13 ms·
Excess protein enabled dog domestication during severe Ice Age winters
- kogens 6y agoIt's an interesting take, but wouldn't it be more favourable for the humans to simply dry the meat and save it, e.g. for summer where there are enough other food sources to mix it and avoid the protein overconsumption? Cold, dry areas are ideal for drying meats, like they do with Norwegian stockfish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockfish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockfish
- m45t3r 6y agoDid they known how to dry meat though?
- AlotOfReading 6y agoYes, foraging groups in dry climates are quite sophisticated at short-term meat preservation. I know the Hadza for instance regularly dry meat on nearby tree branches or cook it over a fire.
- benglish11 6y agoIf a dog is useful it may be a better use of the excess protein, especially for nomadic peoples. The dog will carry around all of that extra meat and provide a service. Drying/storing the meat may also attract predators.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIf you watch Werner Herzog's "Happy People" documentary about trappers in the Siberian Taiga, and see the relationship between dog and man there, it's easy to see how this relationship could have played out. A bit of frozen fish or meat for the dog, but not too much, means protection and assistance on the trap line, and a companion through the winter. EDIT: My border collie currently lying behind me on a bed is anxiously and steadily watching me because what she really wants me to do is put on my skis and go for a hike in the woods with her. She won't really be happy until I do that.
- virgulino 6y agoHerzog's documentary is just a new cut of the original Russian documentary, adding Herzog's old hippie narrative. The original version is fantastic, and much more authentic. Available on YouTube, with subtitles, on the director's own channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbhPIK-oBvA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbhPIK-oBvA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dIdHG9zyrtE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dIdHG9zyrtE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnAF_amhups https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnAF_amhups https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjCs8qi3R0U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjCs8qi3R0U
- xwdv 6y agoDepends, you want to get fucked up by bears?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mc32 6y agoIt’s an interesting theory; on the other hand people domesticated birds of prey to assist with hunting as well (falconry).
- yesbabyyes 6y agoMy pet theory is that corvids and canines were best friends long before humans came around, and that we have hunted all three together, for mutual benefit.
- hirundo 6y agoThis has a strangely hostile anti-paleo spin given the core finding. Here's the title: > Dog Domestication May Have Begun because Paleo Humans Couldn’t Stomach the Original Paleo Diet If they let the wolves eat the lean meat they didn't want, doesn't that mean too-much-lean-meat was not a part of "the original paleo diet"? Does she imagine that we had to eat it before we started to domesticate wolves with it? > “Because we humans are not fully adapted to a carnivorous diet, we simply cannot digest protein very well,” Lahtinen says. “It can be very fatal in a very short period of time.” Yes, if you eat all lean meat you won't last long on that. But nobody thinks that was the paleo carnivore diet that we adapted to. Our ancestors, if current hunter gathers are a guide, ate nose to tail, prioritizing the fatty parts and eating the lean parts only as necessary, else it became scraps for scavengers. It's like saying we're not fully adapted to a plant-based diet because it's dangerous to eat too much (insert toxic plant food here). Well sure, but that just means we're better adapted to other plants or plant parts. Like we're better adapted to eating a nose-to-tail animal than just the lean meat.
- Retric 6y agoIt’s saying that our ancestors where actively avoiding ketosis which is the core of the Palio diet. Rabbit starvation doesn’t mean we can’t eat rabbits, it means we need to eat other things like fat, carbs while also eating rabbits. However, if your hunting rabbits you don’t have a source of fat in hand.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- radford-neal 6y agoYou need to eat either fat or carbohydrate to go with the protein. If you're eating fat with the protein (and no carbohydrates), you aren't going to avoid ketosis (and you'll be OK).
- Retric 6y agoClarified, my point. If you have a source of fat then you don’t need to hunt rabbits. But, if you have a source of carbs then rabbits are a reasonable food source. Therefore if a hunter gather was eating rabbits they where also avoiding ketosis.
- momirlan 6y agoDoes this mean that domestication of raccoons is next ? They seem to enjoy excess protein from urban garbage.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoAs an owner of a border collie, I'm starting to think that certain animals are too smart for domestication. Raccoons, like border collies, might just be better adept at training their humans, rather than the other way around. :-)
- wiremine 6y agoWe recently adopted a Sheepadoodle, and this comment really resonated with me. It's a combination of a poodle and an old english sheep dog, which many think are originally from border collies. She's a wonderful animal, but really, really needs mental stimulation! She's got us trained to be sure. :-)
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt's such a particular kind of intelligence, too, in that they get such pleasure of things that honestly annoy most human beings. Ours will just go for hours rolling a ball back and forth to you, totally fascinated by the way the ball moves across the floor, and how she's getting you to do something for her. For a human, it's just tedium. You can see how useful they'd be for moving sheep around for hours while responding to commands. They just like it. And don't care about weather, or distractions, or anything. Last week I had mine out in the bush here and she was carrying her frisbee with her. A rabbit bolted out not 5 feet in front of her and she completely ignored it, because she was currently stopped in her tracks, busy, giving the frisbee "the eye"
- yowlingcat 6y agoRaccoons combine border collie intelligence with /hands/. I'm not sure I'd be able to handle the level of mischief these adorable critters could get up to.
- sradman 6y agoThe paper Excess protein enabled dog domestication during severe Ice Age winters [1]: > Humans are not fully adapted to a carnivorous diet; human consumption of meat is limited by the liver’s capacity to metabolize protein. Contrary to humans, wolves can thrive on lean meat for months. We present here data showing that all the Pleistocene archeological sites with dog or incipient dog remains are from areas that were analogous to subarctic and arctic environments. Our calculations show that during harsh winters, when game is lean and devoid of fat, Late Pleistocene hunters-gatherers in Eurasia would have a surplus of animal derived protein that could have been shared with incipient dogs. This is based on reference [2] A review of issues of dietary protein intake in humans: > A suggested maximum protein intake based on bodily needs, weight control evidence, and avoiding protein toxicity would be approx. of 25% of energy requirements at approx. 2 to 2.5 g .cntdot. kg-1 .cntdot. d-1, corresponding to 176 g protein per day for an 80 kg individual on a 12,000kJ/d diet [~2800 Cal]. This is well below the theor. maximum safe intake range for an 80 kg person (285 to 365 g/d). [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-78214-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-78214-4 [2] https://chemport.cas.org/cgi-bin/sdcgi?APP=ftslink&action=reflink&origin=npg&version=1.0&coi=1%3ACAS%3A528%3ADC%252BD28XksFSru7s%253D&md5=903b349d78332aeaecec077b07762d38 https://chemport.cas.org/cgi-bin/sdcgi?APP=ftslink&action=re...
- HarryHirsch 6y agoContrary to humans, wolves can thrive on lean meat for months Does that imply that you feed the dog lean meat and you get to eat a fat dog in return? What does the archaeological record have to say on dog bones?
- bsima 6y agoit implies that the humans ate the fat and organs, while the lean meat was given to the dogs
- greenie_beans 6y agoi'm reading the book 'Merle's Door: Lessons from a Freethinking Dog' right now. it's about a man who befriends a wild dog and takes him home. he lets the dog live like a wild dog and gives the dog a door to his house so the dog can live as he pleases. the writer has a refreshing approach to caring for dogs. he also explores/refutes a lot of dog origin myths, while engaging with the scientific history of dog study. very much recommended if you're a dog owner or spend a lot of time outdoors. https://www.indiebound.org/book/9780156034500 https://www.indiebound.org/book/9780156034500
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI can't speak to the nutritional aspect of it, but having attempted various high protein or protein/fat heavy keto diets in the past with varying levels of success I do have to say it doesn't take long before you just get sick of eating meat. The charm of it wears off. Our paleolithic ancestors would have craved and sought out any and all carbohydrate sources, and preserved summer fruits and berries as much as they could have. First nations here in Canada made/make pemmican, a mixture of animal products and berries from the summer, as a winter food, and I'm sure this practice goes back for a very long time. At a certain point, I'm sure being sick of meat (especially from fairly large and omnipresent megafauna), the services of a companion dog/wolf would have been worth the waste. Also many northern hunter gatherers eat the contents of the stomach of their kills as a way to get carbohydrates, trace nutrients and vitamins, etc. Between that and a source for furs, leathers, bones (for tool/structure making), one might make more kills than necessary and have excess meat.
- k__ 6y agoTrue. I did a low-carb diet once for three months and lost 10kg. Most of it because I just couldn't see eggs, cheese, and meat anymore.
- Jtsummers 6y agoMany vegetables and some fruits can still be consumed (though not necessarily much fruit) and maintain a low-carb diet. The other thing to do, or that I did, was to use a variety of spices and herbs. Most add nothing (or very little) with regard to carbs (certainly not the processed sugars low-carb diets aim to avoid) so don't impact the diet overall. And a well-stocked spice cabinet means you can have chicken for a week or even a month and never really have the same meal twice.
- com2kid 6y ago> Many vegetables and some fruits can still be consumed (though not necessarily much fruit) and maintain a low-carb diet. The other thing people don't always realize is that the longer you've been on a low carb diet, the more carbs you can eat and stay ketosis. After 6 months or so, even an entire medium sized apple (19g of sugar) isn't likely to be a problem. This is even more true for people who work out, heck 40g of sugar from fruit followed by 1 hour of high intensity workout, probably not an issue. Starting out strict is needed to get on the keto train, but, but a low sugar ice cream with 10g a serving twice a week isn't going to kick most people out of Ketosis if they've been there for awhile.
- nabla9 6y agoThis seems to support self-domestication hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-domestication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-domestication Scarps left by humans generated differential survival environment where less aggressive, more cooperating individuals were able to get closer and closer humans and get the best bits. At some point most domesticated individuals could form bonds and cooperate with humans. Eventually humans could take over and use selective breeding to finalize the process.
- bjornsing 6y ago> Tame canines can guard against predators and interlopers, carry supplies, pull sleds and provide warmth during cold nights. But those benefits only come following domestication. Despite more than a century of study, scientists have struggled to understand what triggered the domestication process in the first place. Is it so hard to believe that early humans could imagine the benefits and purposefully domesticated canines? I mean, we’ve gone to the freaking moon, for no immediate benefit at all... Humans do a lot of things for the hell of it.
- ekidd 6y agoI once read an article by a man who raised an undomesticated wolf. It's a huge hassle and not exactly safe. But he wound up with a relatively loyal animal that disliked being separated from him. (And which routinely wrecked his house.) If you spend your life hunting game animals with a spear, then maybe a barely tamed wolf seems like a reasonable risk in comparison?
- wtetzner 6y agoI imagine it would offer protection for nomadic hunter-gatherers.
- sunstone 6y agoYes I have a feeling dog domestication went along these lines. The first were wolf puppies that were raised with the tribe and were imprinted on this "pack" as their own as they grew up. Dogs and humans made an effective combination. The dogs could look after and protect small children, a huge benefit. Dogs might be able to partners in hunting. And finally dogs would be excellent "house alarms" when enemies are nearby.
- hnick 6y agoBy all accounts hunter-gatherer societies had a lot more free time than we do, and no Netflix. Personally, I'd absolutely do this just to see what would happen.
- jere 6y ago>Nutritional deficiencies came from the absence of fat and carbohydrates, not necessarily protein. Indeed, if humans eat too much meat, diarrhea usually ensues. And within weeks, they can develop protein poisoning and even die. “Because we humans are not fully adapted to a carnivorous diet, we simply cannot digest protein very well,” Lahtinen says. “It can be very fatal in a very short period of time.” What? This seems flat out wrong. Carbohydrates are the only macronutrient you can live without. Regardless of the long term health outcomes, many people live for years on carnivorous diets. The first sentence might be talking about our past digestive systems, but the rest is about the present.
- abfan1127 6y agoI have to agree with you. Having lived a zero-carb lifestyle for years in my late 20s (losing a ton of weight and becoming the most athletic I'd ever been in my life), either that line is patently false or I'm a super hero.
- Jtsummers 6y agoThe line in question: > Because we humans are not fully adapted to a carnivorous diet, we simply cannot digest protein very well So you spent years of your life eating nothing but meat, maybe eggs? You never had dairy, never had fruits (bananas, apples, oranges, lemon in or on something), never had vegetables (carrots, onions, leafy greens) in that time period?
- GordonS 6y agoI'm not the OP, but a ketogenic (very low carb) diet is not exactly uncommon these days. I follow one myself (for health reasons, I have reactive hypoglycemia), and have done for a few years now. While it was difficult at the start, after a while you get used to it. And I lost a ton of weight without even trying. I don't eat bread, fruit (barring a small amount of lemon/lime juice in food), or any grains or root veg (potatoes are worse than table sugar for spiking blood glucose!). I do eat meat, eggs, and lots of low-carb veg - leafy veg, broccoli, cauliflower, asparagus, chicory, aubergine, courgette, peppers, tomatoes, carrots, onions etc. I also eat plenty dairy too - cheese has no carbs, and a small amount of milk/cream has very little.
- adamc 6y agoThis made me laugh. Admittedly, I don't eat much meat, because I get sick of it so easily. Somehow I imagine roots and berries were a sought after alternative.
- aszantu 6y agoin the past, dogs were also used as a food source, with the excess protein from big game, they might have fattened up the dogs they would eat?
- aritmo 6y ago"excess protein" is more interesting in a scientific paper than "offal and bones".