17 ms·
Flanderization
- dontbeevil1992 6y agothis website is such an incredible compendium of wisdom and facts. how has this been accomplished?
- strombofulous 6y agoIt's a wiki
- klenwell 6y agoIt is definitely one of the internet's great rabbit holes. > how has this been accomplished? I always assumed it was user-driven like Wikipedia or Stack Overflow and that appears to be the case: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Flanderization?action=edit https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Flanderization?a... I think the wiki is one of the modern world's most underrated -- and underexploited -- innovations.
- eindiran 6y ago> I think the wiki is one of the modern world's most underrated -- and underexploited -- innovations. Agreed on the underrated front. But I feel like I interact with enough wikis that its not obvious to me that they are significantly underexploited. What is an example of a place where you think a wiki could be used to significant effect?
- chaosharmonic 6y ago> It is definitely one of the internet's great rabbit holes. There's incidentally an entry for those: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WikiWalk https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WikiWalk
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I always assumed it was user-driven like Wikipedia or Stack Overflow and that appears to be the case Interestingly, there is now an "official process" for getting a page created. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Administrivia/CreatingNewPages https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Administrivia/Creatin... I created a page a while back after reading the Wiki Magic page, which at the time described how a page might be created without much content and, if the community saw value in it, fleshed out by community members, as if by magic. The example given of the process was the Mega Neko page. All of that has been removed, along with the notion that it might be OK to just create a page and see what happens. But although the official process was already in place when I made my page, the direct process hadn't been shut down. I didn't even realize I wasn't supposed to. Coming back to something of a point, TvTropes, like Wikipedia, seems to have come around to the conclusion that user-generated content was valuable in the past, but they don't want more of it than they already have.
- nsajko 6y agoSimilarly as with Wikipedia, TV Tropes is a good source of interesting factoids, viewpoints, trope descriptions and examples; but, even more obviously than Wikipedia, TV Tropes suffers from a lack of editorial oversight: there are usually many unverifiable, nonsensical and/or false factoids per page.
- rektide 6y agoI refer to it as the great index of humanity. what is tv/cinema but a way of capturing & portraying the many foibled forms of humanity? trying to re-distil those many portrayals out into organized, trope-ic forms? pure gold. an index of all humanity.
- EamonnMR 6y agoIt's got no notability guidelines and no real verification. It's a free for all. Also it tries to be fun to read.
- emmanueloga_ 6y agoI wonder: * How many of the wiki authors are actually screenwriters or showbiz ppl? * How many pro screenwriters actually use this site for reference/inspiration?
- Apocryphon 6y agoThey're fandom people.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoThat doesn't stop them from being screenwriters.
- h2odragon 6y agoIt is the best current version of "the hitch hikers guide to Human Society"
- lmm 6y agoIt's a wiki that didn't get taken over by deletionists. Its original guiding principle was "there is no such thing as notability".
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoExcept, of course, when the trope or title be sexual enough that the advertisers might complain, then the “content policy” kicks in — which is of course really all about how pornography has no plot and thus has nothing to talk about, not at all purely about advertisement revenue, as was originally freely admitted. - The original statement: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Administrivia/TheGoogleIncident https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Administrivia/TheGoog... - The later historical revision: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Administrivia/TheContentPolicyAndThe5PCircuit?from=Administrivia.ContentPolicy https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Administrivia/TheCont... Of course, describing tropes that deal with graphic maiming, slavery, mass murder and all that deliciously family friendly matter that Google AdSense doesn't complain about, as the full might of the collective Soccer Mum has never been unleashed against such things, can carry on without incident.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gitgud 6y agoFlanderization, seems to be a result of appealing to a larger target audience. Nuanced characters just can't be quickly understood, so sitcoms unwittingly simplify characters to predictable stereotypes... Also, great site!
- toyg 6y agoI believe it’s more about available time. When you only have 20ish minutes to pack as many gags as you can, and the narrative setup is fundamentally immovable (i.e. episodes are entirely self-contained, there is little or no substantial continuity), subtlety will soon go out the window, and characters will become stereotypes who exist to trigger jokes. Also, that sort of narrative setup tends to accrete over the years: if you’ve seen Barney being the idiot drunk for 5 years, that’s where your mind will go as soon as he’s in the picture, even if he’s had the occasional redemption story (he’s a poet, moviemaker, etc).
- bcgraham 6y agoIt’s driven by the nature of jokes in a long-running medium. Jokes both require and create context; this joke’s punchline is that joke’s setup. If the setup isn’t rooted in the current context, it’s nonsensical. If the punchline is in current context, it’s boring. It’s easy for this process to feed back, especially with large casts of characters. I heard a writer once talk about “protecting” characters from some jokes, I believe to prevent a process like this.
- gwd 6y agoInterestingly, I feel like in "Big Bang Theory", the opposite happened -- the first few episodes, the characters were almost entirely a bag of stereotypical "geek" quirks; they slowly became more human as the show went on. I think I remember in an interview one of them saying that filming before a live studio audience actually helped with that -- you got immediate feedback about what the audience thought of the characters and the show; and people are just more interested in characters they can identify with.
- viraptor 6y agoI'm surprised that Monica from Friends is not there. It's amazing now normal she is in the initial episodes. But I get the case of doubling down on the traits over time like in Simpsons. They need to run for so many years you need both some kind of character change and still a lot of familiarity, so... let's make characters even more of the same. Different from Southpark with "we'll change what we want".
- rektide 6y agowhat did Monica turn into? no idea what her character was.
- cuddlybacon 6y agoThe bossy and neat-freak aspects of her character definitely ramped up across the seasons.
- Tenoke 6y agoJoey is my go-to example of this.
- viraptor 6y agoI can't remember this one... Did he get more clueless/gullible over time? Or getting more women?
- lambda_obrien 6y agoHe became the dumbest sentient being in the universe, basically.
- raverbashing 6y agoEspecially in the series switchover (from Friends to Joey). Even Matt LeBlanc had an issue with it.
- TheHypnotist 6y ago
- rektide 6y agoI feel like a lot of political elements in modern society are self Flanderizing.
- runawaybottle 6y ago‘All the world’s a stage, And all the men and women merely players’, once you find your role, you’ve got a part in the play. AOC is a good example in politics, suddenly everything coming out of her mouth is some truth bomb tweet espousing every cutting edge liberal perspective. A caricature, totally insufferable and not an ounce of nuance. She found her role and is playing it to the max. Weird, Trump found his role in the exact same way, and he never let off the pedal. Neither for a brief moment ever tried to think about anything they say from a broader perspective, it’s simply not their role.
- wpietri 6y agoSpeaking of self-Flanderzing...
- runawaybottle 6y agoI prefer to punch up with my self-flanderizing.
- monkeybutton 6y agoIt is an optimization process of sorts, no?
- MichaelZuo 6y agoIndeed, the tricky thing is what to do when we get stuck in sub optimal Nash equilibriums. Historically civilizations got out of that by having a sufficiently large external shock, but now for the first time ever we have a global civilization. Actually that dynamic seems to apply to all levels of this trope too, curious!
- dragonwriter 6y ago
- omarhaneef 6y agoAll the characters on that show got Flanderized. Simpson was kind of slow, Bart was kind of naughty, Lisa was kind of smart and they become extreme versions of those traits over time. (The article sort of alludes to this)
- trhway 6y agoone can also see that as a symmetry breakup process. The things getting caught in their potential holes/local minima, or an emergence of an attractor under the same map being iteratively applied many times, etc.
- peteretep 6y agoRunkle going from a very competent and slightly weird agent in Californication to a constant punchline is a crime against the character
- motohagiography 6y agoI read this as a trope that described a metonym for synecdoche, which by itself was impressive, but not sure if it was entirely intentional.
- gfxgirl 6y agoSpeaking of tropes, It's probably because I'm old and jaded but I find it gets harder and harder to enjoy many movies and TV shows because having watched so many I see the tropes. I think the most obvious pattern in many modern TV shows/movies is the musical interlude. You insert some famous pop song as 3 minutes of filler and try to transfer the affection for the song to the show. A recent example is in The Umbrella Academy one of the characters dances to "I Think We're Alone Now" by Tiffany. It is entirely superfluous. It's not a new technique. I recently watched Love Actually for the first time and it had at least 3 of these types of scenes. When they happen though I just tune out as my brain screams "you're being manipulated". They're filler. They're like "design by committee" or "marketing checklist". Related is the downbeat 3 minute musical interlude montage. Something disappointing to the character happens and then there's a downbeat montage of them brooding etc. IIRC Angel had 1 or 2 per episode but they're all over in modern shows.
- runawaybottle 6y agoThis happened to me after awhile, so I literally shifted to watching movies from a different culture. It’s all the same tropes, but delivered differently from a different cultural lens. Ip-Man 4 is just a hilarious version of Chinese exceptionalism (as opposed to American exceptionalism ((hilarious as in woah this how ridiculous our version of exceptionalism must look like to everyone else))), if you’re looking for an English movie to get an idea of what I’m talking about. 90s Bollywood is great if you want to see how equally ridiculous Indian version of romance/marriage is idealized (as opposed how Americans idealize/romanticize their conception of guy-gets-girl). The things they do really well are often pretty unique if you’re not familiar with their tropes. It’s very snobby and meta, but I can’t watch American movies anymore without getting bored.
- vidarh 6y agoIf you want Chinese exceptionalism, watch Wolf Warrior 2. I watched it in a theatre in London full of Chinese people, and it was a surreal experience, because to me it felt like watching a Chinese version of Hot Shots or similar crazy parody, but nobody in the cinema were laughing. I really enjoyed the movie, but it also shows Chinese filmmaking reaching the level of over the top patriotism you saw in 1980's US war movies. American studios eventually turned to mocking that, as in the aforementioned Hot Shots movies and others. I wonder when we get to see the same mocking of Ip-Man and Wolf Warrior by Chinese movies.
- umvi 6y agoThe comic graphic in the top right corner reminds me of Penny Arcade. Look how the main characters change over the decades: 1998: https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/1998/12/21/the-patch-parade https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/1998/12/21/the-patch-para... 2009: https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2009/01/28/further-songs-of-sorcelation-part-six https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2009/01/28/further-songs-... 2017: https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2017/02/15/the-latest-fissure https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2017/02/15/the-latest-fis...
- LukeShu 6y agoInteresting example, the visual aspects of the Penny Arcade characters have definitely been exaggerated over time, but the writing of the characters has been toned-back I think. Artwork: Some of this is Flanderization pure and simple, but I think some of it is that Mike's progression as an artist has allowed that to happen. In the early days if things were so exaggerated, it would have been sloppy; but as he's improved as an artist he has an increasing ability to exaggerate things and have it be stylized rather than sloppy. And so he utilizes that stylization to have the characters better emote. Writing: I think there are 3 parts to this. I think part of that is that they let more of their true selves through to the characters, and easing up on the invented personas. I think as the characters develop more "real" personas they don't have to lean as much on the initial defining traits of the characters. I think they've mellowed as they've grown up; once they were uber-hard-core and could spend 16 hours in a raid; now they have children and responsibilities (or put more in terms of the comic: These days there's a place in the comic for more casual gaming that did not exist in the early comic).
- alanbernstein 6y agoIt's credited in the article, but it's actually from subnormality, which is a great comic, if wordy. I recognized the style immediately. http://www.viruscomix.com/subnormality.html http://www.viruscomix.com/subnormality.html
- krebs_liebhaber 6y agoThis is only tangentially related, but I love that first comic. Without knowing when it was published, you wouldn't understand the joke, because that's now the reality for many triple-A releases. I think the world itself is getting Flanderized.
- basicneo 6y agoThe Big Bang Theory exhibited this quickly.
- allenu 6y agoIs there a general term for this sort of thing? It's like a Simulacra and Simulation kind of thing where over time, representations become symbols, maybe because it's "easier" and a shortcut to communication, and soon we've reduced things down so everything can only be described with few discrete symbols, making it difficult to have nuance discussion. Maybe I'm overthinking this or getting it wrong. I have not read Baudrillard. Perhaps I should.
- alanbernstein 6y agoIcon, in the abstract sense? E.g. "Icon: Any image used to represent a person, place, thing, or idea.", from Understanding Comics.
- Andrex 6y agoNever thought about it in quite this way, you may be on to something.
- steveads 6y agogood luck. I love Baudrillard's philosophy but had a hard time getting through Simulacra and Simulation.
- dvtrn 6y agoThis sums up some of my problems with the JJ Abrams take on/Kelvin-verse Star Trek, existing character traits seemed to consume the characters entire presences instead of being elements in parts that made up the whole. Kirk getting the worst of it, the risk taking, jovial and daring Starfleet officer who sometimes clashes with his superiors? Let’s just turn him into a total renegade who disregards authority and gets into bar fights while jamming to 20th century hip hop and end the trilogy with Kirk on a motorcycle...while jamming to 20th century hip hop. And I know: the movies were trying to give us younger versions of the crew but sheesh.. About the only character who seemed like someone who could even remotely come close to growing into the character of old was McCoy, and that’s probably just due to Karl Urban absolutely crushing the role—-even though I thought the scripts gave him almost nothing to do until the third movie.
- XorNot 6y agoJJ Abrams is a terrible storyteller who really only knows how to do nostalgia and mystery boxes. Everything he does is basically "remember this? Remember this thing you liked? Here it is again but I made it bigger and faster!"
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoHis "mystery boxes" shtick has gotten so old. It sort of made things interesting in Lost, but it seems like he keeps doing it, over and over again, in each of his films.
- CamperBob2 6y agoLost's final episodes were more like, "Box? What box? I don't see any box here. Who said anything about a box? What are you talking about?"
- namdnay 6y ago"it was a character study all along" no it bloody wasn't
- plibither8 6y agoFlanderization is so obviously employed in The Office. Characters get crazier or weirder over the seasons. Kevin was initially a slow guy, but understood everything and got things done. They ruined his character by turning him into a "stupid fat guy". Really bummed me out.
- haram_masala 6y agoIn some ways Dwight was un-Flanderized. He stopped being a hapless sycophant to Michael, and he started showing comprehension of other peoples’ feelings. Mellowing him out like that made him more relatable but ultimately not as much fun.
- plibither8 6y agoExactly. Character development is one thing, and I do appreciate it. But they way it was done in The Office seemed sort of off to me.
- brundolf 6y agoOther than Kevin (you're right about him), I feel like all the characters had several focal traits, not just a one-dimensional schtick. They definitely refined and brought these to the forefront over time (especially right after season 1), but I don't feel like they ever got flat. Also, a huge part of that show is the number of "main" characters, and seeing how those handful of traits among a large number of characters mix and mash and interact, both with each other, and in varying situations. I.e. Andy and Oscar may not be that complicated individually, but they hardly interacted until like season five and then suddenly got put in a situation or two together, which made for something fresh. That kind of thing happens constantly over the course of the show.
- plibither8 6y agoYep! The comedic cringe and the awkward, ludicrously brilliant situations were amazing, and very well written. One of the reasons why it's still one of my go-to shows when I have nothing to watch :).
- DoreenMichele 6y agoSit coms are really hard to do well for more than one season. The reason is in the name: It's comedy rooted in some situation, so you can't allow the situation that is the source of humor/drama to ever resolve or the premise for your show ceases to exist. This is why MASH was so long-running: The situation in question was The Korean War and the conflict between career military types and draftees who had hippie-like values and really didn't want to be there. This allowed for a lot of swapping out of characters when things went sideways. The TV show was based on the movie and over time Burns became increasingly toxic and crazy and they finally wrote him out of the show and replaced him with a character who could have some of the same inherent frictions with other characters without it being Flanderized into something really stupid and ugly and no longer actually funny. I've long considered writing a blog about the moral bits in MASH and/or other sitcoms. I sometimes think that might be a better outlet for my keen eye for social patterns than turning my baleful eye on actual people, which tends to be taken as extremely cutting. It's sort of an "occupational hazard" as someone who spent too much time in therapy and sorting my own crap to be at all socially acceptable for small talk with most people.
- Uhhrrr 6y agoThe situation might wear out, but if they do a good job, the writers and to some extent the actors will figure out the sweet spots in the characters. Also, a lot of useful context will get built up, which makes it easier to tell richer stories. I would say Seinfeld, NewsRadio, and Frasier are good examples of this.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoSeinfeld, NewsRadio, and Frasier I'm not familiar with NewsRadio, but both Seinfeld and Frasier are simply named after the main character. This inherently gives the show some latitude. But, say, Three's Company was based on the premise that this guy was pretending to be gay in order to justify living with two women because they all were pretty poor and he couldn't find another place. That's pretty constraining as to what you can do with the plot line. It means that any episode that was at the beginning holding out hope that one of the characters would suddenly start making more money and be able to afford to move or something was an episode where the viewer could confidently predict that this would fall through because if it didn't you no longer had a show with the premise that some guy needs to pretend he's gay in order to have an affordable housing situation where he lives platonically with two women. What's funny there is the tension of, no, they aren't having a threesome. No, he's not sleeping with either of the women. No, he's not really gay, but most people would never believe he's honest to god just living with two women to split the rent if he weren't pretending to be gay. It's funny because it casts some light on a lot of serious social issues in a way that's socially acceptable to poke fun at, but it's extremely contrived and you can't otherwise try to address those kinds of topics. They are too hot button. So you can't do it humorously without an extremely contrived situation and you can't do it in earnest without it being terrible drama. Humor is one of the ways society processes hot button topics and works through them without it turning into terrible real life conflict.
- brundolf 6y agoSlightly OT, but I find tvtropes.org as a whole totally fascinating. Partly it's having my eyes opened to the substructure that spans across our media, and partly it's just awe at how enormous and meticulously thorough this taxonomy of concepts is.
- ghayes 6y agoThe wealth of knowledge is unreal, however, I feel it's unorganized. For example, I wish I could see the most noteworthy examples of a trope, but often times you basically get a list of "In season 2, episode 6 of Avatar: The Last Airbender, Aang uses the phrase "dang" which is a euphemism"
- Veen 6y agoYour comment made me wonder if there was a more precise term for that type of euphemism. Apparently, it's called a "minced oath". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minced_oath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minced_oath
- Waterluvian 6y agoWhat they did to Flanders really sucks. He was a wonderful character. The Leftorium episode is absolutely heartbreaking, but gives Homer such an opportunity to redeem himself. Those fleeting moments of humanity and growth were my favourite part of Simpsons as a kid.
- ghayes 6y agoI'd argue the show has worked their way out of this trope in the recent 5 seasons or so. Ned Flanders in recent episodes has figuratively grown a backbone: he stands up to Homer, he remarries a woman with a colored past, etc. His character has certainly evolved (possibly with awareness from the writers of this specific trope).
- tomcam 6y ago> The trope is named for The Simpsons character Ned Flanders, who was originally depicted as a friendly, generous Christian neighbor and a model father, husband and citizen, thus making him a contrast to Homer Simpson. As seasons progressed he became increasingly obsessively religious to the point where he eventually embodied almost every negative stereotype of the God-fearing, bible-thumping American Christian evangelist. I bet this happens with a lot of Muslim characters too, right? Right? Because there’s definitely no anti-Christian bias in Hollywood. And no, I am not Christian, not by a long shot.
- mod 6y agoWriting a Muslim character into an American cartoon in 1987 would have been highly unusual, so I'm not sure it's evidence of a Hollywood bias.
- jessaustin 6y agoMaybe I don't watch enough TV, but I'm sort of drawing a blank on Muslim characters now in 2020.
- Slow_Hand 6y agoAs a counter-example of this phenomenon I think the character of Joe MacMillan from Halt and Catch Fire moved away from being a sociopathic manipulator with infinite charisma in the first two seasons and ended up as someone with sincere/honest intentions and genuine empathy for others without needing to exploit them for his goals. I was a little disappointed to see them tone down this aspect of his character, which made for some compelling scenarios in the first two seasons. Nonetheless I’m happy that they gave him a more nuanced arc, even if it did make for less captivating TV. Granted, the show is not a sitcom, so perhaps it’s not a great example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoThey sadly did the opposite with Alan Shore. In early appearances, he would blackmail, hide evidence, embezzle, extort, threaten his own clients into admitting their wrongdoings, taunt his superiors, and everything other. In later appearances, he's mostly a funny wisecracker with an inappropriate sense of humor.
- eloisius 6y agoOh my god. I love it when I learn there is a term like this that perfectly explains what I’ve been trying to say about things like why I used to love It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia. We get it, Dennis is probably a sociopath, Mac is gay and confused, Dee is desperate to mean something to someone, and Charlie is really dumb. But it was a lot more fun when all those traits were more nascent and only peaked out from behind their more normal personalities every now and then. Now I can predict how just about every interaction they have will unfold because they’ve found their formula and it’s all they do.
- martin-t 6y agoThe writers do this because people sometimes do this to real people too. Are you kinda smart and look/dress/talk the part? You're now "the smart guy" in many people's perception. Do you know how to sound authoritative regardless of actual knowledge/capability? People will gravitate towards of you as their leader. There's a downside too. Did you embarrass yourself a couple times? You're "the clumsy guy" for many people. Then how people treat you in front of others affects how others perceive you - similarly to how first impressions work. People are full of cognitive biases.
- watwut 6y agoThat is something completely different then the trope.
- martin-t 6y agoIs it? Your personality (how others view it) is simplified to its most defining traits and then that perception is gradually reinforced by how people treat you (consciously or not). Seems pretty similar to me.
- watwut 6y agoYes it is. Following does not happen: > Your personality (how others view it) is simplified to its most defining traits Instead, the more people know you, the more they perceive your other traits and the more complex opinion of you they have. > then that perception is gradually reinforced by how people treat you There is definitely such a thing as strong influence of various people on each other. But, it does not do flanders-like simplification to single trait nor does it persistently exaggerate that single trait all that much.
- samspot 6y agoYou are talking about main characters in your life, the people you are getting to know more over time. Ex: The Simpson Family Parent comment is talking about side characters, people you spend very little time with but run into somewhat frequently. Ex: Ned Flanders
- dajomu 6y agoI wonder if you could apply this to social media, but with outrage instead of funny? It'd be a good exercise to look at an outrageous personality's tweets over the years and see if the same thing happens as they slowly adapt to realising that saying worse stuff gets more attention.
- Gravityloss 6y agoIt feels like so much of what is done is very predictable, derivative or random. Ie not only music or television, but even real life. What if you were told Simpsons already aired an AI generated episode and nobody noticed. Or a talk show guest was not the real person but an AI version trained on past appearances. A lot of the stuff is quite formulaic. (That said, Simpsons is doing new things all the time)
- interblag 6y agoWas thinking about this recently in the context of Yoda in Star Wars. In the original movie he sometimes spoke in what has been dubbed "Yoda speak", e.g. "Speak backwards, I do" but I didn't get the sense that it was the form for the majority of his dialogue. Then it felt like it became a meme and, by the time that the prequels came around, this was the main way that he spoke, to the detriment of his overall character. Thanks for the magic of internet some amazing person has done the numbers on this: https://buydemocracy.wordpress.com/2015/12/18/yoda-speak-orig-trig-vs-prequels/ https://buydemocracy.wordpress.com/2015/12/18/yoda-speak-ori... TLDR; Empire: 22% Yoda Speak. Jedi: 33% Yoda Speak. Phantom Menace: 74% Yoda Speak. He seems to have become very much a caricature of himself during his pop culture hiatus between the movies. Many thanks for posting this and giving me a name for this phenomenon :).
- paleogizmo 6y ago(Slightly) related: See Poirot-speak. Unlike Yoda-speak or Flanderization it's not a progression. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PoirotSpeak https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PoirotSpeak
- paleogizmo 6y agoEDIT: While TV Tropes is an amazing rabbit hole, the article of Poirot-speak surprisingly gets it wrong. The key of course is mispronouncing or getting wrong common English words or phrases while having no trouble with more complex or esoteric ones.
- jfengel 6y agoOf course not. He's from Ellezelles. It's 30 miles from Flanders.
- scott_s 6y agoI have a personal theory where the character from 30 Rock, Tracy Jordan as played by Tracy Morgan, is an example of reverse Flanderization. In the first episode, his character has a breakdown and is wandering the Brooklyn Bridge in diapers swinging a fake lightsaber screaming “I’m a Jedi.” It’s hard to get crazier than that. Tracy stays crazy, but the novel stuff because his normality. In the mid-seasons, they have arcs where he hates partying and has never cheated on his wife - despite the image he has created that imply those things. He never becomes normal, but he starts out over-the-top. When a character starts there, sometimes showing normal behavior is more surprising than trying to be even more over-the-top.
- mjburgess 6y agoPerhaps this is just Flanderization of his humanity?
- armandososa 6y agoBefore clicking the title I thought "Flanderization" referred to another phenomenon I've noticed. Here comes a rant. I'm a christian protestant, have been a christian protestant my whole life and I live in Mexico, where being a christian protestant is not the norm. So I am used to the media making fun of me, or people like me and my family. At 40 it seems just normal, you know? "Ha! christians are so backward-thinking close-minded goofus people" is a recurring trope and even I will laugh if the joke is funny. I also recognize that a lot of the mocking is well deserved. People like that do exist and they do harm. But, recently I've been noting how Hollywood and media in general is bent on not showing any kind of positive representation of christians. Take the Tolkien biopic (2019) for example, where there's not even a passing mention of him being a Catholic and the great importance theology and religion had on his work and on his life. I'm now expecting the new Amazon LOTR series to tone-down or even subvert the obvious christian motifs of Tolkien own works. Another example is A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019), based on the life of Mr. Rogers. Like I said, I grew up in Mexico and I didn't know anything about Fred Rogers, but 15 minutes into the movie I was incredulous on how saintly the man was portrayed to be. Turns out he was not only a Christian but a presbyterian minister, something which the movie goes greats lengths to "hide". I'm not saying people should not make negative portrayals of christians (or any other religious group), but come on, wouldn't be great to have a positive representation of a christian minister who is good and kind and very anti-racist? I guess we'll never know.
- dghlsakjg 6y agoI think that it should be remembered that there are maybe a few things at play. 1. Christianity of some flavor is the dominant religion in the west by a huge margin. Media can make fun of Christians safely because it is punching up. Punching up is pretty safe. Pick on any other religion and you are punching down. Punching down when it comes to identity is pretty dangerous. 2. A minority of Christians loudly do very un-Christian things in the name of Christ. You won't see people making light of faith based organizations that feed the poor. You WILL see people making fun of evangelical ministers with private jets. I'm not a Christian or a bibilical scholar, but I have a hard time believing that Jesus would approve of a lot of the more right-leaning American christians.