5 ms·
It's easy to come onto HN and dismiss something like this. If the EU agreed to count emissions from China there would be something else to complain about. This
by maccard 6y ago
It's easy to come onto HN and dismiss something like this. If the EU agreed to count emissions from China there would be something else to complain about. This is a huge move, and by itself it's not enough, but that doesn't mean it's not worth doing. It's also likely that an agreement like this is a required precondition of enforcing this with trading partners.
The actual implementation of this will likely be a little from column A and a little from column B, and will likely have a positive impact on the current situation.
- dudul 6y agoIs it really a "huge move" though? I feel like we've seen something like that once or twice a year for the past decade at least.
- oseityphelysiol 6y agoI supposed what's different from previous announcements is now that we're to see somewhat more tangible deadlines, not "30 years in the future" which will likely never happen. It would be nice to plan for an even shorter amount of time, 5 years for instance, so that people announcing these goals are actually accountable if they're not reached, but it's a nice start.
- toyg 6y agoGlobal polices take time to bubble up. Say you get a local authority to agree to something (news), then multiple ones (news), then the entire state (news), then multiple states (news), then a continent-sized entity (news), then multiple continent-sized entities (news), then all entities (news). That's a lot of announcements for what could be, in practice, a single policy. When the problems are as many and as interlocked as this particular one is (involving emissions, energy sources, level-playing market issues, etc), you will have a multitude of agrements and initiatives, which will feel "multiplied" through news channels.
- pydry 6y agoAdded to which, China can be dealt with via restructuring a trade agreement provided there is the political will. Which it looks like there is. The fact that this plugs one hole in the sinking ship and not two is hardly evidence that it's crap.
- maccard 6y ago> The fact that this plugs one hole in the sinking ship and not two is hardly evidence that it's crap. This is a much more eloquent explanation, and I am saving this for the future. This is exactly what I meant.
- mamon 6y ago> Added to which, China can be dealt with via restructuring a trade agreement provided there is the political will. Which it looks like there is. Except EU is already too weak to force China to do anything, and by moving carbon-intensive production outside Europe they would be giving China even more leverage...
- patrickk 6y agoChina is highly dependent on the EU and the US for trade. The EU is the biggest trading bloc in the world. The EU has a lot of leverage. The problem is that China trivially buys off a single member state to nix things like this from happening, as the EU must agree unanimously on these matters.
- mamon 6y ago> The EU is the biggest trading bloc in the world. That recently changed: https://www.dw.com/en/asia-pacific-nations-sign-worlds-biggest-free-trade-agreement/a-55604659 https://www.dw.com/en/asia-pacific-nations-sign-worlds-bigge... > China is highly dependent on the EU and the US for trade This is double-edged sword - EU and US are dependent on the imported goods. if the trade between China and the rest of the world stopped China would end up with abundance, and EU would be in serious trouble, not being able to buy basic things they need. Always better to have some real stuff than virtual money.
- LunaSea 6y agoIs it a huge move in the same way the Paris agreement was? Because it turns out that not one single country managed to hit the targets that were set.
- titzer 6y agoFirst, could that be because the accord was signed in 2015 and its emissions targets are in 2030? Second, countries set their own emissions targets. So it's more of a gentleman's agreement. Third, it's also false. At least 50 cities are on track [https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/dec/11/paris-climate-agreement-54-cities-on-track-to-meet-targets https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/dec/11/paris-cl...]. In fact people track who is naughty and nice and there are some countries making good progress and still on track [https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/2019/09/climate-change-report-card-co2-emissions/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/2019/09/clima...].
- jogjayr 6y agoIndia is hitting their targets.
- burlesona 6y agoWith any policy there is a serious risk of unintended consequences, however. If this policy does not explicitly include trade, there’s a real risk that European companies will lose in the market as their products are more expensive compared to high pollution imports, or they’ll be forced to move manufacturing to locales where they are permitted to pollute more, both of which are bad for the EU and the world.
- londons_explore 6y agoThe people want green policies. The people vote in the politicians. The politicians tend not to last more than a few years. The fact that many industries (and associated jobs) will migrate outside the EU by the end of the decade is a tragedy for the EU, bit isn't on the minds of either the politicians or the people right now.
- foepys 6y ago"Will somebody please think about the economy?!" We will run this planet into the ground until there is nothing left but at least the stock market will be healthy.
- deburo 6y agoThe economy is the biggest concern of any country. The actual solution is a economically viable path to green energy, not "let's just migrate everything and ignore the cost", because people (particularly in poorer classes) will revolt otherwise (or elect the other, more fiscally responsible party).
- bryanlarsen 6y agoThis policy is probably a necessary precondition for including trade. It lets them negotiate from the moral high ground.
- beervirus 6y agoFrom the mora high ground, but economically from a weak position. “We’ve cut our emissions and are importing a lot of your gadgets. You should cut your emissions too, so that we can stop importing your gadgets.”
- whiddershins 6y agoTo be fair the ‘let’s just import everything from China’ column has been getting the majority of entries in recent decades. If done wrong, the regulation just becomes a forced offshoring and willful destruction of national industry.
- georgeplusplus 6y agoToo say this is a prerequisite to bring negotiations to the table so that partners like China will have something to match, well to that I say, just look at how good that did in the USA or Australia.
- standardUser 6y ago"It's easy to come onto HN and dismiss something like this." So easy that it happens every single time, like clockwork. There seems to be a cross section of people who eagerly confuse blanket cynicism with thoughtful analysis.
- calkuta 6y agoI find the criticism of this policy to be poignant.
- disown 6y ago> It's easy to come onto HN and dismiss something like this. It's easy because the EU and european countries have a history of virtue signaling. Like how they are so great at recycling by sending their garbage to china. https://www.thejournal.ie/ireland-plastic-waste-3786393-Jan2018/ https://www.thejournal.ie/ireland-plastic-waste-3786393-Jan2... Norway is such an amazing "green" country. https://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Energy/Oil/Production/Per-capita https://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Energy/Oil/P... Pretty much everything from environment to human rights, the EU and europe are the most destructive and yet pretend to be the best. If the EU cuts emissions by 55%, it just means that they are going to ship their emissions to china, ASEAN, india and eventually africa in the next 80 years. That's it. I highly doubt they are planning on lowering their standard of living by 55%.