29 ms·
Great! I love night trains. For distances of around 1000km, they are effectively the fastest way. Imagine two transports: - "fast", which can be a plane or h
by GuB-42 6y ago
Great!
I love night trains. For distances of around 1000km, they are effectively the fastest way.
Imagine two transports:
- "fast", which can be a plane or high speed train. Travel time is around 3h. The plane is faster but with getting in and out of the airport, boarding, etc... it takes almost the same amount of time in the end.
- The night train, travel time 9h, let's say from 10pm to 7am
You want to get to your destination at some time in the morning.
With the "fast" transport, you have to get up really early and take the first train/flight. Expect a short night, and it may not even be possible without arriving late. The other option is to travel the day before in the evening and book a hotel, not ideal either. In any case, you will spend 3 active hours of your day for travel, or sleep 3 hours less.
With the night train, you have a good night sleep (generally, sleeper trains are comfortable) and didn't waste the best part of your day. And you may even save a hotel night.
Think of it as a traveling hotel.
- Tomte 6y ago> Think of it as a traveling hotel. With privacy (alone in compartment) and a non-shared toilet and bathroom?
- drran 6y agoYes, if you can afford it.
- tpm 6y agoYes I took a night train trip from Vienna to (I think) Göttingen (final destination was Kassel) last year and was able to have a single compartment with bathroom all for myself. It was pricey but not pricier than a flight from Vienna to Frankfurt and then a train from there to Kassel, because low-cost airlines don't fly this route.
- GuB-42 6y agoIt is possible but expensive. But the kind of night trains I used to take, no. But that's because I was cheap. I even took regular, non sleeper night trains. Sleeping on seats is not as good as on beds but much than on planes or buses. These tended to be really cheap. One interesting thing they did in France was to run high speed trains at low speed through the night (iDNiGHT). The idea was to get an extra "free" slot. Really cheap (I think I paid something like 10€ for a ~900km trip) but not the most comfortable. Still managed to sleep. I liked these but few people did, so they cancelled the service.
- roywiggins 6y agoI took a cheap sleeper train across Germany once and the sleeping surface was essentially unpadded. I don't know if this is normal- maybe everyone brings their own?- but sleeping on an upholstered plank (billed as a "couchette") did not make for a restful night. I don't think I slept at all. The joke was that I had a sleeping pad with me, but I didn't dare try and dig it out of my pack in the dark cramped shared compartment.
- morsch 6y agoI usually use a thin (cotton/silk) sleeping bag because I can't be bothered with the provided linens. No sleeping pad, and I don't think I've ever seen anyone use one. I think the padding is fine, it's certainly not unpadded. The more expensive compartments do have more comfortable beds.
- gpvos 6y agoYes, couchettes are differ a bit in hardness, but not everyone can sleep on them (I can about half of the time); in other languages they're called "lying-down cars", as opposed to "sleeping cars", where you get a proper mattress. I've never seen someone use a sleeping pad on top, but you could definitely try; I have thought of doing that too but not tried it yet. It would be easier if you get on a bit earlier in the evening, or the starting station.
- coddle-hark 6y agoIt’s not that expensive, we had a private cabin going Florence - Munich for about the same price as a hotel night. That was with a shared bathroom but we had a sink in the room.
- iso1210 6y agoCertainly that's the case on the London-Scotland sleepers.
- jnxx 6y agoWhy do you need that? Are you alone when you travel in a plane?
- Tomte 6y agoI'm alone in a hotel room. That was the frame of reference.
- Kyro38 6y agoonly downside, very few have double beds. (Only twin beds with one over the other).
- jvvw 6y agoI'm laughing at the 'good night's sleep' bit! After a lot of sleeper train travelling (mostly in Europe but also Russia and China), I still sleep incredibly badly on them and have had times where I have arrived exhausted but not able to check-in to my hotel for hours.
- flemhans 6y agoSame experience, walking around Lviv at 7am, until I finally had to buy a hotel room just to get a 2-3 hours of good sleep and then check out again. They must have thought we booked that room as a "love hotel".
- inglor_cz 6y agoI took several night trains in my life (Prague-Warsaw, Prague-Tatras, Wien-Venezia, Prague-Frankfurt) and while the experience is interesting, the shaking movement of the train underway plus the freaking loud station loudspeaker announcements whenever you arrive somewhere resulted in very bad sleep. 2-3 hours at most.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoAlso short beds. I'm not freakishly tall, so the bed was missing just a few centimeters, but combined with the other factors you mentioned it wasn't a great time.
- tasuki 6y agoDo you always sleep with your legs stretched out?
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoCome to think of it, I actually do. But of course if you don't then you won't have problems with the length of the bed.
- codethief 6y ago
- auganov 6y agoHow many such routes are there in Europe? Checked a bunch and seems like 9 hours is a decent timing even for the fastest train option. While by plane you're always looking at something under 2 hours.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoDoes your flight include all of your travel time? I mean, I can be at the train station fairly quickly (10 minute walk): The airport is out of town and I'd take a bus - an earlier bus than I think I need just to be safe. Does the flight mean that you get a hotel that you could skip on a night train? How long are you waiting at the airport? Airport time isn't just flight time.
- auganov 6y agoThe main point is the ideal night train scenario as per grandparent comment could be rare. Checked a number of possible 1000km routes [0], most were over 10h. Found just one that took 8h, Paris - Berlin. And these are not night trains. The night train for Paris Berlin seems to take 12 hours. I traveled a relatively short distance by plane recently and the airport time+location overhead was just about 1 hour (got from one house to my other house in 2 hours with a 1h flight). And the train would have about 20 mins of overhead. So the effective overhead was more like 40 mins in this specific case. Of course it could be much worse for many routes. But probably mostly under 2h even under very unfavorable conditions. So you're looking at 3-4h by plane. [0] and was being pretty generous by only checking western europe too. In many parts of Europe buses can be faster than trains.
- lmm 6y agoBerlin is the end of that route, so the arrival is a bit later than ideal - Paris to Hannover (say) will be more conveniently timed. Maybe the ideal pairs are 800km rather than 1000km, but there's quite a few of them - I've done London-Glasgow, Paris-Munich, Munich-Budapest, Paris-Rome, Turin-Salerno. Even if it does end up being 10 or 12 hours, it can still be more convenient than a night flight in terms of "can I finish work here at 18:00, have a decent dinner and a good night's sleep, and be ready to start work here at 09:00" - that's the question that actually matters. > got from one house to my other house in 2 hours with a 1h flight That sounds pretty exceptional. 45 minutes is usually given as the minimum time to go through airport security, since you have to allow enough time to not miss your flight if you do get pulled out for some reason (or be prepared to sometimes miss your flight, I guess). Airports are usually about an hour away from anywhere in the city you're going to. So I'd say 3 hours' overhead is the norm, and it gets worse if you're trying to fly after a day's work because the transport system of the place you're going to is usually shutting down by the time you arrive.
- bluGill 6y agoProblem is you need a destination that is 7-9 hours away. There are not a lot of those. Europe doing away with customs inspections at all the borders made it possible.
- itsangaris 6y agoIn theory it would work well in the US as many major cities are spread roughly that distance from one another.
- DominikPeters 6y agoThere are a few city pairs that are linked by Amtrak overnight, for example Pittsburgh->Chicago, Buffalo->Chicago, Omaha->Denver, Flagstaff->LA, Salt Lake City -> Reno.
- jnxx 6y agoAs an aside, I used Amtrak to travel from Rochester, NY to NYC and it was totally weird when I asked people in Rochester (which has a population of about 200,000) for the train station. Most people literally didn't know where the train station of their city was! And it turned out to be as small as a regional rail or European sub-urb S-train stop. Only two platforms with no people on it.
- estaseuropano 6y agoFor context: medium sized European city will have anything from 12-30 platforms - and often several main train stations and several dozen local ones in the city. E.g. Brussels, Paris or Berlin have several huge stations.
- matkoniecz 6y ago12-30 is a bit overkill. Kraków, Poland with 780k inhabitants has "only" 10 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=18/50.06881/19.94768&layers=T https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=18/50.06881/19.94768&laye...
- muro 6y agoI was traveling by night train twice a week for multiple years in early 2000s, Vienna to Bonn, Cologne and other places in Germany. If I could afford to fly, I would. It got me to the destination, but I never learned to fall into relaxing sleep - the day after the travel was always bad. Still better than taking a bus.
- muro 6y agoThe best sleeping train experience I had was from southern Thailand to Bangkok. The whole car was one big compartment, but it was surprisingly clean and comfortable.
- jtakkala 6y agoI've done Surat Thani to Bangkok in a first class sleeper, and indeed recall sleeping blissfully. One of my most memorable train journeys.
- cure 6y ago> Still better than taking a bus. A lot better! I once took a UK overnight bus from Birmingham to Inverness, it was a horrible experience. Night trains are absolutely lovely, by comparison.
- RLN 6y agoI did Amsterdam to London by bus overnight once. From memory via Rotterdam, Antwerp and Lille. It was appalling but really something to be experienced. The next day was a write off but I suppose we didn't help ourselves with pints on the ferry and arriving just in time to wait outside Wetherspoons for it to open. I can't wait for Europe to reopen and travel in a more civilised manner!
- switch007 6y agoIt's a shame there are no premium coach services in the UK, like the Spanish ALSA Premium or the Argentinian Executive Bed/First Class Suite services
- 6y ago
- freeflight 6y agoThere's also the environmental angle where trains are generally way more efficient [0] in terms of emissions per passenger, particularly compared to plane travel. [0] http://ecopassenger.hafas.de/ http://ecopassenger.hafas.de/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emteycz 6y agoDoes this count in the building and maintenance of railroad and the movement of all the maintenance/support/construction equipment (-> super-heavy diesel trains) etc?
- itsangaris 6y agoI doubt it, but if that’s the method of comparison then you’d want to include the building and maintenance of the airport.
- emteycz 6y agoNope - I didn't ask to include train stations. You can include runways only. I have no idea about the numbers, but it wouldn't surprise me if including building the railroads and maintenance would make plane and (electric) train equal. You don't want to know the amount of diesel smoke that's coming from the nearby railroad reconstruction. I wonder where could one find this data
- Asraelite 6y agoWhy would you include railways and runways but not train stations and airports? It's not possible to create a new destination, add additional capacity to an existing destination, or maintain existing capacity without additional costs to all major parts of the infrastructure, for both trains and planes.
- 6y ago
- makapuf 6y agoI'm on the nightrain, I love that stuff I'm on the nightrain, an' I can never get enough I'm on the nightrain, never to return...
- waihtis 6y agoIn case someone is interested, the ”nightrain” referred to here is actually a cheap brand of alcohol.
- dheera 6y agoYES! I love night trains and I travelled all over Europe and China with them. I've travelled probably at least 100000km on night trains. As much as I love high speed trains I hate it when a night train that eats zero of your daytime gets taken out of service and gets replaced by a high speed day train that eats half of daytime.
- jnxx 6y agoYou are perhaps of a different generation. In the 1980s, it was possible for young people in Europe to get a all-in-one ticket where you could travel as much as you could for four weeks in the summer. The tickets costed about 250 €. It was a bit a thing that defined my generation. People who traveled on budget did meticulous time-tables to spend as few nights as possible in paid hostels, traveling to Paris then to Vienna to Athene to Rome then to some small place in Portugal and so on. Returning hungry, exhaustauted and longing for a good shower but with bright eyes and full of experiences, meeting unknown people, made many new friends, and seeing a nice bit of the continent. It is perhaps one of the reasons why my generation defines itself as Europeans. And it is utterly painful to me that my young niece and her generation, at least at the moment, can't do it.
- iso947 6y agoCovid of course has caused all sorts of issues but that’s an odd thing to find utterly painful compared with everything else. There’s always next year.
- koyote 6y agoThey are great for weekend trips and you're absolutely right about relative time saved. A trip I've done several times is London to Edinburgh. It's a quick flight and even a quick train during the day but if you want to spend Saturday and Sunday you'd have to get up early on Saturday to catch a plane or train which would get you in by noon. Instead you take the Caledonian Sleeper on Friday evening and arrive in the morning in Edinburgh, ready to start the day. Although you won't get the absolute best night's sleep, if you come prepared (sleeping mask + ear plugs) you'll get a very decent night's sleep (better than having to wake up early on Saturday). It's also fun going to sleep and waking up somewhere different!
- dan-robertson 6y agoThe Caledonian sleeper is a funny one because the trains got to fast so the train now just stops in a siding near Edinburgh for a few hours to let people sleep and continues a little later in the morning
- joking 6y agoBarcelona - Seville did the same, as it went through the high speed rail network, and I couldn’t sleep during the stop because the absolute silence, meanwhile while it was moving I sleeped very well. shame that they closed the line, I recall boarding at 9, having a nice dinner on the restaurant, and sharing the bunk with my girlfriend. Then, waking up, taking a shower in the smallest posible bathroom and be ready to visit the city.
- andrewshadura 6y agoA night train from Bratislava to Prague spends most of the night on a siding in Břeclav.
- gpvos 6y agoThe one from Malmö to Stockholm arrives at 6, but you can stay in the train until 7. Ideal.
- AndyMcConachie 6y ago
- bigbubba 6y agoEven Amtrak's coach class is a hundred times more comfortable than flying coach. I'd sooner spend ten hours in a train than two hours on a plane and try to do so whenever I have a chance (which is not nearly as often as I'd like.) Not getting molested by the TSA is a huge bonus.
- dheera 6y agoYes this, and also, it's such a pleasure to just cook food at home or visit the supermarket and meander over to the train station and eat it on the journey. No restrictions on liquids/gels, and you aren't restricted to expensive crappy airport fast food. Restrooms on Amtrak don't make you deaf. No stupid food carts blocking the way to the restroom. Even on parts of the world that have food service on trains, the carts don't block people from walking past them. You can walk the entire length of the train whenever you feel like for exercise. Turbulence is not a thing on trains, and there's much more space to get from the window seat to the aisle without needing to crawl over a stranger's lap. Also, there's scenery almost the whole way.
- mcv 6y agoSomehow I'm completely unable to sleep in a plane. Even when it's a 10-hour trip to the other side of the world. Train is by far the most comfortable way to travel. Maybe ship too; I don't have a lot of experience with that for long trips.
- tacostakohashi 6y agoHow are you flying to the other side of the world in 10 hours? Obviously not on a passenger airline, do you own some kind of supersonic aircraft?
- kingofpandora 6y agoYou win the I-take-every-statement-literally award for the day! Congrats!
- 6y ago
- cassepipe 6y agoCould not agree, only trick is : Get yourself some earplugs.
- marton78 6y agoI regularly take the Berlin - Budapest overnight train. Usually it's lovely, but now during Corona times it's an absolute nightmare. There are no sleeper trains, because something something infection, so you get to sleep in normal compartments. Also, the train passes through five countries. Normally you don't notice, but now they'll wake you up at every single border too look at your passport, say hmmmm and then let you sleep again.
- nunja 6y agoYeah the way we are travelling right now in Europe is absolutely not what it used to be. Reminding a whole generation (mine and beyond) that nothing is granted.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoIIRC during the migrant crisis the passport controls were also reintroduced for quite a long time.
- HelenePhisher 6y agoNo, this is definitely a COVID scenario. There have been spot checks in the past because of the high number of refugees but this was back in 2015 or 16. Took a sleeper in February this year, crossed four borders, no checks at all.
- JAlexoid 6y agoSpot checks happened all the time. I had my passport checked once crossing from Austria to Italy on a train, in 2003.
- skrebbel 6y agoYou got me nerd sniped, I count Germany, Czechia, Slovakia and Hungary. Which is the fifth country? :-)
- andi999 6y ago
- agf 6y agoNow imagine the consequences to people's travel decisions when you can do this for any two locations within, say, 500 miles of each other, because you can sleep in your self-driving car while it takes you there. Not just locations linked by train. Wilderness areas, second homes, minor tourist destinations of all kinds. It has the potential to totally change the economies and usage patterns of those areas. I live somewhere that's just far enough from the major east coast population centers to keep weekend traffic down. But when sleeping in a self driving car is a reality? We're talking 100 million people who can spend a weekend here easily. It's going to change everything.
- ghaff 6y agoThis sort of thing may be further out than many here think. But it will absolutely change the equation when a 2-3 hour each way day trip or a 5-6 hour each way weekend trip is practically effortless. (Not sure about 500 miles but definitely distances that aren't easy today.)
- baq 6y ago500 miles of highway/autobahn/autostrada is definitely possible, i'd say even with 2020 tech. i fully expect a long-distance self-driving passenger van/minibus service in the next 5-10 years - get on on a park&ride close to a highway, get off in the morning 500 miles away in a park&ride, take taxi/uber/train to the city center. even better if my own car could do that - it'd make road trips on vacation so much better.
- rmason 6y agoIn general I agree, but there are exceptions. I was taking a night train from somewhere in Germany to Nice, France and the conductor put me on the wrong car. I woke up somewhere in Italy. They were good about it and got me re-routed. But I ended up on this extremely slow train that was filled with high school students. Then I spent hours in the Bologna train station which I got to know extremely well ;<). It killed an entire day!
- riffraff 6y agoI like night trains, my issue is that while traveling in Europe they're consistently more expensive than a low cost airline.
- dijit 6y agoBut, cheaper than a hotel+flight. Which is the real comparison.
- riffraff 6y agoit really depends on the routes and specific fares, even ignoring the availability of early morning/late night flights or existing accommodation in place (when I visit friends and relatives I don't pay for lodging). For example, suppose you want to visit Budapest from Rome over the weekend[0]. If you fly out this Saturday, the flight is €10, you arrive at 10AM. If you want to whole day, you can fly out on Friday, for €23, and find accommodation for €45, totalling 68 euros[1]. Traveling by train is sadly way more expensive. Consider instead Berlin -> Budapest, it's €10 on Friday, direct, with Wizzair, but >100€ on Saturday with stops. The train is both cheaper and faster! [0] this is where I live and where my family lives, the route I fly most often [1] prices are from skyscanner, airbnb
- Leherenn 6y agoThat's a general issue with trains, the infrastructure costs are massive and don't scale very well compared to planes.
- phillc73 6y agoNot a night train, but a reasonably random journey I just looked up. Christmas Day, Graz (Austria) to Munich. 5hr 57 minutes. 1 change in Salzburg. €26.90 one-way. The same journey at decent times in the afternoon on Christmas Eve only increases to €36.90 - €46.90. Seems pretty reasonable to me! In general, the trick is to book in advance to make use of Sparschiene prices. Or if a frequent traveller, buy a yearly rail card, which offers the equivalent Sparschiene all the time.
- japanuspus 6y agoOne of the really revolutionary effects of self-driving cars would be that you could always travel like this. Have a lunch appointment 2 hours away? Get in the car at 9, bring a book or some work and tell the machine to take a scenic route. Need to cross the continent? Bring the sleeping bag to the car and let it roll. Edit: hyphen.
- madaxe_again 6y agoThese are the same arguments I make in favour of airships - I can see people preferring a slower transoceanic trip in much greater comfort than a jet affords. Also, sky cruises. The cruise industry is going to need one hell of a hook to recover from this year’s PR hell.
- fumblebee 6y agoCouldn't agree more. Though I've taken only a single night train in my life: from Beijing to Xi'an. While slightly pricier than flying, I had a bed and could freely move around the cabin. To top it off - anecdotally, though intuitively it holds - those who travel by train are less stressed than those travelling by plane, and therefore friendlier and open to conversation. A great experience overall. I hope to do more of this in Europe.
- fivecountries 6y agoDid the same trip, just the other way, in 2010. Clean, comfortable, cheap (comparing to night trains in Central Europe). Couldn't get much sleep though, because as the only European in the car, so many people wanted to chat with me. And we were all very slow in looking up in the dictionary.