4 ms·
BTC prices have approximately zero relation to inflation in the real economy (for whatever definition of that you want to use). Rising BTC prices are driven by
by loeg 6y ago
BTC prices have approximately zero relation to inflation in the real economy (for whatever definition of that you want to use). Rising BTC prices are driven by pyramid scams, fraud, and speculation. There is no useful signal here related to anything else.
- doggosphere 6y agoBTC prices have been driven by institutional demand and federal monetary policy.
- vulpesx2 6y agoI've seen sources to corroborate institutional demand, but is there a source for your claim on the link to federal monetary policy? Ideally beyond correlation to show causation.
- doggosphere 6y agoI don’t, but it is one of the core reasons why Bitcoin is attractive to anyone. Asset prices are up across the board.
- aent 6y agoOr 21 billion fake tether dollars.
- opendomain 6y agoI have serious questions about tether. As far as I know, they have not proven they even have 1 billion on reserve. How can they claim 21 billion? Is this pyramid scheme the real reason bitcoin prices are so high?
- tanseydavid 6y agoDo you believe that speculative activity is not related in any way to inflation or expectations of inflation?
- brianobush 6y agoIs there a useful signal in the dollar price? Price of silver? They are all used in hedging bets. Same for BTC, people with a lot of cash are looking for a safe spot while we have the possibility of hyper inflation.
- pjlegato 6y agoThe entire BTC market cap is minuscule -- about 600bn as of this writing. That seems like a lot, but compare it to Apple -- the market cap of just this one company's stock is currently ~2,238bn. The market cap of gold, US dollars, Euros, etc. are all many times more than Apple. The value of all BTC is a tiny microscopic speck compared to the amount of USD or gold in the world. This means (among other things) a few small players (with tiny capital relative to, say, the size of all USD) can swing the BTC market either way with a comparatively tiny amount of value moving around. That would seem to greatly limit BTC's usefulness as any kind of inflation gauge for the broader economy.
- pojzon 6y agoTo give an another view: 600bn is more than gdp of majority of countries.
- pjlegato 6y agoCorrect, and those countries' economies also give us little to no signal about US dollar inflation. The proposition was that BTC prices somehow inform us about that.
- fernmyth 6y agoMarket cap is a stock. GDP is a flow. Comparing the two is nonsense.
- imtringued 6y agoGDP is income. What you are doing is the equivalent of comparing your mortgage payment with the price of the house when you bought it.
- sunshinerag 6y ago(or) you are wrong and there are some people who see asset inflation caused by stupid governments printing for everything and moving away wealth from these systems into Bitcoin.
- spelunker 6y agoIMO BTC's relation to inflation in the real economy is the same as any alternative investment like gold - it's usage as a "safe haven".
- vulturalcptlst 6y agoPonzi schemes give an INCOME RETURN Bitcoin gives a PRICE APPRECIATION RETURN One could call this then a “greater fool” play except it has algorithmic reduction in supply which repairs “greater fool” aspect.
- imtringued 6y agoIf the limited supply was the only thing bitcoin had going for it then it would merely perform exactly like gold but it is over performing which means there is an additional irrational component driving bubbles and busts.
- rossjudson 6y agoI guess "I want to invest in crime, but I don't want to have to do crime to invest in it" falls under speculation.
- DeafSquid 6y agoIf I wanted to invest in crime I'd buy bank stocks and US bonds.
- imtringued 6y agoIn theory the USD price of bitcoin is tracking the inflation of the USD but with excessive volatility. However, it is possible for it to grow slightly faster than inflation if a significant portion of the central bank money is arriving in cryptocurrencies. In practice it's getting dwarfed by the factors you mentioned. Lots of irrational investors are pumping BTC until it crashes. Over the long term (several decades) you can expect it to perform like gold once it has turned into a mature market.
- cool_dude85 6y agoSorry, the USD price of bitcoin is tracking the inflation of USD in theory? What theory's that?