10 ms·
> However I really, really hope they can work on a good backup and restore process as losing my message history because I have to reinstall the app on my deskto
by izacus 6y ago
> However I really, really hope they can work on a good backup and restore process as losing my message history because I have to reinstall the app on my desktop[1] or have to reset my phone is a horrible experience.
I've tried to report bugs and talk to developers about this but there's one fundamental problem here - the Signal team fundamentally does not value chat history the same way a lot of people do. They think that destroying all chats is a reasonable thing to do when things get hard - which is the exact opposite to many WhatsApp users, which deeply value images and texts sent to them on that platform.
As such, they've been very very resistant at making the backup process for Signal easy for people. This is also why deskop app regularly happily just trashes all its state and fails to resync. This is why they will never let you make the backup process easy and portable.
It's not a technical issue - they just think you're wrong when you want to keep your conversations.
Unfortunately that's can also be a significantly bigger issue than privacy for a lot of people.
- madeofpalk 6y agoI doubt they think you are wrong - they just don't value it themselves personally, and lack empathy for their users who have different values.
- jstummbillig 6y agoThis right here is the definition of a technicality -- so much so, that (on second thought) I wonder if this was meant to be tongue in cheek. If so, bravo.
- simias 6y agoSignal's devs, for better or worse, are very opinionated. If you don't do it moxie's way then you're doing it wrong. I was once shut down on HN by the Signal posse because I said that I'd like to have a Signal client library that I could use to write my own custom lightweight client. Apparently I'm not worthy and clearly incapable of writing secure code. Meanwhile I have to use that crappy, gigantic official electron app that cost them at least one serious security vulnerability in the past (JS injection, if memory serves). If you want to make a nerdy niche chat client that's probably a good mindset, but if you hope to appeal to the masses you'll have to put some water in your wine eventually. I managed to convince a couple of my groups to migrate away from WhatsApp lately, but unfortunately always towards Telegram. Signal is just not there yet if you want a drop-in replacement.
- Mediterraneo10 6y ago> I'd like to have a Signal client library that I could use to write my own custom lightweight client. You already have that. Signal-cli is based on a standalone Java library distributed as part of the Signal codebase. Of course it is an unofficial client and the Signal team would really prefer you not use it, but if the Signal-cli team can develop something from that library, you probably could too.
- xrisk 6y agoOff-topic but does Signal support independent multi-device yet? Sorry I can’t find reliable information about it online!
- izacus 6y agoNope. You can't even use it on a tablet without owning a smartphone.
- xrisk 6y agoSo is the model similar to that of WhatsApp web? can you receive messages on the desktop app if your phone is switched off?
- mauricioc 6y agoUnlike WhatsApp, the desktop app receives messages when the phone is off. Also unlike WhatsApp, messages received on the phone before you paired the desktop app do not get transferred to the computer.
- OkGoDoIt 6y agoNope, and that’s the biggest blocker for me. I own multiple smart phones (work and personal), iPad, and two computers (windows and Mac). So far Facebook messenger is the only reliable way to do messaging across all of them, which is a shame because I hate Facebook and I don’t particularly like messenger. But I have not found a single other solution that works cross-device and cross-platform. It also helps that basically everyone is on Facebook messenger, but I’d be willing to put effort into trying to migrate people to other chat solutions if there was literally anything else out there that works well on multiple devices.
- j1elo 6y agoI might see why they think that way, but I'll have a harder time sympathizing when the parent's use case starts being more prominent: what happens when your app grows in usage, gets out of the "niche curiosity" category for the mass public, and people start wanting to use it for "serious" matters? Not being able to back some conversations up is not an option. It would be very ironic if the answer to this was "well, then don't use Signal, because we don't care", and people who cared about the WhatsApp stuff ended up being pushed into Telegram (which seems to be the only other popular alternative, by a wide margin).
- WaitWaitWha 6y agoSignal is used both in many governments, and by groups in danger of punishment. In my opinion, Signal is not a "niche curiosity", and mass public is rarely right.
- upofadown 6y ago>...the Signal team fundamentally does not value chat history the same way a lot of people do. Keeping around old messages more or less negates the value of forward secrecy. The Signal Protocol is obsessively forward secret. So it would be reasonable for those that have put so much work into getting rid of old messages for good would not value them.
- godelski 6y agoHonestly I personally just want the ability to save specific messages. My friend sends me a recipe? Save. Just shooting the shit? Don't save. I don't understand why people want to save their whole chat history but I do understand why you'd want to save specific messages, and that's a big missing feature.
- jolmg 6y agos/specific messages/& and conversations/ > I don't understand why people want to save their whole chat history Valuable messages and conversations can happen too often that it's a hassle to save them manually. This is probably more common in group chats where lots of people occasionally share valuable stuff.
- hackmiester 6y agoYour point and use case are valid but unrelated. I agree with the parent comment but not with your sentiment.
- FalconSensei 6y agoThe thing is: your use case and wants seems to be different than like, 90% of Whatsapp users, as they expect to never lose their history. So... Signal is not a replacement to Whatsapp
- hackmiester 6y agoThat's fine with me. I was just pointing out that those two requests are not really related. I don't know much about WhatsApp, and I've never lost any message in Signal, so I am not sure I am well equipped to discuss whether it's fit for that purpose. But I would certainly love to save individual messages in some sort of vault, as well.
- Lutger 6y agoReally? I can't believe that. I mean, in a sense, all software is just a vehicle for the data it processes, and the actual value lies in the data - not the software. That data is chats for Signal. If they think that's worthless, even just the history of it, it means they don't really value their own application. They are wrong.
- herbstein 6y agoThe Signal protocol is forward-secret. I don't know the nitty-gritty specifics of the protocol, but the essence is this: You don't want someone getting access to your account two years from now to be able to access every old message. Consider every message a separate object that gets encrypted. The keys are changed/updated each time a new device is added to an account. That new device only knows the new key(s), and thus can only decrypt new messages.
- tw04 6y ago>You don't want someone getting access to your account two years from now to be able to access every old message. The messages I don't want people getting ahold of are either created with expirations or I manually delete them. I couldn't care less if someone 2 years from now can read a chat log between me and my mom if it means that I can actually read them 2 years and multiple devices away from now as well. What I don't want is to be forced to message with one app for secure chat and something completely different for daily driving. It's a pain, and nobody in my circle is willing to do it (and I don't blame them).
- FalconSensei 6y agoCompletely agree with that. This whole 'I don't care about history' discourse can change greatly for some people after a loved one dies, for example.
- hackmiester 6y agoNeither you nor any Signal dev knows what I want (i.e., what security vs convenience tradeoffs I am willing to make). I will choose the tool that allows me to use it in the way I want to use it.
- nucatus 6y agoIf history is not something to care about, then what is the point of importing WhatsApp history?
- gshulegaard 6y agoI think it's astute of you to point out that the Signal developers do not value chat history the same way many people do, but I am not sure I track with this: > It's not a technical issue - they just think you're wrong when you want to keep your conversations. as much. When you are treating security as a number one priority I think there are a lot of things that become technical issues which aren't typically. Transferring or backing up history between disparate devices, which become trusted at different times, is one of those things that I think _is_ difficult to do without sacrificing security. For example, in the classic case when a user adds a new device and wants history to be available on both you can't let the devices controlled by one person simply sync with one another. To do so would be making a security concession to the other members of the chat in that they no longer verify every destination of their message. If you are unwilling to make a security concession everything in this area becomes magnitudes more difficult. I wouldn't say it is impossible, but it's definitely not trivial. My gut reaction is also that it is difficult to _guarantee_ history in this type of security first mindset. If you add a new device and someone doesn't approve/verify/trade encryption keys with the additional client then there isn't much you can do besides not make that data available no? So I don't think it unreasonable for developers to hold the mindset that history is not a priority for a security first application.
- verytrivial 6y agoIt's a bit of a cart before the horse issue, no? I mean what is the point of obsessing about the security of the messages if you don't value the messages themselves? Some people[1] clearly value message history far beyond the transfer point to chat itself, and making people choose between being spied upon and not having message history, I think many people will choose trusting that they won't lose their messages. [1] Myself included. I check with Signal[2] every six months to see if they have a backup option, then switch back to WhatsApp when I see they don't. Phones die. My messages are more important than my phone. [2] https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007059752-Backup-and-Restore-Messages https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007059752-Ba...
- mandelbrotwurst 6y ago
- FalconSensei 6y ago> the Signal team fundamentally does not value chat history the same way a lot of people do This is the core problem as why many projects don't get mainstream. They have 2 options: they can focus on what they think is a priority, or on what the public thinks is a priority. I'm not saying Signal is wrong on doing what they are doing, as they are being successful among some niches (i.e: tech). But to grab Whatsapp users, they need feature and UX parity, at least to some level
- skrowl 6y agoThis is exactly why Telegram is beating Signal. They're singularly focused on the user experience and what users want. Uninstall / reinstall / multiple-devices works flawlessly.
- freeone3000 6y agoI fundamentally distrust any program which claims E2E encryption and is capable of recovering my chat history onto a new device. This means that Telegram is technically able to recover my chat history, making the "E2E" bit of the encryption smoke-and-mirrors.
- FalconSensei 6y agoI can be wrong, but on Telegram E2E is not default. Those are used only in 'secret chats', which I believe are not recoverable. So you can use regular texting for everything you don't care much about, like sending youtube videos and memes to your friends, and use the secret chat to things that re more sensitive. That's great for most people that currently use Whatsapp
- greiskul 6y agoHow is that great? On whatsapp everything you do is E2E by default.
- 6y ago
- beebob 6y agoInteresting piece of information. I'm one of the people that values the chat history. Mostly as there are often occasions where I would look up something like a product or a website someone sent me. Also for nostalgia. It would be perfectly fine if exporting/importing chat history would be a manual process via encrypted files and if it was disable by default. But not having it at all is an issue for me. That said: It isn't exactly easy with other messengers. WhatsApp does have some backup/restore. But afaik it is limited to the platform you are using (Android or iPhone). The export is limited and cannot be imported again. Telegram has all the messages on their servers... which... ah well, let's just leave it at that. Makes me think that I need some private third party database that just ingests and consolidates all my chat data for me. With something like that it might be okay just having a few days worth of chat history on the phone.
- cromka 6y agoThis answer from their AMA on Reddit from 3 hours ago makes it sound that they are very aware of the issue and working on resolving it: https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_private_messenger_team_here_we_support_an/gikux5b/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/signal_p...
- codazoda 6y agoMy favorite Signal feature is the setting that automatically deletes messages after a set number. I don't want that kind of history on my phone. Messages are temporary to me. But, maybe I'm special.