15 ms·
Covid: New lockdown for England as cases surge
- sonotmyname 6y agoWoohoo - more inconsistent and unscientific policies! * Restaurants can continue to offer delivery for food, but takeaway alcohol will be banned __ So alcohol spreads COVID? Good thing restaurants don't count on alcohol sales to stay afloat. * Amateur team sports are not allowed, but elite sport such as Premier League football can continue __ 'Elite' athletes, as is the case for the rest of the 'elites', should not have to follow the same rules as the plebs. * Outdoor sports venues - such as golf courses, tennis courts and outside gyms - must close __ Yeah - let's take a game (golf) that's done outdoors, in groups of 4 or less, and ban it. Don't worry - you're allowed to walk around the exact same golf course for excercise (as that's one of the only reasons you can leave your home), but if you have to swing a club you'll catch COVID.
- CodeGlitch 6y agoI agree with you on the football thing, although the players will be getting regular tests, and the sport generates a tonne of cash. The rest of it make sense to me. Your example of golf: the sport includes the whole social aspect (the golf club rooms etc). Remember they have to keep the rules simple. Also allowing people to order alcohol to be delivered within the hour probably isn't the smartest!
- gruez 6y ago>The rest of it make sense to me. Your example of golf: the sport includes the whole social aspect (the golf club rooms etc). Remember they have to keep the rules simple. closing the clubhouse is hard?
- CodeGlitch 6y agoSo now the rule is: "Golf clubs can open but the club house have to stay shut" Then you have to think of all the other sports and possible places people can gather and make rules about those too. My point was that the rules have to be simple otherwise people won't read them.
- gregmac 6y ago> Also allowing people to order alcohol to be delivered within the hour probably isn't the smartest! Why? What is the difference vs someone who keeps a quantity on alcohol in their house (other than being exorbitantly more expensive)?
- CodeGlitch 6y agoThe same reason why we have limits of where and when you can buy alcohol - because it's a licensed drug. Why are people confused about this?
- waterglassFull 6y agoYou can still buy alcohol in stores; by take-away this means in a ready-to-drink fashion. Alcohol delivery to a house is fine unless you're assuming people are still having parties.
- monksy 6y agoLimit the amouunt of pre-prepared alcohol that can be delivered to a house at one time. You shouldn't be an ondemand keg delivery at this point or delivering 2+ cases in one go. Also part of the delivery portion of this is about supporting the pub/bar. Not the access to alcohol. (Otherwise you'd just go to the store)
- waterglassFull 6y agoYes, this would make sense.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danans 6y ago> * Restaurants can continue to offer delivery for food, but takeaway alcohol will be banned Is restaurant takeaway alcohol even a thing in normal times in the UK? In CA at least, the state temporarily removed the normal restriction on takeaway alcohol in order to help restaurants during lockdowns.
- bananapear 6y agoNot sure if it’s really that common, but it’s a staple of Friday evenings at City firms if you have to stay late. You order a meal via the corporate Deliveroo/Seamless etc., to the firm-paid limit and immediately call the restaurant and ask for beer of the same value to be delivered instead.
- CamouflagedKiwi 6y agoNo - but lots of places (particularly pubs) had started doing takeaway alcohol last year in order to have _some_ sales, there was some general restriction-lifting to help with that kind of thing. There's of course not any evidence that it's a meaningful contributor to infection, but lockdown is such a crude tool that it's going to hit it regardless.
- monksy 6y agoAll states should have done that in the first 2 weeks. It's irritating to see the bible belt/NC wait 9 freaking months to now allow for take away alcohol. It feels like the governments are: 1. Trying to limit the enforcement and severity of actions or 2. They don't know what they're doing. (Which creates more resistance)
- foota 6y agoIt does make sense imo to allow elite sports to continue while banning amateurs, there are relatively few elite players so the additional risk overall is low.
- gruez 6y agoYou can make the same argument for top level ministers. eg. "well it's fine for the PM and the cabinet to ignore lockdown directives because they're only 0.001% of the uk population" It's still inconsistent, bad for PR, and puts the whole government into question.
- JohnCohorn 6y agoI dislike sports, but I do see that making pro sports broadcasts continue could provide the entertainment needed for folks to be happier to stay inside their homes like they should.
- monksy 6y agoI love the fact that they're open and televising the fact that no fans are there. That really stops people from trying to pressure venues from "sneaking in".
- djsumdog 6y agoWhy not let everyone else sports to stay healthy and strengthen their immune systems, as well as get outside (where it's warm enough) and get the vitamin D they need? Why should people who get paid a million get special treatment over those who are barely making it an unemployed? Being able to shoot some hoops seems more valuable for the 20 year old's mental health than watching some rich top-of-their class play in am empty stadium with cardboard cutouts.
- Daishiman 6y agoBecause everyone doing sports kind of defeats the purpose of social distancing.
- waterglassFull 6y ago"__ So alcohol spreads COVID? Good thing restaurants don't count on alcohol sales to stay afloat." The problem isn't the take-away alcohol itself, the problem is what people do with it. We routinely get people around our area (East London) who buy take-away beer - stand two meters away from the pub - and drink it with their friends. It promotes people spreading COVID. The UK government aren't confident enough to actually curtail people's behaviour (eg mask wearing in public, fining people etc) that they stop the things that people inherently do. I don't think it's a great policy, but it's a step in the right direction. The science itself is all in the messaging and tone.. but they make it easy to get out of with "valid reasons". Stay home.
- monksy 6y agoThat's kind of (rolls eyes on pure practical sense) how Chicago is handling this. Our liqour sales are banned after 9pm from stores, and bars are able to do carryout|outdoor (we have some Canadian spies that live here.. so outdoor dining is still a thing [It's 0C or below on average right now.. chill it's a joke]) until 11pm. My best guess for the store liqour sales is that the southside used liqour stores as a bar and would congregate outside, also the limitation of store liquor sales limits people going to impromptu parties. Behavior change is hard to do right, but it also can be changed in completely unrelated but minor inconvenced changes. (I.e. changing a process or labeling may be more effective than a control and punish model) It's also very difficult to communicate for free societies on why a restuarant or bar ban still needs to be in place when the black market succeeds [underground raves/parties etc]. (Sigh "studies that claim most of the transmission in a household vs bars" (well where did that household interact with a different household... ))
- toolz 6y agoThere isn't any science there, just conjecture from the government on how their restrictions will alter social behavior. It's rather mind blowing to me after seeing extremely well funded and massive projects like the war on drugs in the U.S. fail, to now where the government thinks it can successfully push society in the right direction with even more drastic measures.
- f6v 6y ago> So alcohol spreads COVID? This always gets me. Isn’t it obvious that alcohol consumption is a social activity? Not all of it, but to a large degree. Limiting the consumption seems logical. Of course, you can’t assess the impact of individual measures at the moment, as you need a controlled experiment and proper statistics. But is this measure really something to be that upset about?
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago> Limiting the consumption seems logical. Lots of "plans" seem logical and this is precisely why technocracy is a vexation on society. Unintended consequences. The presumption of knowledge and control. All of these elite presumptions are illusory and fundamentally hubristic. You know why "limiting the consumption" of alcohol is a dumb suggestion? We have tons of evidence that it was a massive failure: Prohibition and the War on Drugs. No matter how well-intended you are - it'll backfire and people will ignore it. Humans are fundamentally social creatures. Millions of years of evolution have seared into their biology the instinct to be social. The idea that we can force humans into acting against their fundamental instincts to socialize is folly. Not only folly - but abuse. But seriously, it's bizarre. The obdurance of so-called experts set on working against the grain of every human instinct, as though that's likely to maximize the success of their plans.
- f6v 6y ago> The idea that we can force humans into acting against their fundamental instincts to socialize is folly. Do you really want to go down that road? Well, here we go: procreation is a fundamental human instinct. Do you want to legalize rape? Didn’t think so. You see how folly your argument is?
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago> Well, here we go: procreation is a fundamental human instinct. Do you want to legalize rape? This is non-sequitur. A better comparison is like legally enforcing abstinence to eradicate HIV. If you can't get the idea that isolation is counter-intuitive to humans and damaging to their health and psychology, and therefore bound to be hard to get compliance, I'm not sure what to say. This is why jail is jail. Isolation is unnatural. It's punishment. No one voluntary chooses this.
- rusk 6y agoAlcohol spreads COVID. Not exactly ... but it breaks down social barriers and can cause people to be careless. If we had banned or at least curtailed alcoholic sales I can guarantee you probably the numbers would be half what they are now. A big problem is that once you close pubs clubs and other outlets then people start having secret house parties and these are very hard to police. I guarantee you, that even the best intentioned host will have a super spreader event on their hands before long. It doesn’t take many - 10 even to churn the virus among themselves and then head off home to give it to whomever is there. I’m really sorry that you feel your rights are being curtailed, but what we are living through is hopefully a once in a lifetime event that if we could have just knuckled down at the start and endured some discomfort we would be pretty much over it by now. So much for that “blitz spirit” all we hear is moan moan moan ...
- djsumdog 6y agoThis is complete and total arbitrary nonsense. You're taking a conclusion and trying to walk back a path of logic to some type of justification. Let's see this for what it is: arbitrary decisions that curtails the human rights of all human beings by politicians who are figuratively drunk with power. They are banning things for the common people while they leave their regions, have expensive $1k dinners for their political backers and ignoring all the rules they've imposed on the population. From Canada to California to the UK, we watch elected leaders ignore the bullshit rules they put on people, either because they think it doesn't apply to them or they've seen the numbers and know the risks are bullshit. We're talking about a disease that's literally has over a 98% survival rate if you're under 55 (which causes people to spout more "long COVID" narrative media non-sense). 100 years from now, do you really think scholars will see 2020 and 2021 as anything other than the largest cast of mass hysteria to date? Let's isolate the elderly and vulnerable, or anyone who wants to be isolated, and let the rest of the world evaluate their own risks again.
- rusk 6y agoSorry but this is derived from actual contact tracing (not the UK where they haven’t really bothered but a culturally similar neighbour) - but of course you’re so outraged that’s what matters more. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/09/k-overlooked-variable-driving-pandemic/616548/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/09/k-overloo... This article is about 6 months old, and we’ve moved on even more since then. It’s so saddening to see so many bright people unable to keep up. Tell me again about Sweden sad lol
- edoceo 6y agoIf England stopped football there'd be riots the next day.
- dahfizz 6y agoThis reminds me of how the Massachusetts governor closed hair salons and golf courses ... between the hours of 9:30 pm and 5 am. I'm sure ladies getting their hair done at midnight were the real super spreaders /s. Honestly, its not hard to see how government's hypocrisy and inconsistency fuels conspiracy theories. Another example is the Massachusetts mask mandate that explicitly requires masks when nobody is near you. I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt, that this is just to remove ambiguity and make enforcement easier. But its not hard to imagine the reaction of someone who is prone to tinfoil hatting when they are told they must always wear a mask outside, even if miles away from the nearest human.
- uncledave 6y agoTakeaway alcohol is not banned. This point was a crap article by the Independent who didn’t read the actual guidelines. Why the downvotes. It's on page 18 of the issued document. ffs.
- Someone 6y agoTakeaway alcohol sales run a real risk of alcohol consumption on the streets in the neighborhood of alcohol sellers. That, in turn, can easily lead to loose interpretation of social distancing rules. The argument for allowing elite sports to go on typically is to give the population some distraction during lockdown (it’s a bit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses) As to golf: if you allow that, why wouldn’t a group of four people be allowed to kick a football around? Tennis be allowed? Also, part of lockdown is the prevention of people mixing over longer distances. A local outburst of COVID-19 is bad, but if the infected move home over tens of kilometers (as, I guess, is quite normal for golf), you’re asking for a much bigger problem. Having said that, it is safe to assume the government is far from an expert on what are the risky things to do. Nobody is.
- iso1210 6y agoA lot of it is virtue signalling, and that's not a bad thing if you want people to actually think "we're all in this together" Young people can't play football, so rich old white men play golf or go grouse shooting Premier league footballers don't care much if they're playing or not, but the average person wants to watch it on TV. Food delivery is fine, but they don't want people buying alcohol and meeting on the street to drink with friends
- twoslide 6y agoOne of the things that irritates me most is that Boris portrays the variant as a kind random piece of bad luck. Don't know much about genetics, but I guess such a variant becomes more likely when there are many infections (more of the virus to mutate), and the strategy has consistently been to run things "hot" and tolerate high case counts.
- JohnCohorn 6y agoIf other countries(like the US!) are running it hot it could just as easily develop there and still have spread to the UK.
- twoslide 6y agoGood point, we’re a small share of global cases. I’ll temper my wrath a bit.
- Veen 6y ago> Boris portrays the variant as a kind random piece of bad luck That's pretty much the definition of a mutation.
- twoslide 6y agoYes, but you have a lot more chances to have the bad luck if the virus is spread widely
- f6v 6y ago> Boris portrays the variant as a kind random piece of bad luck It’d be hilarious if UK blamed China for engineering the virus in the lab at the same time. Or they do?
- protoman3000 6y agoWhat are the reasons why we can’t have a very hard 4-week long Chinese style total shutdown?
- malka 6y agoBecause UK is not a dictatorship. China is.
- f6v 6y agoYeah, lockdown parties are a basic human right.
- jeofken 6y agoAgreed. No man has the right to violently hinder free people from living free. My body is my property and not the property of the state.
- ubercow13 6y agoAny state on the planet will violently hinder their people from doing certain things, that one of the jobs of most police forces. Often it's to protect the rights of other 'free people' in the population.
- jeofken 6y agoLike my body is my property are the bodies of others also property of theirs, and I have no right to violate their property right. It is instead right to proportionally defend rightfully owned property.
- djsumdog 6y agoGathering is a basic human right: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances. There is no reason stated. There is no exception for "virus." Human rights laws were not written for fair weather. They were written for crisis and disaster.
- itsmemattchung 6y agoCan someone elaborate on the differences between the numbers reported by the gov.uk website NOIDS[1] (notifications of infectious diseases) versus the numbers reported another gov.uk website[2] ? Looking at NOIDS's weekly reported COVID-19 cases from Week 52[3], I only see 85 new COVID-19 cases. Whereas when I look at the coronavirus.data.gov.uk website, the numbers soar and continue shoot through the roof. What's going here? What's the NOIDS UK government website even reporting and why are the numbers significantly lower? [1] NOIDS - https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/notifiable-diseases-weekly-reports-for-2020 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/notifiable-diseas... [2] https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/ https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/ [3] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/948507/NOIDS-weekly-report-week52-2020-1.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- ageitgey 6y agoNOIDS is an outbreak detection program. The idea is if a primary care doctor suspects someone has something important and unexpected, like Cholera or Polio, they can let the disease control authorities know so they they can be on the lookout for outbreaks. It's an early warning system. During a giant epidemic, no primary care doctor is detecting a new covid outbreak and reporting that up the chain as though thats new information - not when people are told to get tested outside primary care and aren't allowed to come into primary care with covid symptoms and tens of thousands are testing positive each day and have known covid cases. There's just no reason to do that. So NOIDS numbers are meaningless for Covid. But if covid recedes, then the system is in place for detecting future outbreaks.
- qeternity 6y agoIn the UK, 95% of the deaths are people over 60. There are more deaths for people over 90 than under 70. When are we going to start putting all these efforts and resources into focusing on the vulnerable populations and not painting with a broad brush. We know that lockdowns are too blunt an instrument which is why most of Europe is having to engage in ever more draconian measures. We are mortgaging our future here, without questioning the cost. We don't need more of the same. It's not a question of willpower. It's a question of approach, and currently nobody is asking the hard questions. EDIT It seems downvote brigade has arrived to ensure that any contrarian opinion is snuffed out. No rebuttal with data, just downvotes.
- spaetzleesser 6y ago“nobody is asking the hard questions.” Maybe they have asked these questions and concluded that this is the best path? Seems most countries are following similar paths.
- matz1 6y ago>Seems most countries are following similar paths Doesn't mean it is the best path. Monkey see monkey do. As Desmond Swayne called it 'Herd Stupidity'
- chacha2 6y agoHospitals are quickly filling up, young people need hospitals as much as anyone. What's your suggestion, allow elderly covid patients to die at home?
- qeternity 6y agoNo they aren't. NHS occupancy in 2020 was lower than in 2019. We are currently 50% below our peak ventilator usage in April and the 7 day trend is very flat. This is just not true. Go look at the data instead of parroting headlines. EDIT Lol again downvotes but no replies. Does anyone want to bother educating me on this topic and showing me where hospitals are filling up? I would love to see it, because the NHS figures certainly don't show it.
- open-source-ux 6y agoEverything seems so last minute and ad hoc with this Conservative government. Their announcement of another level 5 lockdown (which hadn't existed until today) and the u-turn on school closures makes it clear they are simply making things up as they go along. The goverment's level of incompetence is simply off the scale. How has this nasty, rotten government gotten away with some much? (No doubt helped by our nasty right-wing press.)
- Veen 6y agoHow would it work otherwise? The lockdowns are announced when they happen. What's the alternative? Announcing them weeks before they go into force? Then people would be up in arms the nasty Tory government are delaying the lockdowns. They are "making things up as they go along" or as it's more charitably known, reacting to events.
- xyzzyz 6y agoBlaming it on Conservative government and “nasty” right wing press might make you feel better, but there is no reason to believe you’d get better outcomes if someone else was pulling the strings. Sure, UK government’s response to covid has been stupid, inconsistent and making things up as they went along, but the same is true about government response to covid almost everywhere else.
- f6v 6y agoThat’s right, nobody took it seriously. I remember my biology professors at the university joking about COVID in March: “Anyone came from Italy recently? Hahaha”. That was surreal.
- djsumdog 6y agoI agree. It's a power grab and security theater. It's like the TSA at airports. Let's show we're doing something for the people who keep screaming at the government to do something. It's like trying to stop a hurricane or an asteroid impact. Everything is for show and most of it is just going to make things worse.
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoHopefully the two vaccines currently being rolled out in the U.S. and Europe will largely eliminate the need for future lockdowns. Once the most vulnerable populations are immune, it's just a matter of weeks or months before herd immunity among the general population is achieved and life can pretty much go back to normal.
- pageandrew 6y agoYour optimism is appreciated but the situation seems so bleak I cannot believe it could be that easy
- 0xffff2 6y agoWhy not? Provided the vaccines work (hard to doubt at this point) and we can manufacture enough of them, what's going to stop us?
- f6v 6y agoMaybe in a year or so... There was another HN discussion on production capabilities, tldr: distribution and production takes a long time. Until then, there’s no way other than lockdown. I doubt contact tracing is going to get better, at least here in the EU.
- abridgett 6y agoSadly the timescales are looking more like 1-2 _years_. That's before we get to anti-vaxers and there'll be a lot (there will also be plenty of side-effect cases - due to the sheer number of people being vaccinated at once, not because it's not safe!)
- djsumdog 6y agoEven with a vaccine this virus will not go away for at least 10 years. It took 185 years to eradicate SmallPox (mostly from the WHO push of 20 years in the 60s/70s). Vaccine manufactures are claiming 95% efficacy, but that's honestly not a comforting number. It leaves lots of room and since Challenge trials are unethical (they shouldn't be, but they are) we don't know how accurate that number really is. We still haven't eradicated Polio. This virus may be with us for another 100 years honestly. The next generation will grow up with it and likely won't be affected at all by it. Who knows, maybe the common cold Rhino and Coronaviruses killed millions in human pre-history and now they just give us the sniffles.
- jeofken 6y agoUncountable seeds of friendship and love never take root, due to meeting people being banned. Untold numbers of ideas and plans never made between entrepreneurs. All due to people with power over government arms or mass media being caught up in a mass hysteria. Governments will print money Weimar-style to fund their debts and liabilities in the 2020s, as they kill commerce and free life. In my country we were spared from lockdowns or restrictions until recently - and compared to how friends in Germany, Hungary, Denmark, etc live it’s such a relief. Still no more people have died here last year than on average - 90k deaths/year as usual [0] [1] [0] http://www.scb.se/om-scb/nyheter-och-pressmeddelanden/overdodligheten-i-sverige-har-foljts-av-underdodlighet/ http://www.scb.se/om-scb/nyheter-och-pressmeddelanden/overdo... [1] http://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/sverige-i-siffror/manniskorna-i-sverige/doda-i-sverige/ http://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/sverige-i-siffror/mannisko...
- djsumdog 6y agoBy closing businesses and shutting down the means of people to provide for themselves, governments are also forcing people to depend on handouts. Printing money without increasing value will not last. It has already damaged our economy and made us dependent on states that have not shutdown (some with terrible human rights violations like the CCP government). It should be clear it's a means of control, used as an excuse by World Economics Form to continue with their plans for debt reset (only for certain people of course; Bezos and Gates won't have their wealth affected to devalued, just everyone under a certain income range). I agree. This is insane and it bothers me few people on HN see it as such. There is no room for discussion on this forum for the true weight and reality of what we are seeing unfold.
- flagrant 6y agoThe citations do not support what you say. Citation [0] says only that excess mortality in specifically the third quarter of 2020 was not higher than previous years. It says nothing about the excess deaths for all of 2020. Citation [1] is data for 2019, before COVID-19. Why did you cite these articles and pretend they say something they don't?
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lamplighton 6y agoI live in Southwark, and it's always astonishing how people don't wears masks around here. Customers, Cashiers, Barbers... Iceland, Off-license, Asda... It's like people don't care at all. Only about 50% of people are wearing masks. Sharp contrast with France where people need to wear masks all the time, and it's heavily enforced. I don't expect the number of cases to go down TBH.
- CodeGlitch 6y agoI live in Warwickshire - it's pretty unusual to see people not wearing masks. I even see them wearing them on my walks in the countryside (when they are on their own!). The only people I have see who have refused are some of the mums at my kid's school during dropoff/pickup. Would be interesting to understand why regions differ so much on this.
- djsumdog 6y agoThat masks are scientifically shown to do anything. They are more superstition at this point. You can look at numbers between regions with high mask usage and low mask usage and there's literally no correlation. Meanwhile they are contributing massive amounts of plastic waste, textile waste, and provide a placebo while also providing alienation between individuals. The larger factor that correlates is population density. Low population areas around the US rarely impose mass mandates and they also don't have high numbers. Lastly, hypothesis: people who are convinced of the merits of a masks are also likely to murder the people in the other room in the Stanly Milgram experiments.
- JohnCohorn 6y agoThere’s debate on how much masks reduce spread, and obviously a lot of variation in effectiveness given wildly different materials and design for masks that are not designed to be protective. But I’ve never heard of any serious scientific debate about their helping to some reasonable degree. With possibly high benefits and very low cost(in dollars and in freedom as compared to other measures) wearing masks while indoors in public seem like a no brainer. There are probably issues with how much people obsess over them though. I feel like people get a false sense of protection. People tend to stand right next to you in line when masks are required rather than keeping some distance!
- bananapear 6y agoI submitted this a couple of weeks ago but it didn’t get any discussion - a list of questions for the government based on empirical data: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zkE00ANmITzyXaSM-S_44ZWEJTxoUtp3/view?usp=drivesdk https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zkE00ANmITzyXaSM-S_44ZWEJTx...