8 ms·
Seuss-Star Trek mashup crashes and burns at Ninth Circuit
- dbcooper 6y agoBig thumbs up to the reporter for the “Victory is life” DS9 reference.
- FlyMoreRockets 6y agoHow could "To Boldly Go" not be considered a transfomative work? Well, I guess this answers that question: https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=15758460119711775481&q=Dr.+Seuss+Enterprises,+L.P.+v.+Penguin+Books+USA,+Inc.&hl=en&as_sdt=6,33 https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=157584601197117...
- the_unknown 6y agoIs this really necessary? "xxx is a George W. Bush appointee. xxx also a Bush appointee, and Barack Obama appointee xxx joined xxx opinion." Perhaps when discussing items of moral importance and life or death judgments it may be of historical/cultural reference but a copyright conflict seems rather out of bounds for such detail.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Perhaps when discussing items of moral importance The scope of free speech protections (and, on the other side, the scope of personal property rights as well) is a matter of moral importance, moreover the scope of free speech protections is a matter on which there is particularly active current controversy in which a sharp partisan divide on the issue is part of a central political narrative, and this is a significant factor in modern American politics.
- ghaff 6y agoI dunno. A lot of people jump to the conclusion that things are partisan political decisions these days even when they're not.
- kristopolous 6y agoThat's my reading: a defense of the party impartiality of the judiciary more than any attribution to a partisan group. Of course they could still be biased say, in favor of those with power and capital. But since in practice, both political parties bow to capital with effectively equal deference, such a bias wouldn't surface by merely listing out which president appointed whom.
- newacct583 6y agoYes, it is. In fact, I missed that last paragraph while skimming for the link to the decision and went straight to wikipedia to check the details on the three justices involved. It's nice to imagine that we shouldn't attribute partisan lean to our courts, but in the real world we all know there is one in many cases. And it's important to know when evidence cuts against that trend as much as it is when it confirms our priors.
- AequitasOmnibus 6y agoIn this case it's probably superfluous to include under which president the judge was appointed, but there is merit to including the information generally. The Circuits ordinarily hear cases in 3-judge panels (occasionally cases are heard en banc, where more/all of the circuit judges will hear the case). The outcome of a large number of cases can be predicted based upon the composition of the panel. So where "conservative" judges make up 2/3 or 3/3 of the panel, you tend to see "conservative" (read: pro-business, pro-prosecution) outcomes and vice-versa with "liberal" judges. It could be coincidence, but as someone who has followed circuit opinions for years, the panel composition has corresponded with the ultimate outcome a surprising number of times. (N.B. it would be interesting to statistically track the panel composition/outcome metric to see how often the correlation actually exists).
- fy20 6y agoThat seems somewhat wrong...? I mean these judges are supposed to be impartial, but if outcome is mostly based on who gets picked, then that isn't the case.
- AequitasOmnibus 6y agoI think it comes down to how both sides view impartiality. There's definitely confirmation bias when the president nominates a judge - often the candidates come from the same party so they share some broad ideological positions. Most judges I think do see themselves as impartial jurists even if the results tend to skew toward political outcomes.
- josv 6y agoHah! That’s not the “confirmation bias” I’m used to, but very apt.
- iguy 6y agoAgree it seems a bit wrong. Worth bearing in mind that cases which go to higher courts are usually ones which lower courts think aren't clear, or different courts disagree.
- vmception 6y agoVery necessary, it validates how impartial the court is to some people. There are people that would question a court's validity more if some midwestern appeals circuit had 3 Trump appointees reversing an opinion, just like there are other people that would raise an eyebrow at anything the ninth circuit rules. So they list who was appointed by whom.
- throwaway2245 6y agoIt's useful for voters to know how they can expect appointees to rule, and to hold administrations to account. This might seem obvious, but: if copyright is within the scope of the court, then it's within the scope of the appointment. Therefore, it's relevant.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoI guess it depends on what one considers necessary... If you did a survey, I would believe public opinion to be closer to "judges are partisan and always decide along ideological lines" than reality. With that assumption, mentions of who appointed judges when writing about their decisions would also work against public cynicism on this issue. Unless, of course, people somehow manage to give more weight to evidence confirming their biases than evidence against.
- patcon 6y agofunny, that was the main thing I noticed and appreciated about the journalism. why would you not want this made clear in the context of judges doing the very thing we're thinking about when they're appointed (ruling on stuff)? imho, this is the "rubber hits the road" context. if we want our opinions of appointments to be grounded in... well... reality, then we should maybe care less about appointments when they're abstractly happening and we're horse-betting, and think MORE about them when they're ruling. Frankly, I'm confused how you're thinking about this, such that you would think someone WOULDN'T appreciate having this inline. Do you think politics are some dirty thing that we should become amnesiac about as soon as someone is executing their duties...? Sorry, I'm just confused. Can you explain the foundational belief underpinning your comment?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoMany people (including myself and I assume the original commenter) feel that judging is supposed to be an apolitical duty. So saying "Randy Smith, also a Bush appointee," sounds problematic to me in the same way as "Randy Smith, also male" would: it's not false, but the mindset where it matters is deeply concerning.
- LordDragonfang 6y ago>judging is supposed to be an apolitical duty Supposed to be, but in many cases is not, which is why those details are important.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe problem is that emphasizing the details also feeds back into the politicization. It would be like responding to political bias at the DMV by having every clerk wear a little badge saying which party they are: there might be a few people who will use that information to better investigate and detect bias, but a lot of people are going to see the political labelling and conclude it's just a deliberately political function of government. And I don't think this is an abstract hypothetical; I've seen an increasing number of people in recent years dismiss even the aspiration to a nonpartisan judiciary as silly and naive.
- mortenjorck 6y agoThe article doesn't specifically mention the concept of parody versus satire, but it's instrumental here: The authors of the book wanted to make the case that their book was a parody, but the court essentially ruled that it was satire. A quick primer on the difference: https://lizerbramlaw.com/2019/03/06/fair-use-or-not-parody-vs-satire-in-copyright-law/ https://lizerbramlaw.com/2019/03/06/fair-use-or-not-parody-v...
- nkurz 6y agoThanks, I wasn't really aware of that distinction. I haven't read the decision yet. Do you have a sense of how important the distinction actually is in this case? I assumed the larger question was whether it was "transformative". For comparison, I was astounded by the decision that Richard Prince's work was considered fair use: http://www.artistrights.info/cariou-v-prince http://www.artistrights.info/cariou-v-prince. Quoting from that page (which I realize is just a synopsis and not a legal opinion): "In order to be fair use, a secondary use must transform the original by employing it in a different manner or for a different purpose than the original in order to produce a new expression, meaning, or message. A secondary use does not need to comment on or critique the original in order to be transformative as long as it produces a new message." Is this really less transformative than painting a guitar and some face paint on someone else's photograph? Given that both cases involved overturning the decision of a lower court, clearly both sides are arguable here. It makes me wonder if this is really just a Circuit split, with different standards in different regions. Is there a canonical Supreme Court case here with national precedent that would unify these decisions?
- kevinventullo 6y agoIt sounds like Prince’s work really had a different meaning than the original photograph, whereas the Star Trek “Go” had essentially the same message as the original.
- NoodleIncident 6y agoI'd be interested in seeing a meta-analysis of all of these fair use copyright cases. The only consistency I see so far is that the side with more money ends up winning. Seuss > crowdsourced star trek pictures sold for $8k total < paintings sold for $2M each
- anonymousiam 6y agoCorruption or influence from local industry isn't supposed to affect the decisions of federal judges, but it's hard to not notice the trends. Everybody knows that the place to file patent infringement suits is East Texas, and the place to file copyright infringement cases is San Francisco, because that's the place where you are most likely to win.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> the place to file copyright infringement cases is San Francisco, because that’s the place where you are most likely to win. I dunno, Oracle kept losing against Google in the case they in the Northern District of California (the district encompassing San Francisco), and kept having the get the Federal Circuit (in Washington, D.C.) to revive the case for them. If you mean to insinuate something about the court that actually ruled here (the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit), you don’t actually have to file in San Francisco, or even its judicial district, for that court to be in the appellate chain (the case here was filed in the Southern District of California), because the Ninth Circuit is the appeals court for normal cases (but not cases that ever had patent claims, which go to the Federal Circuit) for a wide area [0]. And it would be silly, because (1) I don’t see any evidence that the Ninth is particularly copyright maximalist compared to other circuits, and (2) to the extent that it has taken a hard position on copyright claims in certain cases, its often been portrayed as hostile to the music and film industry that is so powerful in the state in so doing. [1] [0] https://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/content/view.php?pk_id=0000000135 https://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/content/view.php?pk_id=00000001... [1] e.g., https://www.forbes.com/sites/schuylermoore/2019/11/12/the-ninth-circuit-is-tone-deaf-to-copyright/?sh=553127243eab https://www.forbes.com/sites/schuylermoore/2019/11/12/the-ni...
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoRobot Chicken should call their bluff.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- forrestthewoods 6y agoSeems like the correct ruling given the law. Maybe the law should be changed, but that’s a different issue. No one would give a crap about this if it didn’t mashup two extremely IPs. Should people be allowed to freely cash-in on existing IP? Maybe! Can they today? Not really no. I quite like many of the Sherlock Holmes remakes that exist. I’d love to see IP enter the public domain far far sooner. Seuss and OG Star Trek should almost definitely be public domain by now IMHO.
- mindslight 6y agoI'm no friend of copyright, but I've got to agree that this seems like the correct decision. The real problem is insane copyright terms making our cultural commons owned by private parties indefinitely. Twenty years (like patents) should be more than enough, especially as works under copyright protections are generally easier to bring to market.
- forrestthewoods 6y agoI’d go for something a little more tiered. First Harry Potter book came out in 1997. Do I think publishers or printing press companies should be allowed to sell Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone without giving Rowling money? No I do not. But I wouldn’t extend that past 50 years. And I might set compulsory licensing of some kind. Particularly for redistribution of existing work. I think some type of gradient between 20 to 50 or 30 to 50 makes sense. I also like the idea of having copyright expire after 10 years but require an increasing annual fee to extend. This would allow abandoned IP to recirculate but still give creators control over their work if it’s worth their time and money. I’d make the fee growth non-linear so that very few things are worth extending beyond 20 or 30 years. It’s a variant of “use it or lose it”.
- TylerE 6y agoAn idea I've always liked is a perpetually extendable copyright with rapidly escalating fees. E.g.... First 10 years are free The next 10 years cost $50 - Basically just enough to make it worth the time to process...basically a bozo filter for abandoned works) Years 21-30 cost $5,000. - Starting to cost real money, but not overly onerous to anything in active commerce. Years 31-40 cost $50,000 Years 41-50 cost $500,000 - Worth it only for highly lucrative works Years 51-60 cost $5,000,000 - You've got to really want it After that keep adding on zeros, I guess. I haven't really thought about the exact numbers. I personally have no problem with Disney keeping all rights to Mickey Mouse in perpetum if they write a billion dollar check every year for the privilege.
- newacct583 6y agoThis is a circumstance where I honestly believe a commerce determination needs to exist in fair use law (that wasn't the basis of the decision, btw). What happened here is that someone wrote a funny mashup based on a famous Dr. Seuss book with Star Trek jokes and sold it, as a book. Clearly there's transformative value here. The jokes look funny. But absent the original properies, there's no commercial value to this thing, so without Seuss and Roddenberry this book wouldn't exist anyway. I think it would be a much happier world if we could trade transformative jokes and memes on the internet with impunity, but still agree that there's a bright line between that and trying to trade on someone else's idea. Right now we end up on one side or the other: either we have to agree that sometimes good stuff needs to be banned entirely (imagine a world without Baby Yoda memes!) or we have to allow someone else to come along and "transform" our revenue sources for their own benefit (faceless corporations steal ideas just as often as they have them stolen!).
- Animats 6y agoBut absent the original properties, there's no commercial value to this thing, so without Seuss and Roddenberry this book wouldn't exist anyway. Exactly. The value is in the original properties. As an original work with new characters, it would flop.
- dmurray 6y ago> I think it would be a much happier world if we could trade transformative jokes and memes on the internet with impunity, but still agree that there's a bright line between that and trying to trade on someone else's idea. Isn't that the status quo? If you make a "Oh, the places you'll boldly go!" joke on HN, the Geisel estate won't come after you - or if they do, your post will be taken down after almost everyone who was going to read it has read it. If a million people make a million "Oh, the places you'll boldly go!" jokes on social media, maybe they'll come after the 10 most popular. If so, the world can live with the other 990,000. More likely though, they'll come after the 10 guys , the 10 guys selling T-shirts with the meme, who you already agree are fair game.
- newacct583 6y ago
- jrockway 6y agoI don't necessarily disagree with the legal opinion here, but I think copyright has gotten way out of control and it's time to remake these laws. It should prevent flat-out photocopying and resale of a book, but nothing else. If you draw your own illustrations for the text of some book -- have at it. If you invent your own scenarios involving the characters of a book -- have at it. If you invent new words for an existing song -- have at it. All of these things are under threat and probably completely illegal at this point, and I don't think that's where society wants to be in another 200 years. It might be time to rethink what people actually want here, and change the laws.
- jacobolus 6y agoI would be fine with authors retaining rights to such uses for 14 years optionally extensible to another 14. But the current effectively perpetual copyright regime (plus additional trademark rights over characters from copyrighted works) is a gross overreach.
- awinter-py 6y ago'parody' vs 'just a mix' will be a really important distinction in the next few years as people use generative AI models to 'auto cross' media, and claim that they have created something new / are in fair use territory I suspect this is an unanswered question in the case law, but absolutely not my area
- darepublic 6y agoAll I can say is -- where can I find a copy. Both the Star Trek one, and the Dr. Juice one.
- psalminen 6y agoCame here to ask the same. Quick search just brought up this news.
- tehjoker 6y agoIt'll be nice when we can finally get rid of copyright when the writers of a property are long dead. Looks like Dr. Seuss and Gene Roddenberry died almost 30 years ago. It's kind of ironic that Star Trek envisions a post-scarcity society where we can abandon pettiness like this and build on each others works and explore the universe while in the real world the petty owners of the copyright use the power of the state to prevent people from writing their own book using their own labor, creativity, and funds using characters from the 1960s or earlier. In effect, the copyright owners are saying: "We own the society and its culture. Do not touch."
- EvanAnderson 6y agoBut how will we incentivize Dr. Seuss or Gene Roddenberry to create new works if we don't "protect" their current works? /s (Don't even get me started about companies whose entire business is built on "monetizing" the public domain and locking it in a "vault"... >sigh<) Edit: I'm not anti-copyright. Egregious length of copyright term is my main beef. I think limited time monopolies (patents and copyrights) can produce a lot of good for society. The contract has to be favorable to both parties, though. Letting those who "own" items of "intellectual property" starve the public domain for too long, particularly when so many works end up being orphaned (and effectively unusable for anyone), is what I have a problem with. Right now the contract for copyright is too stilted in favor of the "owners", to my mind.
- floatingatoll 6y agoWould you consider this an acceptable first step? It is clearly a compromise, as it does not attempt to reform 'sale of rights' nor does it place works into the public domain until fifty years after they're created, but it explicitly neutralizes the ability to perpetuate and renew copyright through inheritance, transfer, or inclusion wrapping, while protecting against hacks such as modifying the law (as Disney likes to do), since those modifications could only affect future works, per the immunity clause. "When this law takes effect, the following terms are irreversibly assigned to all past and future copyrights, and in case of contradictions, these terms have ultimate precedence over all past and future declarations: Copyrighted works enter the public domain in the sooner of ten years after the death of all persons identified as creators of the work, fifty years after the creation of the work, and fifty years after the registration of the work; those works where no persons are registered as the creators shall enter the public domain in the sooner of ten years after the dissolution of non-person entities registered as the creator, thirty years after the creation of the work, and thirty years after the registration of the work."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 6y ago> ... McKeown, a Bill Clinton appointee, wrote. > Sammartino is a George W. Bush appointee. U.S. Circuit Judges N. Randy Smith, also a Bush appointee, and Barack Obama appointee Jacqueline Nguyen joined McKeown’s opinion. It makes me sad that the judiciary has become so politicized that most news outlets point out which president appointed a particular judge. The proliferation of this feels like a fairly recent development, but maybe I'm just biased.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoAmazing demonstration of how intermable copy right terms have enabled asinine rent seeking behavior.
- TRcontrarian 6y agoOh the Places You Go was first published in 1990 and is protected by US copyright for the life of the author plus 70 years. Dr. Seuss died in 1991 (OtPYG was the last book published in his lifetime) and so the book will remain under copyright until 2061. My problem with this ruling isn't that it clashes with my instincts, it's that it will continue to be enforceable halfway through the century.
- jrochkind1 6y ago"‘violent, sexual, sophisticated adult entertainment’ of Star Trek" Wait, what though? Sophisticated debataly, but Star Trek is not particular violent or sexual, is it?
- lostmyoldone 6y agoCompared to a children's book it is both, but compared to a lot of other TV-series with similar audiences, not at all. As the context is a bit unclear, I don't thing there's a straight cut answer here, but perhaps it's not unreasonable to think it's in comparison to the other literary work involved in the suit. With that other work being a essentially children's book, Star Trek - in comparison - is all those things.
- joeypickles 6y agoReminds me of the lawsuit brought against South Park by Brownmark Films over the recreation of their infamous video, also done in a faithful “side by side” manner. Interesting that the courts decided the opposite in that case.