19 ms·
> Free speech platforms usually end up being extremist platforms. ...when the popular platforms stop being free speech platforms. Reddit, in its earlier days,
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Free speech platforms usually end up being extremist platforms.
...when the popular platforms stop being free speech platforms.
Reddit, in its earlier days, was never dominated by the Voat contingent. They were there, but they were far less extreme there than they were on Voat. And then whenever they would post rank inaccuracies, there were clearer-minded people to point out why they were wrong, in the same place where the same people could see it. Meanwhile in the 7% of cases when they actually had a legitimate point to make, they could make it, and the people who benefited from hearing it would actually hear it instead of continuing to be unawares and consequently continuing to be wrong about something.
But it doesn't work to have one popular platform which allows nearly everyone except for Those Deplorables and another that allows "everyone" but the only people with the incentive to move are the people being forcibly ejected from the popular one. Because witch hunts are bad, but if there is a place that owes its existence solely to a policy of not having witch hunts, it's going to be full of witches.
So the answer has to be to stop the witch hunts in the places where everybody else already is.
- koheripbal 6y agoI think part of the issue is that the average age of Reddit users plummeted. It was in the high 20s, but I've seen some research that puts it in the high teens these days / early 20s. That has a huge impact on the quality of conversations.
- 1_player 6y agoAnd politics have infected every single discussion. Nowadays it's cool to be partisans, decades ago a teenager talking about politics would be dismissed with a "get a hobby, nerd." It is an absolute disgrace how it's become normal. Or that mine is an unpopular opinion nowadays.
- 0xy 6y agoReddit stopped caring about political manipulation by organised bots and paid shills since before the 2016 election. In fact, PACs openly admitted to the practices during the election. Reddit absolutely doesn't care, they'd rather bombard you with ads and tracking garbage and pretend they're a viable platform through half-assed initiatives.
- gdulli 6y agoI don't understand. Why is it a disgrace that teenagers talk about politics, or are allowed to do so without being insulted?
- nitrogen 6y agoI think they were saying that the coolness of partisanship is what's disgraceful.
- dlp211 6y agoIt's a disgrace that people have taken to discussing politics in a democratic-republic?
- sharatvir 6y agoI generally hear this sentiment from those who are self proclaimed “centrists” and are relatively unaffected by politics. It’s a little sad how many people think political discussion shouldn’t take place in democratic countries.
- HexagonalKitten 6y agoThere's a difference between discussion and the five-minute hate where people recite a list of manufactured transgressions. Most people who say we should discuss politics more seem to mean that we should affirm the local viewpoint.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> decades ago a teenager talking about politics would be dismissed with a "get a hobby, nerd." I was a teenager three decades ago. 1. No one would ever say “get a hobby, nerd” (“get a life...”, OTOH) 2. No one would say that about teens talking about politics, which non-nerd teenagers did commonly. They would say it about talking about computer code, though. > It is an absolute disgrace how it's become normal Why? > Or that mine is an unpopular opinion nowadays. The continuous political vigilance widely acknowledged to be necessary to prevent liberal democracy from devolving into tyranny is incompatible with the political disengagement you seem to prefer, so I think would be not at all a disgrace if your opinion were unpopular. Though lamenting political engagement isn't particularly unpopular (but, amusingly enough since it often is overtly tied to complaints about partisanship, seems particularly popular among partisans of the right.)
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The continuous political vigilance widely acknowledged to be necessary to prevent liberal democracy from devolving into tyranny is incompatible with the political disengagement you seem to prefer This is backwards. The tyranny is caused by the vigilance.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The tyranny is caused by the vigilance. Not of those interested in liberty, but, sure of the vigilance of would by tyrants when met with the apathy of those who prefer liberty. “It is the common fate of the indolent to see their rights become a prey to the active. The condition upon which God hath given liberty to man is eternal vigilance; which condition if he break, servitude is at once the consequence of his crime and the punishment of his guilt.” —John Philpot Curran
- iKevinShah 6y agoI am not the original commentor but would like to address : > > It is an absolute disgrace how it's become normal > Why? I have seen where almost ALL discussions lead to judgement based on politics and that takes away from the core discussion point. What is the point of having separate subs then? For example take this link (https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/khlnyz/ronaldinho_on_twitter_dear_friends_my_mother_is/ https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/khlnyz/ronaldinho_o...), this was the top post on the subreddit when I saw it last night, the top-most comment is not about well wishes for his mother OR about how he thought about Covid OR whether or not he denied covid but rather the fact that he is "right-wing". Now I understand how bad it is but that is not the point of the sub. And that has become the norm , at least on reddit, which if not a disgrace, at least leaves a bad taste. I've seen people take time to go through your profile and dig out one comment and then label you, just one. That feels like a disgrace.
- faizshah 6y agoKind of ironic that anti politics discussions seems to derail every HN thread these days.
- zapataband1 6y agoIdk what you define as being cool but here's Tom Morello destroying a guitar in front of a Nazi Lives Don't Matter screen. https://twitter.com/TerranSocialist/status/1340925049994424320 https://twitter.com/TerranSocialist/status/13409250499944243...
- ignoranceprior 6y agoThen the question is whether it's better to allow people with unsavory views a minority platform on mainstream sites where they'll try to convert others, or force them to their own niche echo chambers that will inevitably be extremely toxic. It's basically a tradeoff between visibility to the public and density of toxic content.
- intended 6y agoNot density, Absorbablity. Even 1 headline, as outlandish as it may be, if it is read it can influence a user. Crucially there are some ideas/content that will just get through filters, no matter how thin it’s presence.
- mr_toad 6y ago> niche echo chambers Letting every sub have it’s own moderators with nearly free-reign is a big part of the problem.
- intended 6y agoThose days ended fast. I saw it happen. On my forum, that very question was asked, and it wasn’t a philosophical debate. It was an operational one - how do we balance free speech ideals vs actual forum evidence. The framework that fits the evidence and the ideals was 1) we want a market place of ideas to function 2) there is content that easily dominates and sidelines all other ideas. 3) there are Maliciously engineered arguments that need complex rebuttals to Massive emotional payloads, which will never be accepted. 4) cat videos, pictures and memes will out perform everything else We let things be for a long time. Very light touch approaches. It doesn’t work. The good ideas will become irrelevant before theY are even read, and that is long after bad ideas redefine reality. The underlying nexus is that our ideals on free speech do not take into account human wetware bandwidth. If reality must be perceived, and the perception system is flooded, then it doesn’t matter how good our science or reason is. The system is still blind.
- sfblah 6y agoCan you give some specifics of #3 just for color? I'm not interested in debating or trolling at all. I'm just curious what people say that does this. Is it just people cheering for Trump or something?
- lordCarbonFiber 6y agoTones of statements fall under that header. It can be Trump supporters tallking about election fraud, nazis talking about "race based IQ distributions" or transphobes talking about "bathroom predators"; there's no shortage of these kind of bad faith low effort "arguements". There are mountains of high quality sources you can use to argue against the claims but it takes many times the work than just showing up to "just ask questions" as bigots are want to do. Having a 0 tolerance policy for these kinds of people makes your space safer for maginalized communities and ends up with better debates/discussions over all since, as i alluded to, these arguments aren't actually in good faith or rooted in any sort of data.
- sfblah 6y agoNo interest in wading into the specifics of these topics obviously. But, it occurs to me that deciding which topics are troll topics and which ones aren’t confers a lot of power. I have actually seen people banned from communities when coming armed with pretty detailed data and thorough argumentation. I wonder if there’s a principled way to separate low-effort trolls from those simply willing to argue the unpopular side of a controversial topic.
- tootie 6y agoThe problems on reddit started the second it became commercially successful. First came paid promotions, then came the propaganda. Too much of the "free speech" was totally insincere attempts at manipulation.
- jml7c5 6y agoWhat time frame are you talking here?
- tootie 6y agoI don't really recall the whole timeline. But it wasn't long after the Digg debacle that reddit started getting gamed by content farms leveraging popular accounts. Then the process got more and more refined and professional as it also became more lucrative.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Reddit, in its earlier days, was never dominated by the Voat contingent. One of Reddit's most visited subreddits in the early days, between 2007 and 2011, was one dedicated to sharing suggestive pictures of minors[1]. It was chosen as "subreddit of the year" in 2008 and the subreddit was the second most searched term on Reddit[2]. There was definitely a core of users with questionable characters on Reddit for whom "free speech" meant sharing extremist, or at least perverse, content. The Reddit CEO even issued a "memo on free speech" to address the situation[1]. [1] https://venturebeat.com/2012/10/17/reddit-ceo-issues-internal-memo-on-free-speech-and-outing-of-violentacrez/ https://venturebeat.com/2012/10/17/reddit-ceo-issues-interna... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversial_Reddit_communities#Jailbait https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversial_Reddit_communiti...
- greggturkington 6y agoThose weren't the early days; Condé Nast owned it and you could make your own subreddits by then. Early on it was very science, tech, and liberal. Mysogynistic, but not alt-right/hate content like Voat.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hhjinks 6y agoLooking at the second link just makes me nostalgic for the heyday of reddit drama. So many shitty subreddits on there I forgot all about.
- vkou 6y ago> ...when the popular platforms stop being free speech platforms. No, this always happens, any time you get more than two people in one room together. Eventually, intolerable assholes drive either everyone else away, or they get driven away. Meanwhile, people who aren't bothered by that particular intolerable asshole shrug their shoulders, and ask 'What's the big deal?', and 'Can't we all just be rational robots who get along?', and 'This is purely an intellectual conversation, the outcome of which has absolutely no material bearing on my life, why are people getting so worked up over this?'
- specialist 6y agoWhat would a witch hunt free reddit look like?
- krapp 6y agoVoat.
- phire 6y ago> Reddit, in its earlier days, was never dominated by the Voat contingent. Reddit never had free speech as a key attracting point. People came to reddit not because it was free speech, but because there was good conversations and content there. Reddit's early "free speech attitude" came about mostly because they had a staff of 4 people who spend all their time trying to keep the site from crashing as it scaled. It was a stance of convenience which they kept as long as possible. Vote explictly advertised it as a "free speech alternative to reddit". Free speech was it's number one advertising point. It's really not surprising it instantly attracted the wrong type of users and drove away everyone else.
- schoen 6y agoI recall a clear period of time when at least some of the people running Reddit seemed very proud of how they didn't take down or ban subreddits that many people thought were inappropriate, offensive, or harmful. Unfortunately, since Aaron Swartz was the only sometime-Reddit leader I knew, I can't immediately point to other people from Reddit leadership who were explicit about this (as Aaron certainly was). I believe there was a rough Reddit equivalent to Twitter executives' famous "the free speech wing of the free speech party" statement, but I can't cite one and I may be letting my memories of Aaron's views get projected onto his colleagues.
- ashtonkem 6y agoAny sufficiently large forum will eventually attract edgelord types from 4chan or wherever. Even if your rose-tinted view of early days Reddit is true, which I very much doubt, you still have to plan what to do once the trolls show up.
- ianmcgowan 6y agoOne person's witch hunt is another's "defense of tolerance". There's definitely a line where free speech runs into ideas and positions that are not compatible with free speech, e.g. how can you have a reasoned discussion with a Nazi if they believe certain groups are literally subhuman, and you happen to be part of (or even have normal human empathy for) one of those groups. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- concordDance 6y ago> how can you have a reasoned discussion with a Nazi if they believe certain groups are literally subhuman, and you happen to be part of (or even have normal human empathy for) one of those groups. Well... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daryl_Davis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daryl_Davis I've had interesting discussions about whether or not people like me should be allowed to vote or breed and whether people like me not existing would make the world a more peaceful place.
- UncleMeat 6y agoDaryl Davis doesn't scale. Everybody likes to point at him but there is a reason why he is a unique case. Especially since it would be trivial for fascists to monopolize his time by just claiming to be open to discussion while actually not being interested in changing their views. This is why Davis holds his conversations in private. When done in public, his approach is exploitable to create a seemingly legitimate channel to spread fascist propaganda.
- renewiltord 6y ago> So the answer has to be to stop the witch hunts in the places where everybody else already is. Got to be honest, bro, I don't really care to sacrifice for "the good of society" or whatever. If you make a website where some dude is going to post anti-Semitic shit everywhere and someone else is going to have to politely explain that Jewish lizard people are not conspiring to elect a Black woman as President then sure, you can have it. But that's not a sacrifice I want to make. I'll go to the website where I don't have to do that. And the website will come to me. Like, I don't see you moving to the ghetto and putting your kids in shitty schools so that you can even things out. This ain't different. I don't like those people at the party, so I'm not gonna go if you invite them. So you pick: them or me? Either choice is fine. Reddit picked me. Voat picked them. And we are where we are.
- riggernetard 6y agoReddit didn't 'pick you', it kicked out most of the people who made it a great site in the first place - not even the rightoids, but the original, deviant, unique, outcast users who were there in the early days of the site. They made it special, and they are gone.
- croon 6y agoAt the risk of making a reddit comment... "relevant nickname".
- optimalsolver 6y agoSo I'm sure those original people went on to found some awesome new community, and us normies are stuck with some lame site that we're still happy with. A win-win for everyone involved.
- roenxi 6y ago> post anti-Semitic shit everywhere and someone else is going to have to politely explain that Jewish lizard people are not conspiring to elect a Black woman as President Your actual argument - yeah, sure. All for it. But it is a lot pretend people are anti-Semitic lizard conspiracy theorists if they aren't there to defend themselves. If Reddit wants a more ideologically aligned user-base good luck to them. But this exact scenario has played out many times through history - having a majority culture doesn't magically confer greater moral integrity, or intelligence.
- pjc50 6y ago> Meanwhile in the 7% of cases when they actually had a legitimate point to make, they could make it Reddit bans posts and accounts, but cannot ban individuals. If you have something useful to say you can make a non troll account for it.
- croon 6y agoI just have to say I strongly disagree, and I've been on the internet for a while (multiple decades). The only reason reddit wasn't overrun by asshats even before more subreddits were banned were due to moderation. The same has been true for all forums and BBS:es since the beginning of time. Truth and sensibility doesn't win out. The loudest voices with the least filtered speech does, because the least amount of filter produces the most amount of output. With risk of making too broad of a generalization, everything dies without moderation.
- romwell 6y ago>Reddit, in its earlier days, was never dominated by the Voat contingent It has less to do with fReE sPeEcH and more to do with reddit being a niche platform for nerds in the early days (and as far as 2008). >They were there, but they were far less extreme there than they were on Voat. Until reddit became mainstream. Then the front page got taken over by /r/The_Donald crowd. There is a reason that subrredit is no more. >And then whenever they would post rank inaccuracies, there were clearer-minded people to point out why they were wrong, in the same place where the same people could see it. And there flowed rivers of milk and honey.... Wait, no, you'd get banned from /r/The_Donald faster than you can blink after you post something that didn't align. And it wasn't even the worst subreddit. >Meanwhile in the 7% of cases when they actually had a legitimate point to make, they could make it, and the people who benefited from hearing it would actually hear it instead of continuing to be unawares and consequently continuing to be wrong about something. Cry me a river about losing the educational value neo-nazis provide. You don't eat an apple that's 93% rotten, you throw it into the compost pile. This post shows that the compost pile couldn't even sustain itself. >But it doesn't work to have one popular platform which allows nearly everyone except for Those Deplorables To the contrary, the platform that works for these "deplorables" (your words) doesn't work for literally everyone else. As a proof, we see this very post. Nobody is interested in having these people around. Reddit wasn't a popular platform when it started out. It gained a huge amount of users because Digg messed up. If kicking the Voat contingent out were a mistake, Voat would bethe new reddit (it has the same features platform-wise, after all). >Because witch hunts are bad... Straw man argument. These people were kicked out for their hostile and toxic behavior, not for their ideas. Kicking out people who poop in public places is not a "witch hunt", because it's not based on identity, but on bad behavior. There are plenty of alt-right and neo-nazis on reddit still. They are just behaving a little better. And again, I'm sorry, but I have little interest in attending venues where throwing poop around is OK. This post is an indication that I am in the majority.
- eertami 6y ago> And then whenever they would post rank inaccuracies, there were clearer-minded people to point out why they were wrong, in the same place where the same people could see it. I don't think this works on reddit either, since subreddit moderators can simply delete such comments.
- wooger 6y agoIt's the moderators on Reddit that are much of the problem. There are organised subreddits (/r/AHS) that seek to get certain subreddits not in agreement with the latest SJW ideology banned. They do this by posting illegal / banned content themselves in the subreddit, then mass reporting it. They also do this at a user level, including targeting mods of any subreddit they disagree with. If they get the mods of a subreddit banned, they can take it over with their own friendly mods - easily done as there are clearly Reddit employees with an activist agenda who will help them out. Once they've done that they're free to stifle debate, ban any users who speak out against their point of view and generally create a culture of fear. This is why all the womens issues, feminist & lesbian subreddits have trans (i.e. male) moderators. And why entire communities of women have left reddit forever.
- starfallg 6y ago>So the answer has to be to stop the witch hunts in the places where everybody else already is. No, the system is working as it should. If a platform is so full of fringe extremists that the vast majority of people want to have nothing to do with, then they have to bear the commercial and social consequences of that. Your right to free speech doesn't take priority over my right to have nothing to do with it. Go find your own little patch of land to shout your opinions from. Free speech doesn't mean you have to right to make me hear you. It just means that government is not allowed to restrict it (for the fear of political suppression). That's it.
- arbitrage 6y agoSo, what you're saying is that there are good people on both sides? Piss off with your fascist apologist garbage. Hate isn't guaranteed a platform.
- Heracleides 6y agoWell, Reddit also likes to censor criticism. For example, if you criticize power moderator Ani625's unreasonable deletions of legitimate posts, you risk an account suspension.