17 ms·
Neofeudalism and the Digital Manor
- jl6 6y agoThe chaos and banditry is caused by software churn. Nothing is ever finished, so nothing is ever secure, so you must ally yourself with a powerful warlord. This is why I am in the process of migrating my website from HTML to PDF/A.
- mwcampbell 6y ago> This is why I am in the process of migrating my website from HTML to PDF/A. With tags for accessibility, I hope.
- konjin 6y agoWho cares? We should not force the majority to be serfs so a minority is served.
- ksm1717 6y agoYou’re a serf
- coldtea 6y agoYou can very easily end up in that "minority". It's just an accident or disease away -- and if not, time and old age will get you anyway (presbyopia, motor decline, and so on).
- konjin 6y agoI use a screen reader already. It is sad that you're so selfish that you can't imagine minorities would be willing to give up quality of life to improve it for the majority.
- coldtea 6y ago>It is sad that you're so selfish Is that how you've been taught to discuss? With ad-hominens, absolute self-certainty on your prioritizations, and pop psychology attacks?
- konjin 6y agoA discussion is impossible when one side assumes the other is arguing in bad faith. You started from the assumption I need sight to navigate and when I pointed out I don't you doubled down on sanctimoniousness. Again: why should the needs of the few trump the needs of the many?
- coldtea 6y ago>You started from the assumption I need sight to navigate Yes, and it was a legitimate assumption, given that your comment implied as much (speaking of those people as a minority in the third person, saying "who cares" about those, etc). There certainly wasn't any "I am a person with accessibility issues myself, and I consider open formats for the majority more important than accessible content" implication. >Again: why should the needs of the few trump the needs of the many? First, disabled / elderly etc. people being able to have access to content, knowledge, entertainment, isn't just some random small thing we can just toss aside. Nor does it concern some insignificant minority we could ignore with minimal loss. Second, putting out unaccessible PDF content is 100% certain to be problematic for people with accessibility needs. Whereas having HTML instead of PDFs (the latter being what the grandfather suggested and you supported) is far from certain to make people "serfs" (which is a loaded metaphor from feudal times) or to be of much significance. If anything HTML is open source and free, and implementing a browser to read basic HTML (as opposed to full WPAs) is trivial - more trivial than PDF for that matter, and with more FOSS browser engines in existance, from full-on to minimal like Links. So even at the basic factual level the concern is misplaced.
- konjin 6y ago>Second, putting out unaccessible PDF content is 100% certain to be problematic for people with accessibility needs. That's where you're wrong. A plain PDF/A is the simplest thing to scrape for text. You know what is a nightmare to deal with? Html with javascript: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/index.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/index.html Try a screen reader on the above nightmare and tell me what you hear. For me it's: iframe-iframe-iframe-iframe-iframe-iframe-iframe-iframe-iframe... turning it into a png and trying to scrape text doesn't help because there is literally zero predictable structure to the text, is it one, two, three or 8 columns wide? Depends on where in the page you look. So again, thanks for the outrage, but we don't need people like you who don't understand the first thing about what we go through defending us and shitting on people trying to make the world better.
- jl6 6y agoYes. I use LibreOffice Writer to export Tagged PDF/A-2b.
- mxuribe 6y ago>...migrating my website from HTML to PDF/A. I'm genuinely curious as to how having an online presence (like a website) implemented as PDF is advantageous? Do PDFs offer some security or authenticity of content that html lacks? Not bashing, really just want to learn.
- baud147258 6y agoI think the idea of using PDF/A is that you only have to maintain a single file that contains all the content, without external dependencies like pictures or fonts. It also supports ways to sign the file, to protect its integrity. At least it's how I understand it. Edit: following the link on the parent's profile, there's a few explanations (in https://www.lab6.com/0 https://www.lab6.com/0): """ PDF makes a stand against the churn. I’m publishing this document in PDF because: - PDFs are self-contained and offlineable - PDFs are files. - PDFs are decentralised. - PDFs are discoverable. - PDFs are independent of browsers - PDFs and a PDF tool ecosystem exist today - PDF is an open standard - PDFs are part of the web - PDFs are page-oriented """ (abridged for readability, each of the bullet points are expanded in the document)
- jl6 6y agoThank you to the sibling content for quoting the headlines from my polemic, but yes, validated PDF/A is guaranteed to contain only static content with no tracking malfeatures and a vastly reduced attack surface compared to HTML5. It’s hilariously impractical if your goal is to build a web application, so a direct comparison to HTML5 isn’t fair, but if you just want to publish information, PDF/A is state of the art.
- api 6y agoThis is a really good point. The endless and often needless churn in software creates a treadmill effect, making it really hard for open source and smaller companies to keep up. It inherently favors large players with deep pockets able to employ vast numbers of developers.
- ericwood 6y agoThis confuses me; the core of HTML is relatively unchanged since its inception and static HTML is fairly secure. PDF is notoriously complex and has had many security issues associated with it as a result. Regardless, if it's content you're producing I'm imagining it can be done securely with either format?
- jl6 6y agoPDF is notoriously complex but PDF/A isn’t.
- selfhoster11 6y agoPDF/A is a reduced subset of PDF, optimised for archival storage. A compliant PDF/A reader has a greatly reduced attack surface compared to a full PDF format reader.
- walterbell 6y agoAny recommended readers?
- jl6 6y agopdf.js in Firefox - as it’s sandboxed. Safari on iOS also natively displays web-hosted PDFs very snappily. Okular is an excellent PDF reader for the Linux desktop and supports attachments.
- tomjen3 6y agoPDF/A is meant for archive purposes (e.g remain pixel perfectly the same when read out of some tape archive 50 years from now archival purposes) and doesn't allow things like javascript. Plus it requires fonts to be embedded.
- twic 6y agoBuddy just post one big PNG.
- f430 6y agoWhat really puzzles me about Apple fans and it's userbase is that they do not care. They simply do not care at all what's being done to them. It's the strongest example of consumer cultism. Absolute in their exceptionalism and ignorance. Similar problems discussed in the article are found in Tesla. The lowest common denominator of consumer cultism is surveillance and it's no surprise that both Apple and Tesla do exceptionally well in authoritarian countries like China. When our data is worth more than a barrel of oil, strange things are happening.
- jasonv 6y agoAnd what to do about it? Windows & Linux probably aren't the answer to the trillion-dollar juggernaut that is Apple. OSS has drawn the talent, and there's a lot of talent building enterprise applications, most of which are the bricks in the wall of mega-tech as they re-write our rights. Macs are great if you want access to the financial funnel that is the app stores now. That probably defines the echo chamber of silence that exists on this subject.
- oblio 6y ago> Windows & Linux probably aren't the answer to the trillion-dollar juggernaut that is Apple. Windows, that indie project from the mom & pop software store :-)) Microsoft is another trillion dollar corporation, not that far behind Apple.
- staplers 6y agoThey simply do not care at all what's being done to them. This is an ignorant view to take. I'm a pretty dedicated apple user but only because the other options don't have the tools I need and the UX I desire. Likely many of the flaws apple products have are piling up to a "straw that broke the camels back" situation for users in a few years or decades. When you assume other's intentions and feelings, bad things happen.
- amelius 6y agoSo you're saying that privacy (Apple knows what apps you're running and when) and autonomy (Apple controlling which apps you may run) are less important than the improvements which Apple has made to its OS over competitors? This is totally fine. But there's where the friction between the two viewpoints is.
- BryantD 6y agoI love the idea of a Ulysses Pact. Something like https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491 would be good. I note that while right now there’s no way to override the malware safeguards, Apple's promising to fix this. (I believe that update was made after this article was written, btw.) Now: it’s absolutely true that Apple could change their mind. Given that possibility, I understand why someone might prefer to avoid Apple. I'd be sincerely interested in some thoughts on how you can make such a Pact enforceable, or do you just have to take it on a case by case basis?
- grishka 6y ago> there’s no way to override the malware safeguards There technically is, because Macs don't come with locked bootloaders, and, you know, system files aren't exactly burned into one-time programmable memory. I mean, you could patch the binaries and have it your way if you really want to. But in reality you don't even need to do that — you only have to completely disable SIP and add change the kernel arguments (something like `amfi_get_out_of_my_way=1` iirc) to disable signature verification altogether.
- BryantD 6y agoTIL! Although I’d argue it has to be accessible by my mom before it’s really useful.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y ago"There is no way for us to defend ourselves: even skilled technologists who administer their own networked services are no match for the bandits. To keep bandits out, you have to be perfect and perfectly vigilant, and never make a single mistake. For the bandits to get you, they need merely find a single mistake that you’ve made." Ooof. What a boot-to-the-face reminder. Despite my use of a Tor Router, three ubikeys and Google authenticator, password manager, non-GSM voice (GoogleVoice), and several hard tokens from various financial institutions, I still have no idea if I'm doing enough because I don't control any of my three OSes, including Ubuntu 18.04 (we almost missed elliptic key backdoor in OpenSSL, what else is in there?).
- gen220 6y agoYou could run your system completely in RAM, to at least limit the duration of exposure. Persistence is overrated! :)
- xaduha 6y agoYou're joking, but I don't think I will be running Windows without uwfmgr.exe aka Unified Write Filter if I ever decide to use it as my main OS again. More people should be aware of it. It's only for Enterprise editions, but maybe there are similar options out there.
- walterbell 6y agoOr a VM with snapshots / non-persistent storage.
- amelius 6y agoHow do you apply security updates?
- walterbell 6y agoImmediately after a clean boot, apply security update, reboot to test, then immediately shutdown and allow that snapshot to persist.
- gnicholas 6y agoIt would be great if there were a way to ally with multiple 'warlords' to achieve security without having to trust just one of them. It should be possible since there's the hardware level, the OS level, and the application level. At least for computers, it should be possible to build an alliance that doesn't require you to put too much trust in any single warlord. Of course on mobile, there's so much vertical consolidation (especially on iOS) that you just have to pick one warlord. EDIT: curious about the downvotes — what part of this do people disagree with? That it would be good to not be stuck with this dilemma? That mobile is vertically integrated?
- m463 6y agoHe's a very eloquent writer. As far as I know, the door isn't quite shut on macos, and maybe a ulysses pact is sort of in place. But if they could do that for ios, I would be so. happy.
- ece 6y agoI only see two differences between MacOS and iOS: kernel development is allowed on MacOS, and running self-signed code doesn't delete itself even if you don't pay like it does on iOS. Running unsigned code doesn't exist on MacOS anymore with Big Sur, unless you self-sign everything. Stop kernel development (going to be "higher friction" going forward) and a daemon to delete self-signed code, and it's iOS. Allowing neutral parties to do app-signing for Chromebooks, Windows 10 S or i/MacOS (the way SSL-certs are issued and trusted by browsers, Mozilla App Store anyone?), alternative app stores (iOS), alternative signed-OSes on hardware (Occulus) are all Ulysses pacts that Apple, Google, Microsoft, Facebook and others could do.
- m463 6y agoI thought you could still disable stuff on macos and then run your own code to your heart's content. You know, boot into recovery and turn stuff off. Is that not true with Big Sur? On the other hand, there is no procedure like this on ios. I think you can run your own code, but you need an apple id (therefore apple's permission) and you can only run code for 7 days.
- Klonoar 6y agoYou can, even on the M1. It's more annoying now, sure, but still possible. Apple's been very clear that kernel extensions are going the way of the dodo, eventually, though - developers should be moving to DriverKit/etc. In truth, it's actually a better system. Slowly becoming more of a hybrid/micro kernel.
- chaganated 6y ago"for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction"
- codeulike 6y agoReminds me a bit of "Serving at the Pleasure of the King" - Coding Horror, 2011 https://blog.codinghorror.com/serving-at-the-pleasure-of-the-king/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/serving-at-the-pleasure-of-the...
- hinkley 6y ago> If Microsoft added a feature to Windows that duplicated a popular application's functionality, developers would be screaming bloody murder Jeff had already forgotten ten years ago that we did, in fact, scream bloody murder. They kept doing it. For decades. And now they wonder why there are people who will never cut Microsoft a break for anything.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 6y agoNixOS everywhere is the only thing to me that feels like enough sovereignty that good security is possible. Tons of Free Software is too complex or just shitty be secure (not that proprietary software is better though!), but at least I am in full control of that which I need to fortify.
- EGreg 6y agoAt Qbix, we have recognized the Feudal nature of Web 2.0 for a while. You can talk about this for years and years (as people have done with UBI and other things) or you can build the solutions. The same way that talking about vegetarianism is never going to convert people as much as the Impossible Burger, an actual meat alternative, ever will. About 20 years ago, the original Web 1.0 has disrupted AOL, CompuServe, Prodigy etc. which were walled gardens. It unleashed trillions in value through new business models like SAAS and E-Commerce. But there is no good open source alternative these days to the Web 2.0 feudal lords, including Google, Facebook, etc. Because it's harder to do. Without sound overly cocky, I think we are perhaps the closest to do it. You can see for yourself at https://qbix.com/token https://qbix.com/token (you can ignore the token part, as it's optional, but it's basically building a micropayment monetization model for digital content, including journalism and open source software, on the new open source Web 2.0)
- dweberz 6y agoThe only path that makes me hopeful involves a combination of 1. FOSS software (ie forkabke when the warlord misbehaves) 2. user owned / governed networks, so the warlord can't easily get extractive against their users.
- type0 6y agoYou are forgetting the importance of open hardware, in ideal world we shouldn't need to install Libreboot to fight proprietary drivers and firmware that can be turned against you any second.
- thombles 6y agoUnfortunately the way he describes the "Ulysses Pact" is fantasy. He makes it sound like it would be just like today, except a savvy user could sideload Signal for example if Apple was compelled to remove it. What would _actually_ happen is a long list of companies would say "brilliant, we don't have to conform to the app store guidelines any more" and go sideload-exclusive. Within a matter of months it would be common for users to have both official and unofficial app stores, sowing widespread confusion, and UX would go to pot while apps run in the background, chew up battery and take advantage of undocumented/buggy APIs to track users or steal data. The warlord analogy is a good one. It's a tough nut to crack. The only defensive mechanism that's actionable for the average user is to keep as much data as possible offline. Sure, if Apple wants to they can ship code that exfiltrates data off my external USB hard drive, but that's way beyond the threat model we're discussing today.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- itsoktocry 6y agoSo what you're saying is you are willing sacrifice personal privacy and security so that technically illiterate people can have a good user experience? I understand that from Apple's perspective, but I, personally, couldn't care less about the battery life on someone else's phone. I feel like the market would sort it out, probably with optional walled gardens. That's better, no?
- thombles 6y ago> So what you're saying is you are willing sacrifice personal privacy and security so that technically illiterate people can have a good user experience? Well, yes. Who is this for if not the tech-illiterate? I’ll be fine. I can use PGP and Tor if I want to.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago"What would _actually_ happen is a long list of companies would say "brilliant, we don't have to conform to the app store guidelines any more" and go sideload-exclusive" This hasn't happened in Android, why do you think it would happen with Apple?
- breck 6y agoWe need to abolish IP Laws (aka "Imaginary Property" aka "Illogical Property" aka "Incongruent Property" aka "Invalidates Property Laws"—the other term is a big lie, don't repeat it). Not "reform". Not "compromise". Abolish. If 2020 taught me anything, it's that society can come close to the brink pretty quickly. I thought there was an inevitable trend toward freedom, but recently think it's perilous. We need ideas to flow to create a more distributed, less unequal, world, and we need it now. We need to unshackle the people. If anyone is working toward this, let me know how I can help (including funding). I'm supporting things like SciHub/LibGen and the like, but we need far far more organizers fighting to #EndIp, #AbolishCopyright, #AbolishPatents. Trolls feel free to reply with the rote lies about how these laws make any sense. Anyone with a conscience doing something about it please get in touch and let me know how I can help!
- konjin 6y agoIP laws are bad because they have been taken past any sane limit. However the original terms would are not too onerous, with provisions and updates there is no reason not to give the people who invent things short and clear monopolies on their ideas. 15 years is plenty of time, then everything needs to be released into the public domain.
- krapp 6y ago>with provisions and updates there is no reason not to give the people who invent things short and clear monopolies on their ideas. The lack of a monopoly creates competition which accelerates innovation and leads to cheaper, higher quality products for the consumer. The person who invents a product should simply be one competitor in the market, they can have the first mover advantage, but shouldn't be allowed to control the market entirely. If we believe in the FOSS ethos that no one has the right to own software, even if they write it, then why would this only apply to software? Why not to all forms of intellectual property? Why do I have a moral right to fork, rewrite and redistribute Firefox but not Star Wars or Pfizer Pharmaceuticals?
- konjin 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yyyk 6y agoThe diagnosis is correct, but the prescription is lacking. His technical idea is fine, but this is a political issue that cannot be solved by technical means alone. If any 'warlord' implemented Doctorow's idea, they'd just weaken themselves. Eventually the legal and financial incentives will ensure the 'warlord' returns to form or is replaced. There's no replacement for a political pressure campaign to make digital neofeudalism obsolete by changing the relevant laws.
- mistermann 6y ago> There's no replacement for a political pressure campaign to make digital neofeudalism obsolete by changing the relevant laws. https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/494602-poll-69-percent-of-voters-support-medicare-for-all https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/494602-pol... Sixty-nine percent of registered voters in the April 19-20 survey support providing medicare to every American, just down 1 percentage point from a Oct. 19-20, 2018 poll, and within the poll's margin of error. Support among independent voters was steady at 68 percent. However, support among Republican voters declined 6 percentage points over the course of two years, from 52 percent support in 2018 to 46 percent in 2020. I doubt you'll find many issues as fundamentally important and with as much bi-partisan support support as Medicare For all, and no politician is ever going to actually try to get that passed, despite what they may claim on TV or the campaign trail. I am afraid we will have to find a way to be content with the legislation that is chosen for us by the Reality TV political system we allowed to form while we weren't paying attention.
- quibbler 6y agoWhat would be a safe way to opt out, though? One that people can't easily be tricked into taking, to installalwate? I don't think Doctorow has thought that through.
- worik 6y agoIs it impossible to use a MacBook (? Apple laptop thingee) without a Internet connection? Seems very odd to me.
- renewiltord 6y agoNo, it will function just fine. Just verified with my Macbook Pro 2019 on OS 11.
- markus_zhang 6y agoClassic feudalism: The king offers lands for loyalty, army and better development of his lands. Modern feudalism: extend land to everything that generates revenue.
- konjin 6y agoInteresting take but it's missing the other part of feudalism: the Catholic Church. Today we don't have one monolithic church but we do have a very large number of priests who can excommunicate you over nothing at all. The larger outside of the centres of powers you get the juicer target for these people you get. This has gotten so bad the Linus of Linux fame has to have a literal guard around him at all times as to not be accused of rape: https://www.theregister.com/2015/11/06/linus_torvalds_targeted_by_honeytraps_says_eric_raymond/ https://www.theregister.com/2015/11/06/linus_torvalds_target...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"As with Apple, the best way for Google to avoid being ordered to turn over data on its users is to not collect or retain that data in the first place. And, as with Apple, the next best thing is to give users the power to turn off that data-collection and data-retention altogether, something Google's gotten marginally better at in the past year." Google is very aggressive in its data collection. Its scope keeps increasing not vice versa. For example, I have been experimenting with blocking some of YouTube's data collection using a forward proxy to deny certain request URLs. It appears one could do this within Developer Tools using request blocking and regex. But who would ever use that. Is it any coincidence this is not named "User Tools". It is possible to watch YouTube videos without having every interaction with the website logged and collected by Google as "data". You will not see any ads if you do not use the Google-supplied Javascript video player. However avoiding data collection takes some effort on the part of the user. Tech companies know this, they know most people are not really "into computers" and cannot be bothered to spend time fiddling with them. We cannot expect Google to make avoiding data collection "easy" for anyone. This is no different from expecting tech companies to "self-regulate".
- ece 6y agoYou can go to https://myactivity.google.com/ https://myactivity.google.com/ and turn off everything there. I think most users can do atleast that if you have a Google account. Using adblockers, fingerprint avoiding browsers, and diligently opting out of all forms of tracking where possible is also doable. This only minimizes data collection. It's sending companies like acxiom and sift science requests to delete your data based on identifiers that most people will likely not do. I would like to see banning of data collection IDs, including IDFAs. No ad re-targeting IDs, no Verizon injecting IDs into network traffic, no Facebook SDK IDs, no IDFAs enabling data collection. I think that would do wonders for big tech minimizing their data collection.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoThis requires sign-in. (Signing-in, the "business" of creating non-anonymous profiles, is as I see it the essence of the problem. "Tech" companies hoping to do "work" for free and profit via online advertising want to build profiles for advertisers to target, without having to ask for consent to create them. Some users do not want profiles nor advertising.) "Myactivity" does not stop data collection. It is, to quote the web page, for "managing" the data they have already collected and will continue to collect going forward absent intervention from the user. The data collection is already happening before one ever signs in. Sure, someone can tell Google to stop collecting, but by then it's too late. They have created a profile at Google's urging , identified themselves and put their name on data that Google has already collected and attached to other identifiers. The solution is simple, as stated above: stop collecting data on people without their prior consent. Legislation could address this, but I doubt the US will ever see any meaningful regulation in this area. As I am typing this I am thinking of the case where Google was sniffing people's Wifi and storing the data. I can find the cite if needed. They later stopped after people complained, and they were sued, but that was a nice example of how aggressively they pursue data collection "within the bounds of existing law". Wrong but legal (for now). This is the "tech" industry in a nutshell.
- sneak 6y agoI'm a little bummed that this repeats the standard apple-vs-the-FBI (in the San Bernardino shooter case) false narrative. Apple provided all of the shooter's phone data, unencrypted and available to Apple thanks to the non-e2e iCloud Backup (on by default on every iPhone) to the FBI. The whole "Apple is naughty and won't unlock it for us!" narrative was a coordinated marketing effort carried out by Apple and the FBI following the Snowden/PRISM thing. Apple doesn't need to backdoor the phones. iOS uploads a complete backup of the phone's data, effectively unencrypted (in that it's encrypted to Apple and Apple can decrypt it at any time they wish without the user, their pin, their password, or their phone) every night when it's plugged in.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]