12 ms·
To be perfectly fair, it’s working on Linux natively. Since it runs on stadia. I was part of the efforts of putting The Division 2 on stadia and it really is “
by dijit 6y ago
To be perfectly fair, it’s working on Linux natively. Since it runs on stadia.
I was part of the efforts of putting The Division 2 on stadia and it really is “just Linux” for the most part.
The elf binaries ran essentially flawlessly on my linux machine (although my machine was under powered for the game.)
Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public.
- throw_m239339 6y agoDo you work for Stadia? How is Cyberpunk doing on that system? I'm hesitating buying it there instead of on console.
- axaxs 6y agoNot OP but Stadia user. Played only a few minutes, but it ran well. There's a few people over at r/stadia claiming to be stuck, but I didn't read to much into whether it's true...might be worth it to check out. I'm an absolute Stadia fanboy. I wasn't really interested in Cyberpunk, but they offered a free controller/chromecast if you preordered, so it's kinda hard to say no. Let me know if you have any questions.
- echelon 6y ago> I'm an absolute Stadia fanboy. I'm horrified of Stadia. Google does not need to be in the games business. I'm a twice-burned Google Play Music user with thousands of dollars in music purchases. Maybe I'm completely wrong, but I'd be willing to bet money that Stadia is going to be shut down and all of your purchases, saves, etc. will be deleted.
- Hamuko 6y agoGoogle Play Music purchases couldn't be exported?
- zerocrates 6y agoPlay Music purchases could be downloaded directly through the service when it was still running. They were also transferred over to YouTube Music (and I think can be downloaded from there also), and I believe are/were accessible through Takeout as well.
- Hamuko 6y agoThat sounds pretty fine then. I have zero expectations of any Stadia user getting anything once the service goes down.
- zerocrates 6y agoYeah, I wouldn't expect users to be able to get anything "out" of Stadia.
- Hamuko 6y agoAt best I can see Google throwing like a year or two worth of some Google One tier service as compensation if they kill it.
- CraigJPerry 6y agoStadia as an idea appeals to me but i just can’t see myself signing up for those exact reasons. I’m expected to pay retail for the games i want but in effect i only get to rent them. Nah, no thanks.
- axaxs 6y agoI like Stadia despite Google, not because of, sadly. I don't like having so many eggs in one basket, but it really is by far the best streaming experience. I gave GFN and Luna a fair shot. I wanted to love Luna before it was even released. All that said, sure it could be shut down. But so could PS5, or XBOX. Sure it's probably less likely, but I've come to expect nothing is forever and to enjoy what's here while it's here. And personally speaking, this is probably easier for me since the number of times I go back to play an old game is essentially zero. I'd imagine most console folks are similar.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoThere's no way Stadia will succeed. Sure, Google care now, but they are gonna drop this like a hot potato once the promotions come through. From speaking to devs who engage with Google on Stadia, it appears to be a tire fire, in that the Google people don't appear to care about how much work the gamedevs need to put in to keep up with their API changes (much like lots of Google services, actually). Because of the poor devrel, I will be incredibly shocked if Stadia survives another two years. Without a financial incentive, I'm not sure Stadia would have any games, and financial incentives don't fix the extra work needed when google change things for no reason (or not for a reason that gamedevs are likely to accept).
- sombrero_guitar 6y agoIt sounds like Google has plenty of plans for Stadia in the years to come. > What I can tell you is that we’ve built a roadmap of about 400 games in development right now from 200 developers. So when those games land, whether it’s in the calendar year of 2021 or beyond, is something that you’ll hear more from us in the future. Will there be more developers and more games on the platform? Absolutely. But frankly speaking, my team is almost done with 2021. We’re thinking about 2022 right now — that’s our focus. 2023 is really kind of where we’re aiming our sights. 2021 is in incredible shape. Hopefully, that gives you a sense of the scale of where we’re moving. https://mobilesyrup.com/2020/11/19/google-stadia-jack-buser-director-of-games-anniversary-interview/ https://mobilesyrup.com/2020/11/19/google-stadia-jack-buser-... And Stadia Games and Entertainment, the publisher arm, mentioned "special bonuses" for RPGs coming in 2023 and beyond. https://9to5google.com/2020/11/16/stadia-games-entertainment-seeking-2023-beyond/ https://9to5google.com/2020/11/16/stadia-games-entertainment...
- tdrgabi 6y agoWhenever Stadia conversation comes, I always wonder if I'm missing something. Why subscribe to Stadia and risk losing your games when you can subscribe to GeforceNow and play your own games in the cloud. If GeforceNow goes under ... fine, you still have your games. I don't get the appeal of Stadia and I'm wondering what am I missing.
- axaxs 6y agoGeforce Now, due to developer/studio backlash, removed the ability to play most AAA titles. No Rockstar, Bethesda, etc. The only big name I can think of that remains is Ubisoft.
- harpratap 6y agoIt's the same argument as buying digital copies of your Music via iTunes or something vs Spotify. And we all know who won. The convenience of streaming games is too hard to give up
- Hamuko 6y agoI don't think Spotify will actually sell you music that you will still need Spotify's servers to keep running in order to access.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y agoThe difference is that Google has a well-known reputation for killing products.
- tirpen 6y agoThe problem is that Stadia is streaming only, so no downloads or offline play, but you still have to buy each individual games. So it doesn't fit either side in your analogy since it cherry-picks the bad parts of both alternatives.
- ric2b 6y agoThat sounds like an argument against Stadia, which forces you to rebuy all your games instead of just paying for the service like with GeForce Now.
- Grazester 6y agoDidn't Google play music allow you to download the music you purchased there? Because I had to option to download mine and I did.
- camel_Snake 6y agoI think this is a very valid concern. I've bought 2 games on Stadia so far, and the solace for me is I don't ever really re-play games I've finished like I relisten to albums. Same with books, tv, movies, etc. It's just not my style, so the potential for Stadia to go poof in a year or two is fine by me, assuming it was a good value while it was still going.
- Hamuko 6y ago>I wasn't really interested in Cyberpunk, but they offered a free controller/chromecast if you preordered, so it's kinda hard to say no. I think that offer is still active for a bit. I'm tempted to buy it at 60€ and then sell off at least the Chromecast to offset my Stadia rental. Google has a data center in southern Finland (about 150 km away), so maybe I won't even suffer that bad of a latency.
- dijit 6y agoThe latency is actually affected more by the codec you’re using. (Surprisingly). If you make sure you’re using vp9 hardware decoding then you shouldn’t notice it- I didn’t (and I’m right in the middle of the two main European DCs and nowhere near a google PoP)
- Hamuko 6y agoI want to play it on a Mac so I don't think VP9 hardware decoding is an option for me.
- camel_Snake 6y agoI play on mac, I just installed the Stadia+ chrome extension and it told me I was using vp9, though maybe not hardware decoded? I don't really have a way to verify that for you though.
- Hamuko 6y agoI don't think hardware VP9 decoding, and therefore 4K, is available on a Mac.
- brendoelfrendo 6y agoI bought it on Stadia and played for about 4 hours tonight. It ran pretty flawlessly, though I did have a problem where the game would think I was holding the attack button (heavy attack/auto fire) instead of tapping it (light attack/single shot). So there I was trying to line up a single headshot and imagine my surprise when I ended up dumping the entire magazine instead. To be fair to Stadia, I don't know if this is a Stadia issue or a Cyberpunk issue. Pro tip: I thought my Stadia stream was having issues, turns out that motion blur and lens flare just make the game look like ass. Turn those off and it's gorgeous.
- 9oliYQjP 6y agoI'm running it on GeForce NOW with all settings turned to highest possible (Ultra where possible, High, and one Psycho). I also have ray tracing on Quality mode and I am at an utter loss for how well this thing runs. This is the first game I've played through GeForce NOW and to be honest...I'm not sure if I need to drop money on a new GPU like I had planned to. I really wanted ray tracing support to replace my aging AMD card but the shortage of GPUs meant I couldn't find one. I'm on FTTH and my goodness even at 1080p it runs at what I'm guessing is 50-60 fps and looks stunning. There are very rare audible pops/hitching when I guess there's a network hiccup...maybe once every 30 minutes or so. But I'll take it, the game runs flawlessly for me otherwise. I'm so sorry to hear a bunch of gamers on Reddit are having issues getting this thing to run well on their systems. There appears to be an older Nvidia driver issue that's limiting utilization to low tens causing weird glitches in the rendering for people. But I tested it on my aging AMD card in an eGPU on my MBP i9 at 1080p with all the settings turned to Ultra. Even there it runs well for the complexity and liveliness of the city; about 30-40fps. Comparing the GeForce NOW remote rendering with ray tracing against my locally AMD rendering, I much prefer the GeForce NOW version with ray tracing. The game makes really good use of lighting and seeing subtle reflections throughout the game as they would be in real life makes me prefer the GeForce NOW version. NOTE: I went with GeForce NOW because it supports ray tracing. Stadia does not, so just be aware of that.
- gambiting 6y agoIm a huge fan of GeForce now, the quality is fantastic and obviously you just play the games you already own. I don't understand how Stadia can even compete with it, it's just a much worse proposition every which way. But also I'm disappointed GeForce now tops out at 1080p, it's great on my laptop but I'd love to play it on my desktop 2k monitor.
- krzyk 6y agoYeah, I'm a huge fun. I used it to play few games before I got into Shadow, but GFN is better for more GPU heavy games so I'll play CP2077 there. The only downside I see is that there is no Linux client (or a browser one, which they promised) and I need to do a strange setup of: 1. Starting game on Android 2. Connecting bluetooth mouse there (so it won't kick me out because I'm not doing anything on the phone) 3. Starting Steam and using Steam Remote Play (Thank you a anonymous user on reddit for letting know that Steam Remote Play works there) (with each step cursing Google for not enabling video out on Pixel 4 USB-C) It is a bit of PITA, but I'm glad it works (other option of using a VM was even worse).
- joana035 6y ago> Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public. That is a bummer indeed :/
- est31 6y ago> The elf binaries ran essentially flawlessly on my linux machine (although my machine was under powered for the game.) > Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public. That's an improvement over not having a Linux port at all, as it reduces the investment needed to publish the game to Linux eventually. Once the Linux gaming market is big enough, studios might consider to release the game.
- ownagefool 6y agoI'm not sure that's much of a distinction between not available and nearly available. Rumour is, WoW had an internal linux client for years, and that didn't help gamers. That said, I wonder if being low-key not released multiplatform might actually mean there's likely less compatibility issues when playing with wine/proton.
- hvidgaard 6y agoWoW ran fine under Wine many years back, building a native Linux client would not make much sense.
- brmgb 6y agoThe post you are responding to was pointing that this client actually existed - if I had to guess probably to allow people working on the server to test it directly on their machine - but was never released.
- hvidgaard 6y agoAbsolutely, but my point is that even in that case, it would make more sense to run it under Wine anyway, instead of maintaining an entire build for a platform that is not officially supported.
- pizza234 6y agoI run Linux, and play games, but all in all, I strongly believe that Wine ports are the only realistic, less-worse, alternative. I'm not the only one - Carmack expressed the same (although, to be fair, I've never read other high-profile devs discussing this idea). This is a real-world Linux game production story: https://twitter.com/bgolus/status/1080213166116597760 https://twitter.com/bgolus/status/1080213166116597760. Note that the developers tried hard to release the native Linux port. Crucial excerpt (from https://twitter.com/bgolus/status/1080214424474906624 https://twitter.com/bgolus/status/1080214424474906624): > We eventually laid out a guide with known good versions of Linux and graphics drivers, but it didn't matter. Part of the allure of Linux is the customizability, so few actually stuck to it, and generally wanted to run the game on older hardware we didn't support. In order for Linux games production to be economically viable, there should be a Linux gaming standard, but because of the Linux culture, there will never be (there's nothing wrong; it's just its nature). Even if somebody came up with a gaming standard... xkcd explains what would happen: https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/927:_Standards https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/927:_Standards. I'm not considering adhoc Linux gaming distributions like SteamOS, as they would have to be treated as an independently installed, separate, operating system.
- shmerl 6y ago> Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public. What was the justification of ignoring Linux gamers, when you already went through all the trouble of creating the Linux version? Are support costs so high that Linux sales won't cover them after that?
- gambiting 6y agoIn this case it will be mostly the fact that Ubisoft Connect does not have a Linux client, so it would be hard to get the game to users and keep it updated. Obviously not insurmountable but you're again running into the issue of it just not being worth the cost - the PC sales are tiny compared to consoles, Linux would be just a small percentage of that again.
- kuu 6y agoWhat is the relation of Ubisoft with Cyberpunk?
- dijit 6y agoMy original post was about The Division 2, which is a Ubisoft Game. Also, Gambiting is right, the blocker was Ubisoft Connect (Formerly Uplay) as it uses a lot of Microsoft technology internally, it would have to be completely rewritten to support linux. Ironically; I had raised this concern when I started working at Massive. I am a heavy linux user myself.
- kuu 6y agoAh, sorry, I misunderstood the chain of messages, my bad.
- ric2b 6y ago> the PC sales are tiny compared to consoles I was pleasantly surprised to see that Cyberpunk sold more on PC than the consoles combined!
- varispeed 6y ago> Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public. Do you know why? Linux is my primary OS and it always breaks my heart when companies decide to not support it.
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoToo small of a market. Most people don't use linux as a desktop OS. Those who do tend to use Chrome OS, which isn't well suited to gaming.
- swebs 6y agoThat doesn't make any sense since all development for Linux is already complete.
- p_l 6y agoThe problem is cost of support, including hard to quantize things like reputation. It's one thing to do it like idSoftware used to, with silent releases done by one guy that were accepted as unofficial and you'd buy the windows release to get the missing files, and another to make a proper purchase of a game for linux with all kinds of expectations about it actually working.
- luch 6y agoBecause if you start to support Linux you actually have to support all the major distribution (Debian, Arch, Ubuntu, Fedora, etc.) with their different idiosyncrasies, package format, libc implementations and/or version, etc. Basically your testing coverage explodes exponentially. That's why in a former gig the team I was part of decided to go from Linux to only Windows since it way easier to test only for ~3 majors OS versions.
- moviuro 6y ago> Because if you start to support Linux you actually have to support all the major distribution (Debian, Arch, Ubuntu, Fedora, etc.) with their different idiosyncrasies, package format, libc implementations and/or version, etc. Feral and Paradox for instance only support one (1) distribution. If you fall outside that, you're on your own for support, but you get runnable binaries.
- CraneWorm 6y agoStadia is bad, fortunately it's an Alphabet's baby so one day they will axe it without warning.
- itchynosedev 6y agoI actually had a lot of fun playing Stadia games. I think FPS and reaction type games are not it's strengths, but some third person action / adventure games have been super fun. Sometimes I forgot it was not running games locally. Impressive tech.
- SquareWheel 6y agoI've heard mostly positive things from those who have tried it. What turned you off? Latency issues?
- CraneWorm 6y agoI'm turned off by the very idea of paying for access to streaming a game. The big players are already doing all they can to convince you you don't buy the game when you buy the game. This will make the situation much worse.
- __turbobrew__ 6y agoDo you also abstain from going to movie theatres?
- CraneWorm 6y agoI unironically enjoy the experience, because until I can replicate the movie theatre in my living room this is what I'm paying for. I go mainly to the festivals, premieres, sometimes there is a prelection before the screening, or Q&A with the director. As an aside, this year I enjoyed an Asian film festival at home and was able to see more movies than any other year... 2020 is weird. I recognize that streaming has its place in the world, but I'd hate it to be the only option, like it is in Stadia model. Also, if you don't buy the game then you shouldn't have to pay like you'd be buying one.
- moviuro 6y ago> Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public. Then sadly I won't purchase it at full price. I expect a full experience at full price.
- antihero 6y agoIf I have a 2019 Macbook Pro and want to play Cyberpunk 2077 without buying a PS4, should I use Stadia or Geforce NOW? Is the MBP powerful enough to run it natively on Windows? What controller should I buy?
- 411111111111111 6y agoThey are imo very different services and both have trial time. Test them both and decide for yourself. I personally prefer nvidias service because I actually play games in my steam library. Stadia has few games and you're always forced to use their services. No way to play locally even if you have decent hardware
- antihero 6y agoOk, so I buy Cyberpunk 2077 through Steam and then Nvidia NOW can stream it to me?
- Aeolos 6y agoExactly. As of today, you can also buy on gog.com and stream from Geforce Now. Gog releases DRM-free versions of games, so that's worth supporting.
- antihero 6y agoAh, I got it through Steam as I already had a Steam account. Been playing around with HL2 and the input lag is there but not horrific. I probably wouldn't use this for multiplayer. Just need to source a gamepad of some description.
- snemvalts 6y agoBoth MBP and PS4 aren't capable enough to run it without serious problems (PS4) or at all (MBP). Best solution is cloud streaming, geforce now seems more capable.
- dusted 6y agoHaving native support for Linux seems very fitting to a cyberpunk game, but given the kind of crazy reactions you get from some people in that community when things a. are not open source and/or b. exhibit the tiniest of flaws, it's probably not worth the bad PR they would generate.
- b0rsuk 6y agoThis is like saying Red Dead Redemption is like running a farm in Texas. Linux is more popular among techies/programmers/hackers. Cyberpunk is a genre focusing on being cool and special, an attempt to steal computers from introverts and hide the boring stuff they find exciting. It's a computer Wild West. Check out the game 'Duskers'.
- dusted 6y agoI disagree with your overly strict definition of cyberpunk :) I'd rather say that Cyberpunk has a focus on what is cool, rather than on "being" cool, with the disitnction that the former definition exploits the inherent coolness of all things cyber, where the latter is much more superficial. Look at the people and works that founded the genre, they looked at REAL stuff and extrapolated, not because the real stuff was boring, but because it was cool as hell and the future stuff would be even cooler as heller. ;-) Success in such a setting is not determined entirely by the luminosity of ones hair, the gnarliness of ones implants, but also the deep technical understanding of all the boring stuff, it's so deep, and so understood that one can do it swiftly and make it look both easy and cool. What we get to "see" in cyberpunk novels, movies and games, is mostly an abstraction sice we're not that cool dude or dudette, we don't have that deep deep understanding or those amazing skills, maybe we just lack the right implants, but nevertheless, the author is forced to portray some hybrid between the "concept of what's going on" and what observers would see. Also, Duskers is a great game. Ps I'm a Linux user and I'd love to see more native games for my platform of choice, but I also know that there's a reason I can't always have nice things, and I don't blame anyone for that.
- b0rsuk 6y ago
- BlueTemplar 6y agoI don't get why. Aren't you and CDPR using Vulkan rather than DirectX by now ? If a small studio like Wube can afford to develop for Windows, Linux and even Mac, why can't you??
- dijit 6y agoAnything I say to this is speculation, but making an engine like Snowdrop is a very-many year effort and usually quite tailored. PS4 (OpenGL) is possible because there are shims provided by Sony which make OpenGL have similar behaviours to DX11. Smaller studios don't have a legacy, usually they're highly targeted or they're using an engine provided by someone who can produce builds on multiple platforms. Engines are simultaneously the most liberating and the most restricting thing in game development. Obviously the Engine was ported to Linux to support Stadia, which is where the major investment would have been if we ever saw a Linux release of that particular game. Since that's done the only conclusion I can come to is financial back-pressure (PC sales are honestly not worth the headache, cheating, piracy, support issues; but are still provided, Linux support would likely be many times that effort again), and there's also Ubisofts platform distribution systems (which is intermixed with entitlement and authentication systems) and does not provide linux support. In all, it makes me sad, because I'm a linux enthusiast and adamantly refuse to use Windows. But I've seen how the sausage is made and I have high sympathy for people making games.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoRight, so I guess we'll need to wait at least until game engines are Vulkan-native... By the way, are the new consoles Vulkan-native?
- expenses2 6y agoOnly the switch is.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoWhat do the new PlayStation and Xbox use?
- agilob 6y ago>Sadly we never released the game on Linux to the public. There was a lot of bad feedback after W2 was released on Linux. It was full price, but full of glitches, bugs, crashes, unexpected dying, invisible sword... and this list can go on. A lot of users released anger on CDP who took offence and said they're not doing anything for linux any more. From what you're saying, CP2077 is more closer to native desktop Linux than W2 is now after years, so CDP could drill into this market of fanboys and try to regain trust of the community.
- account42 6y ago> anger on CDP who took offence and said they're not doing anything for linux any more. I have seen no such statement by CDProjekt RED. Only employees of the porting company decried the criticism they got.
- AzN1337c0d3r 6y agoI dont know how much you know of the politics of the situation, but I'm curious if what is stopping games from being released on Linux is due to the lack of anticheat software?