4 ms·
>But...that is 4K. It's what 4K is defined as, exactly 2x 1080p resolution in each dimension. That's irrelevant though, except if we're talking about consuming
by coldtea 6y ago
>But...that is 4K. It's what 4K is defined as, exactly 2x 1080p resolution in each dimension.
That's irrelevant though, except if we're talking about consuming movies fullscreen.
For a monitor I don't want 4K, I want insivible pixels at viewing distances, so hi-dpi.
I would also prefer no scaling for assets that are bitmap in nature. This ideally means pixel doubling (less cpu/gpu demanding and less fuzzy than fractional scaling).
This, for 27" and more, means higher resolution that 4K. I don't want to restrict myself to pixel-doubled 1920x1080 on my 27" or 32" monitor.
You do get nice DPI, but needlessly large buttons and other assets (compared to something closer to 5K).
- gambiting 6y agoI just completely don't understand your point. There's no misleading advertising here - the resolution is exactly as promised ,at the size promised....what's the problem? If the resolution isn't high enough for you....then buy one where it is? There are 5K monitors out there, maybe even 8K? Or just get a 4K one but in a smaller size? I'm so confused by your comment.
- coldtea 6y ago>I just completely don't understand your point. There's no misleading advertising here - the resolution is exactly as promised ,at the size promised....what's the problem? That would be relevant is my problem was false promises or misleading advertising. But my problem is not (a) "Monitors say they are 4K and they are not" but: (b) "Most monitors out there are BS-4K, but for the best quality/viewing comfort at their 27" and above diagonal they should rather be 5K, but most manufactures like Dell aren't bothered to produce at such a resolution and the few that do have prices to the skies". >There are 5K monitors out there, maybe even 8K? Or just get a 4K one but in a smaller size? Perhaps you've skiped through the thread? My comment responds to (and agrees with) the sub-thread started by a parent commenter writing: "Dell used to have good offerings, but all they seem to push now is the same 27” not-quite-4K 3,840 x 2,160 panels everybody else does.".
- pavlus 6y agoFor me it's hard to believe that 4k on 27" is not enough, I use 1440p 27" 144Hz display as daily driver and barely see any pixels(usually with badly hinted fonts, and still not pixels, but uneven forms of letters), because I sit around one meter apart from it, and sitting closer makes me turn my head around too much, except when watching movies.
- gambiting 6y agoYeah, same - 27" 1440p as a daily monitor for work and I have no issues with it. I have had a 27" 4K monitor for a while but it was just too small at 100% scaling, and at 150% scaling some things looked naff. Prefer the 1440p at that resolution.
- coldtea 6y ago>I have had a 27" 4K monitor for a while but it was just too small at 100% scaling, and at 150% scaling some things looked naff. Prefer the 1440p at that resolution. That's what we say too. 27" 4K monitor is too small at 100% scaling, while too small at 50% scaling (pixel-doubling hi-dpi mode). That's why the idea is to have a 5K at 50% scaling (so everything is pixel-doubled on each axis, and a pixel becomes 4 pixels, doubling the detail you see).
- coldtea 6y ago>For me it's hard to believe that 4k on 27" is not enough, I use 1440p 27" 144Hz display as daily driver and barely see any pixels It's not just about "not seeing any pixels", and "barely see any pixels" is not the same as enjoying hi-res typography and fine detail. 27-inch 1440p monitor is about 108 ppi. That's hardly better from what we used in the 90s and 00s, dpi-wise. Sure, if you haven't used to hi-dpi it looks ok. But try using a 5K/27-inch monitor for a while and then go back to 1440p/27-inch to see the difference you miss. Now, 4K hi-dpi (pixel doubled) on 27" is 1920x1080. This makes pixels just fine and detail is great, but everything too large and cuts off screen space, as it's 33% less area than 1440p (which, I presume, you don't use pixel-doubled) The solution is either 5K/27" (which gives you back the 1440p kind of screen space and UI control size PLUS hi-dpi), or using a non-doubled, fractional resolution, to overcome, (which is not optimal, looks fuzzier, and wastes cpu).
- pembrook 6y ago> There are 5K monitors out there, maybe even 8K? Or just get a 4K one but in a smaller size? The whole point of this thread is people complaining that, outside of LG's fragile Apple collab, there aren't any 5k options widely available. Go on amazon and search for 5k 27. There's the Apple collab LG UltraFine, and then nothing. Ditto for 22" 4k, which would provide the same DPI as your laptop screen for that given size.
- gambiting 6y agoWasn't the problem that 5K displays(or maybe it's just this specific one?) are notoriously difficult to make it work on windows? Last time I looked into getting one I found out that it just wouldn't work without getting a thunderbolt card for my AMD based system, or a DP 1.4 compatible gpu. On the other hand, HDMI 2.1 can now support 8K@60hz, so maybe this is not an issue anymore.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoI have an LG 28" 4K and while definitely isn't as nice as my iMac 27" 5K, it works well enough for coding (I'm primarily concerned about text rendering without visible pixels).
- dragonwriter 6y ago> That's irrelevant Not to the upthread specific claim that the resolution was “not quite 4K”, which is what the comment you are responding to addressed. On the bigger issue, I don't really see the complaint. I have pretty good vision (corrected—to 20/15 or so—uncorrected is crap but I'm not coding without glasses/contacts) and honestly my 34” ultrawide at 3440x1440 is excellent for coding, and pretty much any other use. Now, would I prefer whatever resolution a 5K 16:9 would be when extended to 21:9? Or better a 4320p at the same aspect ratio? Sure, more pixels are always better. But does the sub-4K display look like crap or force bad sizes for controls? No.
- coldtea 6y ago>Sure, more pixels are always better. But does the sub-4K display look like crap or force bad sizes for controls? No. Sure, I can work with a 3440x1440 34". Heck, I've worked with CGA monitors back in the day, and black and white (!) SUN Sparkstation monitors. But, as you said, it's about looking better. "Doesn't look like crap" is a pretty low bar, no? For 2020, and after 10 years of hi-dpi phones and laptops, I expected better from monitor companies...
- TulliusCicero 6y ago> For a monitor I don't want 4K, I want insivible pixels at viewing distances, so hi-dpi. That's cool I guess, I was just objecting to calling the 4K "Not quite 4K".