12 ms·
I mean, they do own Beats - they know exactly how to make headphones that are good enough quality and which sound nice for an average consumer. Now they can bun
by gambiting 6y ago
I mean, they do own Beats - they know exactly how to make headphones that are good enough quality and which sound nice for an average consumer. Now they can bundle that with some of their proprietary tech and that's how you can easily arrive at that price. No one will be comparing these with $500 Sennheisers because Sennheisers don't have all the features you'd buy these for.
- nemetroid 6y agoBeats are widely considered to be overpriced for their audio quality. I think it's reasonable to expect the AirPods Max to be as well, but I think the main draw of this product is seamless integration rather than pure audio quality, and the question is whether you're willing to pay a (substantial) premium for that. I expect that many will be.
- rob74 6y ago> Beats are widely considered to be overpriced for their audio quality That's why Beats was a perfect fit for Apple, Apple products are also overpriced for their performance...
- larrywright 6y agoThe new M1-powered Macbook Air would beg to differ.
- ybbond 6y agoI am shocked by how rationally priced are M1 Macs
- kllrnohj 6y agoThe upgrade pricing is still straight robbery. It's $400 to go from 8GB RAM / 256GB SSD to 16GB RAM / 512GB SSD. The M1 Macs really just continue Apple's traditional pricing - the base model & price is fine, but the upgrades that you're almost certainly going to want are ludicrously priced and oh hey all the user-upgradability (or any post-purchase upgrades) was removed would you look at that what a total coincidence.
- ybbond 6y agoYou either buy the upgrade up-front, or prepare to struggle in your device's lifetime.
- colinmhayes 6y agoLiterally the first product apple has released in the last 15 years that isn't priced pretty far above competitors.
- Jtsummers 6y agoThat’s not true. My first three MBPs (I tend to sell them after 3-5 years years, it’s nice that they hold their value), I specced out equivalent non Mac laptops. For size, screen, storage, ram, CPU, and graphics they were equivalent or lower cost than a non Mac laptop. I can’t comment on the last 5 years because I haven’t done the comparison in a while. That was even accounting for the Apple tax on components like RAM that (at the time) could be upgraded after purchase. Upgrading myself or through Apple, they were still price competitive.
- beagle3 6y agoI think that spot was taken by iPhone SE2. If you consider security updates as a measure of longevity, that’s true for basically every single iPhone. Android are a 2-year device at most if you care about security (and are not a hacker), Apple is a 5-year decice; per usable year, Apple can be much cheaper. And if you consider resale value, Macs have always been cheaper than competitors. A comparably performing dell was always slightly cheaper, but if you sold it 2-4 years later, the Mac came out ahead. And with the M1, it seems Dell doesn’t even have a sticker price advantage - unless you specifically need Windows, Linux or a configuration Apple doesn’t sell (like 64GB ram in a laptop), Mac seems to be cheaper.
- nicoburns 6y ago> Android are a 2-year device at most if you care about security (and are not a hacker) Apple are definitely leading the industry here, but my Samsung S7 (released Feb 2016) got a security update last month (even though Samsung has officially said it's unsupported now).
- beagle3 6y agoThat’s good to hear. Perhaps thi by a are changing - But do note that S7 wasn’t much cheaper (if at all) than the comparable iPhone when it came out; and this length of support is unusual for Android. On the other hand, my 5-year old iPhone 6S got the whole new iOS14 update, and my wife’s 6 year old iPhone 6 seems to still be getting critical security updates occasionally, even though the latest OS that supports it is iOS 12, which was replaced over a year ago.
- stouset 6y agoThe 2000s called and they’d like their meme back.
- matwood 6y ago> Beats are widely considered to be overpriced for their audio quality. Sound quality is also subjective at a certain level. Not everyone wants flat sound like an audio engineer. I like bassy music and headhphones (which the Beats are known to be). Now, Beats may still be overpriced since they crossed into fashion, but I'm not a fan of this blanket talk about sound quality like it's always objective.
- eptcyka 6y agoRegardless of how the bass response is tuned, higher total harmonic distortion is objectively worse than less total harmonic distortion. Headphones are a tool to enjoy audio experiences, and a good tool should get out of the way of said experiences.
- dagw 6y agoHeadphones are a tool to enjoy audio experiences Yes, and the truth is that many people seem to enjoy the experience of listening to Beats headphones and enjoy that audio more than the audio from many 'better' headphones.
- compiler-guy 6y agoHigher total harmonic distortion is an objectively less accurate reproduction of the original sound. But people can have a preference for less accuracy and that is not objectively “worse” except on one single scale that the consumer may not value. Just like sepia toned prints are objectively worse reproductions of the original picture.
- tomc1985 6y ago> the main draw of this product is seamless integration rather than pure audio quality, and the question is whether you're willing to pay a (substantial) premium for that. I expect that many will be. The main draw is that it's an Apple product, and it is yet another way for the rich and spoiled to signal their wealth
- paultopia 6y agoYeah, this. They're not trying to take over Grado's market, they're trying to sell more stuff to people who have already bought heavily into the Apple ecosystem and value comprehensive and simple functionality. For example. I own Sony MX3s. They have decent sound and great ANC but the use is massively frustrating. Swipe controls don't work, the app sucks, pairing with multiple devices is a nightmare. But I keep them for planes, and use my AirPods pro for everything else. If these headphones have sound and ANC at least as good as my MX3s, and in addition have the standard Apple package of features (insta-pairing with multiple devices, tightly integrated with iOS and Siri for effortless feature control, best in class microphones for voice calls, etc. etc., plus looking cool) I'll buy them and give the MX3s away in a heartbeat. (Though... how do they charge? Its not clear anywhere I see...)
- robertn702 6y ago"Simply charge via Lightning connector" source: https://www.apple.com/airpods-max/ https://www.apple.com/airpods-max/
- corobo 6y agowait the old one? Or does this somehow mean USB C in Appleese?
- jackson1442 6y agoYes, the old one. USB-C is sometimes referred to as Thunderbolt 3 but it's usually kept to USB-C.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pdpi 6y agoUSB-C and Thunderbolt 3 are different things. USB-C is a connector defined as part of the USB spec, which was developed in tandem with USB 3.1. TB3 is a different spec, basically an external PCIe interface, that uses the USB-C connector (used to use mini DisplayPort). Typically, TB3 ports are also compatible with USB 3.1, but I don't think that's a requirement.
- mikestew 6y agoYeah, but Beats Studio already do most of what AirPods Max do. I own not one, but two pair of the Beats (like ‘em enough to get the wife a pair), so I’m their “sucker” target market. Sure, maybe one can get better sound for the same money, but as you point out, other headphones don’t connect to my Apple stuff as neatly (or at all; yea, Bluetooth), yada, yada. So I’ll will sacrifice a bit of sound quality (or so the sound nutters say) for convenience. But $550? Even this high-income Apple fanboi has his limits. At that price, the reviews better say the sound is outstanding. Because for one, Apple is competing against the Beats I already own.
- wegs 6y agoHey, this is cheap by high-income Apple fanboi prices. It's cheaper than a simple monitor stand: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MWUG2LL/A/pro-stand https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MWUG2LL/A/pro-stand A monitor stand ... holds up a monitor. This has noise cancellation, wireless connectivity, rare earth magnets, and a ton of precision manufacturing. I'd definitely take the Apple headphones over a monitor stand. At at 45% lower price, they seem like a bargain in comparison. Disclaimer: I'm not an Apple Fanboi, so I'll spend my $550 somewhere else. But I don't think this is that far beyond the pale.
- chrisweekly 6y agoThe thing is, Beats' build quality and technical design absolutely suck. The hinge is weak plastic, and even a little bit of over-opening them can and will break it. This is leaving aside the relative merits of the electronics, audio quality and featureset, where they also fail to deliver for the $. I'll never understand what led Apple to align itself w this overpriced junk.
- gambiting 6y agoBecause Beats have the same quality that Apple products do - people who buy Beats headphones continue buying them, regardless of any other options. I myself own several headphones from different brands, and yet Beats Studio are still my favourite ones - there's just something about that muddy, dirty bass that no other manufacturer can replicate. Even Sony's extra bass headphones with bass cranked up to +10 in EQ don't get anywhere close. For certain styles of music, they are the best headphones I own. And yeah, the hinges have broken years ago, the headband peeled off just as long ago, but they still work and sound as I like - I'd happily go and buy another pair. Apple aims to capture the same market - people who buy AirPods Pro don't compare them with earphones from Sony or Sennheiser - they buy them because they are made by Apple and they integrate well with other Apple products. That's all.
- owenversteeg 6y agoThank you! I don't own any, and they wouldn't go well with most of the music I listen to, but I'm glad to see someone actually defending Beats on HN. One of the weirdest myths around audio is that it's possible to objectively rate specific speakers/headphones/etc - while there's no such objective rating for music, which is _the thing that you are playing_ on said headphones! I've listened to a number of very high end setups, and frankly for a lot of music (most pop, for example) you're better off with a pair of AirPods. Yes, with the $2000 setup you hear all the details, but did anyone ever ask if you wanted all those details? And while bass with more "oomph" might not be the most accurate, it often makes the music more fun to listen to. In my opinion, the entire debate around audio has been focusing on completely the wrong thing: some sort of objective measure of "quality", as if it's some measure you can put a number on and simply compare A to B. Many of my favorite songs, in my experience, lose their power and emotion when listened to on an "audiophile" setup. Sometimes you don't need the details: maybe a bit of distortion and bass is a good thing. And that's just talking about the sound! Getting into the actual experience, there are a ton of non-audiophile products that provide a far superior experience. The actual sound quality of some beat-up 70s rock records and an old turntable isn't great, but the experience is lovely. And the user experience of AirPods + an Apple device is wonderful. Meanwhile the user experience of audiophile products is often (not always, but often) terrible. I've tried a couple of those portable hi-fi players and they are incredibly frustrating. And I love my Etymotics earbuds, but they have to be inserted so deep into the ear that they freak out your average Joe that tries them. That is to say: I feel the whole audio world should stop with the obsession of some weird measure of accurate, "high quality" sound over everything else. Imagine if other things had the same obsession - people looking at art based solely on some weird measure of "picture quality" and "crispness", or buying extremely expensive, ugly, uncomfortable cars because some Internet reviewer made some graphs showing they had better "drive quality".
- chrisweekly 6y agoMy sub-$300 Sennheiser HD1 closed, over-ear, BT (w/ cable option), active noise-cancelling headphones are hands-down the best purchase I made in a decade, maybe ever. I'm not a deluded "audiophile" poseur, but I'm a musician who cares deeply about music, and a software dev / architect whose family depends on my ability to focus deeply on my work, and I wear them for about 8h/day.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anubiskhan 6y agoI love mine. Really wish they had the option to turn off the noise cancelling while on BT though.
- twox2 6y agoThe build quality of beats though is complete garbage. Plastic that can snap in half and then you're boned out of hundreds of dollars. These airpods will live or die based on their durability and battery life. Personally, I love my nose cancelling Sony's. They come in at a lower price point and last YEARS.
- comfyinnernet 6y agoIs cancelling your nose really a price worth paying?
- centimeter 6y agoBeats are mostly cheaply made crap that aren't competitive on price.
- gambiting 6y agoAnd their marketing knows this, just like Apple does - their products aren't competing on price. They are competing on the image and brand recognition, and there are people(me) who genuienly like how they sound and are willing to pay the premium for all of these features.
- MR4D 6y agoYou really think they won’t compare them??? The Momentum Wireless are pretty nice headphones! https://en-us.sennheiser.com/momentumwireless https://en-us.sennheiser.com/momentumwireless
- gambiting 6y agoI really really do, because it's not a product for people who compare brands and prices. Like, think about it this way. Few years ago if I told any of my friends that I have a £200 pair of earphones, they would genuienly think I was crazy. Now, they all have a pair of AirPods, and no one thinks it's crazy. You know why? Because not a single one of them was in the market for a £200 pair of earphones - but they all(as apple users) were in the market for a new apple gadget. Same reason why people who would never consider spending £400 on a watch, happily bought an apple watch. There's just no comparison, no one buying an apple watch considers a £400 mechanical watch instead - it's just not competition. So yeah, in my humble opinion - people aren't going to be comparing £500 Sennheisers or anything else to them - they will just wonder if they can justify it as a new apple gadget or not. It will be sold to people who would never otherwise in a million years consider £500 headphones.
- MR4D 6y agoWow. I honestly never thought of that. Now I’m questioning my own buying behavior!! LOL!!
- zamalek 6y agoAs far as I recall, Beats were using dime-a-dozen drivers. That may have changed in the interim, but people were buying them like hotcakes even when they were garbage.