9 ms·
CentOS dropped because it “was not [..] providing [..] usefulness to Red Hat”
- downrightmike 6y agoJust go debian.
- donmcronald 6y agoI wish there was something like Ubuntu’s LTS, paid support, and release cycle, but with plain old Debian as the OS. Ubuntu’s “innovation” has been negative value since the beginning of time. Oh snap!
- kwk1 6y agoThere is: https://www.freexian.com/en/services/debian-lts.html https://www.freexian.com/en/services/debian-lts.html
- pseudalopex 6y agoUbuntu LTS includes everything in main and restricted. Debian LTS includes whatever Freexian has funding for.
- joana035 6y agoI second that, and here are the reasons why choose Debian: https://www.debian.org/intro/why_debian https://www.debian.org/intro/why_debian Also, the most dependable docker images are Debian based, Google distroless image is Debian based, most single board computer's OS are Debian based, Tails, Kali, Ubuntu, all Debian based and the list goes on and on. It's the most mature and stable disto out there and is reference in the Linux world for more than 27 years. EDIT: ...and is more up-to-date than CentOS, I just checked and CentOS seems to be using an old/non-LTS kernel :/
- dathinab 6y agoMaybe not the most popular opinion but one company maintaining two stable server focused Linux distributions which mostly have the same focus seems to be quite a wast of limited resources (dev time for maintaining both). So it seems to be quite a reasonable decision. Through I'm also not a user of either of them so I might have missed some important differences between them.
- orev 6y agoNot really. CentOS was the “gateway drug” to get everyone hooked on the RHEL ecosystem, which they could then convert to paying customers. It also allowed many vendors free and fully compatible access to make their products for the RHEL platform. Now that that’s gone, the converting users will dry up, and the vendor software will dry up. By saying it was “not useful” to them, they really have an extremely limited and short-sighted definition of “useful”. It really should not have been such a huge extra effort to keep CentOS around in its previous form. RH is already building the packages for RHEL, and CentOS could almost be a side-effect of that process.
- dathinab 6y ago> CentOS was the “gateway drug” to get everyone hooked on the RHEL ecosystem There is still CentOS Stream. Which as far as I can tell is meant to have that purpose.
- Redoubts 6y agoThis raises the question, why acquire it to begin with?
- pjmlp 6y agoTo do exactly what they have done now.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> Maybe not the most popular opinion but one company maintaining two stable server focused Linux distributions which mostly have the same focus seems to be quite a wast of limited resources (dev time for maintaining both). This is kind of obvious. When RH bought CentOS, everybody was saying "They will kill it". But they didn't and said, "See? We are nice folks!" The problem is they got bought themselves and can't be nice folks anymore.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoSo why did they buy it in the first place then?
- tapoxi 6y agoIt's an easy way to acquire a ton of engineers that are incredibly familiar with your core product.
- orev 6y agoDo you mean customers, or the engineers building CentOS? There are only a handful of people working on CentOS.
- goatinaboat 6y agoSo why did they buy it in the first place then? Acquiring a competitor and shutting it down is standard SV business as usual. Just took a bit longer this time.
- tsjq 6y agosounds like dropping CentOS was IBM decision , coz they own RedHat now.
- geofft 6y agoBecause they previously needed it in order to do open-source work that was based on RHEL instead of Fedora, and because as a volunteer-run project, it was not being super responsively maintained. Here is a comment from a long-time Red Hat engineer explaining it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25351295 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25351295
- andylynch 6y agoI never quite understood this either. The original model where CentOS was not affiliated with red hat did though. Could an independent group do the same with the latest RHEL sources?
- thinkmassive 6y agoYes, see https://rockylinux.org/ https://rockylinux.org/
- zapita 6y agoThere’s Rocky Linux: https://rockylinux.org/ https://rockylinux.org/
- dspillett 6y ago> Could an independent group do the same with the latest RHEL sources? Yes. But there would be an up-front investment in effort and a slow start, as there was with CentOS itself. The people who started up CentOS and maintained it pre-RedHat will mostly be off doing other things (possibly within RedHat) so that particular source of experience is not likely to be available at all. You'd need to find enough people who are the right combination of interested enough, capable enough on the technical side, have access to enough hosting resource for it to be practical as a public project, and willing to do it for free (unless you can attract some sponsorship or other funding). Edit: as others said in replies while I was typing the above: it looks like a group has already started working on this, so you might be in luck.
- ofrzeta 6y agoAlso Lenix: https://blog.cloudlinux.com/announcing-open-sourced-community-driven-rhel-fork-by-cloudlinux https://blog.cloudlinux.com/announcing-open-sourced-communit...
- jldugger 6y agoI mean, it was confusing to see it owned by Red Hat, and these changes to effectively remove a RHEL substitute are surprising only in that it took so long.
- throwawaymanbot 6y agoMaybe its time to take opensource back from these Corporate Cretins.
- wcchandler 6y agoCool some useful new information. >>> a restricted free version of RHEL that will be announced sometime before the end of June Hopefully the restrictions are sane and appropriate. E.g. unlimited uses/installs, with full access to repos.
- Veen 6y agoIt says further down the article that the restrictions include providing names and email addresses to Red Hat and that the software can't be redistributed. Not really in the spirit of CentOS and open source.
- orev 6y agoThey have hinted at what it will be, which is essentially an expanded developer license that’s allows use only in limited ways. There’s no indication they will be releasing anything that allows wholesale replacement of production CentOS infrastructures with something officially RHEL.
- awill 6y agoSo Red Hat is promising a possible migration path for CentOS 8 users to some limited, restricted form of RHEL next year, but not announcing it yet? So they deprecate a product, and expect people to wait for an announcement that may or may not work for them? Who is making these decisions??? Why on earth not announce the free RHEL offering now. Or wait until those details are ready to deprecate CentOS 8. It sounds like some CentOS users might be able to migrate to some free version of RHEL, but it's unclear how restricted that free version will be. Probably good for home users, but how about medium or large businesses? And then, why should anyone even use a restricted RHEL when Rocky will be full RHEL for free.
- tyingq 6y ago"Red hat leadership" I imagine it's IBM leadership that decided this one. "It's unclear how restricted that free version will be" Probably not directly restricted. Just restricted in the sense that it won't be an LTS type distribution that matches RHEL's LTS product, package versions, etc. That was the value prop for CentOS.
- IntelMiner 6y agoDidn't IBM put Red Hat in the CEO chair some time ago after the acquisition?
- tyingq 6y agoNo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arvind_Krishna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arvind_Krishna
- rwmj 6y agoFormer Red Hat CEO Jim Whitehurst became IBM's president.
- goneri 6y agoYes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Whitehurst https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Whitehurst (not CEO but President)
- AntiImperialist 6y agoCentOS was acquired by RedHat because it was eating into their market. So, I'm sure that many customers who have been using CentOS just because it existed have no problems upgrading to RHEL because it's such a small part of their budget that it doesn't matter. Meanwhile, CentOS did serve a purpose and those who absolutely don't want to upgrade to RHEL or are looking to start out without a subscription will be looking at other providers such as Project Lenix or Rocky Linux. I think this could have been handled better by IBM. They've made a complete mess out of this by introducing CentOS stream and dropping CentOS. There is value in keeping non-paying users in your own ecosystem. Canonical handles it pretty well.
- sitkack 6y ago> There is value in keeping non-paying users in your own ecosystem.
- arbitrage 6y agopotential value in the long-term. but real liability in the near-term. if the company doesn't want to, or thinks that it can't tolerate that risk over whatever the difference between near & long is, they'll cut the liability loose. to me, this hints at instability in the market and IT sector, which, c'mon, we already know about. so it's likely more of an admission that times are tough, and RHEL/IBM is looking out for themselves.
- sitkack 6y agoSo RHEL is un-differentiated enough to be a commodity provider that doesn't need freeloaders?
- busterarm 6y agoI think of it maybe a little differently. CentOS was acquired as a marketing tool to sell support contracts. RedHat was acquired by IBM because selling support contracts no longer works as an open source software business model. It was a rescue operation (on both sides), really. In a twisted way, it's a success story for OSS. The software is so good and its main users so competent that the support contract has moved from being the value to the value-add. (aside) Unfortunately, this is the same thing driving the adoption of all of these new split licenses, which I don't think is a positive direction. (aside): This is actually the second demonstration of this. The first was when Rackspace got rid of its world-class support organization in a race to compete on costs.
- rubyist5eva 6y agoUbuntu or SLES for Enterprise, Debian for everything else. Red Hat really foot-rocketed themselves with this move to me.
- mrweasel 6y agoHonest question, because I’d love to know: are you actually a paying Redhat customer and a CentOS user, and is CentOS the reason you’re a Redhat customer? I’m asking because I get the feeling that there isn’t much overlap between CentOS users and paying Redhat customers.
- watwatinthewat 6y agoWhere I work there is a bit of overlap because some projects want the dev environment to match the final environment, and Red Hat is basically the only player in the game for prod in government. I can see this pushing some projects to pay for Red Hat for dev machines versus take the risk of having a separate dev environment. Where that isn't a concern though, it will push devs over to Ubuntu (the only other Linux flavor I've seen around here) probably, and quickly the friction in government against non-Red Hat Linux flavors will drop. As an example of that friction, last I looked Red Hat published themselves guides and scripts to get CentOS stig'ed to the level we need here, while neither Ubuntu nor anyone else had automated it.
- rubyist5eva 6y agoI, personally, am not a paying customer but I work for people that are using RHEL for _everything_. I would spin-up CentOS VMs for other things just because I am familiar with RHEL. Now that that way of working is essentially dead, I have no reason to recommend or use RHEL in any capacity.
- tsjq 6y ago>Under Red Hat, the project was directed by an independent governing board and many of CentOS's head developers were Red Hat employees, working apart from RHEL developers as part of the company's open source and standards team. As part of the agreement, Red Hat took possession of CentOS's trademarks. Embrace >CentOS itself was not actually providing that much usefulness to Red Hat Extinguish
- syshum 6y ago>> project was directed by an independent governing board Of which the majority were / are RedHat employees so not really independent at all
- qz2 6y agoPerhaps they got some ideas when they cozied up with Microsoft a while back...
- chasil 6y agoOracle appears anxious to "embrace" the CentOS community. Hopefully, the "extend" and "extinguish" are not on the agenda. The old notice: https://linux.oracle.com/switch/centos/ https://linux.oracle.com/switch/centos/ New blog: https://blogs.oracle.com/linux/reasons-for-switching-centos-to-oracle-linux https://blogs.oracle.com/linux/reasons-for-switching-centos-... New repo conversion script, works with CentOS 8: https://github.com/oracle/centos2ol https://github.com/oracle/centos2ol Free updates available indefinitely. For those who desire paid support, there are several (yearly) price tiers ($119; $499; $1,199; $1,399; $2,299).
- jsty 6y ago> Hopefully, the "extend" and "extinguish" are not on the agenda. There are certain organisations whose prior behaviour precludes "hope" from a reasonable set of expectations. Whether or not Oracle is included is left as an exercise to the reader.
- EvanAnderson 6y ago
- Brian_K_White 6y ago"Look, just because the terms under which we got the bulk of our product stated that 'You can have this, and build upon it, and even sell it, and all you have to do is make it available for the next guy same as you got it yourself...' and we agreed to those terms, that doesn't mean we can actually tolerate a bunch of parasites mooching off us."
- playcache 6y agoI have been vaugely following this and I am likely going to get it in the neck here, but this seems to be people are upset that they can no longer run their commerical business on something for free, as the other business providing the free thing were getting nothing in return, so they want to change it so that at least get something back in return (which is still not monetary, but help fixng bugs).
- Delk 6y agoWell, RHEL consists of open source software. While not all of that software is copyleft, it has AFAIK always been part of the reality and the very premise of Red Hat that someone else can take that, too. If a community project itself stopped providing what it has been providing for free, people would probably be disappointed if they had started relying on what was provided. They might also become wary of relying on community-supported projects. But they would probably not be upset in the sense of being angry. Most people wouldn't feel entitled enough for that. I think what makes people upset in this case is that Red Hat sort of adopted the project, giving it a home, and then stopping to provide what that project had been providing for people outside of Red Hat.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoPretty much. I see CentOS on tons of commercial virtual and network appliances in enterprise environments that bring in a lot of revenue, but Red Hat doesn't see any of it. I'm not shocked if Red Hat sees little value in powering major commercial distributions for free.
- strenholme 6y agoI have no problem with companies saying “if you want this, you have to pay”. I have a problem with a company saying “It will be free, with full security updates until 2029” ( https://archive.is/7Qmtw https://archive.is/7Qmtw ) then turning around and saying “Just kidding, it’s only going to be supported until the end of 2021”.
- waspleg 6y agoThere are famous short-seller investors circling IBM for exaggerated earnings projections. Redhat could very well end up in someone else's hands sooner than later.
- airstrike 6y agoHonest question from a layman: what happens with the AWS-flavored CentOS now that the upstream distro was dropped?
- arbitrage 6y agoShort term: Amazon pays licensing fees to RedHat to keep the product going, if necessary. I don't know if they're at that stage yet, and big companies can have whatever arrangements they would like between them behind the curtains. Long term: Amazon develops a new Distro unbeholden to RedHat/IBM. Only a matter of time.
- QUFB 6y agoNo, they just buy Canonical.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoSwitching from an RPM distro to a Debian derivative is a much bigger jump than building from RH sources directly.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mikl 6y agoNot too surprising, considering how container-based hosting (Kubernetes and friends) are taking off. The market for old-school all-inclusive Linux server distributions is bound to shrink, and it makes little sense for Red Hat/IBM to have two of them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- overgard 6y agoNot defending RedHat here, but in practical terms doesn't this just mean switching to Rocky linux when it's time to upgrade? Presumably Rocky will have a year to prepare a migration path.
- strenholme 6y agoI spent the entire weekend updating MaraDNS’s Docker testing container to run Ubuntu 20.04 instead of CentOS 8, and am in the process of replacing all of my CentOS 8 machines with Ubuntu 20.04 LTS machines. RedHat flat out made a pinky promise that CentOS 8 would be supported with security updates until 2029: https://archive.is/7Qmtw https://archive.is/7Qmtw I installed CentOS 8 on my home network (a non-trivial task) with the understanding things would still be secure in 2029. RedHat broke their pinky promise: CentOS 8 will no longer be supported after 2021. That in mind, while I have been using RedHat since the dot-com days, I am now a Ubuntu user. Breaking a promise like this is non-trivial, and I have stopped using RedHat as a result. If RedHat had said “We’re not going to release CentOS 8” or if they had said from the beginning “CentOS 8 will only be supported until the end of 2021”, I would be singing a very different tune right now.
- LeSaucy 6y agoIn the same boat, but after this lesson I don't think I can even trust Canonical to not do something drastic. Debian is looking to be my CentOS replacement.
- rualca 6y ago> Debian is looking to be my CentOS replacement. To me, Debian sounds like it should be hands down the de facto standard for production environments. It's rock solid, and it sets the bar on reliability.
- ossusermivami 6y agoI agree! i use CentOS streams because i need some sort of redhat environment for my customers, but if i had the choice or if i have to do some opensource work, i would choose Debian over anything else....
- op00to 6y agoChristoph Galuschka maintains that wiki page you reference. Does he represent Red Hat? If not, how does a community member “pinky swear” and Red Hat is now on the hook?
- jlawer 6y agoI am thinking this might end up hurting Red Hat more then many people think. I worked at Red Hat in global support in the RHEL 5/6 era and the developers were very opinionated and the dedication to Open Source amongst developers especially was almost cult like. Many developers were brilliant, and it wasn't uncommon to hear that they took the role with Red Hat earning substantially less then their previous roles so they could have 20-50% work time dedicated to their open source project. Also Red Hat would be fairly flexible and many worked offsite, so were able to have a cheaper cost of living. Many times these open source project wasn't even part of the RHEL / paid offerings, however it was obvious that management liked having a team of brilliant engineers on the book to throw at troubleshooting serious issues. When the largest customers would have a serious ongoing problem, they would often demand these engineers, who would often be thrown in a room with engineers from all the other vendors to "Fix It". I wonder if these people are going to start to leave and need to be retained at higher salaries. If this would then cause a loss of talent that will affect the ability to support those highest value customers. If this ends up costing Red Hat more in the long run.
- ossusermivami 6y agoAfter a bit of "anger" I finally switched over to CentOS streams and can't be more happy with it. I guess it's wait and see how things are going to pan out, i have the luxury to be able to afford some downtime if things are not working well... I was suggested to try Oracle Linux, but I will always trust more Redhat than Oracle..