12 ms·
UK formally leaves European Union after 48 years
- znpy 6y agodumbfu**s.
- tpmx 6y agoDid it happen at midnight CET or midnight BST/GMT?
- xenocratus 6y agoCET, of course :)
- tpmx 6y agoLooks like you're right. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-55502781 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-55502781 > The UK stopped following EU rules at 23:00 GMT
- xenocratus 6y agoIt was the same when the transition period started, guess it shows where the balance stood
- tpmx 6y agoWell, I think the UK got a fantastic deal in the end. (I'm Swedish.)
- spzb 6y agoNot as good as we had before. It’s the only trade deal negotiated with the explicitly stated intention of having fewer benefits than before.
- tpmx 6y agoYou got access to the EU's internal market without tariffs (except for financial services). The EU key people stated for a very long time - access to the internal EU market cannot be decoupled from the free movement of people. But still, you won that. All because you gave access to french fishers to some fishing waters. I think this bribe to one of the EU partners has been the key impetus for a lot of renewed EU resistance in Sweden. As an example: After reading the terms of the deal, lots of Swedes in r/svenskpolitik ("swedish politics") actually wanted the same exit deal. I kind of agree.
- spzb 6y agoWhich is less than we had before. Also we now have non tariff barriers including a load more red tape bureaucracy even when sending things from one part of the U.K. to another thanks to the Irish Sea border
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoDidn't this happen 31st of January 2020 ? That's what wikipedia says.
- lylo 6y agoThere was a transition period through to 31 Dec 2020. That has now ended. Happy new year. :’(
- vesinisa 6y agoYup, it's the end of the transition period. But UK formally left EU 11 months ago. Unless of course the term "formally" has come to suffer similar inflation and inversion as the term "literally".
- xenocratus 6y agoI think it's confusing to some because not much changed until this transition period actually ended, so for the casual folk Brexit only just happened
- matthewmacleod 6y agoThis is technically correct - however, there were few practical changes until the end of the transition period today, and the relationship was essentially equivalent. Today is really where the relationship changes in a practical sense.
- rsynnott 6y agoDe jure, yes. However, in practice the UK remained subject to EU law and retained freedom of movement and single market access at that point. De facto, Brexit happened 90 minutes ago (I am amazed that the Tories didn’t get more upset about the fact that it the appointed hour was midnight CET, not GMT).
- dingaling 6y agoYes, and it began on 1 November 1993 when the Maastricht Treaty took effect and created the EU. But 26 years sounds less dramatic than 48.
- crx07 6y agoSuch a waste.
- vizzier 6y agoMight not be all bad if we get CANZUK out of it. Here's hoping.
- hawkice 6y agoArguably the best country name trade deal abbreviation since renegotiating NAFTA to CAMUS (I know they use a different order but this suggestion is too good).
- shirro 6y agoExcept the ex-colonies want nothing to do with the UK. We can smell the fear and desperation. There is nothing in it for us. We aren't going to bail out the UK or take the influx of economic refugees.
- adventured 6y ago> Except the ex-colonies want nothing to do with the UK. That's a wild exaggeration. The UK is a tremendous export market for the US, we want everything to do with them, there is a lot in it for us ($700 billion per decade in purchased goods). Plus we have a rough split on trade, one of the few major nations we don't have a large trade deficit with. The British import more US goods than the Germans do, and nearly as much as the Japanese do, with a far smaller economy.
- hnracer 6y ago.
- McDyver 6y agoIt seems that the UK will still have to abide by EU rules in order to trade with the rest of the Union. Based on laws they will have absolutely no say in.
- echelon 6y agoExactly what China and Russia want. This weakens the UK and the EU. We should be coming together, not fracturing into scared, nationalistic islands.
- mhh__ 6y ago> Russia want In writing, even, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foundations_of_Geopolitics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foundations_of_Geopolitics
- vesinisa 6y agoFair to call EU big, global and bureaucratic. But with 24 working languages, 27 represented states and 8 official political parties isn't it pretty much the opposite of homogeneous?
- string 6y agoDepends how you look at it. The European Parliament is ethnically pretty homogeneous, for example. The figures are hard to come by because the EU don't record ethnicity AFAIK, but in 2017 there were approximately 17 non-white MEPs out of a total 751. I think 8 of those were from the UK. Given the amount of times I've been called racist for voting to leave the EU, I always find that figure quite hilarious.
- boudin 6y agoNow it's time for uk politicians to find the new scapegoat for their impressive incompetence. Here's for a stupid and xenophobic clown, a decade of ugly politics and the struggle of people hopes that, unfortunatly, will still be unanswered... Now let's hope that the rock bottom that tories just hit will be the opportunity for people witb ideas and human values to step up.
- anonunivgrad 6y agoA great day for the UK, able to now chart their own path instead of obediently marching along to the neoliberal EU apparatus. The big question is whether they will do anything worthwhile with their newfound freedom.
- fwsgonzo 6y agoRemain high on the inequality index, I assume. The UK got destroyed by Thatcher, and hasn't recovered since. > “She destroyed too many good things in society, and created too many bad ones, then left a social and moral vacuum in which the selfishly rich and unimaginatively fortunate could too easily destroy still more of what they don't need and can't see that everyone else does need,” said author Emma Darwin. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/margaret-thatcher-worst-prime-minister-pm-david-cameron-century-100-years-a7367481.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/margaret-that... https://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/scale-economic-inequality-uk https://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/scale-economic-inequality-u...
- fnord77 6y agowow, considered worse than Neville Chamberlain
- anonunivgrad 6y agoThatcher wasn’t perfect, but England was an economic basket case before her premiership. Visceral Thatcher hate is a meme for nonthinking people. The great irony is that one of the most significant effects of the EU has been to replicate many of her reforms across the continent. But the europhiles still reflexively hate her. And why should I or anyone else care about what a fiction author thinks?
- dmje 6y agoYay. Now we're free. Oh wait, no, it's just that absolutely everything got harder, more expensive, more nationalistic, more pathetic and sad. It's all incredibly depressing. Here's hoping our kids manage to vote us back in as soon as those Tory f's are out.
- throwaway3699 6y agoLabour were decimated in the last election. I don't suspect they'll be in power with a mandate to rejoin the EU. Btw, things aren't as split down party lines as they may seem. Half the Tory party are Europhiles, and I know many of my Labour friends are anti-EU in a libertarian small government sense.
- albertgoeswoof 6y agoIndeed, trade deals and international relationships are bipartisan issues, labour’s last leader was anti EU for decades. The party lines in the UK are drawn along class and aspirational values, not policy decisions- although when a referendum is called 2 sides always step out to divide up the electorate in their favour
- dmje 6y agoAgree. I'd always argue that this was broadly an anti austerity / inequality vote: people just basically pissed off with having a rubbish life voting against some notion of "authority" or "centralisation". The sad fact is that it's exactly these people (in the Midlands, NE, those on lower wages, in rural communities, etc) who (generalising a bit, not much) voted out - these are the communities who will be hit hardest.
- mjburgess 6y agoI think this analysis has been shown to be false. This does not apply to significant majority of leavers. It explains a minor boost on the left, not main leaver sentiment.
- 6y ago
- Symbiote 6y agoPlease look after our star [1]. I hope we get it back in the not too distant future. [1] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/brexit-latest-eu-chief-guy-verhofstadt-veterans-a4350856.html https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/brexit-latest-eu-chief-gu... (I donated to fund the projection.)
- dmje 6y agoAww, that's nice :-)
- crx07 6y agoEven as an American with no stake in the UK, this departure saddens me after how hard my family fought in Europe in defense of stability in that region. The best thing that can come of this is that the UK promptly rejoins and everyone tries to put this indiscretion in the past. But even assuming they do rejoin, this tantrum has still significantly increased the risk of a massive conflict for probably a century or longer -- any hell-bent ideological maniac in any member state can now effectively use Brexit as a populist rallying cry that might actually work. (And most certainly, states with minority viewpoints will use it as leverage against the majority for an untold length of time.)
- hedora 6y agoIf they decide to rejoin at some point, perhaps the EU could demand elimination of the pound.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- albertgoeswoof 6y agoI don’t think that would get even 5% of the vote in the UK
- throwaway35345 6y agoOut of spite? Why is that what you think the EU is like?
- ceejayoz 6y agoOut of “you already used up your special treatment last time around”?
- Symbiote 6y agoMuch more important is democratic reform. No more unelected religious leaders in Parliament, no more unelected upper house at all, and a replacement for FPTP for the Commons. However, I don't think the Copenhagen Criteria are this specific.
- Veen 6y agoWhy don’t you demand the abolition of the monarchy while you’re at it? This sort of talk delights Brexiteers because all but a tiny number of hardcore pro-EU zealots will respond with a raised middle finger.
- mtmail 6y agoPlenty (8 of 27) of EU countries don't use the Euro. Denmark, Sweden, Norway for example.
- seibelj 6y agoThis could be very bad or it could be very good. The chains of EU centralized bureaucracy are off, now the UK can chart their own destiny (hopefully for the better).
- hndudette 6y agoThe chains are still on because the UK still needs to trade with said bureaucracy, and of course the fault of that lies with the EU's bureaucratic nature itself instead of the UK's decision to exit. Ultimately we should want the EU to be eliminated entirely and replaced with a multilateral free trade treaty, and UK's exit is a very productive step in that direction.
- riffraff 6y agoHow does that multilateral free trade treaty works? You'd still need the same bureaucracy compiling the norms, except instead of doing it once for 27 countries you'd do it 27 times. See how long it took to create other agreements like the EU/Japan, EU/Canada and failed EU/US.
- spzb 6y agoWe have plenty of our own bureaucracy. We basically invented it.
- galvin 6y agoCould you describe those chains? Specifically, which EU regulations have been holding the UK back?
- rsynnott 6y agoThe (wholly imaginary) one mandating red passports, I assume. The whole ‘sovereignty’ argument was always highly symbolic, and not very interested in specifics.
- Someone 6y ago…and Gibraltar will enter the Schengen zone, abolishing all border controls on its border with Spain (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-55497084 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-55497084) Once that comes into effect, the Spanish/Gibraltarian police will be allowed to enter Gibraltar/Spain when in hot pursuit and to continue observation operations (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area#Police_and_judicial_co-operation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area#Police_and_judic...)
- onecommentman 6y agoWhen will similar restrictions be removed for Moroccan police?
- lemonspat 6y agoIs Morocco in the EU or schengen? I expect those are the prerequisites
- Beldin 6y agoNot all border control: non-Gibraltar UK citizens will still have to show passports at the Gibraltar-Spanish border.
- Someone 6y agoAre you sure? I think they will have to show their passport when entering Gibraltar from outside the Schengen area, not when crossing the Spain-Gibraltar border (the BBC page I linked to says they already have to show it now, so that won’t change) How would that even work, a border where some persons have to identify themselves while others can cross freely? That would catch only the truly stupid criminals. (But what do I know? Reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area makes my head go dizzy with all the exceptions. You can sort-of sneak into the Schengen area via Svalbard or the Faroe islands, for example, so some holes needed to be closed there) Such a system only work when everybody already has to show ID, as is the case when traveling by boat or plane to and from the parts of Spain in Africa (that’s a security check, not a border check. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area#Air_travel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area#Air_travel)
- albertgoeswoof 6y agoIs it really that big of a deal? Was it worth years of discussion and one upmanship from both sides of the debate. It’s a bit annoying, but the UK could emerge stronger or weaker from the whole situation. One thing’s for sure, I wish we spent the last 4 years preparing for a 2020 scenario instead.
- dabeeeenster 6y ago"it's a bit annoying". WTF?
- gambiting 6y agoIt's a synonym for "it doesn't impact me in my life so I don't care, and people who are affected by it should just shut up"
- alblue 6y agoTime to emigrate from the U.K. to a more enlightened country. What countries would you go to as an English expat for a better life? Where can you change a useless English citizenship for another?
- throwaway35345 6y agoIf you literally think your UK citizenship (no such thing as English citizenship) is useless you can renounce it right now if you want to? I guess you won't? So maybe it isn't useless? Ignorant.
- rvz 6y agoSealand? [0] [0] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/10/08/will-happen-sealand-worlds-smallest-micronation-brexit/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/10/08/will-happen-seal...
- jnky 6y agoWouldn't Ireland be your best bet? It's close, English-speaking, culturally similar and some UK citizens are eligible for Irish citizens to boot.
- rsynnott 6y agoYou can go to Ireland, via the CTA. Live here five years, fill out a very long form, wait an indeterminate time for the form to be processed, and you have an EU citizenship again!(You can keep the UK one, too; dual Irish/UK citizenships are permissible and common). Also, check for any Irish or Italian grandparents; you may already have won an exciting new citizenship!
- matthewmacleod 6y agoLittle to celebrate here. The main outcome is that it’s now going to be much more of a pain in the arse to perform lots of basic functions that we took for granted. There is now a bunch more red tape involved involved in buying or selling goods or services to other European counties. It’s harder and more expensive to move for work or education, both to and from the UK. The UK now has a customs border inside it’s own territory (which is fairly mad in itself). We end up trapped in the wake of the EU with far less influence on what that environment looks like. It’s not the end of the world, but it’s hard to find many positive opportunities that arise from it.
- hndudette 6y agoWouldn't it be better to replace the EU with an expansive multilateral free trade treaty that encompasses the same states? Why do we need an additional layer of government?
- matthewmacleod 6y agoHard to answer that without defining what “better” means. It’s not clear what difference you would imagine between “an expansive multilateral free trade treaty” and the EU as it stands. The European single market is essentially the largest international free trade agreement, going far further and deeper than any other by eliminating as many barriers to both trade and individual freedom between states. In order to support that and provide a level playing field, there needs to be common set of rules on things like regulation, worker’s rights, state funding of industry and so on. And in order to administer those, you need a level of bureaucracy. Quite quickly, you’ll find you’ve recreated the EU. It’s totally reasonable to argue for the EU to take a particular direction - like closer integration, or more distant cooperation, or less bureaucracy or whatever. But the arguments in the Brexit case in particular often seem to fall apart on interrogation of the details.
- hndudette2 6y agoEU's stated objectives go far beyond just facilitating free trade, with most of their budget allocated to unrelated projects and goals. To the extent that the EU does facilitate free trade, which is indeed one of its goals, I have no objection, but I believe we can do away with a huge amount of big government/globalist excess and just go for an explicit multilateral FTA with as little bureaucratic overhead as necessary to enact such a treaty. That would look distinctly different to the extant EU.
- person_of_color 6y agoThis will prove to be the worst geopolitical decision of all time.
- mhh__ 6y agoThat's harsh (I would rate the failure of the Russian experiment after '91 as worse), but it's certainly the worst thing we've done since Suez. David Cameron - what a legacy!
- Fifer82 6y agoAs a Scotsman, this is a sad day. My only hope is that we leave the Union and that Ireland can work out it's differences and pursue reunification. There is nothing else left for it. A tragic time to be British and nothing to celebrate here.
- Veen 6y agoAs an Englishman, I'm entirely in favor of Scottish independence. It would save us a considerable amount of money.
- cm2187 6y agoAnd griefs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cycrutchfield 6y agoVery interesting that you would be willing to make yourself into yet an even weaker entity. What a tragic and utterly preventable denouement for a once proud empire.
- Veen 6y agoI'm curious in what way you think rump-UK would be weaker without Scotland? Economically it would be fine: England is by far the biggest economy in the UK. There would be some losses: about 10 percent of the UK GDP, Scottish military bases, natural gas and oil resources, about 5 million people. But Scotland produces only about 6 percent of the UK's total exports. The vast majority of what it produces is "exported" to England, Wales, and Northern Ireland (about £50 billion to the UK compared to £15 billion to the EU and £17 billion to the rest of the world). It also has a fiscal deficit that's largely offset by the English taxpayer. Scotland is much more economically dependent on the UK than the UK is on Scotland. Outside of the UK, Scotland may be a credible middle-ranking small country comparable to Czechia. It certainly could not afford to maintain its current level of public services. Without Scotland, the rest of the UK would remain one of the largest economies in the world. (btw, Scotland was never an Imperial possession of British Empire. The Union with Scotland was peaceful, and largely in the interests of the Scots, who had succeeded in destroying their economy through mismanagement, unwise allegiances with the French, and unsuccessful attempts to build their own empire).
- LatteLazy 6y agoSuch a waste. A once great nation dragged into obscurity by OAPs, handout addicted farmers and racists.
- rhexs 6y agoNot wanting to be in the EU makes you a racist how exactly? Are we using the word “racist” in the same way as it was applied in the last four years in America?
- noncoml 6y agoI visit UK often because of family ties. The most frequent answer I get when I ask people why they voted to leave is that foreigners come over and take their jobs and put a strain on NHS, vaguely referencing the influx of Polish immigrants they got when Poland entered the EU. So maybe not racists, but xenophobes for sure.
- rhexs 6y agoDoes wanting one’s own country to focus on its citizens first make one a xenophobe?
- Sebguer 6y agoYes, nationalism and xenophobia go hand in hand.
- runarberg 6y agoShort answer yes. EDIT longer answer: You live in a society of people, the people that you interact with daily are people just like you. Some of them might be immigrants and some of them might have a foreign citizenship. That does not make them any lesser. They pay taxes to the same government as you, they abide by the same rules as you. If they brake the law, they have to answer for it just like you. The only reason I can think of why they shouldn’t accept the same benefits from your government as you is xenophobia.
- miltondts 6y agoOur civilization is about to face its darkest hour. We need everyone working together, not just in the EU. Instead this type of isolationist response seems to be what we are going for, not just in the UK but the US and other places. Very sad that we don't seem to have learned much form the history of the civilizations that came before us.
- onecommentman 6y agoPlease support your first assertion with a comparison of the quality of life of humans on the planet, decade by decade, starting with whatever date you think you civilization started, and the changes you project for yourself in the “darkest hour” and how they compare...
- orev 6y agoThe entire history since civilization started has been leading us to this point — climate change. Ever since fire was tamed (arguably defining the beginning of civilization), the emission of greenhouse gasses has been leading us here. And we have known it for decades, if not longer. Now it’s here, and this is the fight we need to be united for; not some trite idea of “quality of life”. This is about the whole of human survival.
- atc 6y agoWhy does the UK need political union with the EU to achieve that?
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoIt will be "interesting" to see the economic effects of the one-two punch of Covid + Brexit.
- w_t_payne 6y agoBrexit was a triumph of evil men. We were foolish and naive, and did not expect these craven lies to have such dire effect. This tidal wave of pent up hatred unleashed from these deep and forgotten pools of animus and fear. Nonetheless -- the world keeps on turning. Evil may win a battle here and there, but it cannot be allowed to win the war. What these vandals destroy can always be built up anew.
- onecommentman 6y agoA little...overwrought? That’s how Eurasia got the Crusades, you know. Operation Barbarossa used similar language. Poetry is a poor platform on which to base actions that affect international relations. Leads to goose stepping and such..
- w_t_payne 6y agoNonetheless, Brexit was undeniably evil, and evil must be fought.
- paul_f 6y agoLOL. Was this satire?
- prof-dr-ir 6y agoA sad day indeed, and - as predicted widely - there is not a substantial upside to Brexit in sight. Following UK politics, it is hard to avoid the conclusion that the country is being held hostage by a Conservative (and Unionist, hah) party: past governments have been singularly focused on keeping the party in power and the country be damned. But this is not all: I think Brexit could have been much less destructive if it were not for the remarkable incompetence of and rash decision making of the last few governments. It has been fascinating to see a country play its hand so immensely badly, even more so because the hand did not even need to be played.
- monoideism 6y agoI'm amazed at reading British HNers who are presumably mostly rational calling Brexit "evil" and "racist" on this thread. I personally think Brexit is probably an ill-advised move for the UK, but the feelings provoked here by leaving a historically recent trade and cultural union are far, far out of proportion with the deed itself. If anything actually destroys your country, it'll be the exaggerated emotional response shown by each of the two sides in this debate.
- goodhacker 6y agoThe only sensible comment here
- tpmx 6y agoYou're writing to people who have been fed The Guardian propaganda for years. It's now equivalent to Fox News in its levels of absurd toxicity. It used to be pretty damned good, just 10-15 years ago. I think the monetization rush made it go toxic/extremely one-sided. From the outside it looks like a series of A/B monetization experiments gone horribly wrong. They have essentially gone all in on writing pieces that resonate well with a particular demographic. No other kind of journalism seems to be interesting or relevant.
- hndudette 6y agoJust compare the economic growth per capita of Norway (not in EU) with Sweden (in EU). It's at best an exaggeration that leaving the EU is going to have a significant deleterious impact on the UK.
- monoideism 6y agoIn the long run, it may not make much difference, but I suspect there will be an economically rough transition. But honestly, I’m not an economist and haven’t read a great deal about the projections. And many Brits will accept any difficulties in exchange for increased control over their own political destiny.
- smnrchrds 6y agoNorway is in EEA. For most (all?) economic purposes, being in EU, EEA, and Switzerland is equivalent. The same rules, procedures, responsibilities, and privileges apply whether the country is a member of EU or EEA.
- Proven 6y agoBrexit is best major event in recent history of Europe. Not only are almost all Brits now better off, but Brexit shows that Brussels has an extremely weak negotiating position. Why? Because they don't create anything, they plunder, add debt and regulations. Now we know anyone can leave the EU and be better off.
- onecommentman 6y agoWhat puzzles me the most about Brexit is reflected in the more...effusive...posts here as well. The overheated rhetoric and amazing one-sidedness of the discussion in the online media. Way over the top if you just step into the discussion as an objective observer. It’s been only 48 years, they are all supposedly mature democracies, what is the big deal? I could only think of two excuses: * some powerful entities had made some very big bets in the derivatives market tied to this and it was worth anything to not lose on those trades. Who knows, but seems extreme even for those sorts. * there is some deep existential reason that UK’s membership was key to the EU enterprise. The only thing I, as an outsider, could conjecture on the second point was the UK provided “karmic cover” for Germany (and France) to directly control the other EU member Nations. In the media, Merkel’s statements were seemingly taken as the de facto EU position. Macron made an out-of-band agreement with Merkel, that made no sense if the EU was their platform for interaction. From an outsider perspective it seemed that Germany was running the show. But remember Napoleon? Remember the Kaiser? Remember Kaiser 2.0 (Hitler)? But then remember the UK...they didn’t try a “Deutschland over all of us” or a Napoleonic union at the point of a bayonet. They comported themselves rather well. So the EU really isn’t Germany finally winning WWII if the UK...hey wait, UK, where are you going? That might be worth distorting the public debate in the UK over... Purely an ignorant outsider’s take.
- w_t_payne 6y agoThe true nature of all of this can be seen quite clearly in the fundamentally xenophobic, dishonest and hateful manner with which the Leave campaign comported itself, as well as the tidal wave of racist and intolerant behaviour which accompanied the Brexit vote and stains everything to do with it. There are solid reasons why Brexit is the darling of the resurgent neofascist movement, and it should all be seen as part of the same picture.
- thelastinuit 6y ago“Laß dir Alles geschehn: Schönheit und Schrecken. Man muß nur gehen: Kein Gefühl ist das fernste.”
- ben_w 6y agoI don’t understand the quote. What’s the context?