13 ms·
Bug drone for UK army that weights 196g, has 40 mins autonomy and 2km range
- intricatedetail 6y agoDo you think they built custom batteries or got something off the shelf? If off the shelf which pack do you think it is?
- KamiCrit 6y agoPicture looks like two 18650's or the likes of.
- chillax 6y agoSee also: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Hornet_Nano https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Hornet_Nano
- Daniel_sk 6y ago"Although the Army is seeking a mini-drone for use by individual squads through the Soldier Borne Sensors (SBS) program, the individually handmade Black Hornet is seen as too expensive for large-scale deployment, with a unit costing as much as US$195,000"
- epicureanideal 6y agoBut just the fact that this exists at any price means that it will eventually become ubiquitous, unless something even smaller and more capable takes its place. That price was in 2016, so who knows if it's already down to $100k or below. In 10-20 years, these things will be priced like laptops and be far more capable than the current models.
- chillax 6y agoThey've probably trimmed the price somewhat since 2016: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/26359/the-pocket-sized-black-hornet-drone-is-about-to-change-army-operations-forever https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/26359/the-pocket-sized...
- dimatura 6y agoThat is the cutest drone! I have one of these https://www.eachine.com/EACHINE-E10W-Mini-Quadcopter-Wifi-FPV-With-720P-Camera-2_4G-4CH-6-Axis-LED-RC-Nano-Quadcopter-Drone-Mode-2-p-310.html https://www.eachine.com/EACHINE-E10W-Mini-Quadcopter-Wifi-FP..., which is roughly the same size. It has a functional camera which records to a micro SD card. The image quality is crap, but you can't expect much at $29.
- throwaway4good 6y agoReminds me of the DJI Mavic Mini. How much does it cost?
- grecy 6y agoI have the Mavic Mini 1. It weighs 249g (which is 27% more than this drone). It also realistically only flies for about 15-20 minutes before needing a recharge, which is half as much as this drone. So while similar to the Mavic Mini, I think it's clear they're not in the same league.
- ortusdux 6y agoNote that the cutoff for some regulations in the US is 250g. https://fpvfc.org/sub-250g-regulations https://fpvfc.org/sub-250g-regulations
- throwaway4good 6y agoThey are probably also not in the same price range.
- laptop-man 6y agofor 199 you can get https://www.racedayquads.com/collections/all-pre-built-quads-wings/products/flywoo-bnf-hexplorer-lr-4-micro-long-range-quad-choose-your-rx https://www.racedayquads.com/collections/all-pre-built-quads... close to 1 to 2 mile range (depending on obstructions) 30 min battery as long as your not freestyleing lol. (assuming you have everything else for it. a decent starter set up is close to 200/300 dollars but is compatable with any drone you can stick a rx in)
- grecy 6y agoNo camera, and no camera mount included So once you do, you blow past the 250g limit, and it's in a different class.
- laptop-man 6y ago
- dfsegoat 6y ago> "It was the only nano-UAV able to cope with the uncompromising weather during a recent Army Warfighting Experiment (AWE) event" I hadn't thought too much about how UAVs of any class will need to cope with adverse weather conditions. Seems like that will become an even larger variable in military planning, as UAVs etc. become more prevalent. E.g. it might be hard to totally replace a manned surveillance platform with an unmanned system, if the manned system is 'all-weather capable' and the unmanned is not.
- PeterisP 6y agoThe recent Azerbaijan-Armenia war saw extensive use of UAVs, and yes, weather (e.g. fog in the mountains or the lack of it) was an important factor mostly because of its impact on UAV usage.
- bencollier49 6y agoIt feels like they're paying ludicrous money for these. Can someone in the know explain what differentiates these from shop-bought or scratch-built drones? As per this article below, the Nano 1A UAV Quadcopter Bug drone sells for £4,500 (a tenth of the price of another model, the Black Hornet Nano): https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/drone-nano-bug-army-uk-mod-b1779495.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/drone-nano-b... I appreciate that this is probably a variation on the old canard that goes "I could have written that government software in a weekend", but it does seem pricey.
- vinw 6y agoIt's probably because of the low volume. They've only sold 30 so far, and the R&D costs need to be recovered.
- bencollier49 6y agoIf the selling point is stability in a storm, then the differentiation is in software, which is interesting. You'd expect the price of things like this to tumble. One could imagine great dark clouds of these things in battle over perhaps Eastern Europe or the South China Sea in ten years' time.
- ta8645 6y agoAnd roving cities assigning tickets for illegal parking and all manner of other infractions.
- intricatedetail 6y agoMy guess it is built with military grade components which are more expensive and has got embedded emphasis on reliability. That probably includes custom molds that can be insanely expensive for small runs. I can imagine the firmware must conform to a higher standards than consumer grade firmware.
- oceanplexian 6y ago
- realmod 6y agoDrones are integral to current warfare and will continue to become even more important. And as we've seen in the Caucuses, the nations with the most effective drones will easily conquer other countries without or with worse drones. Aside from that, we've come really far with drones which are amazing technology-wise. We have small drones like these with a 2km-range and large drones that can carry huge payloads, i.e. payloads in the tons of kg, while also having ranges in the thousands of kilometres. Although it is remarkable technology-wise, I believe it foreshadows a horrible future for humans that we have such advanced murder weapons. And especially now that drones have become cheap to produce.
- eloff 6y agoCompared to nuclear and biological weapons, drones don't get my pulse up. A future where terrorist groups can produce their own weapons of mass destruction seems like it may well be on the horizon. Through exponential improvements in the underlying technology. Crispr for biology and laser based uranium enrichment for nuclear. I think it's entirely possible that the great filter might be ahead of us and might consist of our own weapons exceeding our ability to manage them responsibly. Happy New Year all!
- newen 6y agoHundreds of thousands of autonomous drone killbots the size of bats flying around do get my pulse up.
- adamnemecek 6y agoCool! Almost makes me forget that BAE Systems defrauded the American public by bribing Michael Chertoff to buy full body scanners from BAE Systems for $3B. Chertoff then joined BAE Systems as a Chairman of the Board. http://www.allgov.com/news/controversies/chertoff-joins-defense-firm-that-defrauded-us?news=840572 http://www.allgov.com/news/controversies/chertoff-joins-defe... https://www.aofs.org/2010/04/12/secretary-michael-chertoff-bae-systems-and-the-whole-body-scanners-affair-3-billion-over-the-next-eight-years/ https://www.aofs.org/2010/04/12/secretary-michael-chertoff-b...
- mattivc 6y agoI work with nano-UAVs. I am very skeptical that the 40 minute flight time is even close to being real. Especially with a quadcopter design. They are way to inefficient.
- jleahy 6y agoThat's because of the energy density (per mass) of Li-Ion batteries. You basically hit a wall at 20 minutes that's very hard to push past (it almost feels like a law of physics). But maybe they're using non-rechargeable batteries: zinc-air or lithium-iron-disulfide (ie. a 'lithium' AA battery) or something else? Trade offs are different for military.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoThe amount of batteries soldiers need to carry is ridiculous; a 72 hour patrol load out includes up to 25 lbs of batteries already!
- jleahy 6y agoYes but there are no convenient charging points, if the battery runs out then you need to replace it, not charge it. All the more reason to throw used batteries away (they’re cheap and it’s less to carry).
- herewulf 6y agoMilitary radio batteries are typically rechargable and they are heavy.
- plouffy 6y agoBased on the info sheet "A quick change battery" would suggest they went for the non-rechargeable route.
- dimatura 6y ago
- the__alchemist 6y agoTwo thought triggered by this article. 1: What alternative designs for quadcopter would be viable for small drones? Some lighter-than-air quality? I assume the complexity involved in making a helicopter collective would be too heavy. Is it really quadcopters all the way down? 2: Why not smaller? Would an even smaller drone be unfeasible due to battery weight and square/cube law issues? What's stopping us from gram-scale drones? Presumably the interaction with the air would create new problems and things to take advantage of.
- andy_ppp 6y agoInteresting idea to fill a drone with helium, then presumably it could have smaller motors or longer flight time.
- jleahy 6y agoOr have wings.
- dkarl 6y agoA drone could be launched with a disposable helium balloon and remain silent until it needed to maneuver. Rotational maneuvers to aim a camera would be brief and quiet compared to hovering. On a calm night you might even be able to get it back quietly.
- krimpenrik 6y agoWent down this rabbit hole once, you'll need too much helium volume to make any difference.
- dimatura 6y agoThere's plenty of multirotor VTOL drone designs out there, which combine the practicality of vertical take-off and landing (hence, "VTOL") with the greater efficiency of wings for longer range flight. Many proof-of-concept delivery drones I've seen are of this kind. re: size, you can definitely make smaller drones. There's plenty of cute and surprisingly flyable drones out there that are less than 6 cm in diameter, some even with cameras. However, there's a few drawbacks at smaller sizes: - Less power. They can fly fine indoors, but they'll be swept away by any strong winds. - Less space for electronics/camera and batteries, so image quality and flight time will suffer.
- KamiCrit 6y agoI wonder if battlefields of the future will feature kamikaze bug drones.
- pjmlp 6y agoThey already feature missile carrying ones.
- btbuildem 6y agoHaving played a little with micro-drones as a hobbyist, the ability to have an "eye in the sky" is amazing. Just today, we got a little turned around on a hike -- in less than a minute I was able to see our location from above and which direction to bushwhack a shortcut back to the main trail. I can see how this would be invaluable in a "strategic" situation. Even the tiny ones are noisy and give away their position immediately. The effective range is relatively short, so you know if there's a drone, the operator is nearby. Weather is a limiting factor -- winds will tax the battery, and rain or wet snow will effectively disable them. I wonder what counter-methods will be used against drones in the field. Really accurate markspeople? Portable EMPs? From what I've read, around airports etc they've been experimenting with enforcing no-fly zones with birds of prey!
- regularfry 6y agoI'd take a shotgun over a marksman. Buckshot is designed for objects in this size range.
- colonwqbang 6y agoBuckshot is designed for killing "medium to large game" like... bucks. Maybe you mean birdshot?
- regularfry 6y agoErm... Yes. Slip of the brain.
- pjmlp 6y agoTrained eagles and hawks are already used to keep airports and shopping malls safe from unwanted birds anyway, so it just yet another target to deal with.
- neom 6y agoI'd be super curious to know how loud they are, main problem I see with drones being stealthy is they also tend to be quite noisy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TedShiller 6y agoAlso provides plastic pollution
- miles 6y agoSpeaking of tiny army drones and Electric Sheep Comix (yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25549042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25549042), I am reminded of Patrick's series The Spiders: https://www.electricsheepcomix.com/spiders/ https://www.electricsheepcomix.com/spiders/
- mNovak 6y agoIs it just me, or does the pictured drone shell look 3d printed? There is for sure money to be made for any (ABCA based) company to sell minorly tweaked clones of popular consumer drones.
- onepointsixC 6y agoYou're not kidding, the outershell looks like it has signs of either tool marks or 3dprinting artifacts.
- tastroder 6y agoThe higher resolution shots on the manufacturer website look more like it's coated with something. https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Bug-Nano-1A-UAV-Quadcopter.png https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Bug-Nano-1A-... https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Bug-Nano-Image-3.png https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Bug-Nano-Ima...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alphadevx 6y agoPretty big "bugs" they have in the UK, judging by that drone:hand ratio in the pic.
- Sideloader 6y agoHmm...from a tech porn perspective it’s a cool little gadget. But given the shadow surveillance and police state that was erected post 9/11 and how often “national security” outfits have been caught playing fast and loose with the laws of the land, there is a good chance that bugs like this one will be eventually be used to illegally spy on domestic dissidents and whistleblowers. Governments in most western countries have thrown out habeas corpus and have given themselves the right to indefinitely ‘disappear’ anyone they arbitrarily deem a threat to national security. Julian Assange and Edward Snowden come to mind. I wouldn’t trust governments and intelligence services in the post-democratic west with this technology any more than I’d trust their counterparts in “classic” totalitarian states.
- XorNot 6y agoThis is just ridiculous. Why if you were going to illegally spy on people would you use a highly visible and noisy drone when the vast majority of the population live in urban areas where CCTV cameras are common and phone lines conveniently run out to steel covers in the streets (and the entire population is carrying GPS enabled tracking devices full of security flaws?) There's "oh no our liberties" but that train came and went and this particular device has nothing to do with it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 6y agoIt's not either-or.
- thom 6y agoI'm not overly worried by what the government plans to do with this tech, more than any other tech they use for nefarious purposes. I _am_ worried by the endgame of publicly available drone tech though, because it's very difficult to see how technically or legislatively we can avoid a future with tiny untraceable drones with long battery lives, that record audio and video and can go anywhere. The arms race that is going to be necessary to secure your home and workplace against these is going to be very expensive and ugly, and many people are going to have to settle with every conversation and sexual encounter they have being in public, if only for the lulz. Privacy, like the fight against piracy, isn't going to be defeated because it's desirable or not, but rather just because the technology and temptation is inevitable.
- DenisM 6y agoI’ve been meaning to procure a drone to scout best trails before hiking them, and DJI mini 2 seem ideal for the purpose. All I need now is a phone app that would make it easy to browse the tiles shot by the drone (rather than rewind video back and forth). Any suggestions?
- lostlogin 6y agoPlease don’t. I strongly dislike getting buzzed by drones when out in the wild or even just in a park.
- secfirstmd 6y agoSmall point to make but I wonder how things like these are integrated into a typical infantry structure? Are they a section, platoon or company level tool? Do they sit with the platoon commander? Having them with Corporals may make sense though that may be too far forward and lose some benefits plus overload them in contact. At the same time they could be very useful in a number of scenarios. I read somewhere the US Marines are testing adding a systems operator to be beside the Signaller in Platon HQ.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- unicornporn 6y agoBug? More like a bird.
- amitport 6y agoReminds me of Prey by Michael Crichton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prey_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prey_(novel). (from Wikipedia): "The novel serves as a cautionary tale about developments in science and technology; in this case, nanotechnology, genetic engineering, and distributed artificial intelligence." Autonomous flying drone army you say? what could possibly go wrong?
- knolax 6y agoAm I the only one that felt a wave of relief when opening the article and seeing that the drone was palm sized and not actually bug sized?
- PicassoCTs 6y agoIntroducing the counter-strike drone. Analysing the streamed data of the surveilance drone, triangulating the source of the control signal and launching a projectile to take it out. Never has been peace & quiet more easy.
- alkonaut 6y agoThese should be autonomous and able to do surveillance of an area by pre-programmed routes or loitering. Most transmission will be from the drone to the operator in that case. If you intend to do active control, you should be ready to move since your position is exposed. The more autonomous the drone is, the less transmission you'll need. If you are looking for a specific type of vehicle for example, it should be easy to have the drone do it autonomously and not even transmit anything itself until it finds it (and possibly never - it could keep the footage until it returns to the operator). A drone (or a dozen of them) asked to find enemy armor within a map area with zero commincation either to or from the drone would be extremely difficult to hide from. This is a capability that has existed for years with large drones or satellites but they have been expensive, limited use in bad weather, and most importantly not available to individual soldiers on the ground without needing to coordinate that support. > launching a projectile to take it out The problem with anti-drone weapons is that so long as the projectile is heavier/larger/more expensive than the drone, the drone is winning even when taken out. It's an active area of research but other than another drone, the only viable BVR counter-drone I have seen so far is a trained bird...
- tleb_ 6y agoI have searched around a bit, but could not recognize the motors. Here is the best picture available, in which we can clearly see graphical content that would only be on commercial motors[0]. One of the other drone made by the same company uses Align motors[1], taken from a picture[2]. Those are however not used for this bug drone. [0]: https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Bug-Nano-Image-3.png https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Bug-Nano-Ima... [1]: http://www.align.com.tw/en/ http://www.align.com.tw/en/ [2]: https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/hex-Mini-1C-Hexacopter-Multirotor.png https://uavtek.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/hex-Mini-1C-...
- notretarded 6y agohttps://de.amaxshop.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=526 https://de.amaxshop.com/index.php?route=product/product&prod... Nothing special.
- tleb_ 6y agoThanks. It seems to be the 2550kv version. Here are some numbers about it[0]. It might hover at idle if I read this correctly. I don't see how they do it at 196g though. 4 * 31.6 + 2 * 47.5 = 221.4g, with 47.5g being the weight of one 18650, as this is what seems to be inside (weight of a Sony VTC6 taken from [0]). The energy density would have to be a lot better than this, I don't know a thing about non-rechargeable batteries as suggested by others in this thread. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2v1QLmhNxM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2v1QLmhNxM
- zed88 6y agoThe last thing we need in the world messed up by Covid and the military industrial complex is more war machines and normalisation of meaningless wars (all of which have an undertone of neo-colonialism, where we use buzzwords to justify our acts by painting the other side as less of a human). We could use the technology though, in solving real problems.
- spiritplumber 6y agoPretty impressive, I got 30min in 2015. Nobody at the time wanted to buy it though. Do people want to see the video?