10 ms·
Canada's 350-year-old department store Hudson's Bay locked out by landlords
- core-questions 6y agoHudson's Bay had a resurgence around the time of the 2010 Olympics, with lots of Canadian branding and an attempt to move upscale. However, when that faded, what remained? A large department store with high overhead, and products that were not outstanding but certainly cost more than their competitors. I would go into one ever so often, but ultimately I left empty-handed, wondering: who is this store for? I make a decent salary but can't really justify spending that much money on a shirt that doesn't really fit or look any better than something I would get from another clothing store for half the price of less. At that price point, I'm really hoping for someone to measure me, help me find a shirt, and then send it for tailoring so I actually have something that fits. May as well just go to a smaller store for that sort of experience, no? HBC probably needs to rebrand as a smaller boutique, let go of things like appliances and other products they can't compete with more specialized retailers / Amazon / etc on, and push further towards emphasizing the parts of brick-n-mortar retail that still make sense: the personalized experience, recommendations, evaluation of how something looks on you, helping you try things on, etc. The real question is, what the hell do we do with all this gigantic retail space, especially in relatively newer malls?
- 542458 6y agoPrior to COVID I would have said that retail space could be office space, but now? No idea. I feel it would be really hard to convert to residential, so I have no serious ideas. Maybe schools?
- toast0 6y agoMall to condo conversions are a thing. There's probably better links, but I think this one has decent pictures: https://www.popsugar.com/home/Providence-Shopping-Mall-Converted-Apartments-37434301 https://www.popsugar.com/home/Providence-Shopping-Mall-Conve... Living like Logan's Run could be just what we need to break out of the dull pandemic mood?
- the-dude 6y agoMandatory quarantine centers? The Chinese used office buildings for this.
- jasonpeacock 6y agoTurn it all into housing, schooling, clinics, and community centers. It's already happening in some cities. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-06-30/a-case-for-turning-empty-malls-into-housing https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-06-30/a-case-fo... https://livability.com/topics/love-where-you-live/retail-resurrection-7-abandoned-malls-that-found-new-life https://livability.com/topics/love-where-you-live/retail-res...
- pyuser583 6y agoNot churches?
- jasonpeacock 6y agoChurches are in decline, there's no demand for more of them. http://readytoharvest.com/2019/05/18/the-decline-of-mainline-churches-in-america/ http://readytoharvest.com/2019/05/18/the-decline-of-mainline... https://www.pewforum.org/2019/10/17/in-u-s-decline-of-christianity-continues-at-rapid-pace/ https://www.pewforum.org/2019/10/17/in-u-s-decline-of-christ... https://www.christianpost.com/news/1-in-5-churches-face-closure-within-18-months-due-to-covid-19-shutdowns-barna-president.html https://www.christianpost.com/news/1-in-5-churches-face-clos...
- pyuser583 6y agoFor many communities, churches are the community centers/libraries/cultural centers. They preform functions identical to the organizations you mentioned - although they do other things as well. Regarding demand, your sources indirectly say over 100 million Americans attend church regularly (“43% of Americans”). That’s a big number. Regardless, the issue isn’t just demand, but supply. The “market” for churches is extremely local. If large number of Filipinos arrive in San Francisco, their demand for churches won’t be met by an excess of Southern Baptist churches in Dallas. I understand that separation of Church and State. But creating schools, immunities centers, etc. is a function NGO civil society groups. Groups like that have historically helped create Churches, especially for immigrant groups whose demand isn’t met by “native” churches. Many historically Catholic parishes were created with support from Episcopal parishes. Not for religious reasons, but because they recognized that the German/Irish immigrants benefited from them. That dynamic hasn’t gone away, even if only 100 million Americans attend church regularly.
- sergers 6y agoIt was one of those stores that had all the premium brands (vs Eaton's back in the day). Those brands established their own store fronts, while HBC tried to continue to be all. Massive prime retail spaces, floors of merchandise for nearly everything. At crazy high prices (they had great promos with their scratch n save they discontinued long ago). Now it's just a shop old people with money goto. Or may be the only high-end retail space In small town mall where small-town rich people spend their money.
- bdamm 6y agoBreak it up into small units and resell the commercial space to businesses and offices that can actually make money? This is the kind of thing real estate managers are great at so no worries. Some will rot but my bet is most will be resold and developed. Too bad. They had great blankets.
- ghaff 6y agoLL Bean no longer sells their blankets. They sell higher quality look-alikes made by a small mill in Minnesota.
- switchbak 6y agoI think they were just holding on due to the inertia of older folks that were used to shopping there. I think I bought luggage there once, but I avoided that place like the plague. Reminded me of all the worst of retail, all in one spot.
- perardi 6y agowho is this store for? The big one at Bloor and Yonge has very nice bathrooms. There’s that.
- julianlam 6y agoEvery time I step foot in that location I get lost trying to find the mall entrance. There's no way I'd be able to find the bathrooms
- bregma 6y agoI worked there when I was an undergrad (many decades ago). It was right beside the elite Rosedale neighbourhood. I served a lot of well-known faces in my department including the at-the-time billionaire owner of the store, former and future prime ministers, and famous actors. That's not to say it was elitist, but the elite couldn't be bothered to go all the way to Simpson's or Eaton's so it was convenient for them.
- vincent-manis 6y agoBefore the pandemic, when the huge mall a couple of blocks from me was frantically busy, I'd sometimes walk thru the HBC store. It was pretty much always an oasis of peace.
- 8bitsrule 6y agoHard to sympathize with businesses that have been around forever and could have, but haven't seen fit to, own their stores.
- mschuster91 6y agoProbably got gutted by "financial engineers" in some lease-buyback scheme.
- newsclues 6y agoThey owned a lot of land for a long time... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rupert%27s_Land https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rupert%27s_Land
- bregma 6y agoThey "owned" the unceded territory for a long time. Sort of the same way gangs "own" territory in the big cities. They also fought with rival gangs like the Nor'westers over expanding that territory.
- bregma 6y agoMost large retailers spin their real estate into a REIT to convert the asset into cash. There is no advantage to the shareholders to lock their capital up in a non-revenue-generating asset.
- MattGaiser 6y agoHudson's Bay has become a mediocre seller of everything. One of many that just ignored Amazon as it rose. It is unbelievable to me how little challenge Amazon has faced as all their competitors just quietly lie down and die.
- tootie 6y agoHudson Bay actually had some foresight in buying some other brands (Saks, Gilt) and investing in ecomm but it hasn't really turned them around.
- koolba 6y agoThey sold off Gilt over two years ago for a net loss (estimated at $150M): https://www.wsj.com/articles/gilt-groupe-sold-to-rival-rue-la-la-1528154398 https://www.wsj.com/articles/gilt-groupe-sold-to-rival-rue-l...
- andrew_ 6y agoForesight, maybe. An idea of what to do with them once acquired? Debatable.
- m00x 6y agoThey have a 30+ year old system that runs on DOS. It takes forever to buy anything. If you have a gift card, you should be prepared to wait 1h+ for them to figure it out. Prices are not at all competitive, their products are awful. They deserve to die. I bought a $220 sheet set there that the "expert" told me it fit larger beds and that would not shrink. I wash it from the box, and then when I try to put it on, the fitted sheet doesn't is like 2' from fitting. No refunds since I washed it. Complete BS.
- CamelCaseName 6y agoNo comment on their tech, but in my opinion they have a few fantastic products. Specifically their mittens and blankets.
- cmrdporcupine 6y ago
- the-dude 6y agoHB tried to break into Europe in 2017 and rented some prime real estate in NL, which were former Vroom & Dreesman stores. Vroom & Dreesman, a Dutch HB equivalent, went bankrupt in the same shrinking market and after been robbed empty by a PE ( Bain IIRC ). It was a strange move, a bit of we are losing money on every unit, let's make it up by volume. They were gone by 2019.
- _whiteCaps_ 6y agoThey've since reopened, but it doesn't look good in the long term: https://www.tricitynews.com/local-news/hudsons-bay-coquitlam-reopens-forced-to-pay-half-rent-in-interim-ruling-3145061 https://www.tricitynews.com/local-news/hudsons-bay-coquitlam...
- theodric 6y agoIf after 350 years they couldn't manage to turn enough profit to buy real estate then I guess they had it coming
- switchbak 6y agoHey those pelts were all the rage in the late 1700's! Jacques Cartier was a fan, but he didn't really have the best eye for clothes.
- djkivi 6y agoWell, the Bay's been around since God who knows...maybe it's time to move on.
- kmeisthax 6y agoMost retailers actually try to get rid of their real estate. The ones that hold onto it are constantly harassed by their shareholders to either sell to a REIT or spin one off.
- R0b0t1 6y agoBut are the shareholders demanding something reasonable? I've looked into this and can't find anything that isn't just a trick to make the books look better.
- lmm 6y agoA basket of options is worth more than an option on a basket; that's not just accountancy. Shareholders would rather the business and the building were in separate pockets so that if one loses money they can walk away from it and keep everything from the other.
- CountSessine 6y agoReasonable is whatever you want it to be. Shareholders want the share price to go up, and they can make life difficult for the board and the management team. It's awful, but as a shareholder, once that real estate has been sold, the share price went up, and you've liquidated your position, do you really care what happens next?
- inasio 6y agoThe main store in downtown Vancouver, a full block on Georgia st. across from Microsoft and a couple of blocks away from where Amazon is building a massive office was sold a couple of years ago for close to 700 million. I suspect this is what allowed them to survive this long.
- Scoundreller 6y agoMaybe the Van store, sure. But I hear their Winnipeg store is booked as worth $1.
- hluska 6y agoCrazy timing - they just closed the Downtown Bay for good a couple of weeks ago. Here's an interesting quote about what you're talking about: An appraisal of the building, done last year by Cushman & Wakefield for the Hudson’s Bay Company, valued the nearly 100-year-old building at $0 if it were to be leased back to the company. Cushman & Wakefield found with a little more than $91 million in upgrades, the building’s value would increase to $8 million if leased to a single tenant. With a little more than $111 million in improvements that value would jump to just shy of $10.8 million if leased to multiple tenants. https://globalnews.ca/news/7493539/downtown-winnipeg-hudsons-bay-closed-for-good/ https://globalnews.ca/news/7493539/downtown-winnipeg-hudsons...
- superhuzza 6y agoI visited the Winnipeg store 2 years ago. It was a disaster, floors half empty, random half-completed construction in between displays, virtually no employees around. 100% different than the HBC in downtown Montreal.
- gruez 6y ago> HBC said it paid its Bay Centre rent under protest. Is there more to this? Does HBC have some sort of argument why they shouldn't be paying rent? I remember reading somewhere that anchor stores usually have clauses in their lease agreement that they don't have to pay if the mall didn't meet minimum traffic levels. Is this what's happening here? edit: That seems to be the case. > In arguments that echo a similar case against another Toronto-area mall, HBC claims Coquitlam Centre has failed to maintain a “first class” shopping centre as stated in the lease. >That includes not upgrading the HVAC system to reduce the transmission of COVID-19, improving pedestrian control, upgrading washrooms and increasing the number of people responsible for health and safety at the mall, claims HBC. >HBC added that the landlord did not to provide “an environment that attracts substantial numbers of customers and encourages them to stay at the centre for an extended period of time” nor had it taken steps “to adequately market the shopping centre to respond to COVID-19.” https://www.tricitynews.com/local-news/hudsons-bay-coquitlam-reopens-forced-to-pay-half-rent-in-interim-ruling-3145061 https://www.tricitynews.com/local-news/hudsons-bay-coquitlam...
- renewiltord 6y agoI don't understand how companies that should have lots of real estate in what is now becoming prime land as the city grew around them can fail.
- OJFord 6y agoWell, > locked out by landlords so > should have lots of real estate or not, it doesn't, at least not there.
- Animats 6y agoHudson's Bay is really a strip mall operator, NRDC Equity Partners. They'd been buying up failed retailers for years. They also bought Macy's, Saks, Lord and Taylor, and a home improvement chain that was shut down. Hudson's Bay was the oldest buy and they kept that name. Up until the epidemic, they were doing well for a company in classic brick and mortar retail.
- reggieband 6y agoI would be sad to see them go, if only because of the exceptional Hudson Bay point blankets [1]. They are iconic and legitimately good. It is hard to find equal quality thick wool blankets. But if I am honest that is probably the only thing I've bought from them in the last decade. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson%27s_Bay_point_blanket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson%27s_Bay_point_blanket
- mhb 6y agoI'm a big fan of these wool blankets: https://www.risheep.org/rhodywarmwoolblankets.htm https://www.risheep.org/rhodywarmwoolblankets.htm
- wahern 6y agoI did some research a year ago and in terms of reliable quality Faribault (faribaultmill.com) is comparable. Not quite as old (only 1865), but by all accounts they still maintain the same quality product as ever. There's also Pendleton (pendleton-usa.com). I forgot why I chose Faribault over Pendleton for my purchase last year, but I did end up choosing Faribault, FWIW. There are plenty of other quality wool blanket makers, but few if any in North America have maintained or even achieved the same impeccable reputations as these three.
- Ptrulli 6y agoWow, had a feeling something was coming down the pipeline. Didn't they submit some legal challenge about being closed due to covid?
- bigpoppa 6y agothe insolvency phase hasn't even gotten into full gear yet
- julianlam 6y agoThe HBC has been coasting on it's reputation as "Canada's oldest corporation" for too long. The selection is poor, everything is overpriced, and store layouts haven't changed since the 50s. Remember that scene in Queen's Gambit where Harmon buys a dress at the department store? That's basically HBC except they've given HBC a new coat of paint and proclaimed it ready for the 21st century. HBC was one of the prime places to do a wedding registry. They had nearly all the stereotypical registry items, but you had to go in and scan them. I tried using their online backend to add to a registry, and it is firmly stuck in the 90s, stopped working, and nobody bothered to fix it. They do this weird thing where there are multiple counters scattered throughout the store, manned with helpful ladies to answer questions and ring out purchases, except they're always unmanned, except one (on the other side of the store you're standing in), and that one counter has 5 people in line, some who wish to do returns, which take extra time. Their policy seems to be to sell their HBC card at every chance, and if someone decides to sign up, you will be stuck in line while they fill out the entire form. Remember, there's only one till open, and because they ask about the card right before payment, the session cannot be put on hold, in order to ring someone else in. When I worked at Zellers in 2005, they had an ancient text-based GUI for their POS. It's fast if you know what you're doing, but nobody at HBC seems to know how to use it. Oh, and HBC still uses this system in 2020. Want to see a piece of history? Check it out. I can't wait for HBC to die. It should've gone instead of Zellers. All this they're doing to try and defer rent payments is just the death throes of a once great corporation that decided they had it all figured out, and that nothing ever needed to change. There's one nice thing about HBC, which is that they make nice mugs, I guess.
- pbourke 6y ago> They do this weird thing where there are multiple counters scattered throughout the store, manned with helpful ladies to answer questions and ring out purchases, except they're always unmanned, except one That’s a classic department store pattern. Macy’s and Nordstrom also do this. And their counters are often empty as well. I wonder why the pattern persists nowadays since it obviously only works when the stores have twice the staff that they currently do. I suppose it’s just a lack of funds or will to change the layout of the store.
- 6y ago
- Pasorrijer 6y agoAs a fun side note, the CEO of HBC made more than the CEO of American Airlines! Yay for profit before long term business plans, and looting 350+ year companies
- m23khan 6y agoFrom IT point of view, they along with Canadian Tire still use mainframe - I remember 10 years ago Canadian tire had a billion item inventory, can't imagine how much its now.
- andrew_ 6y agoI got to see Hudson Bay's org, at least the HBC Digital arm, from the inside when they acquired Gilt Groupe in 2016. It was an unmitigated mess, and the talent attrition was immediate. Management was chaos. They had told us that the acquisition was primarily for Gilt's tech and talent, but post acquisition they had zero clue what to do with us. Political infighting between HBC management and pushback from Gilt management that stayed created an environment where little got done. Existing HBC projects, though incredibly outdated, costly, and hard to maintain, were given priority. Proposals and work to improve existing HBC properties were quickly shot down by HBC staff. The indecision and political infighting doomed Gilt further, and they unloaded the property to Gilt's main competitor Rue La La two years later for a massive loss. Friends that were still around have told me that HBC lost over $100 million on the deal, and reporting backed that up [1]. This development and their continued decline does not surprise me in the least, based upon what I witnessed. [1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/rue-la-la-buys-online-flash-sale-rival-gilt-2018-06-04 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/rue-la-la-buys-online-flas...
- joshspankit 6y agoStuff like this is both logical based on personal experience, and unfathomable. There is a finite amount of knowledge required to properly run a retail store, and The Bay has been running for waaaay longer than needed to have solid processes. Yes: new tech comes along, as do new opportunities, but at the end of the day the customers want the same thing: to believe in the brand, to get good quality merchandise, and to have a smooth experience doing it. Throw in the bonus of having Canada’s longest-running business, and the business itself could probably sustain (govt assistance included) simply by running it the same way it was run 100 years ago. That management is chaos is just ridiculous.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI'm not sure it's that easy. Retail in the UK has been going through turmoil over the last decade with many big companies cutting shops or even completely failing.
- faramarz 6y agoAcross from my current residence is The Bay tower at Yonge and Bloor here in Toronto. for the past 6months+, the 100 foot illuminated sign at the top of the tower has been broken revealing bright white light at the chipped part, instead of the symbolic yellow of the logo. the brokenness is telling.
- dade_ 6y agoIt's a click-bait title, though it is true they haven't been paying rent, or partial payments across the country. This is what happens when private equity buys up your business and sells off real estate assets to optimize the balance sheet. It is one location and the 15 year lease expired over a month ago: HBC signed a 15-year lease, expiring Oct. 26, 2020, with the predecessor of the current landlord for the store at 6950 North Island Highway, Dover Pointe’s court document said.