5 ms·
I can't find it now, but I remember a story from somebody in the Lean Manufacturing world about a place that was having safety problems, so they appointed someb
by wpietri 6y ago
I can't find it now, but I remember a story from somebody in the Lean Manufacturing world about a place that was having safety problems, so they appointed somebody Safety Director. This signaled to everybody that safety was that one guy's problem, not theirs. Accidents went up further and stayed up until they got rid of the Safety Directory position and made everybody responsible for safety.
That resonated for me because I've seen that happen in software, that classic pattern where cowboy coders ship garbage to QA. The lowest bug rates I've seen are where everybody cares about quality.
With Facebook, I expect that "Chief of Advertising Integrity" is sort of light a lightning rod. The job is not to solve the problem, it's to take the hits.
- drdeadringer 6y ago> That resonated for me because I've seen that happen in software, that classic pattern where cowboy coders ship garbage to QA. The lowest bug rates I've seen are where everybody cares about quality. On the flip side, I get nervous when I hear something akin to "We don't have QA here", sometimes as a matter of pride. Think of those times when you've heard someone snear at "Safety First", but for QA or testing. Perhaps one ideal would be to promote a "everyone cares about quality" environment whilst still having some people focused specifically on QA.
- smillbag 6y agoThat's such a funny story, and so predicate. I would love the source to this if it comes to anyones mind!
- avian 6y agoThis story explains why every workplace safety exam I ever took had at least one question similar to "who is responsible for fire/machine/... safety" where the only correct answer was "everyone".
- jacquesm 6y agoThis goes for computer security as well, but in practice without at least a voice in the management security will get axed on every turn because it is seen as all cost without benefit to the company. This is changing slowly, mostly on account of the GDPR, but it is still the prevailing view.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoSounds like something out of the Silicon Valley TV show.
- dcsommer 6y agoThere are pros and cons of having dedicated teams for work that also has to be accomplished by other teams. For instance, it's not a good idea to skip having a security team using the logic that "other teams will just think its that one teams job." The security team provides expertise and (with cooperative management or other teams) can enact policies that influence the rest of the organization to the benefit of security. That can't happen without a set of people dedicated to thinking about those problems. For your QA team example, the mistake made in some organizations is explicitly removing testing from developer's responsibilities. It's a matter of BOTH/AND -- you need to have BOTH central teams responsible for long term health of {safety,privacy,security,testing,etc.} AND hold developers responsible to deliver the recommendations of and use the tools developed by central teams.
- mcguire 6y agoAww, c'mon, tell me that QA/security/accessibility/whatever isn't regarded as a meaningless hoop to be jumped through as quickly and with the least effort possible so that you can get real work done. Ain't nobody got time for that rigamarole.
- loopz 6y agoWith EU laws, GDPR and UX fanatics, many have to do the heavy lifting or risk multimillion dollar fines. So it's changing.
- georgeecollins 6y agoIn games, QA is taken very seriously. I know with games like Cybepunk people think game developers don't care about QA, but I am sure that is a certain circumstance where they chose to ignore problems. On big games you count on QA for feedback.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vorpalhex 6y agoIf you're shipping buggy and insecure software, you will soon get a whole lot of free time on your hands.
- mathattack 6y agoIt’s the plus and minus of specialization. When you have a dedicated QA team it can be harder to hold the devs accountable for the defects QA doesn’t find.
- gnicholas 6y agoAs someone who works in accessibility and interfaces with folks at big companies, I can see how this type of problem would apply in lots of areas.