3 ms·
Looks like we may have a surprise winner, though I doubt we'll know for sure, for a while. We've certainly cleared the 1M deaths marker. There is a decent chan
by arcticbull 6y ago
Looks like we may have a surprise winner, though I doubt we'll know for sure, for a while. We've certainly cleared the 1M deaths marker.
There is a decent chance that COVID was an accidental release from the Chinese research lab, just as SARS was released accidentally from a Chinese research lab in Beijing - on two separate occasions. These releases were confirmed by the PRC. [1]
To be clear there's not specific evidence or an admission in the case of COVID, just saying there's clearly established, documented precedent.
("By ‘bioerror’, I mean something which has the same effect as a terror attack, but rises from inadvertance rather than evil intent." -- an accidental release would of course fit this bill).
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7096887/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7096887/
- dnautics 6y agoCan error mean to be policy error as well (versus technical containment error)?
- arcticbull 6y agoSounds reasonable to me, I hadn’t considered it from that angle!
- ineedasername 6y agoWhat is sufficient to judge a policy error? Would an ineffective but rationally justified policy count? Given limited information, there can be any number of reasonable paths to choose from. Should it only count as an "error" if it's incorrectness was (or should have been) recognized at the time?
- imtringued 6y agoThere is no global policy. Each local policy is only responsible for a fraction of the deaths. The originator of the virus can be a single person and thereby satisfy the criteria.
- officialjunk 6y agolet's be clear that this is not saying the initial SARS outbreak started from a lab breach.
- marcinzm 6y agoThe SARS release was AFTER it'd spread worldwide and I'm guessing was from a lab studying the already spreading disease. I'm sure plenty of labs over the last 6 months have released COVID as well but it doesn't much matter since it's already widespread.
- littlestymaar 6y agoAlso, SARS was classified BSL3 to allow more labs to study it. The Wuhan lab is a BSL4-certified one, which have much lower leakage risk by design.
- arcticbull 6y agoI mean, none of them should leak. With that said, the Wuhan lab had both BSL-2 and BSL-3 units studying bat coronaviruses before the pandemic [1]. After the COVID pandemic hit the PRC mandated all COVID research be carried out in BSL-3+ conditions; the research they're doing at the moment on COVID happens to be done in their BSL-4 facility but only because of lack of sufficient resources in their BSL-3 facility; that's likely temporary [2]. I'm not sure why a secondary leak after a pandemic already began would be just fine though. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuhan_Institute_of_Virology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuhan_Institute_of_Virology [2] https://www.sciencemag.org/sites/default/files/Shi%20Zhengli%20Q%26A.pdf https://www.sciencemag.org/sites/default/files/Shi%20Zhengli...
- littlestymaar 6y ago> With that said, the Wuhan lab had both BSL-2 and BSL-3 units studying bat coronaviruses before the pandemic [1]. That's interesting indeed. Thanks. > I mean, none of them should leak. In theory, there's no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is. BSL-3 shouldn't leak, yet we don't put super scary viruses in there, because we know the probability it could happen isn't that low. > I'm not sure why a secondary leak after a pandemic already began would be just fine though. Fine isn't the word. It's still an industrial accident, but not necessarily a catastrophe. Do we even have an example of such leak that would have triggered an epidemic in the vicinity of the lab?
- wporr 6y agoDoesnt it say that it needs to surpass 1m deaths within a 6 month period? Covid didnt hit that mark until 10 months after it appeared in wuhan
- scottlamb 6y agoWhat makes you think we'll ever know?
- gpm 6y agoIt's impossible to prove the negative, and if it's the positive the people responsible both have all the evidence in their hands and plenty of reason to destroy it.
- jkhdigital 6y agoYes, if it happened then the hard forensic evidence is gone forever. The only remaining evidence would be witness testimony, and if anyone even remotely credible ever says a word they will be destroyed. So... yeah. The world will never get a solid answer on this one, sadly.
- adventured 6y agoIt has been more than a year since SARS-CoV-2 began spreading in China and the WHO is still too busy cowering to state that it originated in China. That's the first pitch of the first inning and they can't even do that. It's absolutely a safe bet the zero-credibility authorities will never provide an answer as to the origination of the virus. Their entire obvious goal is to never - not under any circumstances - blame China. They still dodge and evade that at all costs. They've collectively humiliated themselves and should be mocked frequently for it, for a long time. Every other sane person already knows where it came from: Wuhan, and likely inadvertantly escaped from their biolab after having been sampled from bats. It's the only credible, rational explanation given what is known (including about their sampling program and horrific lab security); every other explanation requires farcical, laughable stretches to go far out of the way to avoid blaming China (it was India; it was imported via frozen food; it was the US army; etc).
- arcticbull 6y agoThe job of the WHO is not to hold member states accountable during a pandemic, it's to provide support, services and intergovernmental collaboration. To share learnings. To provide their expertise to those involved. It's to provide health care to the poor and to share understanding. They're not "cowering" to a country that provides them a teensy tiny fraction of their operation budget. Not to mention, they're not the "Health Police," they're doctors and epidemiologists. The WHO has a ton of credibility. They've only been mocked by people spreading misinformation guided by their personal political beliefs. They certainly aren't the ones humiliating themselves. If you want someone to hold China accountable for... honestly, there's no clear evidence the state of China did literally anything right now... take it up with the UN Security Council. You don't get mad at your doctor for the flu existing, and you don't get mad at the WHO for doing their jobs.
- staplung 6y agoThere is essentially zero evidence that SARS-CoV2 was engineered in a lab. In any case, the evidence that it's natural born doesn't have to be believed by everyone, only by Rees and Pinker. Then again, 2020 still has 21 days left to fuck us one more time. https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2020/05/scientists-exactly-zero-evidence-covid-19-came-lab https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2020/05/scientis... https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/09/coronavirus-origins-misinformation-yan-report-fact-check-cvd/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/09/coronavir...
- creato 6y agoNothing in the parent post claims it was "engineered in a lab". Being accidentally released from a lab is not inconsistent with being "natural born". I think this is still highly unlikely, but it is annoying seeing people talking past each other on this point.
- staplung 6y agoTrue, but for the purposes of the bet, you'd have to effectively _prove_ that it escaped from a lab, which seems virtually impossible. In any case, the linked articles talk about that possibility too. Then again one could make the argument that incompetence in the world's collective response to the pandemic is "bioerror" although again, the debate and terminology only really have to be resolved by the two bettors.
- est31 6y agoThere is a huge outdoors lab where we run a gigantic experiment "what happens when humans encroach on natural habitats of mammals on a never seen before scale and humans also are highly mobile, able to spread novel diseases across the globe before they even get discovered or their severity assessed?".
- breck 6y ago> Then again one could make the argument that incompetence in the world's collective response to the pandemic is "bioerror Pinker specifically spells this out: "I assume a mere lack of preparedness doesn't count)" So I think it would have to be agreed with >50% likelihood that it was released by a Chinese lab or some similar error for Pinker to lose.
- bewaretheirs 6y agoI nominate CDC's bioerror: allowing a test reagent to become contaminated and then distributing that contaminated reagent as part of its first batch COVID-19 test kits[1]. My recollection is that this delayed widespread availability of COVID-19 testing in the US for something like a month during the crucial early stages of the pandemic; that may well cause a million excess casualties from the pandemic -- especially if you count economic casualties (lost jobs). The FDA's regulartory approach (being slow to license tests and quick to crack down on unauthorized testing) contributed to this bioerror. [1] https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20200623/early-cdc-covid-19-test-kits-likely-contaminated https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20200623/early-cdc-covid-19-...
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoEven if that were a satisfactory incident under the terms of the bet, there would not have been sufficient casualties due to that error alone.
- imtringued 6y agoThat's a good point. The arguments based around complacency can't count because each countries' response is different. There is no global preparation against the virus so all the additional deaths that can be attributed to local lockdowns not being sufficient cannot be attributed to a global cause. Each of them would be attributed to the individual countries' politicians. 10000 politicians each causing 100 deaths is not the same as an incompetent or malicious researcher leaking the virus on his own.
- vmception 6y agohey there, there are cases from other areas of Hubei outside of Wuhan that predate the whole animal market / nearby research lab thing. so it nullifies or decreases that theory
- arcticbull 6y agoIt might, or it might not. Nobody's saying the WIV created this virus de novo, they studied it in the lab. That meant they of course found it out in the wild, and collected samples. There existing cases in the wild doesn't preclude the involvement of the WIV. Although, again, there's no evidence the WIV is involved.