16 ms·
An Invisible Tax on the Web: Video Codecs (2018)
- akersten 6y agoIt's incredible that the MPEG-LA mafia has gotten away with 23 patents on a system of mathematical operations. Math is explicitly outlined as non-patentable. While this extends to all software patents, I'm astounded that even this very narrow case hasn't been challenged on its face. We can't move to unencumbered codecs quickly enough.
- vulcan01 6y agoMy understanding (IANAL) is that although maths are not patentable, the use of maths is – much as science is not patentable, but the use of science (technology) is.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoExactly this - otherwise inventions in physics would not be patentable (such as the laser - a purely theoretical construct long before it was engineered, same as the transistor), or chemicals (chemistry follows from physics, which is made of math..) And on and on. Using math to engineer solutions to problems is patentable.
- gaius_baltar 6y ago> chemistry follows from physics, which is made of math Is that a reference to XKCD #435 ? ;)
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhen you patent a laser, the patent doesn't stop someone from calculating the laser's results. With math, you are prohibited from making certain calculations; very different.
- vulcan01 6y agoAgain, IANAL. But my understanding is using ideas in a patent for "experimental purposes" is legally protected: https://nysstlc.syr.edu/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/NYSTAR-The-Experimental-Use-Exemptions-to-Patent-Infringement-Fall-2005.pdf https://nysstlc.syr.edu/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/NYSTAR-Th...
- darawk 6y agoYou aren't prohibited from doing the calculations per se. You are prohibited from doing them for a particular purpose, specifically video playback, in this case. If you just want to sit down with a pencil and paper and calculate H264 by yourself, there's nothing illegal about that. It only becomes illegal when you embed it into a video player.
- dclowd9901 6y agoRight, but encoding video is literally just pushing numbers through a function, is it not?
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoIt's more concrete than that there's an input, from a computer, with some sort of physical storage, and an output, again with some storage, that ultimately is for viewing. The goal is to do stuff with those numbers outside of the computer, ie create light patterns on a viewing medium.
- nybble41 6y ago> It's more concrete than that there's an input, from a computer, with some sort of physical storage, and an output, again with some storage, that ultimately is for viewing. None of which is novel, or even directly related to the subject of the patent. The patent isn't about the input mechanism, the computing hardware, the storage media, or the display tech. It's about the abstract math that is carried out mechanically by these existing computing elements. Evaluating a mathematical formula and visualizing the results as a grid of colored squares—all by hand—should never be found to infringe on anyone's patent. (This appears to be relatively uncontroversial.) Doing the same, only faster thanks to the aid of a computer, should be similarly exempt from all patent infringement claims. The patent doesn't cover the computer, which already existed. All that's left is the math.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoI have a lot of sympathy with your position and conclusion. Really I was trying to explain the position applied, it's not what I would do. Ultimately, legislatures (or those who control them) want to encourage developments that lead to faster, cheaper (less energy intensive) methods of encryption and encoding and so the law will be wiggled until it fits this need. Hence in Europe we effectively have, AIUI, a variation of the long-standing "technical effect" requirement where if the development can be concretised it can be patented. Things are slightly tighter in UK law and much looser in USA; I don't follow patent law in other countries.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIt's the application of the maths for a purpose, not the maths itself.
- dheera 6y agoMaybe it's the future of software will be built in a jurisdiction of the world that doesn't take a shit about software patents. All software is just a big number after all.
- mandelken 6y agoPerhaps in China? I support your sentiment, but most countries with strong software communities appear to have strong software patents (US, EU, Taiwan, SK). Maybe the only outlier is Russia (and possibly India)?
- dheera 6y agoI'd say China, India, Russia all have pretty strong software communities and are good candidates. China also has a strong hardware community as well.
- dariosalvi78 6y agoin the EU software is not patentable, though many companies find loopholes: https://fsfe.org/activities/swpat/swpat.en.html https://fsfe.org/activities/swpat/swpat.en.html
- granzymes 6y agoTechnically all information is just a big number.
- ric2b 6y agoAnd that number is 42. Now the question is how to write all the functions to decode what we want from it.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoUse this encoder : https://www.dangermouse.net/esoteric/lenpeg.html https://www.dangermouse.net/esoteric/lenpeg.html It allows for compression to a negative, unbounded number of octets. I guess you just have to run it in reverse ?
- chacha2 6y agoIs CocaCola a patent on chemistry?
- ducksuck 6y agoIt's a trade secret.
- tims33 6y agoCoca-Cola is a trade secret. No one has figured out their recipe to date.
- djsumdog 6y agoSo with Coca-cola, the ingredients are fully known, it's just the process that's secret?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> No one has figured out their recipe to date > So ... the ingredients are fully known ... ? No... because nobody has figured out their recipe. They just said that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula
- laoganmaplz 6y agoAlso the proportions. While (in the US at least) manufacturers are required to list their ingredients in the order of greatest proportion to least proportion, they are not required to disclose what those proportions are, which also adds some difficulty to reverse-engineering the recipe.
- sgerenser 6y agoI think the biggest catch is being able to throw potentially thousands of different substances under the generic “natural flavorings.” Read the Coca Cola ingredients list and you certainly don’t see “coca leaf extract” on it.
- 6y ago
- djsumdog 6y agoSo are companies in New Zealand not bound by H264 licensing fees? They banned software patents years ago.
- centimeter 6y agoFrench companies are not bound. This is why VLC and other video players are developed by french devs.
- grodeni 6y agoIs this true? Software patent is a gray area in the EU and I would not recommend to take for granted that European companies do not have to pay the h.264 license, even if they only distribute in Europe. Concerning VLC, their FAQ [1] does not mention the EU aspect: they say that they cannot pay for the license because the software is free and that "the end-user becomes responsible for complying with the licensing and royalty requirements" (whether this would be defensible in court is debatable) [1] https://wiki.videolan.org/Frequently_Asked_Questions/#What_about_personal.2Fcommercial_usage.3F https://wiki.videolan.org/Frequently_Asked_Questions/#What_a...
- ric2b 6y ago> the end-user becomes responsible for complying with the licensing and royalty requirements Exactly. If you're using h.264 without a license in a country that requires it, it doesn't matter that some french people wrote the software for you. That's all they're saying.
- zinekeller 6y agoAccording to VideoLan's Legal team (in the French section of https://www.videolan.org/legal.html https://www.videolan.org/legal.html under Brevets): Patents According to article L 611-10 of the French Intellectual Property Code, software patents are not allowed under French law. At the [EEA] level, Article 52 of the European Patent Convention has also excluded the protection of computer programs. As a result, any software supplied by VideoLAN is not subject to licenses on any software patent, regardless of its origin. The relevant section of the French IP law states that: 1. New inventions, in all fields of technology, involving an innovative approach with industrial application are patentable. 2. The following are not considered as inventions within the meaning of the first Section of this Article in particular: a) The discoveries of scientific theories as well as mathematical methods; b) Aesthetic creations; c) Intellectual plans, principles and methods in the areas of sport or economic activities, as well as computer programs; d) Presentation of information. 3. The provisions of Section 2 of this Article shall exclude the patentability of the elements listed in the said provisions only to the extent that the patent application or patent concerns only one of these elements considered as such. 4. Subject to the provisions of Articles L. 611-16 to L. 611-19, inventions relating to a product consisting wholly or partly of biological material, or to a process for producing, processing or using biological material, shall be patentable under the conditions laid down in Section 1. Biological material is considered to be material that contains genetic information and can reproduce itself or be reproduced in a biological system. Interpret that as you wish.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoAlgorithms are not simply math, in the same way mechanical engineering is not simply math. The patents are the result of engineering to create very precise and complicated tools. And if it were simply math, then there would be no way to work around those patents, which plenty of open source codecs have done in various directions. Unfortunately, most open source codecs are not as good at compression, mostly since the patented ones have a massively bigger pool of engineering behind them from dozens of companies banding together their work to develop best of breed solutions. And eventually the patents expire, and the world gets these codecs free to use.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> And if it were simply math, then there would be no way to work around those patents, which plenty of open source codecs have done in various directions. What makes you say that? Math usually leaves many ways of calculating the same thing. > dozens of companies banding together You could probably get a bigger group if there wasn't a patent vs. no patent conflict. > And eventually the patents expire, and the world gets these codecs free to use. How many of these techniques wouldn't have been reinvented a dozen times over in less time, if the original patenter never existed?
- ChrisLomont 6y ago>How many of these techniques wouldn't have been reinvented a dozen times over in less time, if the original patenter never existed? In the exact same details? None. There is an extreme number of parameters and details in each of these codecs. How many times have you or a small band of people invented a world class video compression codec? They take a huge number of people and a lot of funding to create. That funding, in many cases, was paid for by places like Fraunhofer that has invented many such codecs before anyone else, and they do so because they know they will get a revenue stream to pay for the work. If these things were easy to make, there would be constant new ones, each improving the last one. This is not the case - they take years and the effort of a lot of people to make new ones that are better enough to slowly replace old ones. A simple way to see it - if these were so easy that people would invent a dozen if only patents didn't stop them, then people would invent those anyway and publish them for fun. I am unaware of ANY world class video codecs that some hacker invented in their basement, and the only ones close to best in breed were funded to the tune of the prices above by huge companies that want to use their leverage to move markets, for their own gain. These things are in no way trivial to create. > You could probably get a bigger group if there wasn't a patent vs. no patent conflict. Removing a funding channel means there would be less, not more, incentive to pay tens of millions to billions to develop one. If you pay the R&D and anyone else can simply take the work and not pay for it, then less companies will work on it.
- kmeisthax 6y agoStrictly speaking, pretty much any patentable invention is going to use maths. Video codec related patents aren't just "I patent the discrete fourier transform". It's "here's how you can use frequency domain transforms, texture lookups, entropy coding, and other things in order to build a low-bitrate video codec". There's detailed explanations of what the invention does and what is legally being claimed, which will usually be a quite-small improvement on an existing technology. Many of the standards-essential ITU/MPEG patents have active litigation surrounding them, and the defendents would have been daft to not try to challenge video codec patents on exactly the sort of basis. The fact that the patents still stand would indicate that they are more than just maths.
- akersten 6y ago> The fact that the patents still stand would indicate that they are more than just maths. I insist that the fact that the patents still stand is rather an indication of the systemic failure of the court system to enforce the non-patentability of what is ultimately still purely mathematical operations. Sure, any patent-able invention uses math. That's a distraction. These patents are on the formulae (the data transforms) and their use itself. You're on the right track pointing out that it would be ridiculous to patent the discrete Fourier transform. These kind of mathematical discoveries should not be encumbered, they should be free for anyone to use and implement.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoThis is my personal opinion and in no way relates to my employment: I rather think that the courts have enforced the line the legislators endorse, which supports their ends of promoting industry: It's not a mistake of the court system, inventions that apply maths to achieve technical gains are patentable and maths itself remains un-patentable. The courts seem largely to properly discern where that line lies. Developing maths that saves bandwidth, storage, and energy, for example, is beneficial and countries use the patent system to encourage that.
- arp242 6y agoIf I invent a new type of chair that can be stable with two legs, then the way this operates is essentially just a mathematical formula, no? No one would challenge that this would be patentable, and any patent application would describe the mathematics of it, and the usage of this mathematics would be covered in the patent. I don't really like patents in general, but I don't really see this sharp distinction to be honest and I've always felt that the case against software patents in particular as a special case was rather weak.
- ksec 6y agoWe can argue about the patents system all day. But we can call it a fact this it is not just "23" patents. I am not even sure how they arrive at the 23 numbers. I was thinking if it was some kind of joke that doesn't work with my /s detector.
- ReaganFJones 6y agoLuckily, it seems like the industry is coming along with AV1. I'm not aware of any major companies opposed to AV1. There's going to be a lag time before enough HW is being used that fully supports it but it'll happen eventually.
- my123 6y agoSisvel AV1 patent pool: https://www.sisvel.com/licensing-programs/audio-and-video-coding-decoding/video-coding-platform/license-terms/av1-license-terms https://www.sisvel.com/licensing-programs/audio-and-video-co...
- lights0123 6y agoAOMedia claims that's not valid, and will defend you against potential claims: http://aomedia.org/press%20releases/the-alliance-for-open-media-statement/ http://aomedia.org/press%20releases/the-alliance-for-open-me...
- ReaganFJones 6y agoSisvel isn't directly named in this statement but it's clearly targeted at them: http://aomedia.org/press%20releases/the-alliance-for-open-media-statement/ http://aomedia.org/press%20releases/the-alliance-for-open-me... I trust the AOM will handle this the moment Sisvel actually attempts to file suit. If their patents are as solid as they're claiming, they probably would have sued someone like Netflix for using AV1 already. IIRC, Sisvel did this for both VP8 and VP9 and it didn't end up going anywhere.
- gnicholas 6y agoSome interesting details on how the H.264 patents are priced, from an article [1] about how much Google pays. Google had threatened to pull H.264 support circa 2011, but ultimately they decided in 2013 to pay a few million bucks/yr to keep it. IIRC, H.264 is one of a few non-Google technologies that is included in Chrome, but is not included in Chromium. > So, how much does those rights cost? Under the terms in place for 2011-2015, the royalty rates are the same regardless of whether a product is part of an OS. There's no royalty for the first 100,000 units of a licensed product; sublicensees pay 20 cents per unit up to 5 million and 10 cents per unit above 5 million. The current agreement includes an annual limit: “The maximum annual royalty (‘cap’) for an Enterprise [is] $6.5 million per year in 2011-2015.” What happens in 2016? Under the MPEG LA license, the terms are "renewable for successive five-year periods … on reasonable terms and conditions.” The per-copy royalty rates "will not increase by more than 10% at each renewal.” If rates go up by the maximum 10% for that five-year period, the cost of 10 million licenses will increase by $150,000 from a current rate of $1.48 million to $1.63 million. There's a small gotcha in the new MPEG LA license agreement. Footnote 17, which appears in tiny print at the very end of the summary of license terms, notes that “Annual royalty caps are not subject to the 10% limitation.” Although that sounds like a loophole, it really only affects the largest players in the market. 1: https://www.zdnet.com/article/a-closer-look-at-the-costs-and-fine-print-of-h-264-licenses/#:~:text=Although%20the%20license%20agreement%20uses,until%20the%20end%20of%202015 https://www.zdnet.com/article/a-closer-look-at-the-costs-and....
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoDoesn't Windows bundle an H.264 decoder? If Chrome made use of that, would they have to pay for their own licence?
- kfarr 6y agoIIRC this is what Firefox tries to do -- use the OS decoder. For many reasons it is not a great user experience.
- devbug 6y agoWindows bundles software decoders (for H.264 and H.265) that are available through MFT and DXVA.[1][2] Chromium leverages both already.[3] It's also a low effort way to support hardware-accelerated decoding as vendors (Intel, AMD, NVIDIA) register MFTs that wrap their propriety SDKs (Quick Sync, AMF, NVDEC). These provided MFTs have to meet certain minimum requirements for certification by Microsoft, which amounts to "good enough." Results vary in practice and can be incredibly frustrating (especially encode). It's often better to use the underlying SDKs but that comes with a lot of hassle. (I've been working on a video capture and sharing app inspired by Shadowplay.) Windows 10 is also rolling out support for AV1, though not bundled.[4] [1]: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/medfound/h-264-video-decoder https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/medfound/h-26... [2]: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/medfound/about-dxva-2-0 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/medfound/abou... [3]: https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/master/media/gpu/windows https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/master/medi... [4]: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/av1-video-extension/9mvzqvxjbq9v?activetab=pivot:overviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/av1-video-extension/9mvzqv...
- ghjuuhhhy 6y agoIs it just my impression that pretty much all sites except youtube/fb/twitter have difficulties with video? A lot of times video struggles to start, buffers for a long time, stutters, .... I'm not talking about small blogs, but about sites like CNN, WaPo, ...
- erichocean 6y agoIt has to do with not having edge nodes. In theory, Cloudflare is in a good position to address this disparity…
- Everlag 6y agoMy team agrees with you :) https://developers.cloudflare.com/stream/ https://developers.cloudflare.com/stream/ Happy to take any critique y'all may have.
- rasz 6y agoYou skipped the most popular video serving platforms - pr0n companies. Also no problems there, everything works smoothly.
- ksec 6y agoYes. Not only that but fast forward, backwards, skipping. Crash with Javascript. High CPU loading because some other JS is messing with the Video in a way that shouldn't be. etc etc. Someone on HN asked me what's wrong with HTML5 video. I forgot to reply as I was gathering examples and informations.
- temp667 6y agoHN would be up in arms and lobbyists would be running to congress and DOJ to get google and others in major trouble - but if google and apple just stopped supporting H.265 it would go away. Block uploads and streaming on youtube of 265. No support in chrome. This would never happen, Apple in particular is in premium / everything costs big $ space so often doesn't mind the fees. But a few big players would make a big difference if they took action.
- randomifcpfan 6y agoApple is a member of the MPEG-LA patent pool, and receives a cut of the H.265 royalties. They support AV-1 only reluctantly, likely due to pressure from content providers like Netflix and YouTube.
- dehrmann 6y agoAh, so that might be why they stubbornly refuse to support VP9 on iPhones.
- temp667 6y agoThat is interesting! I'd always been confused WHY Apple with its focus on audio / video wasn't pushing more here for some better open standards. The AV1 support is obviously a step though in the right direction.
- ducksuck 6y agoApple advertises as premium. This is distinctly different from being a premium/high end product.
- snoshy 6y agoBut the truth is that while Google might not _like_ paying the MPEG LA for these costs, it would be a foolish business strategy to do so. Obviously Google would rather pay zero dollars for a video codec, but if it means losing out on a profitable source of revenue, it's a no-brainer to just grumble and move on. As a sibling comment mentions, Apple actually receives money for their role in the MPEG LA, but I doubt that this is anything more than a tiny dribble of money compared to the rest of their business. They're sitting just fine not having to pay out. Not to mention that getting the entire Web ecosystem to adopt a different codec can take ages - new hardware has to support accelerating it, and software implementions need to be added to thousands of different ecosystems before it becomes worth using on the Web.
- thinkloop 6y agoWhat's the issue? Is it very hard making video codecs? Or is it a network effect issue? Why can't any one of these companies take a few months to make one alone and release it and be done with it?
- wtallis 6y agoTwo of the biggest obstacles to deploying a new codec are avoiding patents on existing codecs, and getting hardware decode support added to important mobile platforms. Software decoding is basically a non-starter for battery-powered devices.
- kccqzy 6y agoIt's both. Making video codecs is hard. Making your own video codec and then convincing video sites and browsers and hardware vendors to adopt it is even harder. Video sites won't adopt your custom codec because people can't play it; browsers aren't interested in supporting it because (a) there's no content (b) there's no hardware acceleration. That's why the AOMedia consortium (behind AV1) includes semiconductor firms, browser vendors, video producers, and video distributors.
- snoshy 6y agoVideo codecs, like any other software, ultimately do have to compete on merits other than cost. In this case, it might not be "hard" to make a video codec, but it is hard to make a codec that is competitive with anything of the leading codecs from the MPEG LA. Bear in mind that your new codec needs to likely be the best or leading in most of several hundred metrics: power efficiency of encode/decode, compressed size in transmission, video/audio quality measures of many sorts, flexibility of storage in various encapsulating containers, etc. etc. It's a rather long list, and all the while you have to dodge the efforts of many many patent trolls waiting to sue you over infringing their patent. After having gone through that effort, the costs of it better ultimately justify the outcome, and the MPEG LA licensing rates are very carefully to get you to avoid just this outcome.
- bagacrap 6y agogoogle created their own called webm, released it for use without royalties, simultaneously pushing it hard with Chrome and YouTube. Afaiu this was crucial in reaching a royalty settlement with h264 patent holders.
- rossmohax 6y agoAV1 have other costs, AFAIK it's so slow to encode that encoding farm cost become much more significant.
- bastawhiz 6y agoFor now. When h.264 was new, I remember my dual G5 Mac taking 2-3 times the duration of a 1080p video to encode. Today, my phone can encode video of roughly equal resolution in near real time. It would be unsurprising to see the next generations of processors include optimizations for AV1.
- pdxandi 6y agoCould that be in part because newer iPhones perform H264 decoding on the GPU?
- kfarr 6y agoIIRC there's usually a dedicated piece of hardware for h264 encoding in most phones now (not the gpu per se)
- pdxandi 6y agoJust realized they were taking about encoding anyway. I’m not sure if that’s usually performed on the same chipset. I don’t know if iPhones have a dedicated chipset for H264, I would be a bit surprised. I could probably look it up later.
- ksec 6y ago> I don’t know if iPhones have a dedicated chipset for H264, Yes it does, both H.264 ( AVC ) and H.265 ( HEVC ). But that doesn't really matter because your ( initial ) point still stands, real time H.264 encoding isn't taxing on an A14 anymore. Remember H.264's work started before 2000 and finalised in 2003. That is like playing Doom 3 on your iPhone. No longer technically taxing by any means even if you are playing it at native resolution. However the industry is well aware of the slow down [1] of Moore's law. The cost increase as well as TDP headroom. So thinking we could continue to throw hardware at the problem simply doesn't work. [1] Moore's Law actually includes a time frame within it, so it would not be wrong to say the law is "dead" considering it has slowed down way beyond its time limit within margin of error. But modern day's media and computer PR tends to use Moore's law as word for transistor improvement.
- rossmohax 6y agoNvidia DLSS shows impressive quality upscaling games up to 4x resolution. I wonder if same tech can be applied to video encoding?
- my123 6y agohttps://developer.nvidia.com/MAXINE https://developer.nvidia.com/MAXINE
- BenTheElder 6y agohttps://www.nvidia.com/en-us/shield/support/shield-tv/ai-upscaling/ https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/shield/support/shield-tv/ai-ups...
- erichocean 6y agoMozilla, with their $50M annual budget, can't pay the fees. Okay.
- bastawhiz 6y agoThey say in the post that it would cost almost $10M/year to license H.264, and that HEVC would cost ten times that. Do you expect them to put 20-200% of their budget into a single video codec?
- erichocean 6y agoI expect them to negotiate on rates like an adult. Mozilla is taking an activist role, and (to me at least) have been flaunting their incompetence for at least a decade on this topic.
- kmeisthax 6y agoThe whole point of these patent pools is that they charge a uniform fee schedule to all users of a particular technology. There isn't much room for Mozilla to negotiate. MPEG-LA demands their pound of flesh.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mastax 6y agoFirefox has ~220M monthly active users [0], which would easily hit the current maximum royalty cap of $6.5M per year, so more than 10% of their yearly budget going to a single ancient codec. [0]: https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity
- comex 6y ago(2018).
- djsumdog 6y agoI honestly don't care about anything Mozilla says at this point. They're opposition to distributed social networking platforms and their recent statement on freedom of speech is absolutely appalling and disgusting. They could be absolutely right about this but the media is the message and the medium of Mozilla no longer even remotely represents the values that brought me to Firefox and the open source world back in the early 2000s. I'm wondering how services like PeerTube and ffmpeg operate with H264? It appears Linux services can encode and decode H264 fine without explicit payments. Is it because we're under a certain threshold? If a site with H264/H265 content gets too big, will it start to see legal letters for these costs?
- j-james 6y ago> Their opposition to distributed social networking platforms Is there something I'm missing? Didn't Mozilla recently switch their IRC network to Matrix?
- sstangl 6y agoThe parent post is objecting to a statement from Mozilla opposing "the rampant use of the internet to foment violence and hate, and reinforce white supremacy." https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2021/01/08/we-need-more-than-deplatforming/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2021/01/08/we-need-more-than-d...
- demifiend 6y agoNazis, fascists, and white supremacists already have a safe space that nobody seems to care about knocking offline. It's called Stormfront, and it's not Mozilla's fault if a web forum running since the 1990s isn't good enough for ignorant hitlerjugend who mistake corporate-owned social media platforms like Facebook or Twitter for "the internet".
- djsumdog 6y agoMozilla has recently published an article on the "decentralized web of hate." As a long time fediverse user I found the article appalling. Who decides what "hate speech" is? You realize 100 years ago, speech advocating for homosexuals would be considered deeply offensive, deplorable and unsafe, right? At least in the US, the law is very specific about speech: direct calls to violence are banned, and should be. But now we have Big Tech, Mozilla and others, tells us what is and isn't hate speech. You say "Nazis" and "fascists" but it's just a stand-in now for anything and everything you disagree with. It's all Nazi Nazi Nazi and it has no real meaning. When you ban speech, when you dictate what language people are and aren't allowed to use, you control though. We are literally talking about though policing here. Distributed social networks help prevent though crime and Mozilla opposed them in ways that feel more fascistic than anything they're claiming the "Fascists" are doing.
- koolk3ychain 6y agoGiven the difficulty and investment involved to engineer and produce codecs - I'd argue those guys deserve every penny of their royalties.
- Kaze404 6y agoI don't think anyone is saying otherwise. But that doesn't mean people can't come up with a free, better version.
- koolk3ychain 6y agoI patently disagree. Why would anyone with the requisite skills create something this complex knowing they'd never be compensated? Even if they attempted to leverage an open source "enterprise" licensing scheme big corps would likely just use an existing industry proven codec.
- Kaze404 6y agoBecause they want to? Sometimes that's all it takes. Besides, the proposed solution is being developed by multiple corporations who will profit precisely from not having to pay licensing anymore.
- einpoklum 6y agoI say otherwise. It is oppressive and immoral to try to prevent the use of technology by those who have not received permission to use it.
- Kaze404 6y agoI agree, and I'm glad people are taking steps to move away from that :)
- callesgg 6y agoMPEG-la did not create those codecs they just use the patents to make money. The people that actually made the codecs are long gone.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mxmilkb 6y agoWhat kit has AV1 decode? Encode?
- lights0123 6y agoThe latest gen Intel, Nvidia, and AMD cards have AV1 decode. No general-purpose cards with encode, though.
- klodolph 6y agoOne of the weird parts of this is just how damn good x264 is. I have a bunch of videos on my website, and because I'm some kind of basement-dwelling cretin, I manually encode them with FFmpeg to MPEG-4 and WebM. Encoding to MPEG-4: Easy, fast, high-quality. Encoding to WebM: Much slower to encode, requires tweaking the parameters, video usually looks noticeably worse at similar bit rates. I don't know how much of this is caused by the encoder, how much is caused by the codec, and how much is caused by poor selection of parameters on my part. I use "recommended settings" that I find online and H.254/HiP.
- WindyLakeReturn 6y agoIf the cost is great enough, why hasn't a new standard been adopted? Is it that there aren't better options, or is it the challenge in getting enough buy in onto one specific option for it to be of use and capable of being seen as a new standard? The article mentions some newer options that are better but cost more, but where is the OSS version? Surely major websites have the incentive to create one that they can then use for free.
- prvc 6y agox264 does indeed punch above its weight. Which has been, counterintuitively, a boon for codec freedom.
- samoa42 6y agoprobably because h264 en-/decoding is supported in hardware even on dated platforms
- everyone 6y agoWow that article was a real eye opener.. It has always pissed me off that popular proprietary / walled garden type platforms like xbox, playstation, smartTVs, smartphones etc. cant play HEVC. Since they are so popular it means that the most popular and most heavily seeded torrents of films and tv are always crappy x264 encoded.. so 5 or 6 GB for a 1080p movie instead of a nice lean 1GB HEVC file. I used to think it was simply because those platforms are computers but crippled ie. you cant install codecs (or VLC for example) on them, you can only install whatever is available via the walled garden store. But now I know that HEVC support is expensive so Sony, MS etc really dont want to support it.
- NavinF 6y ago> 5 or 6 GB for a 1080p movie instead of a nice lean 1GB HEVC file Woah there, HEVC and VP9 are not that good. Both are 25-30% better than h264. See Netflix's benchmarks. We're talking 4gb vs 6gb A 1gb movie will always look like crap, even with an even better codec like AV1. Pause the movie during an action sequence or explosion and it'll look like you're watching the video on YouTube with all the compression artifacts that entails.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoWell, the point about lossy video compression is that you aren't supposed to pause the video…
- samoa42 6y agomaybe growing up with PAL is hampering my expectations here, but imo 1GB/hour in h264 looks just fine whereas same size HEVEC, while having supperior contrast and sharpness, almost always has fucked up colors so i try to avoid it. also HVEC makes my fans spin up.
- videoborat 6y agoI think it's important to understand that google wont even let you use any HEVC decoder thats already installed in your OS to decode video in their walled-garden browser. They just deliberately block this technology.
- demifiend 6y agoWhat if streaming multimedia on the web was a mistake? What's wrong with downloading media and viewing it in an external player, like VLC?
- Triv888 6y agoCompanies dont want you to download it... They would much rather charge you every time you enjoy it.
- samoa42 6y agoyou dont even need to download it because most players can access an url just fine. mpv with ytdl integration is my goto for viewing sites that just wont give users access to the video-url (youtube/twitch/vimeo...)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BlueTemplar 6y agoIf I'm not mistaken, these days (unlike in old days with RTSP)'streaming' videos are chunk-downloaded instead. BTW, VLC can read videos while they are being downloaded just fine. It can also stream videos from, for instance, YouTube. Also, youtube-dl is your friend.
- Hnsuz 6y agoPeople would invent more codes if browsers would actually allow MSE.. Safari is today's gate keeper of many things. Just like Microsoft in 90s.
- navanchauhan 6y agoI honestly prefer Safari because the WebKit team deliberates before deciding whether to implement or not. This is evident by their status page.[0] This has its pros and cons, and is up for debate (Eg. Web Bluetooth API[1], another example is how much time it took Apple to implement Google/YouTube's codec). I personally prefer their slow and steady pace as I feel the browser is lighter and more easy on the battery than Chrome and Chromium based browsers. [0] https://webkit.org/status/ https://webkit.org/status/ [1] https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=101034 https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=101034
- callesgg 6y agoWhat do you mean? from that thread it seams like they have no intention of implementing web Bluetooth and that seams final.
- navanchauhan 6y agoI believe that was what I was trying to highlight by giving that example. Their strategy is not perfect. This is one of the cons of letting one team decide about the future of the project without letting people challenge their decisions.