11 ms·
Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihoods at risk
- Darmody 6y agoCan't they somehow verify themselves and then be allowed to upload anything they want[1]? I thought the problem was that anyone could make an account and upload whatever they wished like child pornography, hidden cams, etc. [1] As long as it is legal and it's their own stuff.
- manigandham 6y agoThat's not the problem, as stated in the article. It's payments being cut off by card networks.
- marcinzm 6y agoIsn't that because PornHub didn't verify anything and was filled with content that exploited people? In the end, the issue seems to be PornHub rather than the card networks.
- NeutronStar 6y agoThey removed all unverified content a month ago. So that's clearly not an issue anymore.
- Darmody 6y agoThe article also says the following. Credit card giants Visa, Mastercard and Discover have blocked all payments to Pornhub, after the adult site was accused of being "infested" with child abuse and rape-related videos. So if PH solves that problem I don't see why they couldn't be back in business.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoDidn't they solve it? I heard they deleted something like 80% of their videos last month.
- Mavvie 6y agoThe article also says they have solved that problem, by deleting all videos not uploaded by "verified users". So I don't see why the credit card companies wouldn't unblock it relatively soon.
- t-writescode 6y agoThis misses some historical context around credit cards and online pornography companies where credit card companies basically just refuse to be allowed to be used for online porn, primarily around chargebacks. If they’ve found an excuse to not need to work with PornHub, they could easily retain that for perpetuity because credit card companies don’t like being associated with the porn industry. I’ll be surprised if PornHub ends up working directly with the major credit cards again.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mst 6y agoHowever, the accusations were made by anti-sex-work groups, not anybody who genuinely cares about the performers' safety or livelihoods. It's generally advisable in cases like this to go find what the sex workers rights advocacy organisations are saying, because mainstream reporting is often puritan trash. (also, so long as the performers were well compensated, I don't honestly see why we should care about "rape-related" given e.g. 50 Shades of Grey was very much 'written porn for women' and while I don't understand that particular kink I'm unwilling to judge what people want to fap/schlick to)
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoThe cat-and-mouse game between adult industry workers and the credit card industry is legendary. Credit card processors have never been kind to that industry, and once they find a reason to kick someone to the curb it stays that way.
- adrian_b 6y agoWhile I cannot know for sure what Pornhub does, as I have never used it (but I use other sites with erotic content), I have read about the evolution of this case. It was said that after the accusations have been published, Pornhub has reacted by removing the content that was claimed to include illegal parts and they have changed the rules for using the site (e.g. disabling anonymous uploads and downloads) in order to prevent such cases in the future. Only after the Pornhub reaction, VISA and MC blocked the payments, at a time when there already was not much more that PH could do, except maybe closing the site completely. So only Visa and MC can change anything now.
- kitkat_new 6y agoCan't believe people still use PornHub anyways. In my experience, the content is not the greatest
- ImprovedSilence 6y agoWhat's better, more ubiquitous, or has higher quality content, all while still having largely ad-driven revenue and not being pure cancer?
- secondcoming 6y agoreddit ticks 4 out of those 5 boxes
- TedShiller 6y agoBitcoin
- cyberbanjo 6y agoAnd for a number of national currencies there's liberapay. https://liberapay.com/ https://liberapay.com/
- bdcravens 6y agoThis has been done before by others in response to credit card networks cutting the cord, and it never replaces the lost revenue.
- postalrat 6y agoThe way things are going crypto may actually become a real currency and you would never need to convert to dollars. I don't own any crypto and never thought I'd be saying this so soon but things have changed a lot in the past 6 months.
- ryanmercer 6y ago>The way things are going crypto may actually become a real currency Not as long as it continues to have insane electricity demands and bogs down when it receives even a fraction of the transactions in a given period that Visa or Mastercard processes routinely in an identical given period.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoHow do you ensure that the person performing sex work is being compensated for sex work, versus some form of exploitation (whether that's the platform or an individual exploiting)? A sex worker union [1] who can negotiate with distribution companies and platforms, lobby legislators and payment facilitators (who should not be prohibiting payments for legal business transactions), and ensure quality working conditions and anti-exploitation controls are in place. [1] https://www.iusw.org/ https://www.iusw.org/ (just an example, not familiar with them specifically, just demonstrating the existence of such an org)
- ImprovedSilence 6y agoInteresting question, because I would be tempted to say "use the same safeguards as any other labor", but there are definite grey areas there. I suppose a union is the best way to go about it, but I don't know how that helps independents, side gigs, or people just trying to break into the industry..?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoSame way you ensure any other person isn’t being exploited. Society provides resources allowing the person to have the opportunity to not be leveraged into exploitation as their only option.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYeah, not so much. North American developed countries aren't shining examples of labor protection champions. I'd refer to parts of Europe [1] and New Zealand [2] on how to protect sex workers in a more substantial way. [1] https://www.nswp.org/sites/nswp.org/files/Declaration_booklet_colour%20icrse.pdf https://www.nswp.org/sites/nswp.org/files/Declaration_bookle... [2] https://www.nzpc.org.nz/The-New-Zealand-Model https://www.nzpc.org.nz/The-New-Zealand-Model
- ravenstine 6y agoWell that and the labor protections we do provide end up primarily benefiting businesses and unions over the individual workers themselves.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt would really be ideal if some of these sex workers could get their own platform. Pornhub seems like it was frankly unresponsive on a lot of serious concerns until they were forced to deal with them by the panic articles that went around last month And frankly it seems to me like it's still trivial to go on there and find what seems to me to be a lot of content that has dubious consent or related issues. These performers would be better off with a platform that was highly moderated, something Pornhub and the sites similar to it don't seem to be able to (or want to) properly do.
- bdcravens 6y agoOnlyFans allows them to sell their content directly (not the same as it's up to them to solve the discoverability problem)
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIn a perfect world, you'd have something like Patreon or OnlyFans that runs like a utility out of a non profit org (such that Signal, Let's Encrypt, Wikipedia, and similar platforms operate as 501(c)(3) non profits). Removing the profit motive removes a lot of room for bad behavior on the part of the platform. Verify the creator, provide a way to get payments to them without you acting as the intermediary, charge reasonable fees for your tech stack to organize and distribute digital content, and keep a paper trail when regulators, legislators, and law enforcement knock. I want to really stress as a financial infra and payments system armchair enthusiast and scholar that crypto payments don't fix this. The law just comes for you if you try to subvert the law with crypto. You have to drive home the point (lobbying, marketing) that consenting adults adhering to the law should not be in fear when exchanging value in a transactional business and should not have their payments intercepted.
- qchris 6y agoEven something like a public benefit corporation in a state with more strict reporting requirements could even fill the same niche, without dealing with the rigamarole of obtaining/maintaining 501(c)3 status. It'd be interesting to see how the corporate charter would be written.
- dheera 6y agoWell yes, and defunding fur trade will put poachers' livelihoods at risk, and defunding Amazon will put Amazon warehouse workers' livelihoods at risk. Jobs will always come and go. New jobs will come.
- dubcanada 6y agoAre you trying to imply this is the end of pornography? Cause that's super not going to happen, they will just move onto other sites that may or may not be more "sketchy".
- manigandham 6y agoSimilar to the recent actions by Twitter, Google, Apple and Amazon; Visa and Mastercard are private companies and can do whatever they want. Anyone who has an issue with what Visa/MC did must also take issue with the others.
- cathyreisenwitz 6y ago"Visa and Mastercard are private companies and can do whatever they want." Not without DOJ pressure, unfortunately.
- bjeds 6y ago<I deleted my comment because people only want to argue.>
- marcinzm 6y ago[delete]
- read_if_gay_ 6y ago> browse PornHub's recommended videos in incognito mode. Go through a few pages. Click into a few categories. Don't even do weird searches, just go through what it recommends. Yeah, I totally never did that before at all.
- jowsie 6y ago>I found some of what it promoted disturbing to be honest. But was it illegal?
- andrepd 6y agoAre you implying abuse, or just "kinky shit"?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> "There's not a lot you can do about it, which makes you feel really helpless. I have friends who are considering leaving the business as a whole, just because Pornhub was such a big source of income." I would guess for at least some of the public, sex workers leaving the business would be seen as a feature rather than a bug.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoYes, me for example
- paulgb 6y agoOne of the performers quoted summed it up well in the article: > "The real target of these groups is not to help victims or fight illegal content on the internet, but to ban all forms of adult material." A few years ago I was doing some research to figure out how I felt about SESTA/FOSTA, and one of the things I quickly came to realize is that a lot of groups and politicians who are ostensibly anti-trafficking are actually anti-porn, and use the boogieman of trafficking to build a broader coalition than they could on a purely anti-porn agenda.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIt's not really a secret. Even when actual "trafficking" charges get filed in court, the most common type is prosecuting a woman for trafficking herself.
- mst 6y agoOn top of that, anti-trafficking NGOs tend to be unnecessarily friendly with law enforcement groups and both get more funding by exaggerating the problem.
- noitsnot 6y agoMoody doesn’t seem to care about the abuse or victims that is rampant in the industry, she just wants to get paid.
- anigbrowl 6y agoIf you can get paid reliably then abusers have less leverage in the first place. I've been friends with a lot of sex workers and their #1 gripe is that prohibitionist types create the conditions for abuse.
- marcinzm 6y agoA lot of the people being mentioned as abused aren't sex workers and do not want to be sex workers. They don't want to be paid for or involved in sex work.
- anigbrowl 6y agoMy argument is that the criminalization of sex work is what incentivizes abusive people to set up criminal enterprises around it.
- marcinzm 6y agoMost people wouldn't be happy to give up a large percentage of their income to help someone they didn't know. If they were then charity donations would be a lot higher than they are.
- ravenstine 6y agoFew seem to care enough about the abuse that exists in Hollywood and in tech, so why the hullabaloo over sex work? Oh, yeah - sexism against women because they're not supposed to be sexual.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNot getting paid for your work is a form of abuse. None of us can solve all the world's ills and most of us focus on things that hit close to home. Think of all the foundations that have been created because some wealthy celebrity (or a relative of theirs) had a particular medical condition. Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson's Research https://www.michaeljfox.org/ https://www.michaeljfox.org/ Christopher and Dana Reeve Foundation https://www.christopherreeve.org/ https://www.christopherreeve.org/
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoI don't know if I honestly care though. Their livelihood is to have sex on camera for money, it's not something I or many other people really value. COVID restrictions on movie theaters put a lot of actors / actresses livelihoods at risk and I don't care. They don't provide a lot of value past entertainment (for some).
- xg15 6y agoI'm really glad that no one in this subthread proposed anything involving a blockchain.
- dang 6y ago"Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoI find that surprising. I think cryptocurrencies are the worst technology known to man, but avoiding censorship is what they are built for and their only legitimate use case.
- coliveira 6y agoThe big concern of NYTimes is that this is a Canadian company making lots of money from the American market. I wonder if they would be so harsh with an American conglomerate.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kbar13 6y agosex work should be legalized and regulated, just like marijuana. sex work and porn has been a reality since the beginning of time, and making it "illegal" and letting it fester in dark corners is unhealthy. without proper education, acceptance, and oversight, it encourages predatory behavior and other mental health issues like porn addiction. you don't have to think "porn is good" or "prostitution is good" to acknowledge that it is something that a large % of men consume and protect workers and consumers. we know that alcohol and drugs are bad, but they're legal and regulators do try to educate and protect the public. why not have the same for sex work?
- cathyreisenwitz 6y agoSex workers prefer decrim to regulation because regulation ends up creating a white market dominated by a few anti-competitive players and a vast black market with all the existing problems.
- elliekelly 6y agoSource?
- pdkl95 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DZfUzxZ2VU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DZfUzxZ2VU Both the video for interviews and the bibliography links in the description.
- elliekelly 6y agoSurely you’re joking. Is this person a sex worker? Or do they have any qualifications to speak on the subject of sex work? Because it seems like a channel dedicated to alt-right/far-right talking points and I don’t consider a Steve Bannon superfan to be an authoritative speaker on the topic of what sex workers want when it comes to their safety.
- 6y ago
- antisthenes 6y agoI'm surprised no one's mentioned platforms like OnlyFans so far. That's the path forward for adult entertainment content (among other content). It puts the power back in the hands of content creators, and removes a lot of avenues for exploitation. As long as VISA/MC don't do the same thing there, of course.
- yiny123 6y agoSo was Pornhub. That's what the sex workers in the article are upset about. They were able to sell their videos. They can still make ad revenue but the ban by Visa/MC just ends up hurting them. I doubt it will be long before the religious lobbies go after Onlyfans.
- urbandw311er 6y agoI noticed that a lot of the porn actors sticking up for Pornhub were the ones putting out their own home-grown content, who essentially benefit from Pornhub as a publishing platform. Rather than ones with pre-existing professionally published content who have seen their revenue and livelihoods decimated by the tacit acceptance of illegally pirated material that is essentially Pornhub’s business model.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]