the car drive off a cliff because they thought admitting there was a cliff there would make them look weak.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAlso (to extend this metaphor to all three modes of transport), they were sure that - should any cliff present itself - the greatest nation on Earth will not fall down it, but will boost off and fly towards the sunset.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoProbably also contributed by the fact that the opposition pointed out that they should avoid the cliff so the only option left is to intentionally drive off it.
- 24gttghh 6y agoNah they weren't asleep, but they were standing on the wrong ship, looking backwards.
- cbg0 6y ago> I don't understand why we don't implement the isolation procedures of countries that have gotten this under control I'd hazard a guess that it's because they don't want to completely kill off tourism, an industry which is hurting pretty bad because of covid (see TSA arrivals screened https://www.tsa.gov/coronavirus/passenger-throughput https://www.tsa.gov/coronavirus/passenger-throughput) No tourist would be interested in coming over to stay two weeks on their own dime locked in a hotel, only then to be able to do some actual traveling.
- josephg 6y agoSpeaking as an Australian, I'm not allowed to travel to the US at all right now, unless I'm moving there permanently. Keeping everything open (and thus keeping covid rates high) isn't doing your international tourism sector any favours.
- jedberg 6y agoI don't think a lot of tourists are interested in coming right now anyway, given that our virus load is most likely worse than their home. That being said, this obviously needs to be paired with a relief bill that helps those businesses survive.
- cbg0 6y agoIf you've recently had covid, it might be the perfect(cheapest) time to do it.
- vecinu 6y agoI suppose I haven't read definitive literature on the topic to be convinced but can you not catch it again, especially a different strain? It still feels awfully risky to travel at the moment.
- oblio 6y agoThe anecdotal evidence I have says that you can be reinfected. I don't know if it was with different strains, but it's still troubling.
- deanclatworthy 6y agoI think is a case of a little too late. There's probably a higher risk of a traveller coming to US leaving with it, than arriving with it - currently. If this had happened 9 months ago, there might have been a chance of this working - with better leadership in other areas - as other child comments have pointed out.
- usremane 6y agoHope the two random phone calls are video calls and not just audio. Otherwise people would leave the phone with someone at home to answer for them.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoI assume this is combined with some kind of mandatory GPS tracking. The GPS tracking knows the phones location and the call confirms the user is next to their phone.
- Tepix 6y ago> Otherwise people would leave the phone with someone at home to answer for them. Or they would just do the sensible thing and not break quarantine.
- josephg 6y agoWe do that in Australia too and its worked great. (Well, except for a notable quarantine breach 6 months ago due to mismanagement.) The problem is all this is closing the fence after the horse has already bolted. The average person arriving into the united states is less likely to have covid than a resident. Currently 2.7% of the US population is infected with covid19, compared to 2.4% of people in the UK, 0.9% in Italy, 0.2% in Canada, and ~0% in Australia, NZ, Singapore, India, China, etc. Almost all new infections in the US come from domestic transmission.
- chii 6y agoit should be departures from the US that require quarantine (pre-departure), not arrivals!
- mercutio2 6y ago0% in India seems like you must have mistyped, or something. India's infection rates are not comparable to the island nations that have successfully contained the virus.
- josephg 6y agoI was surprised too! Google took me here[1], which says India is down to 210k active covid cases at the moment. For a country with a population of 1.366 billion, thats only 0.016% of the population currently infected. Its possible India's covid testing isn't telling the whole story - but they've apparently done 178 million tests to date. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/india/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/india/
- toomanybeersies 6y agoBy comparison, Australia has done 12.1 million tests [1] for a population of 25.4 m people. [1] https://www.health.gov.au/resources/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-at-a-glance-12-january-2021 https://www.health.gov.au/resources/publications/coronavirus...
- syshum 6y agoI know its probably crazy to ask, but tell me where in the US Constitution does the federal government have the power to force me into a hotel at my expense I know in "times of emergency" people seem to think the constitution is suspended and the government as "unlimited power" but last I checked Emperor Palatine was a fictional character, and saying "Singapore does" well Singapore is an Authoritarian nightmare IMO, one i do not really want to replicate here in the US. I pass taking public policy lessons from Singapore
- jedberg 6y agoIt's part of protecting the borders. The Supreme Court has already determined that anything within 100 miles of the border is the "border zone" and gives the government broad authority to enforce border protection within that zone. Also, it could reasonably argued that it is part of their "protect life" job.
- syshum 6y agoThat is a stretch of the reading of those provisions, the court has generally (and wrongly IMO) allowed Federal Law enforcement to stop people with in the border zones to establish if they crossed the border illegally, once Citizenship is established then normal protections snap back into place Even at border crossing the government has been allowed to seize Devices and other things but they generally can not prevent a US Citizen from entering, they can stop you from bringing your stuff, but they cant stop you (outside the limited questioning detainment certainly not 14 days) unless they have an arrest warrant or some other cause of action to arrest you
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoBecause this is a violation of the 5th amendment and the 1st amendment right to peaceably assemble.
- jedberg 6y agoThe Supreme Court has already ruled that neither of those apply at the border. Nor does the 4th.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoWould you agree with the court when it determined that the rights of black people were different between northern and southern states, or that internment of the Japanese was legal during WWII? The supreme court has been wrong on many issues for decades on end throughout US history. They haven't all of a sudden become infallible in the last 20 years.
- jedberg 6y agoThey certainly aren't infallible, and were wrong on those rulings. But until someone with standing brings a new case, that is the law as it stands.
- chillacy 6y agoIf you're hinting that what is legal is not necessarily right, it seems odd to fall back to this position when the original comment about the 1st and 5th amendment are legal, not moral. Instead of just mentioning the 1st and 5th amendment, it may have been better just to say that the US has a culture of privacy and personal freedom.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoYou are taking jedberg's comment too literally > The Supreme Court has already ruled that neither of those apply at the border. Nor does the 4th. reply This is an extremely overbroad generalization. The supreme court may or may not rule that forcing someone to be surveilled by federal agents in order to travel by plane is unconstitutional, or it may not. And it may be right or wrong. My qualm is legal and moral.
- iamEAP 6y agoThis would require a level of coordination and leadership at CBP that we just haven’t seen, at least under the current administration.
- balls187 6y ago> I don't understand why we don't implement the isolation procedures Because the largest driver of infections isn't foreign travelers. It's far and away due to the people who are already here.
- jedberg 6y agoSure, but we got that new strain from a foreign traveler. It still cuts off a vector of transmission.
- bigiain 6y agoMaybe... With all Australia's hard border closures and mandatory hotel quarantine, we've still had the UK Covid strain get out into the community. A cleaner at a quarantine hotel caught it from a returned citizen in quarantine (they're still not sure how), and spent 5 days in the community while infected. So far, it looks like we got very lucky, and the only person they've found that she infected is her partner. From my point of view, the US (and UK and India and many other countries) have a categorically different problem to Australia (and New Zealand and Singapore and Taiwan and a few other countries). We've _largely_ got things under control in Australia. Most of our cases in the last ~3 months have been hotel quarantine, with worrying incidences of outbreaks where it's escaped from quarantine but been tracked back and identified. Sydney currently has 3 clusters, with about 200 locally acquired cases between them in the last 4 weeks. I'm pretty sure every single one of them has been contact traced back to it's source of infection - and that contact tracing has also proactively got forward to get a very significant percentage of close contacts of infected people contacted and tested, and the places they visited while infectious identified, contact traced where possible (lots of venues are required to have covid checkin so people can be contacted an informed if they've potentially been exposed) - and any venues where they are not confident the covid checkins are comprehensive they publicise fairly widely and strongly encourage testing for anyone who visited during similar times. This _only_ works because the numbers are so low. It all went to shit in Melbourne when a quarantine hotel breach happened and it got up over 700 cases a day, the contact tracing ability totally fell apart, and Melbourne went into a hard lockdown for several months to get it back under control. In the US? Our approach just won't work. The virus is out and prevalent in your community. You have no hope of comprehensively contact tracing all of your positive cases, or identifying and mitigating all the venues they were in while infectious and contacting all the people who are at risk of exposure. The scale of your problem is totally insurmountable using the tools that work for us. If vaccination and/or herd immunity doesn't work out soon? You people might be totally fucked. ~1% of you will probably die from the virus, and quite likely a lot more will die from your medical system breaking under the load.
- deeeeplearning 6y ago>I don't understand why we don't implement the isolation procedures of countries that have gotten this under control, following these procedures for both foreign citizens AND US citizens: Because that would be communism!! /s
- bokchoi 6y agoYep, this is working great in Taiwan. Before you get on the plane you need a negative test, but even then there is a mandatory 14 day quarantine. When you arrive you are required to have a SIM card. During quaratine, they track your device and call randomly one or twice a day to be sure your phone is on you. Breaking quarantine is a big fine (up to $33k USD) and there is a carrot if you complete quarantine without any incidents ($500 or something?). Individuals are provided quarantine housing if they can't pay but employers are expected to pay (e.g, workers from Indonesia).
- anewaccount2021 6y agoCovid isn't remotely impactful enough to create de-facto internment camps.
- Tepix 6y agoIf you don't want to spend two weeks locked into a hotel, you can stay at home instead.