25 ms·
Brave Introduces Brave Today, the Privacy-Preserving News Reader
- jb1991 6y agoBrave today, gone tomorrow.
- kristerv 6y agoI think they are spotting a trend. Not one I'm a fan of, like the newsfeed to the left of my homescreen on my Pixel phone.
- isaacremuant 6y agoYou can disable that. It's not intuitive but once you do, you're so much better off without that kind of constant spam of very low quality. Then you can just use an RSS reader like Flym which works just fine and access the websites that you want when you want it with a mobile browser.
- byte1918 6y agoI wish browsers would stick to being browsers. 'Brave Today' could easily be a website, PWA or a plugin that I can happily ignore.
- jansan 6y agoYou can ignore Brave and use Lynx.
- WillYouFinish 6y agoBecause the modern web runs on Lynx.
- lionkor 6y agojust write a little GET request and do it manually, then you print out the html source code and interpret it by hand. It's how I do it, and it's far superior to Lynx. Lynx is just a multitool, not really good at just GETing and rendering.
- jlkuester7 6y agoI agree with the spirit of your comment (web browser != news feed). However, in this case I think the whole value-proposition of Brave Today is that it is not just another web site. Meaning that instead of needing to compile a sketchy privacy invasive cloud-profile on a user in order to surface relevant content, since Brave Today runs locally it can make the decision locally about what content is relevant to the user (based on the local browser data) without having to send anything to a centralized service. > The Brave Today news reader ranks stories locally for the user from hundreds of popular RSS feeds using an algorithm that weighs several factors, including the user’s browser history and article published date. Ideally, though, I would like to see this implemented as a browser extension or something like that that can be added/removed as desired.
- tobyjsullivan 6y agoIf this is actually the motivation - that Brave believes web sites are inherently bad because they cannot run locally - then Brave sounds like a web browser with a serious identity crises.
- jonathansampson 6y agoIt's not that web sites are inherently bad; it's that the browser is able to protect the user in ways websites cannot. Brave has local access to information about you; websites do not. Even if you were to give over all of your data to a website (why would you?), you now have to worry about that site sharing it, losing it, selling it, etc. With Brave, the data is on your device; cursory network scans confirm that it doesn't flow outward either (see https://www.zdnet.com/article/brave-deemed-most-private-browser-in-terms-of-phoning-home/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/brave-deemed-most-private-brow...). It's much better to do this as a feature locally than as a third-party service remotely.
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoI would argue that corporate surveillance dystopia exists precisely because everything is done in the cloud. While I agree that browsers should just be browsers, but your newreader app should be a separate desktop app that is just a newreader app.
- ljlolel 6y agoOne of the best things about reader and hacker news and twitter is really fast loading of top news. This also preserves the relationship to the reader while blocking nuisance ads and still compensating news agencies while preserving privacy. Bravo brave!
- asar 6y agoI would like really like if news aggregators somehow indicated paywalls to users before they click. Reading and searching for news these days is incredibly frustrating. I understand that quality media comes at a price, but it's sad to see where things are headed...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crankyadmin 6y agoWhy is it pegging the CPU out at 100%? Right... I've had enough now..., back to Netscape I go!
- Number157 6y agoNo no no. I'm tired of everyone pushing their opinion pieces everywhere. I use browsers to find information that I want. I don't want the browser to become a vehicle for others to push their views on me. F* off.
- visarga 6y agoCorporations don't want to let users decide for themselves what to see. Google ranks pages (decides what to hide), Twitter and FB do the same with feeds. Advertisers infest any corner of the net, like cockroaches. Political parties buy targeted ads in huge amounts and generate tons of self serving press to put into our feeds. We need to put the filtering / ranking function back into our hands. We need a browser that can learn our preferences and enforce them, while protecting our privacy as well. Ad block lists are a start, but they only filter ads and don't re-rank the feeds.
- permo-w 6y agoA customisable search engine would be great too. I would love the ability to: Permanently block Quora and Pinterest from any results Choose how to sort my results. Why doesn’t google have that? Have the option to prioritise forum pages Have a clear choice between getting generic results and personal algorithm results
- pedro2 6y agoThe decision process on Brave Today sounds to be (mainly?) local. You need the filtering processing to be local and visible but you can't win the fight by avoiding all filtering. IMO what makes sense is manually curated sources for your knowledge area and the rest machine-picked for you to read and retain a general knowledge of the world.
- zby 6y agoI want others to push their opinion pieces on me - this is the only way to get out of my bubble and learn new stuff. But yeah - the problem is whom can I trust with such a power.
- ashleshbiradar 6y ago
- hijklmno 6y agoWhy the negative perception? If you don't like it, turn it off. I switched to brave 4 months ago after trying all the available ones (Chrome - memory and power hog, Everything else – no good app store). First use it, before you review it! Duh!
- user-the-name 6y agoBecause Brave has a long history of very questionable business decisions, and is not really trustworthy. They have collected donations on behalf of people without the consent of those people, they have secretely added affiliate links, and they are deeply involved the incredibly shade business of cryptocurrencies.
- ketamine__ 6y agoThey made some mistakes and took responsibility. Consider that Brave is taking on Google with the GDPR. That's pretty cool.
- user-the-name 6y agoThey absolutely did not take responsibility properly. They dragged their feet, they argued and argued that they were doing nothing wrong, and them finally reluctantly changed things when they could find no other way to weasel out of it.
- mthoms 6y ago>They absolutely did not take responsibility properly. They dragged their feet, they argued and argued that they were doing nothing wrong, and them finally reluctantly changed things when they could find no other way to weasel out of it. This is not only a lie, it's a particularly egregious one. And very easy to verify. Original tweet (2:36 AM Pacific, June 6 2020) https://twitter.com/cryptonator1337/status/1269201480105578496 https://twitter.com/cryptonator1337/status/12692014801055784... Response from Brave (10:00 AM Pacific, same day) https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1269313200127795201 https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1269313200127795201 It took them all of one whole business hour to respond. One hour. That's absolutely unheard of. The above just goes to show how eager some people are to spread FUD in a blatantly dishonest and malicious way about certain things they oppose. It blows my mind.
- lebaux 6y ago> The Brave Today news reader ranks stories locally for the user from hundreds of popular RSS feeds using an algorithm that weighs several factors, including the user’s browser history and article published date. What "algorithm" you ask? > We’re using Brave’s new private CDN to fetch RSS feeds anonymously via the browser and the browser’s personalization capabilities to rank the headlines for users with a simple algorithm that will make the experience interesting for everyone. This seems like spying... with extra steps. In the meantime, Vivaldi added good old, classic RSS reader (and email client). To their experiments[1] (not affiliated). Brave might be great, but it feels like Crypto AG[2] spinoff. https://vivaldi.com/blog/vivaldi-mail-technical-preview https://vivaldi.com/blog/vivaldi-mail-technical-preview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_AG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_AG
- notahacker 6y agoNot sure there are necessarily third parties involved, but given Brave's track record of lying about not tracking users (whilst actually inserting affiliate links onto websites they visited and collecting revenues and data from them) as well as lying about donations they solicited going to the parties whose name they solicited them in, I don't see why any privacy-conscious person should trust them
- ketamine__ 6y agoAffiliate links were in the address bar and not injected into the webpage. You are spreading lies.
- byte1918 6y agoYou are correct and it's equally as awful.
- boogies 6y agoEqually as harmless. The affiliate codes don’t give anyone any information that they don’t already have (if you’re one of whatever tiny fraction of users edit their user agent strings, why the heck would you choose to accept the the URL suggestions‽ And if you really care about strict privacy, why would you use a Chromium-based browser in the first place, when invasive features have been discovered in Chromium’s codebase long after they were added before?). The sheer stupidity of the toxic FUD people spread about Brave makes me angry in its behalf (despite never using it beyond a test run myself).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 6y agoSomewhere far down the page it says that somewhere down the line we might be able to add our own RSS feeds :/ Not really interested until then.
- CharlesW 6y ago> …it says that somewhere down the line we might be able to add our own RSS feeds Even then, what this really means is that when you "add an RSS feed", it'll be added to Brave's back-end system so they can continue to own the distribution. This demolishes the creator/consumer relationship, which is an incredibly sleazy thing to do to content creators. Imagine the HN outcry if Chrome worked the same way, and could no longer fetch web pages directly. I will personally never use a so-called news reader that inserts itself as a centralized middleman between myself and everything I read.
- jonathansampson 6y agoWhat do you mean by "own the distribution"? Brave passes the content through a privacy-respecting CDN. It goes to great lengths to knowing nothing about who is accessing what. If you don't mind sharing, please elaborate on your concerns.
- CharlesW 6y ago> What do you mean by "own the distribution"? Brave passes the content through a privacy-respecting CDN. Yes. Brave [EDIT: the company] is unilaterally putting itself between the creator and the consumer, usurping the task of serving the RSS content without the permission of the content owner. Among other problems, this destroys the ability of creators to get even basic readership metrics for people who might choose to use Brave. Imagine that Brave [EDIT: the browser] started copying and serving your entire web site in your name without your permission, rather than just your RSS. Does that help you understand why this is a problem?
- jonathansampson 6y ago
- thefounder 6y agoBut...Brave's private cdn is a 3rd party...
- jonathansampson 6y agoNot [a] third-party, but a set of unrelated third-parties. Like ODoH, this ensures the data identifying the user is not associated with the data identifying the resource(s) requested. As a result, third-parties (which can't be avoided) are incapable of tracking users or their data.
- miedpo 6y agoSo I've gotta admit, the way they do the CDN privacy is kinda cool. It works like HaveIBeenPwned does passwords almost (they send a subset of articles to all users, and then locally it is chosen, and then for images, they use a reverse proxy in front of a CDN to make sure people can't match an IP to an article). Give it a read, they talk about the technical details. https://brave.com/brave-private-cdn/ https://brave.com/brave-private-cdn/ Same about the algorithm (see the link in the article in the top). It's kinda nice knowing what algorithm is controlling what you are seeing.
- beshrkayali 6y agoI was somewhat interested until I read "an algorithm".
- ffpip 6y agoAlthough I will probably disable this like Pocket, thank you for doing this in a more private way than Google does with the newsfeed in Chrome.
- miki123211 6y ago> the Brave browser fetches directly from the source of the content, so publishers maintain their relationships with readers on their own sites, instead of being forced through a redirect [...], compelled to publish through Google’s AMP proxy[...] or another such proprietary proxy. As a screen reader user, I want a newsreader that does the exact opposite, actually. Nothing but article contents should be let through, no "related stories", no GDPR pop ups, and no "we don't seve European users here" error pages. I would be happy if I could force my browser to display everything as AMP, whenever there was an AMP version available. Kind of like the default reader view in Safari.
- r-w 6y agoHonestly? Disabling JS accomplishes most of that.
- miki123211 6y agoIt removes the popups, but it doesn't remove the navigation, the copyright footer, and all the useless parts of the website that make it hard to get to the actual article, assuming the website isn't designed properly.
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoHow far does Firefox's Reader View takes you in terms of stripping out all the crap?
- deltron3030 6y agoThey broke my old.reddit experience with their shitty tip icon on every damn comment after "brave helper" switched me to a "browser variant", without asking of course..
- jonathansampson 6y agoThe in-situ Tip button can be hidden by going to brave://rewards, scrolling down to 'Tips', clicking the and unchecking any of the properties you wish to exclude. That said, if this broke the layout on Reddit, we definitely consider that a bug and would like to fix it. If you don't mind sharing, are you using any extensions which augment Reddit in any way (e.g. Reddit Enhancement Suite)?
- the_arun 6y agoWhy everyone is after news? Is it to get their customers hooked on to their client regularly? OR there is ton of money in that domain?
- jonathankoren 6y agoWell that's the thing. Regular ephermal news is essentially a commodity, and while I do love some privacy preserving edge computing, but it's hard to figure out how to monetize this. If you have a browser, you can, but if you don't have the browser, you can't really, unless you can get people to install your extension, and that seems like a very limited business model.
- iJohnDoe 6y agoI just want to say Brave has been an awesome browser. It’s fast, it blocks ads, it upgrades connections to SSL, it’s stable. Runs great on desktop and mobile. I’ve never once cared or noticed the crypto stuff. It’s a simple toggle off. We’ve deployed Brave across our entire enterprise worldwide, mobile and desktop. There is a negative anti-Brave campaign that comes sweeping through every time Brave is posted on HN.
- k__ 6y agoYes, I'm using it for a month now. It blocked most ads and I even made around 2€ in BAT with it. For that I got small text ads as a popup in the bottom right corner. I switched from Firefox, which I used for a year, because using heavy web apps are my bread and butter.
- kbelder 6y agoI'm testing it, and so far I'm happy with it. I think I'm going to expand it's use, as Firefox continues to disappoint. You're right about how it seems to... generate a certain kind of negative reaction when mentioned. The comments about Brave not respecting privacy because it inserted affiliate links is nonsensical but repeated over and over, which makes it seem that someone is on a crusade against them.
- yepthatsreality 6y ago> There is a negative anti-Brave campaign that comes sweeping through every time Brave is posted on HN. There seems to be a positive one too. Brave’s shortcomings are not completely unfounded. EDIT: Added “completely”
- wutbrodo 6y agoFully agreed that there's much to criticize about Brave, but the parent comment is talking about isn't just criticism _per se_, it's a higher proportion of poorly-reasoned and surprisingly negative comments than one would expect. I've noticed it too, and it reminds me of nothing more than Android-Apple threads in the early 2010s. I doubt this is a complete explanation, but a lot of the nonsensical comments I've seen come from Firefox fans who can't deal with a browser neutralizing one of the most compelling arguments against Chrome (privacy), so they have to pretend that Brave's odd business model (which is totally worthy of criticism!) has flaws that it doesn't, particularly as experienced by the user.
- thamer 6y agoI love Brave's privacy features but this constant addition of bundled features and services feels more and more like the crappy bundled software you get with a cheap phone or laptop. I've literally turned off all of their crypto/ad/sponsor features and it's starting to get pretty annoying; every time Brave gets a major update I feel like more crap is bundled that I'll have to hunt down and turn off. Their crypto tips feature added tip buttons on various websites (like Twitter). This is not ok. People would be hugely annoyed if Chrome started adding "Tip with Google Pay" under each tweet. I get that they're a company and need to make money. Their stance on privacy is awesome but I wish there was a better way to do this. I would pay for Brave+ with none of this bundled stuff and all of the privacy features.
- devwastaken 6y agoExactly. This should all be under an extension that if you haven't selected won't be installed and won't be updated.
- josht 6y agoThis. I'm sure all these bundles help keep the metaphorical lights on in the short term, but I can't help but see this as a risk posed to Braves long term adoption.
- Hallucinaut 6y agoNot just long term adoption but short term retention. The ads and forceful promoting of crypto and Brave services while browsing are distasteful enough that it leads me to question the validity of the premise on which I first picked them up. Brave Rewards is a nice idea. But I'm not interested at all. So continually trying to put it back in my face means I trust them less as a whole. Personally, I'm uninstalling as soon as I shrink the open number of tabs down to zero (which does take me some weeks sometimes!).
- Spivak 6y agoI don't understand why you're using Brave then though. Don't get me wrong I think all the stuff you listed is crap I wouldn't want in my browser either but isn't that the whole reason to choose Brave over UnGoogled Chromium?
- commandlinefan 6y agoI feel old - I was expecting a Usenet client.
- agilob 6y agoBrave is doing what we hoped Mozilla would do.
- soupson 6y agoI haven't kept up with Brave, is there a totally ad-free option yet? I mean, I pay money, and you don't show me ads. At all. My attention isn't for sale, and I want a company that will let me pay to make sure that's the case. Does this hit that mark?
- ketamine__ 6y agoAds have always been opt in.
- istjohn 6y agoNot true. There are ads on new tabs that are opt out.
- jonathansampson 6y agoThose are Sponsored Images, which aren't categorically the same as Brave Ads. The latter have always been opt-in, but you're correct that Sponsored Images are on by default. That said, they can be hidden with 2 clicks form the New Tab Page.
- istjohn 6y agoCall them what you want, they're ads.
- mind_half_full 6y agoReally think Brave is gonna become a dominant browser in 2021
- _hyn3 6y agoFor a Linux user, you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially with cron by downloading the RSS feeds with curl, parsing the XML with jq, and then using SVN or CVS on the final text.
- hartforc 6y agoyarrr
- w0m 6y agoI don't understand Brave. 'We protect your data! By stealing it ourselves and having less accountability than the larger companies.' Am I missing something? They blatantly collect and use (monetize?) the same data they pretend to protect.