14 ms·
Somewhat Tangential: Without any instruction my 2 and 4 year olds know how to turn things into weapons to beat each other with. Like puppies they seem to be tes
by Waterluvian 6y ago
Somewhat Tangential: Without any instruction my 2 and 4 year olds know how to turn things into weapons to beat each other with. Like puppies they seem to be testing limits to rough play.
What surprised me is what happened when I didn't intervene: a few times the older one completely dominated and got his way. But more often than not the older one displayed empathy and tried to apologize and give kisses and give the younger one additional toys.
Maybe this is an unoriginal idea but it bears repeating: I think kids have more ability to self regulate than we typically treat them as having.
- Darmody 6y agoThat's why it's so important to let them play. They end up figuring out a lot of important things by themselves that it would be almost impossible otherwise.
- Waterluvian 6y agoIt's kind of like watching kids invent society. Really quite fascinating to watch.
- thepete2 6y agowho knows, maybe they come up with something better
- Darmody 6y agoI don't know if they are inventing society or they are learning how to act on a society. And what I mean by "how to act on a society" I mean to learn how to interact with others, where are the limits, the consequences of your actions, etc.
- Ensorceled 6y ago> I think kids have more ability to self regulate than we typically treat them as having. This "kids need adult supervision" is a relatively new thing, we used to be sent out to play as kids for HOURS (be home by dinner) and ran the woods and parks or played murderball (soccer with tackling) and other forms of roughhousing, all without serious mayhem. Parents would let us "work it out" if there was a fight.
- dfsegoat 6y agoHaving grown up in the manner you describe, and being a parent of several young kids - I do find the prospect of them having a similar childhood pretty terrifying. I am forever thankful for a childhood like that - but letting my kids run amok in this day and age for hours brings me a lot of anxiety. It is an interesting paradox that makes me a bit sad. edit: for the record, we have them in wrestling / jiu jitsu - so their plate is still full re: physical activity and social interaction.
- sjg007 6y agoWhat makes you anxious about it?
- topkai22 6y agoNot the GP, but for me the answer is "cars." And child services coming after me for being neglectful. And rattlesnakes. But mostly cars. Even with statistics about danger being down across the board, in still pretty worried about my kids getting hit by an automobile. The raw statistics are even one area where danger is rising- fatality numbers are back over the mid 90s.
- colejohnson66 6y ago^ this. You can show someone who’s afraid of flying that it’s the safest form of travel all you want, but you’re not going to convince them. Anxiety usually isn’t rational, so rational means of convincing don’t work.
- phdelightful 6y agoI disagree, I think the main purpose of reason is to overcome negative irrational behavior. Doesn't mean it's easy or automatic though :)
- topkai22 6y agoAny chance you'd like to take a stab at convincing me I shouldn't worry about my (young) kids getting hit by cars? I feel like it's an unfortunately rational anxiety.
- dalben 6y agoYes! Risky play is an essential part of child development, it's how children learn to estimate and handle risk.
- macjohnmcc 6y agoWhen my son was around 4 I was playing GTA and was not playing it violently when I took a car from someone and they tried to pull me out he said "Hit him dad! Hit him!" but never in his life (he is 21 now) has he struck anyone. It was just a game to him.
- Waterluvian 6y agoMy four year old watched me play a Dark Souls boss and just laughed and wanted to try (and get crushed).
- macjohnmcc 6y agoMy son now regularly crushes me in all video games and has for more than 10 years. :)
- bcrosby95 6y agoA week ago I pulled out my warhammer miniatures and my 5 year old picked the leader and started shooting and stabbing people. Then she proudly stated that he was "collecting dead people". I was quite surprised because her normal play involves taking care of her baby dolls.
- jimktrains2 6y agoThe morbidity of children never ceases to amaze me. Death, in play at least, doesn't seem to frighten them. I guess its the same among adults, but it's interesting that make-believe and reality are seperable even at a young age. I don't think we adults give kids enough credit for how sophisticated they can be. (Probably because there are a lot of areas where they aren't and it's easier to just bucket them in whole.)
- emilecantin 6y agoOne thing I (thankfully) realized pretty early on when raising my kids is that they're fully-intelligent humans pretty much from the start. They just dont _know_ stuff, but their intelligence is all there from a much younger age than most people seems to think.
- Shivetya 6y agoIts not unoriginal but it ignores the issue where the professionals and government officials want to interfere. They want you to believe you cannot handle the situation properly so that their existence can be maintained. Sadly there are enough abusive parents and such to keep them in existence to interfere with parents who are otherwise doing just fine
- bcrosby95 6y agoI think it depends on the kid. You just have to rely on the parents judgement. When our oldest was 4 our twins were 1 and she was very abusive towards them. She was trying to make them hurt and upset. At 5, now they mostly get along fine. Unless they get in her toys. Then it's bodyslam time.
- sharkweek 6y agoThank you for saying this, because I’m the parent of a toddler and an infant right now and I swear my only job is trying to keep the older one from hurting the younger one.
- Dumblydorr 6y agoEvolutionary psychology teaches us that mammals play to learn social skills, so you're right on with your assessments.
- primitivesuave 6y agoI think people form stronger ethical boundaries when it is self-motivated - i.e. your 4 year old learns how to be sincerely empathetic because you allowed them to deal with the emotions from rough play, rather than forcing them to play nicely. I used to teach kids for many years, and I noticed the "helicopter parents" tended to have more mischievous children, presumably because these kids rarely feel intrinsically motivated to do anything (it's always coming from the parents).
- giantg2 6y agoI agree. I think this can even be true of adults. Many times I see people make absolute or semi-extreme comments about a topic, but they've never been in the type of situation they are discussing. I think through mistakes as a child, we learn to question our emotional responses/impulses more.
- nelsonenzo 6y agoSome kids have the ability to self regulate more than others. Much of it is just based on their observations of the world and experience within. The problems is that as parents we often just group all kids together in how we treat them. They think it's either one way or the other for all kids rather than treating them as individuals with different experiences and different minds. The one thing I have seen to be true amongst all my peers children is that if you talk to them and treat them like adults, they are much more likely to act like adults at a younger age. That is to say, take into consideration their experience and feelings any time you want to intervene or have an interaction. *not parenting advice, just imho. apply as you see fit.
- MrZongle2 6y agoSome kids, yes. That your children do this I think speaks more to your aptitude as a parent and nurturer than human nature in general.
- Supermancho 6y agoReminded of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=206 https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=206 and less so, more peterson spam, as it were. https://youtu.be/txyGqaeAMbQ?t=27 https://youtu.be/txyGqaeAMbQ?t=27
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoThere was a story recently about a real-life event that started out a lot like the scenario in Lord of the Flies, i. e. a group of children stranded on an island. It turns out their society started looking after their weakest and made decisions based on consent. Meanwhile, the book just confirms everyone's beliefs not only about children but mankind itself, namely of a Hobbesian/Darwinian/Randian rule-of-the-strongest being the natural state of affairs.
- wussboy 6y agoI think Hobbes and Darwin would both object to being grouped in with Rand. Hobbes would say the world is violent therefore we should take measures to protect ourselves (with a neutral external force or Leviathan). Darwin would say that ruthless competition has driven genetic change, but would never say that this ruthless competition was intrinsically good or should be encouraged. Rand, on the other hand, showed casual disregard for human suffering and would glorify in winner take all competition (even though that’s not how societies best organize themselves nor how evolution plays out in the real world where cooperation is usually a winning strategy)
- svara 6y ago"Competition" in the Darwinian context is often understood in a too narrow way anyway. Organisms can become more fit by carving out a specialized niche for themselves where they don't have to compete. Or by becoming more cooperative as a species. The association with ruthless domination of others can be misleading.