8 ms·
>I still remember Craig Silverstein being asked what his biggest mistake at Google was and him answering "Not pushing for ECC memory." Did they ( Google ) or H
by ksec 6y ago
>I still remember Craig Silverstein being asked what his biggest mistake at Google was and him answering "Not pushing for ECC memory."
Did they ( Google ) or He ( Craig Silverstein ) ever officially admit it on record? I did a Google search and results that came up were all on HN. Did they at least make a few PR pieces saying that they are using ECC memory now because I dont see any with searching. Admitting they made a mistake without officially saying it?
I mean the whole world of Server or computer might not need ECC insanity was started entirely because of Google [1] [2] with news and articles published even in the early 00s [3]. And after that it has spread like wildfire and became a common accepted fact that even Google doesn't need ECC. Just like Apple were using custom ARM instruction to achieve their fast JS VM performance became a "fact". ( For the last time, no they didn't ). And proponents of ECC memory has been fighting this misinformation like mad for decades. To the point giving up and only rant about every now and then. [3]
[1] https://blog.codinghorror.com/building-a-computer-the-google-way/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/building-a-computer-the-google...
[2] https://blog.codinghorror.com/to-ecc-or-not-to-ecc/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/to-ecc-or-not-to-ecc/
[3] https://danluu.com/why-ecc/ https://danluu.com/why-ecc/
- djur 6y agoYour [3] has a footnote quoting a Google book that reads "Modern DRAM systems are a good example of a case in which powerful error correction can be provided at a very low additional cost... The following machine generation at Google did include memory parity detection, and once the price of memory with ECC dropped to competitive levels, all subsequent generations have used ECC DRAM"
- ksec 6y agoWell They made a big deal out of it and lots of PR out of not having use ECC, and only quietly adding back ECC and listed it out in a book that barely any one reads.
- sitkack 6y agoThe fact that ECC isn't the default across everything is a failure of human cognition and Capitalism.
- jandrese 6y agoI have always been angry that ECC was treated as an "enterprise" feature and increased the price way more than it should have.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sneak 6y agoI feel this way about all software.
- buran77 6y agoIt's treated as enterprise because most regular users had no realistic reason to care about it. The practical consequences of not having this on your phone or home PC are completely invisible for the vast majority of people. Because of this and the fact that in the consumer space prices matter most the situation is quite expected.
- behringer 6y agoUsers most definitely want it. They just aren't technically literate enough to know about it. Hello user, for an extra 10 dollars, would you like to guarantee that cosmic radiation never affects your computing experience, including having to reformat, reinstall, or otherwise reboot your phone/computer randomly when one day something just doesn't work anymore? Was it an update? Was it cosmic radiation? Was it a bad capacitor? Who knows! Why do you think so many problems are solved by rebooting? Sure 99 out of 100 might be software bugs, but the other 1 out of 100 is straight up cosmic radiation, and that 1 percent is growing more and more every year as software becomes more robust and bug free with better tooling.
- buran77 6y agoIndeed, users don't know enough to care but more than that, for most users this is simply not a problem because they haven't been practically affected. Most may never experience a bit flip, and most of the flips won't be obvious anyway (e.g. no visible effect). So your hypothetical dialogue will sound more like a scam to a regular user. You're charging money to tackle a problem they don't have or see, only addressing a single one of the root causes that trigger that same result, and in the end you're not even completely fixing it, just reducing the already infinitesimal odds it happens. It will become mainstream when manufacturers just decides to include it everywhere and not really give the user a choice. Apple is a prime candidate for a company with enough clout to afford this.