13 ms·
Economists like to talk about "utility" and the common good with their theories, but they tend to only measure money so unless you can put a price tag on it it
by jandrese 6y ago
Economists like to talk about "utility" and the common good with their theories, but they tend to only measure money so unless you can put a price tag on it it is invisible to economists. The wellbeing of a prostitute is one of those things that has no market. The same is largely true of toxic workplace behavior. There is a tertiary effect from potential lawsuits, but those are almost impossible to price into a business model.
If your bro culture allows you to succeed over your competitors at the cost of a million dollar lawsuit a decade down the road then it probably doesn't make economic sense to change the culture. Wall Street banks and trading houses were (are) notoriously hostile workplaces, but if your profit margins are in the billions and you're getting good returns then a million dollar suit in the future is basically not a concern.
- nickff 6y agoWell there are (at least) two issues you're glossing over here: 1) Toxic workplace behavior is measurable, you can simply measure the wage premium paid by the so-called "toxic" employers or managers. 2) Bro culture may contribute to business success. I don't like that kind of 'culture', but it may help foster improved productivity in certain industries, and the lawsuits may just be a cost of doing business that's worth paying. Again, this isn't how I live my life, but it is conceivable that this is a workable model.
- dcolkitt 6y ago> The wellbeing of a prostitute is one of those things that has no market. Sure it can. Everyday institutions make calculations that assign a standard monetary value to a human life.[1] And it's not just the market, the government and policymakers do it all the time as well.[2] Heck, you even put a value on your own life. Do you drive the latest car model and live in a house that was built in the last two years? If not, you're trading off money against mortality, by increasing your risk of dying in a car accident or house fire. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-value-of-life/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-value-of-life/
- jandrese 6y agoThat's not a measure of your wellbeing though. Usually they just assume that if you have more money you'll be happier. Maybe a fancy car will increase your happiness, but there is no unit of measure you can divide the purchase price of that mid-life crisis car by. The value of a life is roughly how much money they would have made if they had lived until some arbitrary end date. Happiness doesn't figure into it at all. It's calculated so life insurance companies know how to price their product, which is ultimately just paying off some fraction of the remainder of someone's theoretical lifetime income if they die early.
- gjm11 6y agoThat isn't how the various things called "value of a life" are calculated. The Wikipedia article linked above describes some ways to do it, and if you look at them you will see that with one exception they are not estimating, nor trying to estimate, expected future earning power or anything like it. (Though that might affect the answer.) The first approach they describe: take N people and ask each of them how much they would pay to reduce their chance of dying in the next year by 1/M. Then the average of M times this figure is the group's estimate of the value of their lives. (The description in the article simplifies the calculation by taking N=M, but there is no need to.) The second approach: look at what people are willing to forgo in order to reduce their chance of dying a bit, or willing to increase their chance of dying a bit in order to have. If you're willing to increase your chance of dying by X in order to get Y, that suggests you value your life at no more than (the value to you of Y) / X. Look at lots of different X and take some sort of average of the resulting estimates. The third approach is looking at future earnings. The page adds this caveat: "Another potential issue when using wages to value life is that the calculation does not take into account the value of time that is not spent working, such as vacation or leisure." The fourth approach is more or less the same as the first. It's obvious that aside from the second these are not the same as a person's future earnings. And we shouldn't expect them to be; people generally value other things about their future lives besides the money they may earn. (A kinda-artificial example that I think makes the point. Suppose the following things happen: 1. Economic growth stops or slows sufficiently that no one expects investments to grow appreciably an more. 2. You get rich. 3. You retire, intending to supply your needs and wants simply by spending some of your mountain of cash. In this situation your expected future income is zero. But I bet you would still be willing to pay something to reduce your chance of early death.) Also, though this is a less important point: Life insurance is not only for paying off some fraction of your theoretical lifetime income. E.g., you can buy life insurance policies even after you have retired, even if you have no income. Obviously one reason why you would buy life insurance is to make up for loss of future income; but it could be e.g. that one thing you do is to care for other family members, and that if you died they would need someone else to do that who would need paying, and if you were buying life insurance that would be something you would take into account.
- jjoonathan 6y ago> Economists like to talk about "utility" and the common good with their theories, but they tend to only measure money Yeah, that's the problem. The economic notion of value weights according to wealth while the moral notion of value does not. It's absolutely scandalous that we let economists conflate the two. Feed a starving kid in Africa? Zero economic value. The kid doesn't have money. Figure out how to merge together a bunch of megacorps to build a monopoly, raise prices, reduce quality, and make the lives of millions strictly worse? The market will ejaculate capital all over your value-creating endeavor.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoI am an economist, and I have no idea what you're talking about.
- ajb 6y agoIt is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.
- renewiltord 6y agoIt is also difficult to get a man to understand something when you are not familiar enough with the subject. I suspect that is the more common failure mode.
- SantalBlush 6y agoThis HN cliché notwithstanding, economists actually do understand a lot more about the study of economics.
- imtringued 6y agoIt's just the general strawman. People only see economists when they fail so they think all economists fail even though it is only a subset.
- 6y ago