19 ms·
Yeah, it's real obnoxious of Intel to silo ECC support off into the Xeon line, isn't it? I switched to ECC memory in 2013 or 2014 with a Xeon E3 (fundamentally
by loeg 6y ago
Yeah, it's real obnoxious of Intel to silo ECC support off into the Xeon line, isn't it? I switched to ECC memory in 2013 or 2014 with a Xeon E3 (fundamentally a Core i7 without the ECC support fused off) and of course a Xeon-supporting motherboard (with weird "server board" quirks: e.g., no on-board sound device).
I love that AMD doesn't intentionally break ECC on its consumer desktop platforms and upgraded to the Threadripper in 2017.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoDoesn't intel make ECC available on the i3 line of CPUs?
- minot 6y agoI was going to say no but I just checked and at least ONE latest generation i3 processor supports ECC https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/compare.html?productIds=208656,209735,209736,208074,208079,208920,208652,208651 https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/compare.html?pro... https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/208074/intel-core-i3-1115gre-processor-6m-cache-up-to-3-90-ghz.html https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/208074/... Problem is this processor is an Embedded processor so probably not for us > Industrial Extended Temp, Embedded Broad Market Extended Temp My understanding is Intel does not support ECC on the desktop unless you pay extra.
- makomk 6y agoYeah, that appears to be a BGA-packaged processor designed to be permanently soldered to the board of some embedded device, not something that you can install in your desktop at all. I'm not sure why Intel decided to brand their embedded processors with ECC as i3, though I suspect the reason this range exists at all is because companies were going with competitors like AMD instead due to their across-the-board ECC support.
- hollerith 6y agoThat i3 is for file servers.
- opencl 6y agoThey used to support ECC in the desktop i3 lineup, current gen does not have ECC except in some embedded SKUs. https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/199280/intel-core-i3-10320-processor-8m-cache-up-to-4-60-ghz.html https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/199280/...
- xxs 6y agoNot any more[0] 10300. It used to[1] - 9300: 0: https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/199281/intel-core-i3-10300-processor-8m-cache-up-to-4-40-ghz.html https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/199281/... 1: https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/134886/intel-core-i3-9300-processor-8m-cache-up-to-4-30-ghz.html https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/134886/...
- defanor 6y agoI've considered using an AMD CPU instead of Intel's Xeon on the primary desktop computer, but even low-end Ryzen Threadripper CPUs have TDP of 180W, which is a bit higher than I'd like. And though ECC is not disabled in Ryzen CPUs, AFAIK it's not tested in (or advertised for) those, so one won't be able to return/replace a CPU if it doesn't work with ECC memory, AIUI, making it risky. Though I don't know how common it is for ECC to not be handled properly in an otherwise functioning CPU; are there any statistics or estimates around?
- dannyw 6y agoYou can use BIOS settings to change the TDP to whatever you like, with substantially higher efficiency if you are under-powering and substantially lower efficiency if you are over-powering.
- marcosdumay 6y agoKeep in mind that Intel lies about its TDP.
- paulmd 6y agoNah. Both brands pull more than TDP when boosting at max, AMD desktop processors will pull up to 30% above the specified TDP for an indefinite period of time (they call this number the "PPT" instead, but they need to go higher than TDP to hit full boost, and PPT is the number that governs that). Intel mobile processors actually obey TDP better than AMD processors do - Tiger Lake has a hard limit, when you configure a 15W TDP then it really is 15W steady-state once boost expires, while AMD mobile products will pull up to 50% more than configured in steady-state operation. (the gap is larger than desktop) https://images.anandtech.com/doci/16084/Power%20-%2015W%20Comp%20Agi.png https://images.anandtech.com/doci/16084/Power%20-%2015W%20Co... "the brands measure it differently" is sort of theoretically true but not in the sense people think, and in practice it is not true. On AMD it is literally just a number they pick that goes into the boost algorithm. Robert Hallock did some dumb handwavy shit about how it's measured with some delta-t above ambient with a reference cooler but the fact is that the chip itself basically determines how high it'll boost based on the number they configure, so that is a self-fulfilling prophecy, the delta-t above ambient is dependent on the number they configure the chip to run at. In practice: what's the difference between a 3600 and a 3600X? One is configured with a TDP of 65W and one is configured with a TDP of 95W, the latter lets you boost higher and therefore it clocks higher. Configure them both to a 65W PPT limit and they will boost to pretty much the same place. Intel nominally states that it's measured as a worst-case load at base clocks, something like Prime95 that absolutely nukes the processor (and even then many processors do not actually hit it). But really it is also just a number that they pick. The number has shifted over time, previously they used to undershoot a lot, now they tend to match the official TDP. It's not an actual measurement, it's just a "power category" that they classify the processors as, it's informed by real numbers but it's ultimately a human decision which tier they put them in. So in practice, for both brands, it is just a number they pick. They have different theoretical methods for getting there but ultimately the marketing department looks at where the clocks would put them and pick a power number that they think represents that. It is not, in practice, a pure measurement from either brand, it is just a "category" they use. Real-world you will always boost above base clocks on both brands at stock TDP, at least on real-world loads. You won't hit full boost on either brand without exceeding TDP, the "AMD measures at full boost" is categorically false despite the fact that it's commonly repeated. AMD PPT lets them boost above the official TDP for an unlimited period of time, they cannot run full boost when limited to official TDP.
- fortran77 6y agoWhile it's true that Intel only has ECC support on Xeon (and several other chips targeted at the embedded market) it's not true that ECC is supported well on AMD. We only use Xeons on developer desktops and production machines here precisely because of ECC. It's about 1 bit flip/month/gigabyte. That's too much risk when doing something critical for a client.
- jeffbee 6y ago> While it's true that Intel only has ECC support on Xeon That's not true. There are Core i3, Atom, Celeron, and Pentium SKUs with ECC. E.g. the Core i3-9300 https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/intel/core_i3/i3-9300 https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/intel/core_i3/i3-9300
- loeg 6y ago> it's not true that ECC is supported well on AMD. That's an extreme claim. Why do you say so?
- theevilsharpie 6y ago> it's not true that ECC is supported well on AMD ECC is supported on most Ryzen models[1], as long as the motherboard supports it. In fact, ASUS and ASRock (possibly others) have Ryzen motherboards designed for workstation/server use where ECC support is specifically advertised. [1] The only exception is the Ryzen CPUs with integrated graphics.
- paulmd 6y agoIt's an unsupported configuration and it's not tested. The latter is a big problem, one of the extreme-OC guys (Buildzoid) who interacts frequently with the OEMs (as he is pushing their stuff to the limit and he frequently needs their help) has commented that AMD has a really bad problem with their BIOS teams. The AGESA firmware (the low-level code that the processor actually runs) is buggy as all hell at a firmware level and the OEMs are forced to patch around it in BIOS, but the AGESA firmware also has a massive problem with code churn, so these BIOS fixups basically stop working all the time. And the driver teams at a lot of OEMs are literally one person, so there isn't enough staffing there to test everything all the time. Long and short of it is: stuff breaks in AMD BIOSs, constantly, and they don't notice it. This is obviously a huge problem when ECC is not an officially supported feature, because it means nobody is testing it! You might update your BIOS (as you frequently have to do with AMD machines) and suddenly ECC stops working, it might be running ECC in non-ECC mode and no longer correcting errors. Or it might have screwed up reporting them to the OS. The server/workstation boards are the only ones you should be trusting Ryzen with ECC usage on.
- CalChris 6y agoYeah, the iMac Pro has the Xeon W and ECC. T'would be nice if the Apple Silicon MacBook Pro had it. There's not much of a reason to pay for the Pro over the Air. But like Linus, I'm going to blame Intel for this situation in the market. Maybe Apple will strike out on its own with Apple Silicon but since their dominant use case is phones, I'll not hold my breath.
- DCKing 6y agoUnless something weird happens, the next generation of the Apple M-line will use LPDDR5 memory instead of the LPDDR4X used in the Apple M1. While it probably won't support error correction monitoring, LPDDR5 has built in error correction that silently corrects single bit flips. That alone should be a huge reliability improvement. LPDDR5 will enable some much needed level of error correction in a metric ton of other future SoC designs too. I look forward to the future Raspberry Pi with built in error correction capabilities.
- CalChris 6y agoWell then, maybe I'll wait for the rumored 14.1 MacBook Pro. MacRumors says second half of 2021.
- dannyw 6y agoWill this also exist for consumer DDR5?
- DCKing 6y agoYes, this applies to both DDR5 and LPDDR5. Leaks indicate that DDR5 CPUs and motherboards by Intel and AMD are not going to be out this year though, at least not on the desktop.
- vbezhenar 6y agoYou can find non-Xeons with ECC support. But they are rare and usually suitable for some kinds of micro servers.