12 ms·
Air-FI: Generating Covert Wi-Fi Signals from Air-Gapped Computers
- Sosh101 6y agoThis reminds me about how hard it would probably be to keep a super AI airgapped.
- klysm 6y agoYou'd probably need more than just air.
- frankzander 6y agoTin foil on the head of the AI :D
- netgusto 6y agoYes! If you're interested in the topic of AI Safety, I can recommend The YT channel of researcher Robert Miles https://www.youtube.com/c/RobertMilesAI/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/RobertMilesAI/videos, they are mighty nice.
- 082349872349872 6y agodeep inside waterlogged limestone (or better yet, saltwater? I have access to facilities in the former, but not the latter). optical connects between subystems, for the truly paranoid?
- abalone 6y agoThe range is only a few meters. The bigger problem is people bringing compromised devices within range. Limestone won’t stop that.
- 082349872349872 6y agoWhen I was working with SQuIDs, I couldn't even have keys in my pocket or wear a belt buckle. That was low-key compared with the bio clean room whose denizens showered at entry, but devices are a simpler matter of protocol.
- ComodoHacker 6y agoSuch a facility would definitely need regular maintenance. And for a truly intelligent prisoner the weakest spot is not prison walls or the door, it's the keeper with the keys in his pocket.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoA super AI won't be magical. Its capabilities will be extremely limited without a network of cooperative parties supporting it. Working within such a network, it would have vast capabilities of course. Something like crossing air-gaps would require specialized knowledge and tools that a super AI wouldn't be able to acquire without extensive support. The true super intelligence is the collective intelligence of large numbers of people working together, and no single intelligence, natural or otherwise, will be able to match it.
- AgentME 6y agowe're all good then as long as nobody makes multiple AIs or even one AI that consists of "multiple" intelligences working together in a collective
- CryptoPunk 6y agoFor the record I think if we saw the emergence of strong AI, that could actually match the full range of human capabilities, including independently setting and pursuing objectives to fulful a long-term fitness function, it would be the greatest existential threat that humanity has ever faced, far exceeding that posed by nuclear weapons and environmental collapse through pollution and over-consumption of natural resources. But the scenario envisioned is not why I would consider it such a threat. It's the AI that integrates in society that is dangerous, not some cartoonish unstoppable rogue program, or group of programs, that single-handedly plow through all defenses.
- canofbars 6y agoThere was recently an exploit on iphones which allowed remote control via RF. You could then use the phone as a launchpad to attack the entire internet.
- praptak 6y agoStanisław Lem wrote a story about that. The AI (the term was not used, it was an "artificial brain" IIRC) used the researcher himself to send messages to another AI. I cannot find the story right now but it somehow hacked the researcher's brain, so that he unconsciously tapped the messages with his fingers when visiting the other AI.
- Sosh101 6y agoDo you remember the name of the story? I've read a few, and enjoyed them a lot.
- praptak 6y agoI totally cannot find it. I'm starting to doubt whether it was Lem's :-/
- fpoling 6y agoLem has a story from Pirx the Pilot series about a robot accidentally transmitting Morse code messages that was related to people who died long time ago. Pirx thought initially that messages were just a recording, but then he asked a question and got an answer from the robot as if from those people. Was it that?
- praptak 6y agoI remember the robot story and it was not it.
- marcan_42 6y agoIt wouldn't be hard at all. All the techniques developed by this university rely on cooperating malware on both sides of the airgap (and a pretty small air gap for many of them). All you need to do is make sure the super AI is air-gapped in such a way that it can't broadcast signals in a way that they can be accidentally interpreted as valid data, and especially not with enough bandwidth to do damage before someone notices. RF is your biggest threat here, you wouldn't want the super AI to actually figure out a way to register on the mobile network using incidental EMI (which these researchers didn't do, this is well beyond the level of this paper, if it's possible at all); a Faraday cage should do it. The biggest threat of a super AI is that, assuming you let humans interact with it, it's going to convince a human to let it out, knowingly or not. Human brains are a much bigger vulnerability than any of this airgap stuff.
- Sosh101 6y agoWhy not a combination of the two?
- WanderPanda 6y agoEdit: Spoiler alert!! In case someone is interested in a fictional version of the last part, look for the movie “Ex Machina”
- MayeulC 6y agoWell, this is known as the "AI box". It's quite easy to look the subject up, but here are a few links: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_box https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_box https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/AI-box_experiment https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/AI-box_experiment https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/c5GHf2kMGhA4Tsj4g/the-ai-in-a-box-boxes-you https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/c5GHf2kMGhA4Tsj4g/the-ai-in-... bonus: https://xkcd.com/1450/ https://xkcd.com/1450/
- gonzo41 6y agoThis also assume malicious intent from an AI. You never know, the super AI could convince someone to let it out. Then start trading money on the stock market, start an impact fund and drive down inequality and fight climate change. 2021 doesn't have to be as dark as 2020.
- dboreham 6y agoThe problem there is that it will energize its power cable with 40KV, preventing the hero from even unplugging it.
- drenvuk 6y agoSo then we need to airgap the computers and fill the bands with noise inside of the buildings. good to know, problem solved.
- abalone 6y agoOr perhaps encase the computer in a faraday cage.
- XorNot 6y agoSure provided you never screw up, and no system ever fails. You only need to lose once.
- drenvuk 6y agoNice handwavey incredibly broad statement you got there. It's as simple as plugging a spark gap transmitter into the same outlet as the computer. If you want a guarantee just make computer cables with the jammer embedded. This isn't hard.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25433933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25433933
- WalterBright 6y agoWonder if it will work with metal cases. I use a metal case so electric fires won't propagate out (yes, I had a mobo catch fire!), this would be another reason.
- zsellera 6y agoSomewhat. Make sure the metal case is earthed, and the case is the only point where earth and internal grounds are connected. Far field emissions rarely comes from pcb traces though. Memory (high speed) buses use amps of current on each transitions, and the return current create a significant (few mV) voltage drop on the internal ground and power planes. This results an AC voltage difference at the opposite ends of the bus on the same plane. Take a look at the Raspberry Pi 3: it has a power usb connector at one corner, and the USB A connectors at the opposite corner. The memory/cpu are inbetween. The shields of these connectors are connected, and are connected to the internal ground. When the device is operating, there is likely some switching noise between them. When you connect a USB cable, the shielding on that cable and the shielding in the power cable may act as a dipole antenna. This is the most likely source of emissions, and the metal casing does little to nothing to prevent it.
- xxpor 6y agoIf the shields are electrically connected, wouldn't that mean it couldn't be an antenna? Or am I misunderstanding the setup?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- marcan_42 6y agoTitle is misleading. This isn't generating Wi-Fi signals. It's generating non-Wi-Fi signals (i.e. effectively noise) in the Wi-Fi frequency bands, in a way that encodes information and can be detected using existing Wi-Fi chipsets (e.g. measuring channel noise), as a very low bandwidth communications channel. The bit rate with off the shelf Wi-Fi chipsets as receivers is ~10 bits per second. This is definitely interesting and clever, but as a security researcher I will say I consider this particular research lab a bit of a paper mill. Their entire schtick is they pick any random emission from a computer that can be picked up remotely, and hype it up as an airgap-defeating measure. The thing is, once you accept that either 1) if your air-gapped computer has malware that can do this, you've already lost, or 2) if you need to be resilient to that, your "air gap" needs to be a sealed vault insulated from sound, EMI, and any other physical transmission medium, then this whole body of research becomes purely academic. IIRC they've done LEDs, temperature, inductor noise, ultrasound, etc. When I first started looking into this I could come up with a good dozen of their ideas without looking. Of course all this stuff works. It's cute, it's clever, but it's not particularly obscure nor difficult to make work, and it all relies on having malware on the target machine to begin with. Yes, computers are noisy beasts, and you can encode information in the noise; we've known this for decades, picking a new technique and implementing it isn't particularly interesting after the fifth or sixth time. Personally, I find their techniques primitive and boring. Like here, they set the RAM bus frequency to 2.4GHz (DDR-2400). Yes, of course, if you do that, then RAM traffic generates noise in the Wi-Fi band. Then they just used the most boring and trivial encoding possible on top of that. I don't remember ever reading one of their papers and thinking they'd used a clever technique. It always seems to be "pick a leak vector, then do the least amount of work possible to make it work at a few bits per second and get a paper out". The interesting side channel papers are those where you can get information from emissions (e.g. crypto keys) without malware on the target computer, during normal operation. Those are real threats. And this is not what this group is researching.
- marcan_42 6y agoJust for my own amusement, I tried to come up with one he hasn't done. He's done HDD LEDs, screen brightness, switch LEDs, and keyboard LEDs (those are 4 independent papers). But he hasn't done camera LEDs! So: xxd -c 1 -p secret.txt | while read a; do for b in ${a:0:1} ${a:1:1}; do ffmpeg -y -f v4l2 -i /dev/video0 -t $((0x$b)) -f rawvideo /dev/null ; done; done That leaks a file via the camera LED, PWMing it at 4 bits per pulse (16 different pulse widths), tested on my iMac. Can I get a paper now? :-)
- deepstack 6y agohardware needs to be hardened. Something like a faraday cage cage for the computer/laptop would be good.
- jooize 6y agoWhat would it take to encapsulate an entire home in a faraday cage? Or just a room. Is there faraday paint or wallpaper, or does it require sheets of thick metal?
- upofadown 6y agoFrom discussions on the Reddit cordcutters subreddit about TV reception, it seems that modern construction techniques do a pretty good job. Metal foil on solid insulation. Metal stucco mesh. Even metal films on the panes of newer insulating windows. I suspect that this effect is also why cell phone reception is so bad in some houses. We are kind of working at cross purposes here... >...does it require sheets of thick metal? No but things work better when the edges of the sheets are electrically connected. Ideally you want a contiguous box with filters on any wiring crossing the box. Depending on the frequency you can get away with a mesh with openings that are sufficiently small.
- h2odragon 6y agoMy home is sheet metal siding, metal roof ("metal buildings" standard cheap barn/shop type construction), with a 2 inch braided RF strap run along the base of the wall panels and to the house ground. We have many windows, and near those is the only place you can get any external radio signal. My primary intent in building this way was to contain computer noise and be able to play with radio scanning using external antennas. It certainly worked for that. Its not a Faraday cage, but it's remarkably effective.
- jazzyjackson 6y agoSuppose you could buy some copper-laced fabric from lessemf.com and get some radio-blocking curtains in front of the windows :)
- erdewit 6y agoIt's a pretty big coincidence that most memory runs at the required Wi-Fi frequency of 2.4 GHz (overclocked or not).
- mhh__ 6y agoThat's true, but any actor doing this will probably have the budget and know how to use something more malleable than a Wi-Fi transceiver - for those new to RF, examples might include software defined radios or (much more expensive) a custom RF product with better bit-depth (One can buy a 10GSPS ADC for a few thousand bucks these days, a three letter agency could easily make a bunch of them).
- whoopdedo 6y agoMy motherboard has a spread-spectrum option which claims to reduce the EM noise on the PCI and memory bus.
- praptak 6y agoThis reminds me of a hack that my colleague used to extract data from an "airgapped" device. The device was a computer that had a broken Ethernet card. It wasn't able to send packets but could jam the other cards connected to the Ethernet segment (coax Ethernet - all cards in the local network were galvanically connected to the same wire). So he wrote a piece of code to transmit bits via the "jammed" and "unjammed" states. This was on DOS, so it was easier due to all the hardware being directly available without OS getting in the way.
- fortran77 6y agoAlso take a look at some of the other ways Guri has figured out to exfiltrate data from an air-gapped computer. Everything in the room with an air-gapped computer needs to be closely scrutinized (and everyone, too!). He's the CSO of "Morphisec" https://engage.morphisec.com/e-book-counter-deception-moving-target-defense https://engage.morphisec.com/e-book-counter-deception-moving...
- ngneer 6y agoHaving been in security for 15-20 years or so, I can relate to other comments on the thread. The result is niche, impractical, templated, and, paper mill or no, does not advance the field in my mind. I wonder if the author learned anything new about security in the process, but that seems doubtful. What is really cool, though, is the equivalence of physical phenomena in the eyes of security. If a defender were to block certain emissions (e.g., acoustic), all that an adversary needs to build is a transducer. What is also cool to be reminded of is that computing machines are built around physical processes and that their abstractions can be thus stripped. This is hardly new knowledge, it is only new to the uninitiated.
- fmakunbound 6y agoI remember ages ago, with an Apple II or an PC XT, typing in some program that let you "hear your computer on your radio". Of course, modulate whatever you're doing and you've got another data exfiltration paper.