13 ms·
Central Bank Digital Currencies Are a Bad Idea
- jstanley 6y ago> the predominant Keynesian narrative is that spending drives the economy (hint: it doesn’t - capital investments do) Without taking a side on the actual point: that's not a hint, that's just you stating what you happen to believe with no argument to back it up. It doesn't convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.
- hummusandsushi 6y agoIt's also smugly dismissive of a particularly mainstream interpretation of the economy for a more obscure one, as if the author is privy to some information that key economists do not have. That said, I would love to see the arguments and evidence in favor of either standpoint if anyone has some useful resources to that effect.
- notahacker 6y agoThe standard argument about the role of demand and credit is quite straightforward: the economy consists of people buying and selling stuff. Capital investment plays a supporting role in ensuring a supply of stuff for sale in future (and in distributing money to buy that stuff with), but people will invest more if they anticipate lots of demand to buy their stuff in future and less if they don't. Both demand and investment keep the economy going, but anticipated future demand is essential to investment. Therefore when demand is low across the whole economy, there is a rationale for govts/central banks either to directly boost demand by spending or indirectly lower the costs of capital investment by lowering interest rates. The evidence for and against the efficacy of certain interventions is basically the entire field of macroeconomics, but Keynes' General Theory is the starting point and something like Woodford's Interest and Prices: Foundations of a Theory of Monetary Policy or most undergrad macroeconomics textbooks more reflective of current practice.
- ianai 6y agoMaybe there’s an argument from which markets move more quickly toward equilibrium. If you push the demand up for a slower part of it then the whole economy might tend to react more quickly than otherwise. Forgetting the specifics though.
- imtringued 6y agoFrom what I can tell there is no absolute rule that one economic theory always applies. You can consider these interpretations to be a collection of tools in a toolbox. Some salesmen try to sell their own tool box set as the best that will solve all your problems when the truth is you must use the right tool for the right problem. For example Austrian economics can be the right tool if you have an economy that is suffering from high inflation. Let's take a look at Greece [0]. Inflation peaked at 6% in 2008. You can call that high but most economies that suffer from the negative effects of inflation have double digit inflation. Inflation fell straight to -2% in 2014. It certainly doesn't look like the type of economy where Austrian economics would be the right tool. However, if you were to use Austrian economics in say Argentina [1] you could certainly speed up the economic recovery. It certainly has a place on earth but not in most first world economies. [0] https://tradingeconomics.com/greece/inflation-cpi https://tradingeconomics.com/greece/inflation-cpi [1] https://tradingeconomics.com/argentina/inflation-cpi https://tradingeconomics.com/argentina/inflation-cpi
- feanaro 6y agoWhat does it even mean to "drive" the economy? I've always thought that's such a vague phrase that can denote a lot of different objective, mathematical concepts, depending on the speaker.
- hestefisk 6y agoI think the author refers to increasing economic activity, employment and consumption. The article is quite poorly written, mostly a range of statements about how Keynes was wrong because I think so. The way out of the COVID crisis has been largely Keynesian for most countries (including the US). Without this boost to counter externalities such as a global pandemic, the impact to unemployment would have been much greater.
- Guthur 6y agoWay too early to say whether or not we've got our way out of covid with Keynesian inspired stimulus packages, and some point we'll all have to pay for those packages whether through taxes or inflation and we'll have to see whether or not the boost to the near term economy will stick. If we find that unemployment does not improve quickly enough coming out of this we could be in for some pretty hairy downward spirals.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Way too early to say whether or not we've got our way out of covid with Keynesian inspired stimulus packages The cheques that were/are issued by the US Congress should not be thought of as stimulus packages (which they are not): they are disaster relief. The economy (or economies, plural, of states considered individually) were put into a coma purposefully for health and safety reasons. It would be paradoxical to 'jump start' the economies when they have been shutdown at the same time. The purpose of the cheques is that help those who cannot work, and draw an income, to pay the rent and purchase food. At least that is the opinion of folks like Ben Bernanke and Paul Krugman. Some people are of course labelling them as "stimulus cheques", but that is incorrect: it is probably undesirable for people to go outside of their homes and try to do 'normal' stuff. At least not until vaccines are rolled out in volume.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoIt's also not really an accurate summary of the Keynesian view, which is a theory about the business cycle, i.e. short-run fluctuations in the economy. Capital investment is important for the long run.
- Retric 6y agoNeither are particularly critical in the long term. Economics is bound by diminishing returns, which dampens extremes. Minimal investment results in extreme returns, where extreme investment results in minimal returns. As returns compound the difference shrinks over time. Really it’s mostly a question of short vs mid term results, in a world of feedback loops either can dominate.
- yourapostasy 6y agoWhat is the role of capital investments in economies that have evolved to a stage where highly impactful cognitive inputs are prized at ever-increasing premiums? SMEE and ASML lithography platforms differ not because one threw more capital investments at it than the other. This singular focus upon capital investments and capital flow (especially when it comes to share buyback machinations) in modern management finance practice reveals a "fight the last war" orientation. Appropriate capital investment table stakes, now. Innovation isn't a machine you put capital investment tokens into until you get a breakthrough.
- loceng 6y agoIsn't the author's statement here moot? Capital investment allows spending - assuming the recipient needs to spend the money; giving $1,000/month UBI to everyone 18+ years of age, you can bet 95%+ of them will spend it, it won't sit in a bank account, and it will lead to an ROI - even if that's personal development or quality of life improvement that will have cascading, lifelong productivity benefits to (including counter counter-productivity). Does this author have vested, financial interest-motive in Bitcoin or other crypto-"currencies" - which centralized digital currencies (legitimately fiat, a better transparent version of)? Edit to add: looks like they likely do, re: a project they list in this site's menu - oh, and in their about me: "Early Bitcoin adopter, now Bitcoin Cash supporter." Would it not have been best practice for the author to list their vested interests as they're writing about a competing product/offering? Imagine if everyone countering the positive narrative (propaganda in part) perpetuated by the "army of HODLers" was financially incentivized to counter that narrative whenever they had a chance, and not only that but proselytized their position, Bitcoin et al would have never reached its position today and many people who bought into the hype - or even killed themselves because of their losses - would have not unnecessarily, unreasonably transferred their wealth to someone else; a true centralized digital currency could take the cash you transfer into the digital currency "out of circulation" instead of giving it to someone, Bitcoin et al similarly structured - the "army of HODLers" are akin to a religion that's financially incentivized - even Fred Wilson - https://avc.com/2019/04/orthodoxy/ https://avc.com/2019/04/orthodoxy/ - stated he dislikes the cult-like behaviour of some in their community, without realizing he's in the community but just taking a priest-like role where he's in a more refined position and better controls his behaviour/image. I am glad higher profile individuals are starting to voice their opposition, dislike of Bitcoin et al - Elon Musk recently tweeting out "Bitcoin is almost as bs as fiat money;" https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1340588909974200321 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1340588909974200321 - fiat currency can shift into a better system supported by immutable, transparent blockchain - but with centralized control so no shenanigans can occur hidden from other allied nations you're trying to fairly balance economies with, arguably who will all be democratically elected governments, democracies. Edit to add: With the growing "army of HODLers" with more vested asset holders waiting for the value of Bitcoin et al to recover and then some - while chanting the mantra "HODL!" - we need to pay attention to counter regulatory capture that this newer industrial complex will work towards.
- imtringued 6y agoThe biggest irony is that this hint contradicts the rest of the article. The author complains about central banks handing out too much money to consumers and doing helicopter money. As far as I know no central bank gives you money to buy consumer goods, they give money to commercial banks who let you borrow money to buy real estate (an investment if you rent it out) or to your startup or existing business so that you can expand faster (also an investment). That's the end of the short list of things that the central bank does that had even a tiny chance of directly involving consumers and the vast majority of money does go into capital investments. Finally there is QE where the central banks introduce money into capital markets directly. Again unless you are a retail investor you are not going to transfer that new money into consumer spending. The vast majority of retail investors have a small net worth which means most of the money is going to a minority of wealthy people. Those wealthy people own businesses and would rather earn even more money (capital investment again). So, every time the author complained about the central bank following keynesian politics too much, they didn't... If anything, there is too little keynesianism. Inflation is low because money isn't reaching consumers at all. Now that we have arrived at inflation we can put another piece of the article in perspective. >Economists of the Austrian school understand, that the boom is the real problem and the economic crisis is the necessary and positive cleansing mechanism. Consumer inflation is a positive cleansing mechanism, it tells you "you have to be at least this productive to break even". Companies whose returns are below inflation have to close up shop eventually. Why is that? Because there is a shortage of goods or workers and those few precious goods or workers should be used in the most efficient way. Except this isn't what is currently happening, there is an overabundance of goods and labor and therefore there is no need for any sort of economic cleansing in the name of efficiency. It's the biggest reason why austerity policy in Greece did not work as "advertised". Their unemployment rate was so high that no job or company could be considered too inefficient. Simply getting people to work is already success. I'll take advantage of this to also talk about something unrelated to the article. Some capital owners argue that their wealth should not be taxed on inflation. Well, that would completely go against the idea of the cleansing mechanism and inflation would just be central bank money straight into the pockets of the rich (it already is to a large degree).
- Synaesthesia 6y agoI don't really follow the argument presented here. Seems to be a proposal to have ultra austerity. >Economists of the Austrian school understand, that the boom is the real problem and the economic crisis is the necessary and positive cleansing mechanism.
- MisterBastahrd 6y ago"Why Famine Is Actually A Character Building Exercise" -- somewhere on Mises, probably
- Krustopolis 6y agoFor the non-economists, he is referring to Ludwig von Mises: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_von_Mises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludwig_von_Mises
- jeofken 6y agoHighly doubt von Mises said that. Here is good intro materials to his very rational economic theories https://mises.org/economics-beginners https://mises.org/economics-beginners
- zabuni 6y agoWhy the Quarantine is actual serfdom. https://www.forgac.me/blog/2020/4/5/pandemic-the-shortcut-to-serfdom https://www.forgac.me/blog/2020/4/5/pandemic-the-shortcut-to... Also on Mises.
- paganel 6y agoKeeping hundreds of millions of people locked inside their houses or in a 5- or 10-km radius is pretty close to modern serfdom, I mean, it definitely quacks and looks like serfdom to me. How else would you define modern serfdom? Apparently we must apply these serfdom-like measures in order to win against the current pandemic, but that's a different discussion (one of effectiveness).
- hkt 6y agoIn the UK the payments industry is absolutely dominated by about half a dozen banks. You can't offer a debit card, or sort/account codes cheaply and with a direct, low volume interface into payments. This means there is less competition and choice. The Bank of England is consulting on a CBDC and people from small, nimble providers who can change their tech more cheaply than big incumbents are representing the view that a CBDC can open up the payments infrastructure for them. It is hard to imagine a better development for them, and consumers. Less positively, the whole critique of Keynesianism was answered decades ago and it amazes me that this is still a debate. Facts are facts, people have lives and need to consume, optimising without regard to this is abstracting human consequences out of the equation and therefore morally abhorrent. The Austrian school is for people who don't need to live with the agony of unemployment or deprivation.
- dionysus8 6y agoIt is interesting that you should say that, because last year I tried to open an online (only) bank account. I live in the Netherlands and finally chose for N26, but I was surprised by the large amount of online banks in the UK. Like Monese, Monzo, Revolut, Starling, ANNA, Tide, etc etc
- hkt 6y agoYes, they're all VC backed with bags of cash though. Credit unions, community banks, building societies etc find it impossible to do this. Also, the only two among that list that I know to be actual banks - rather than prepaid card providers - are Monzo and Starling.
- Nursie 6y agoParticularly for payments, Open Banking in the UK should offer some possibilities for non-card based systems. Adoption seems to be small though.
- perfunctory 6y ago> This gives the central banks three very dangerous capabilities. This can be said about any technological innovation since the cave age. It's evil because it could be used for evil. I, for one, don't appreciate this kind of arguments. For me personally CBDC has two big advantages - reduced risk (central banks can't go bankrupt) - commercial banks invest my money on my behalf without me having any control over the process. CBDC is presumably just a store.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoOf course one can see it as an advantage. But it's the opposite of freedom. I want to be free.
- turbinerneiter 6y agoHow are you less free if the a central bank issues a digital currency? You can still bitcoin all you want.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoOf course I can use Bitcoin if it's still allowed. I was referring to CDBCs.
- lifty 6y agoIf Bitcoin becomes big enough I think central banks will make a major push to ban it because it would severely diminish their power. My concern is that in such a scenario our monetary freedoms would be severely curtailed, and we would slide further towards a centrally controlled economy.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoSo, the benefit is that it cuts out the untrustworthy commercial banks? That sounds like a failure of politics and regulation; something that technology is a good workaround for, but a poor solution.
- 6y ago
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoAustrian economics is a bad idea, too, which is why no major modern economy pretends that it works.
- haolez 6y agoWhy? I would like to learn more.
- neilwilson 6y agoFull debunking of Austrian concepts here http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/p/blog-page.html?m=1 http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/p/blog-page.h...
- notahacker 6y agoThe short and relatively sympathetic response is Bryan Caplan's https://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/whyaust.htm https://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/whyaust.htm (TLDR: most of the useful concepts from Austrian theory were incorporated into mainstream economics; what was left were some bold claims and a hostility towards maths and empiricism.) https://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/whyaust.htm https://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/whyaust.htm
- logicchains 6y ago>hostility towards maths and empiricism Austrian economics isn't hostile to maths; it follows a different value system based on ordinal, not cardial utility, which doesn't allow for interpersonal value comparisons. Mathematically speaking this system is actually more elegant, as it has one less assumption (no philosophical assumption that interpersonal value comparison is possible), but obviously in such a system fewer statements can be made.
- notahacker 6y agoThe linked article explains in some detail how Rothbard dismissed much of neoclassical theory based on simply not understanding the maths was valid for both ordinal and cardinal utility preferences. And the philosophical difference is much greater than rejection of interpersonal utility comparisons (a position shared by many neoclassical economists and ethicists) or a dislike of modern algebraic formalism shared with many economists of all stripes but Mises' insistence that economics is "not quantitative" and should instead be a set of conclusions drawn from axiomatic statements about human behaviour. Mainstream economists have written a great deal about the limitations of models, structural flaws of certain models, and identifying the circumstances in which past performance is unlikely to be a guide to future results but only Mises insisted the act of looking at the data was 'childish play with figures'
- contingencies 6y agoBanks vs. central banks. Pot, kettle, black.
- Proven 6y agoLemme make that reall simple: central banks are a bad idea
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoDoesn't the very idea of the 'Central' in Central Bank Digital Currencies violate existential reasons and fundamental functions of digital currencies / cryptocurrencies? This seems to be an attempt at corralling a market by offering something entirely unfit for purpose, but marketed as being backed by the ultimately trustworthy (for surface-level-only reasons of "well, we've gotten you this far") Central Banks, and therefore immune to failure. What can it offer that doesn't already exist and also provide any consumer benefit? The article seems to answer that: nothing, in fact, less than nothing. Cryptocurrencies are anathema to Central Banks, so any embrace by the Central Banks must be looked at as a defensive reaction to a changing landscape.
- claydavisss 6y agoCentral Banks will use a digital currency but not a cryptocurrency. They need to be able to create it at will. The point is to be able to easily zero an account. Paper money in your possession cannot be instantly destroyed without your permission. A digital currency could be used to induce monetary velocity...i.e. spend the money by Saturday or it is deleted. Or, if you are arrested for protesting the Government, your account is zeroed.
- sunshinerag 6y ago>> Doesn't the very idea of the 'Central' in Central Bank Digital Currencies violate existential reasons and fundamental functions of digital currencies / cryptocurrencies? It does.
- dirtyid 6y agoDigital currency =/= cryptocurrency. The ability for state to wield digital currency to surveil and sanction are why central will win over crypto.
- lukeschlather 6y agoOn the other hand, one might describe proof-of-work currencies as an attempt at corralling a market by offering something entirely unfit for purpose, but marketed really aggressively.
- Benmcdonald__ 6y agoThey are the ideal tool for communist China or North Korea. I doubt they see that kind of control over every citizen money as bad
- d_theorist 6y agoPerhaps I’m missing something, but aren’t currencies mostly digital anyway? I don’t actually know for sure, but surely the percentage of fiat money that exists as physical cash is pretty small? Similar for the percentage of transactions that happens physically.
- perfunctory 6y ago> but aren’t currencies mostly digital anyway? yes, but currently only licensed financial institutions (e.g. banks) can hold accounts directly at a central bank. You, as a private person, can't. CBDC will give you that capability too.
- jcfrei 6y agoThe main difference is that physical money exists as a liability on the balance sheet of the central bank. That is special however. Because - as you say - most of the money in existence is digital. However that digital money - ie. your deposit - exists as a liability of a private bank. Meaning if that bank goes bust you are only guaranteed to get back the amount that is insured (probably something like $100k in the US).
- neilwilson 6y agoCentral bank digital currencies are just fancy PR for holding your current account at the central bank rather than a commercial bank. Which then means you don’t really need deposit insurance since if you’re concerned you’d park your money at the central bank. Deposits in commercial banks can then be treated as bank risk capital - where the depositor always risks a loss.
- rswail 6y agoThis entire article is a conflation of two orthogonal arguments: 1. Austrian economics is right, Keynsian is wrong. 2. Central banks are introducing ledger based currencies to increase surveillance of consumers, using the strawman argument about China. On 1), the pandemic has shown that government spending works to keep an economy from failing. The old inflation argument has been proven completely false. If anything, what has been proven is that a greater distribution of wealth is needed as Amazon and online wholesale and retail take over. The boom in online sales is a superprofit, driven by a windfall that government public health measures closed other sales channels. Those profits should be subject to a windfall tax to reduce that concentration. On 2) Central Banks are looking at ledger based currency as a way to allow more distribution channels beyond the existing retail banking network. It allows greater freedom for financial offerings by removing a layer of distribution. In a way, ledger based currencies are the "Amazon" of money distribution by central banks. It allows them to push money out when needed to multiple outlets, while still maintaining regulatory control. If anything, it's a "free but regulated market" at work.
- emteycz 6y agoYou know that all the central banks are actually saying themselves they want to track? It's not even a secret, you can read it right on their websites. The EU bank and Commission use China as the example, check it out: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/648784/IPOL_STU(2020)648784_EN.pdf https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/6487...
- erk__ 6y agoI am not sure where in the 47 pages you are reading that, I can find that the report is reccomending a european internet like the chinese to have higher growth in EU, and to foster european values "such as democratic values, data protection, data accessibility, transparency and user friendliness." Which I see rather pependicular to what you are saying it is telling. It should also be said that this report is not made by the european union, but for the european union by a 3rd party that got paid to make research for them. What it says, may or may not be influential to the future decicions of the EU.
- ilaksh 6y agoTo me it seems a little similar to when I introduced my manager to the idea of agile programming 17 years ago or something. He understood the "faster iteration" part and didn't hear anything else really. Here they have the idea of making a currency "digital" but just see it as mainly enabling the broken model they currently have. Personally I think something like solutions built on Ethereum 2.0 have the potential to really integrate more real-world information and finer-grained control for society. Money is fundamentally a technology and it should be a high technology. But like with everything else, there are extreme differences between the outcome of divergent designs.
- HashThis 6y agoNote that citizens can now pick individually and separately if they want to be Keynesian (USD) or Austrian (BTC/ETH/Gold). 1. This is illustrated by a 50 year old who paid off their $500k house. They sell, keep the cash for 23 months until they move across the country to buy a new house. 2. They could store their $500k in USD w/money printing and be a Keynesian. Money printing dilutes and they can buy less. 3. Another similar couple stores their $500k in BTC or cryptGOLD, as a non-money printing Austrian. Imagine if each person in society is picking individually if they want to be an Austrian or Keynesian based on the currency they select. Costs of USD money printing will be paid by a smaller and smaller group of people as more and more move off of USD.
- analog31 6y agoIs Austria subsidizing the electricity for bitcoin mining?
- Amezarak 6y agoBoth Bitcoin and gold have experienced devaluation. This illustration seems to be analogous to the physics spherical cow - there are other factors that determine the value of gold, BTC, and dollars besides supply. For example, if the 50 year old bought all their Bitcoin in January 2018, and sold them to buy their new house in January 2020, they would have been very, very disappointed.
- gumby 6y agoWhy do cryptocurrency proponents bring up negative interest rates as a problem of conventional central banking? “Hard” assets like gold and BTC by definition can’t be used for fractional reserve banking and instead must be warehoused (or you bury your good in the back yard and hope nobody steals it). Hence yiu are typically paying someone to warehouse your gold (there’s a fair amount of literature on this) or paying for a public wallet, rather than having the bank pay you. How is that any different from paying he central bank to sell you a bond?
- alexcnwy 6y agoHow are you “paying for a public wallet” when you hold BTC?
- seibelj 6y agoBTC and gold absolutely can be used for fractional reserve banking. Gold was used for this purpose for millennia. Private banks store gold and make loans in bank notes backed by hard currency, and provided there isn’t a run on the bank, wealth is created. This is banking 101 and has been completely warped by central banking system with fiat currency printing, to the point where normal banks don’t even serve a real purpose anymore other than to decentralize allocation of capital a bit and outsource the vetting of loans. But these could all be done by the central bank at this point and the fact normal banks exist at all is because of history.
- MrXOR 6y agoCBDCs are the reaction of banks and governments to Bitcoin. They "can" be a good money for the Ministry of Plenty (1984).
- cinquemb 6y agoCB's have jumped the shark with CBDC's… decentralized self stabilizing stable coins are already being used for loan origination in emerging markets for farmers where traditional banks (who CB's are reliant upon in every jurisdiction) have had no interest… this is the type of thing I was waiting for when I jumped into BTC back in 2012… Moral hazards of TBTF/TBTJ and propping up zombies can only get you so far…
- noxer 6y agoThe author of this articles apparently thinks the money supply is increased by the central banks. This is not correct. Banks are the real money printers. Central banks may issue cash but banks can issue credit based on someone else's debts.
- tw25550443 6y ago> Central banks may issue cash but banks can issue credit based on someone else's debts. If you mean deposits, then you're describing fractional reserve banking, and the central bank sets the reserve ratio for those commercial banks, thus the central bank is still in control.
- cinquemb 6y agoOnly if one think's there is no rehypothication going on of collateral (i.e. someone else's debts in the form of government bonds, corporate bonds of all grades, or even stock [which are liabilities on corporate balance sheets]) that is on deposit with some party…
- noxer 6y agoOfc the central bank is in control that's the whole point of the central bank. But the central bank does not single-handedly control the money supply it controls the value to other currencies by buying/selling stuff to maintain a somewhat stable local currency. Which is more or less the main task of a central bank. But commercial banks multiply the money supply by creating credit out of thin air. Fractional reserves are just a trick to prevent a collapse when a bank run happens. It doesn't change the way the system works. Also fractional reserve have been abolished in most places because they are essentially useless if bank runs are physically no longer possible because people dont use or want cash anymore and they think the money they have is on that plastic card. The people are no longer capable of creating shortages. The digital debt balances can be moved around however much people want the bank does not need any reserves for that.
- tw25550443 6y agoThis entire comments section reminds me of every econ discussion I've seen on the web for the past 25 years: wall-to-wall hubris. So, allow me to throw two more tires on this fire: "The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design." "It is no crime to be ignorant of economics, which is, after all, a specialized discipline and one that most people consider to be a ‘dismal science.’ But it is totally irresponsible to have a loud and vociferous opinion on economic subjects while remaining in this state of ignorance."