4 ms·
> like Palantir: a secretive artificial intelligence outfit This is a funny way of describing Palantir. They are just consultants plus data management software
by prepend 6y ago
> like Palantir: a secretive artificial intelligence outfit
This is a funny way of describing Palantir. They are just consultants plus data management software. That’s it. They are no more “AI” than any company that can run Python pipelines.
I’m not sure if this is PR by Palantir trying to up their stock. Or stupid press not understanding data engineering.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- forgingahead 6y agostupid press not understanding Bingo -- not just limited to data engineering though.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- atmosx 6y agoI believe the concerns raised are valid. Palantir had CIA as the only client for years. Was “adopted” in Greece right after Pompeo’s visit. A coincidence? Maybe. The company and the CEO have a questionable reputation and ideas about things I value like “democracy”, it was given to the Greek state for “free” apparently and in 2020 we all know what “free” means. To top it all, Palantir has already being accused of selling public records data obtained by police departments in US states to private corporations. So for all we know they are just funneling data to the CIA and selling data to private corporations while providing trivial “big data” services to governments. By the way, the EU is monitoring Palantir’s presence in Europe. There is feeling that Palantir’a services are “planted” rather than “requested”. Before Snowden one could argue these are wild conspiracies, post-Snowden, I cannot think of a reason for a government to accept official spyware on its digital soil other than lack of sovereignty. Would China and Russia accept Palantir as a big data analysis system to fight COVID?
- secfirstmd 6y agoThey also have made a big push into the data of NGOs and the UN. Many of which collect very sensitive data in some countries with some very complex political, economic and social issues. Palantir was often doing this for free. Maybe it's the cynic in me but in the same way I'd guess NSO Group does in the Middle East, somewhere something would be phoning home to Palantir's bigger customers (CIA, NSA) etc
- prepend 6y ago> Palantir had CIA as the only client for years. I can’t find any source for this. In-q-tel was an early finder but they spun out of PayPal and have always had PayPal and finance as clients from inception.
- CodeGlitch 6y ago> a secretive artificial intelligence outfit founded by a Trump-backing billionaire I'm in no way a Trump-fan, but sentences like the above immediately puts me into the opinion that this article is going to be one-sided - and hence I stopped reading. I don't read www.opendemocracy.net (first time I've encountered it), so perhaps that's there thing?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoEspecially since it’s a half-truth. They’re referring to Peter Thiel, but the co-founder and 16 year CEO Alex Karp is a Trump opponent.
- jhowell 6y agoOpponent of the person, but not the policies. For those at either ends of the spectrum the difference is inconsequential.
- jhowell 6y agoI think they are referring to Peter Thiel. Thiel gave a speech at the 2016 RNC in support of their nominee, Donald Trump. At the time through the present, Thiel continues to have a net worth in excess of $1 billion. Is it the adjective secretive that turned you away?
- slovette 6y agoNo... come on, I think it’s obvious what they should have said: “billionaire investor Peter Thiel.” The man has an identity outside just being a “Trump backer”. Using that descriptor specifically chooses a minor, politically motivated detail about someone and concludes to the rightful reaction of turning away. Choosing to write a “news” article while also choosing descriptors like that make this an opinion piece, not a news article. I think it’s what is fundamentally wrong with most of the Information passed around today; you can’t escape the opinions buried neatly inside EVERY article, desperately persuading you to think and feel a certain way. Everything’s hostile these days, just constantly attacking your mindset.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mgh2 6y agoThis is actually old news ~1 week. Would you rather have media that is: 1. Hyped based on marketing or 2. Speculative because of secrecy Apple has both, Palantir is mostly the 2nd because of the nature of their work
- chrisseaton 6y ago> They are just consultants plus data management software. That’s it. They are no more “AI” than any company that can run Python pipelines. And Dropbox is just FTP and rsync, right?
- bob33212 6y agoDropbox is a total solution. It takes about 5 clicks and 10 minutes and you are getting the core values out of the product. Buying palantir is similar to buying IBM Watson. It is going to take months before anything is being installed. Most of what they are doing is consulting and database administration
- travisoneill1 6y ago> stupid press not understanding data engineering Anybody could understand the difference between data engineering and "AI" in 30 mins of research, which is a lot less time than they have to research a story. Whenever a journalist "doesn't understand" something that could be learned with a simple google search, it's not stupidity, it's malicious. In this case the journalist is pretending to write a story about Palantir winning a contract, but really writing a part of the continuing story "Palantir (and the tech industry in general) is evil and powerful and you should be scared."
- pessimizer 6y agoRather the continuing story "Palantir is an extremely competent, extremely advanced company from the future that spreads secret sauce on data that can turn it into fuel for their mind control technologies" that Palantir and the people who direct contracts to them propagate themselves. This is just another case of journalists responding to tech companies own PR because they entirely operate from press releases and marketing material. See Cambridge Analytics.
- mgh2 6y agoPlaying devil's advocate here for discussion purposes: Isn't the 1st step of any AI to collect as much pertinent data as possible? The potential I see in Palantir is that they have the base infrastructure covered (talent, tech stack, business relationships) to connect to all sorts of disconnected database sources. The 2nd step will be to analyze that data for insights using opensource or in-house engineered algorithms - not Palantir's role right now. Ex: My past firm played with Datarobot's AI solutions which tried to outsource data scientists as "consultants" but did not work very well due to lack of data engineering/domain expertise. Could this be Palantir's next move? Note: This may sound mildly speculative, but trying to approach it from an engineering and business perspective.
- prepend 6y agoI’m not aware of any Palantir contracts that let them use, model with, or analyze data outside of designated purposes. It’s pretty hard to audit cloud services that claim to have isolated dbs, but it seems like such a massive breach of contract if they were actually doing this. It’s the same risk if Microsoft cracked open all the sql dbs to analyze and train AIs. Or if AWS tried to use data stored with them. I’m sure it would be useful but would break every contract they have and since they are trying to make money off cloud services that’s a big risk for minimal return. So unless there’s more evidence just saying something is possible is a rabbit hole for every cloud provider, right?